I'm no supporter of PR speak. The CEO ranks seem to have no problem in finding their next gig. Some some receive ludicrous compensation even when the company does poorly.
I'm just not sure what is the desired outcome here? And how do we get there?
I agree with that part ^
Let me frame this more broadly. _How_ and _when_ should companies adapt? There are many ways, across many timescales.
I'll give a made up example, hopefully in a reasonable ballpark. A company needs to save $250M / year. Let's say there are three options under consideration, not mutually exclusive / can be blended:
Option A: Lay off 1% of 10,000 employees, saving $250M/year.
Option B: 15% across the board salary cuts, saving $250M/year.
Option C: Lower executive and VP-level compensation packages (salary, options, stock, deferred pay, etc), saving $250M.
Fairness in service of the company goals means that all viable options are given due consideration.
It is relatively easy for a CEO to do lay offs, even if other options (lowering their own comp) has better effects.
However, the specific context here is this quote from the CEO:
> we were not as rigorous as we should have been in managing our team growth. That’s on me.
If the CEO admits they made a mistake that led to the current layoffs then I think it would be admirable to take personal responsibility and accept some personal consequences as a result.
In other words, Tony hasn't gotten paid anything from this package, and may never will.
The package is described in the revised s1, and DoorDash is required to report it because they have to account for this package (probabilistically via Monte Carlo simulations) on their books.
https://d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net/CIK-0001792789/8e0717f...
While it's true stock has dropped like a rock since then, it's impacted corporate employee comp as well so I don't agree that stock tanking exclusively impacted the CEO and hence he has paid for the bad decisions.
I'm not sure what people expect, "I will whip myself once for every employee I had to layoff to atone for overhiring during one of the biggest market bull run"?
It's especially weird considering that DoorDash is probably the company that had the best reason to overhire during a pandemic where delivery apps where being used a lot more than usual.
- have a portion of their stock allowance taken back and have to be re-earned based on performance
- have their other benefits and expense account cut and have to be re-earned based on performance
Basically have literally anything they benefit from have to be justified in any way as a reflection of the holistic performance of the company.
I like the sound of that! Joking aside, while physical harm may not fly I can imagine a scenario where it hits the CEOs' wallets either by losing stock options/grants or actual salary based on the number of employees they had to layoff. Because seriously, what does it even mean for the CEO to take responsibility when there are no actual consequences for them? If they're doing it to save the business (which they are) then just say that instead of saying they take responsibility as the latter is just virtue signaling.
What do you think people mean when they say they should take responsibility? Screaming "I declare responsibility!"?
It's an unwinnable game in the court of public opinion, so why do it? Because it signals to the underlings that the CEO is not expecting resignations from them.
Nothing prevents the CEO from resigning and gifting the golden parachute back to the company. You know, if they want to "take responsibility."
Maybe it's reasonable to expect a CEO to resign when layoffs happen during a market upswing but... during a market downturn like this it's kind of inevitable to see layoffs in a services-based company when services are the some of the easiest things for consumers to scale back on when belt-tightening occurs. A change in leadership would only further hurt the people staying in the company, IMO.
I think many employees and investors care about employee retention. I don't know how much it factors in, but it is something.
The morality here is hard because the end results are largely driven by the system. Sure, there are some leaders who are particularly ill-suited for their jobs from the employee POV. Unfortunately some of those leaders serve their investors quite well.
If you point one finger, you'll quickly realize you might need many more to follow the interconnected trail of power.
Also let's not forget that so much of Silicon Valley's advantageous job market is linked to investor behavior, good and bad. My point? Sure, criticize these feaux-emotional layoff letters, just don't forget to look back to see the reality distortion field already in place when you joined that job.
It’s more difficult but that desire to think critically and put in the effort is what makes the community here so much better than most sites.
I genuinely don't understand comments like this. Do you know who wrote the letter? Do you know how much they get paid?
Communications is a real skill with actual, real people that devote their careers to doing it well. And they get paid fairly, unless you know something I don't.
Nobody wants to write this letter, least of all the PR person who wrote it.
What would you have the CEO say, if not what they all say when this happens? "Our business isn't growing like we hoped now get fucked"?
> We sped up our hiring to catch up with our growth and started many new businesses in response to feedback from our audiences.
> Most of our investments are paying off, and while we’ve always been disciplined in how we have managed our business and operational metrics, we were not as rigorous as we should have been in managing our team growth
> While our business continues to grow fast, given how quickly we hired, our operating expenses – if left unabated – would continue to outgrow our revenue.
We grew too fast and revenue wasn't catching up. What other tangibles do you want? Would they somehow help the situation?
> What other tangibles do you want?
In short-form: you're gone, here's why, here's some money. The diction doesn't need to be apologetic. It's condescending.
It was a long letter b/c it provided a lot of information. The information you're asking for was wrapped up in 3 sentences. But I guess that was still too long?
If it's not apologetic, they get reamed for being too cold/unsympethetic.
* This is the most difficult change to COMPANY NAME HERE that I’ve had to announce in our almost n-year history. Today, we are reducing our corporate headcount by approximately n people and saying goodbye to many talented teammates.*
* While there is no great way to manage this process, we strive to treat each of you with respect and integrity. Each of you who is impacted will have the opportunity to speak to a leader this week.*
* While I want to focus today’s attention on our talented teammates who are departing, I did want to say a few words to the team that is staying and carrying the baton. While today’s news is painful, I continue to be very optimistic about our future and convinced of the importance of the role we can play in the world.*