News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:07AM (#33732095)
Cryptocurrency mining does not cause global warming.

Burning fossil fuel does. Why not ban fossil fuel burning, if the concern is pollution? How are all other industries exempt?

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by coltonv on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:13AM (#33732178)
Because most fossil fuel burning is powering homes and factories. You know, useful stuff. Spending 3% of the world's power on sustaining a gambling addiction for a fringe group of gullible people who can't recognize when a technology, despite being interesting, has presented no social utility whatsoever (besides helping make scams easier) is bad policy.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#33732322)
The users and buyers of cryptocurrency sponsor that spending, and find it worthwhile.

Who is the government to say otherwise?

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by piva00 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:26AM (#33732370)
The government is the ultimate safeguard for a whole society, where it should be the steward of common-action when individual action can't be trusted on due to a combination of perverse incentives and issues arising from the tragedy of the commons.

Without that you have an anarchic lawless society where individualism can flourish and people can exploit whatever they want without regards for the 2nd, 3rd, n-th order impact that an action might cause unto others, because it's invisible or severely hidden to them. Or that they simply don't care about said impact because their personal reward is worth more to them than the benefit of society as a whole.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by squaredot on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:42AM (#33732573)
I wouldn't paint everything in black and white. For what concerns the discussed legislation, I think it would be more correct to legislate about goals and leave everybody free on how to achieve them (when needed).
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by afarrell on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:50AM (#33732672)
I want a government which is humble about its ability to declare an activity valueless to society. It would have been vastly arrogant to declare that cryptocurrency is useless in 2012. In 2022 it is… debatable.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by coltonv on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:39AM (#33732538)
The users and buyers of human sex slaves sponsor the human trafficking industry, and find it worthwhile.

Who is the government to say otherwise?

Oh yeah, that's right, the government SHOULD actually make policies to cut down on negative affects of things that some people want to do. You know, because that's the whole point of government.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:42AM (#33733312)
I agree with cutting negative effects. But I disagree with the unfairness against cryptocurrency. Tax or ban emissions universally, instead.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Brian_K_White on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#33732526)
It is exactly the explicit job of the government to say exactly such things. That's who.

Not because they are god, because they are how society codifies what it wants and sets policies to achieve it.

Cryptocurrency isn't even banned, only proof of work.

It's a completely valid thing for a government to set a policy about.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by taolegal on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:12PM (#33739099)
> only proof of work

Banning proof of work is tantamount to banning computation, it's silly and infeasible unless you want to start monitoring what people calculate.

Which for anyone remotely sane is laughable on its face.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Brian_K_White on Friday November 25, 2022 @12:53PM (#33744980)
Enforcement practicality is a separate issue.

The purpose of a state-level policy (state as in government not state as in NY) is to have a state-level agregate effect, not to actually care about each microscopic individual instance.

If you make a policy that in effect Bitcoin is illegal, that will have a population-scale effect.

The fact that you can make an argument that 'it's just computation no different from any other computation' is ignorant of the point and kind of jeuvenile. You didn't say anything they didn't know perfectly well.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by taolegal on Friday November 25, 2022 @01:12PM (#33745186)
> The fact that you can make an argument that 'it's just computation no different from any other computation' is ignorant of the point and kind of jeuvenile.

Why call me juvenile? That's not necessary to make your argument. It's rude too and against the rules.

> Enforcement practicality is a separate issue.

No it's not, enforcement practicality is the only important issue regarding a law. An unenforceable law is useless.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Brian_K_White on Friday November 25, 2022 @07:01PM (#33748341)
I didn't say it's not an issue, I said it's a separate issue.

The question of if a thing is harmful or should be controlled or declared illegal, and the question of how the implimentation mechanics of controlling a thing might be done, are two completely different questions. If you had no way to physically prevent murders, that does not then follow that therefor murder shouldn't be illegal. Failing to realize that is yet another example of jeuvenile.

Practically every law, policy, regulation, code, etc has some element of arbitrariness, interpretation, and discretion or selective enforcement. This one is no different.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by forgetfulness on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:28AM (#33732403)
The government should step in when the market can't serve the needs of society, in this case it's cryptocurrency enthusiasts and profiteers not paying for the externalities, causing a detriment to society. A carbon tax scheme aimed directly at cryptocurrency could be another solution, but it sounds like something that would be way more work to enforce.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:31AM (#33732434)
> A carbon tax scheme aimed directly at cryptocurrency

Why not a carbon tax scheme for everyone, period? This is what I'm asking.

Why is cryptocurrency mining banned, while other "profiteers" (oil companies, gas-electric companies and so on) would not be penalized equally?

The US has among the highest per-capita carbon emissions.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.PC?most_rec...

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by lelag on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#33732532)
I would also welcome a global carbon tax levied at the source (on raw fossil fuel) as it would solve a lot of issues but it's just not gonna happen for political reasons.

Given that the global carbon tax is unlikely to happen, we might has well take action against proof of work now since it would still be a net benefit for mankind.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by afarrell on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:52AM (#33732698)
> why not a carbon tax scheme for everyone

Because the world is not fair and a general carbon tax will not get passed.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by forgetfulness on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:01AM (#33732824)
NYC is not the only city in NY state either, there's lots of sprawl in the rest of the state and punishing car driving that way would be political suicide, besides being a harsh and rushed measure to undo the costly blunder that was planning cities around private vehicle usage.

That's discounting a federal carbon tax that would go this deep, because that's certainly not happening.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by piva00 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:42AM (#33733307)
Because perfect is the enemy of good. A global carbon tax is my dream as well, that won't ever stop me to defend the government trying to tax incredibly wasteful industries as a step towards that. It's not black-and-white.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by smoldesu on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#33732335)
Normally the government steps in when environmental protections are needed.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by iso1631 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:36AM (#33732497)
Those users and buyers do no pay for the externalities they produce
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by goodpoint on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:45AM (#33732618)
> Who is the government to say otherwise?

It's the will of the people and it overrules the will of some cryptobros.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by mola on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:04AM (#33732866)
Will they also sponsor making earth hospitable again? They sponsor a tiny amount of what their activities actually cost.

The goverenment, in liberal democracies, are the people elected representatives.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by smolder on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:08AM (#33732912)
They hope to find it worthwhile, but are mostly disappointed when their money chasing doesn't pan out. Participation in PoW Blockchain stuff is worthwhile for the black market dealers/buyers, hackers, market manipulators, frauds, and a minority of the speculators with good timing, but the overall utility is awful.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by texasbigdata on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:16AM (#33732216)
What’s the fossil fuel burn of Bank of America’a entire IT and anti-fraud department?

I don’t care about the merits of bitcoin, but these simplistic crude and inaccurate legislation attempts are fundamentally market distorting and inefficient and restrict our rights.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by miroljub on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:19AM (#33732266)
> What’s the fossil fuel burn of Bank of America’a entire IT and anti-fraud department?

That brings quite a value. Without anti-fraud measures, you wouldn't have a monetary system.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#33732345)
Unfortunately, an apt description for people shilling alternate monetary systems that I once read was: "For them, the largest problem with the banking crisis of 2008 was that they didn't have a finger in the pie." I often think the lack of anti-fraud features may be a feature and not a bug.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:19AM (#33732249)
Whatever it is, I'm sure it's orders of magnitude more sustainable per transaction than the mighty 7 transaction per seconds of Bitcoin.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by taolegal on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:16PM (#33739114)
Ok looks like you're going to judge bitcoin on its transaction capacity. There's nearly an infinite number of transactions that can occur nearly instantaneously on L2 with the lightning network for example.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:48PM (#33739303)
Ok, since you are such a big fan of lightning network, can you help me with some quick maths? Imagine we get everyone on the world to adopt Bitcoin + lightning. That means we need to open at least one payment channel for each person. How long would it take to create just that one payment channel per person, if we ignore all other transactions in the Bitcoin blockchain?

[Spoiler: it's more than 30 years just for onboarding, for those who are curious. For the unaffiliated bystanders, next time you hear "Lightning network solves all issues, layer 2!" chant from the cult, remember that Bitcoin is still a tired old database at the bottom of it that is still looking for a problem to solve.]

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by taolegal on Friday November 25, 2022 @12:12AM (#33739442)
Lightning works and it's easy for anyone to start using it now. Whether you want to discount it cause it can't immediately onboard the entirety of humanity within an arbitrarily short timeframe is just nitpicking because there certainly will be a protocol capable of achieving that absurd high bar for a trust-less blockchain.

Spoiler: eltoo & an upgrade with SIGHASH_ANYPREVOUT along with channel factories seems perfectly capable.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:12AM (#33742527)
> Lightning works and it's easy for anyone

But it will NEVER work for everyone.

> you want to discount it cause it can't immediately onboard the entirety of humanity within an arbitrarily short timeframe is

The "arbitrarily short" timeframe is 30 years. That seems kinda long to me. But then again I keep hearing "We're still early!" after 13 years of Bitcoin, so maybe you guys are targeting sometimes next century, in which case, my apologies.

Oh, and also, it's not _just_ to onboard, it's the first transaction. Anytime you want to settle, close a channel, create a new one, it's the same congestion. Unless you propose people initiate a channel for their newborn so the kid can eventually start using lightning when they get their third real job at 30? That _could_ work, hmm.

> there certainly will be a protocol capable of achieving that absurd high bar for a trust-less blockchain

"My project is gonna be working by the time for the final! I swear!" stopped working for me when I graduated high school and entered what some may call the real life. Seems cute that it's still alive and well in the crypto fantasy land to judge things by the publicity pieces instead of what they actually are.

Anyway, I'm not nitpicking. I'm punching holes through your tired arguments about an inefficient database and how it's the savior of humanity (just to pump up your coinz.)

To all knee deep bitcoiner, please understand that your future of finance wet dream doesn't actually ever scale to 1% of what's needed, stop burning fossil fuel, and find a new hobby, ffs.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by taolegal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:59AM (#33742950)
> stopped working for me when I graduated high school and entered what some may call the real life

> future of finance wet dream doesn't actually ever scale to 1% of what's needed, stop burning fossil fuel, and find a new hobby, ffs

This just seems needlessly vitriolic rather than a substantive argument.

I gave you a protocol that doesn't "take 30 years" and you say it's a pipe dream.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by lightedman on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:41AM (#33732562)
To quote from BofA's site:

"We also are making our operations more sustainable – including achieving carbon neutrality and procuring 100% renewable electricity in 2019, a year ahead of schedule."

Drastically lower than Bitcoin if this is anything to go by. So low you might as well put BofA into a fossil fuel burn limbo contest.

Given that result took less than three seconds of searching, I'm wondering if you have an ulterior motive in targeting BofA specifically.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by texasbigdata on Thursday November 24, 2022 @01:56PM (#33734987)
They’re just big, no real ulterior motive.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by 0x62 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:33AM (#33732453)
HN has always been quite anti-crypto, but I'd like to pose a counter argument. I run a remote services-based organisation in a related industry, and we switched to 100% crypto payments across the business.

It's massively simplified our processes, and improved UX. Our customer base is already crypto-native, which is what makes this possible.

Users pay us simply by sending funds to our wallet. Our entire payment processing engine is under 300 lines, including USD-denominated fees in crypto. Payments arrive instantly, with almost zero fees, from any country.

We have no chargebacks or (traditional) payment fraud.

Our remote staff are paid in crypto, arriving instantly with no cross-border issues.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:35AM (#33732489)
What is the service that you are providing? Because whatever field I am in, being unable to provide a customer a refund is a large no-no.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by mcherm on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:45AM (#33732616)
The irreversibility of payments in nearly all crypto systems does NOT prevent providing a refund to a customer. That can always be done by making a new payment to the customer.

One might argue that crypto makes customers unable to demand a refund, or that it is impossible to send a refund to a customer who is so anonymous that the merchant cannot even communicate with them, but these are less obviously a "no-no" for a business.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by 0x62 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:29AM (#33733157)
Software development and consulting. None of this prevents us issuing refunds, we can simply reverse a payment by sending the funds back.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dekhn on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:36AM (#33732511)
none of those details justify egregious waste of power
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by 0x62 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:33AM (#33733207)
YouTube used over 175 times more energy watching Gangnam Style in 2019 than Ethereum uses per year. Paypal uses 100x the power consumed by PoS Ethereum in a year [0].

This argument was (and still is) valid for PoW algorithms, but energy consumption is now barely a factor for Ethereum, which is the main network we take payments on [1].

[0] https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/

[1] https://digiconomist.net/ethereum-energy-consumption

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dekhn on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:57AM (#33733483)
I am not opposed to proof of stake but your arguments that youtube and paypal are more wasteful isn't super convincing- after all, you picked a video that's been watched billions of times, and paypal provides a very important service.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by 0x62 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @12:14PM (#33733694)
My argument isn't that Paypal is more wasteful necessarily, it's more pointing out the inconsistencies in how value vs sustainability is weighed up.

Ethereum is currently doing 30 TPS [0], and Paypal ~200 [1]. Assuming that energy usage scales linearly (a naive assumption, but for arguments sake), it could deliver similar value with 10x lower energy consumption, I don't find arguing against the adoption of PoS crypto solely based on sustainability very credible either.

[0] https://ethtps.info/

[1] https://www.ing.uc.cl/en/boletines/engineering-student-scale....

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by goodpoint on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:48AM (#33732648)
> HN has always been quite anti-crypto

Not even a bit. The tide has changed after endless failures on the side of cryptocurrencies.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by datadata on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:11AM (#33732954)
The cognitive dissonance here is amazing. Here is an actual application of crypto that is downvoted, while empty talking points around how crypto has zero use cases are always the top comments.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Gazoche on Thursday November 24, 2022 @06:13PM (#33737279)
> Our customer base is already crypto-native, which is what makes this possible.

You've said it yourself. If the only way to accept crypto payments is to have a "crypto-native" userbase, what does this say about its utility for society? If the entire crypto industry is self referential, then once you peel back the layers there's not much left but a big system that moves money around in a circle.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by ashwagary on Thursday November 24, 2022 @07:24PM (#33737690)
>a big system that moves money around in a circle.

Aren't you describing all fiat currencies? How is the US dollar any different?

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by havnagiggle on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:05AM (#33732868)
Just curious if you have considered what level of adoption is needed to change your mind about its utility. If 50% of a country's transactions are through crypto is it now legitimate? If 1% of global transactions are through crypto is it now legitimate? If BTC reaches 100k+ a coin (or a million, idk pick a number) is it now legitimate? Or is it only legitimate once you specifically decide to sell off fiat? If you don't know when you would consider it successful, I am not interested in when you consider it a failure.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by coltonv on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:31AM (#33733181)
I'd say 15 years of basically completely unregulated time to come up with even a single reliable use case that even a minority of people get social value out of is enough time to decide a carbon spewing "innovation" has not been valuable and it's time to cut our losses. Looking at crypto now and saying "the use case could come any minute!" is just sunk cost fallacy here. It's important to compare crypto with other innovations. The internet wasn't popular for a while but it was immediately useful and obviously powerful to a steadily growing group from the very beginning and it had no major negative externalities. Lithium ion batteries took decades to become widespread but their consumption of world resources scaled in tandem with their use, they didn't start using consuming massive amounts of lithium capacity BEFORE they were usable, unlike crypto.

Lithium-ion is a great comparison to because we should, even though there has been adoption of Li batteries, still be willing to say that massive scale lithium strip mining might be worse than having electric cars and it might be worth regulating away. Even if crypto was highly used, doesn't mean we shouldn't regulate it, particularly if it's externalities are worse than the alternatives (and they are).

Even if crypto did reach 50% of transactions or any of your other examples, and it can't, trustless environments demand waste so that kind of scale isn't possible without earth shattering waste, but for the sake of argument let's say it did, I'd still argue for it's abolishment at a societal level because it does transactions WORSE than everything else. Higher risk, fewer safeguards (oops wrong address, now my money is gone forever vs oops, I'll just call my bank), more emissions, more dark money, more money laundering, more room for scams... I could go on, but hopefully I've made my point.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by havnagiggle on Thursday November 24, 2022 @12:35PM (#33733959)
It sounds like you're decently informed but then make obviously wrong statements like there is no use case. How can you say decentralized value transfer would not be a "reliable use case that even a minority of people get social value out of"? Decentralized value transfer is its primary use case, and solves a problem for hundreds of millions of people.

A global currency has now been established successfully (done organically too with no authority behind it), but 15 years is entirely too short of a time frame to guarantee adoption. The primary growth issue has been secure on and off ramps for local users, but that's a short term problem. Amazingly, we already see adoption in some of the poorest corners of the world before the richest. But you already know why that is: first world countries are fine paying a higher premium on every transaction because we can be more wasteful. It does offer some additional services like chargebacks, short-term debt financing, etc. Others aren't as fortunate due to local currency values, local infrastructure, etc. Also worth mentioning, sending any kind of remittance across the globe has a punishing level of fees attached as well. I don't think you are justified to say what we have right now is good enough, because across multiple dimensions it isn't for millions of people. The adoption curves for other countries demonstrates this: there is a need for something new.

Visa claims their network can handle 24k transactions a second. There are multiple crypto that can approach that throughput without much increase in waste. Lightning network's energy use doesn't scale with the volume of transactions. The security of the network and transaction volume are different dimensions on energy usage, so I think you are off on that point.

Energy waste is definitely a concern, but IMO should not be the concern for a much needed global financial network. Energy waste must come from global emission agreements and local regulation. High non-renewable energy users should be taxed more. High individual users can also be taxed more. The good thing about crypto is the tradeoff of value add vs energy used is extremely clear to everyone involved. If it doesn't make money people stop doing it, or commit a crime that can be pursued (whether or not it will be is another issue). The economics are transparent, which is extremely important.

The externalities are not worse than the alternatives, and it's fairly obvious. The alternative is no global finance network. The alternative is an unstable money supply. The alternative is continued manipulation of powerful countries to perpetuate financial repression. The continued funding of middle-men. The slow erosion of financial privacy (TBF, only 1 crypto actually improves this).

We'll find the energy savings somewhere else, such as the overwhelming wasteful industrial and transportation sectors. Crypto will continue do what makes sense economically. It will continue funding renewable energy and lift up areas with low industry potential but high renewable energy potential.

The current system loses hundreds of billions of dollars in credit card scams. But CC companies are still profitable. Wire fraud scams are up to $3.5 billion per year. Crypto has a better chance of fixing these through new security processes (there's room for custodial wallets) than the current system. The bank is already going to tell you to take a hike if you were scammed.

Cheers

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Closi on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:11AM (#33732154)
One argument would be that the energy isn’t really creating anything extra for the world as mining crypto is a zero sum game - ie adding compute to the network doesn’t create additional coins it just increases difficulty (thus it’s burning fuel for no gain in output in aggregate).

Ideally we want to use/focus our resources to create things which then create net value.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:14AM (#33732193)
The "zero-sum" game is sponsored through buying/holding and transaction fees of cryptocurrency. People see value in it, in spite of its costs.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Closi on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:19AM (#33732252)
I don’t mean in terms of the value of the coin - I mean that if mining activity increases, power consumption goes up but coins produced remains static.

More mining does not provide more coins, only increased fuel burnt per coin.

So in total for society, we are burning fuel for nothing in return in aggregate. And let’s be honest - a majority of these coins aren’t going to “citizen crypto miners”, they are typically going to huge scale crypto farms so it’s hardly spreading the wealth.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:26AM (#33732360)
I got what you meant.

But apparently people agree with the >$600k/hour costs [1] it takes to process Bitcoin transactions.

This cost is taken from the Bitcoin price (via miners selling) and from transaction fees.

Therefore, they must think they are getting at least that much value out of the system.

[1] - https://www.crypto51.app/

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#33732536)
You very conveniently ignore the cost to society that is caused by the extra pollution. That is an externality that is paid by society and not Bitcoin miners, and thus society has a say about whether miners are allowed to run on fossil fuel in a particular state or not. As it turns out, a lot of things are profitable if you ignore societal costs.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:04AM (#33732858)
A fair solution would be to tax pollution, without exceptions.

The specificity of this law exposes the corrupt interests that have captured the politicians (i.e. Big Oil).

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:12AM (#33732959)
If making big bonfires out of old tires and keeping them burning continuously is a new fad, do you ban that by (a) banning old tire bonfires, or (b) taxing tires highly and letting the free market sort it out? Is a government choosing (a) necessarily in the pocket of Big Tire? Or are they also considerate of people who need tires for legitimate purposes, such as driving?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Closi on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#33732530)
I’m going to produce a new currency which will be backed by blasting CFCs into the atmosphere. 1 ozone coin is awarded per hour, based on a lottery where you get tickets depending on how much CFC you managed to blast.

If people are willing to trade this, it must be valuable and also thus must be worth more than the environmental damage being caused.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:16AM (#33733015)
Ah well, here I argue that CFCs, same as carbon emissions, should be regulated.

But it should be fair across all industries.

My hypothesis is: special laws betray special interest - here, Big Oil still wants most of the world to pollute, but Big Banks want Bitcoin out of the picture.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Closi on Thursday November 24, 2022 @09:41PM (#33738595)
> But it should be fair across all industries

I think this is at the heart of the difference in opinion - if the free market efficiently determines the best use of resources.

My personal view is that it often doesn’t, and that where it doesn’t that the government should sometimes intervene.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:21AM (#33732294)
Gamblers have always liked to gamble, however from time to time we have banned certain venues of gambling when we have deemed the "value" it provides those certain gamblers do not exceed the social cost of that particular venue of gambling.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#33732331)
Well then ban it under a gambling argument, not an environmental one.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by woodruffw on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:47AM (#33732637)
The gambling and environmental arguments are both variants of the same social externalities argument. It just happens to be the case that PoW schemes produce both negative externalities, rather than just one.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by marcinzm on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:20AM (#33732272)
Did you read the linked letter? It says the ban is specifically on crypto-mining that uses fossil fuel power plants but allows it using other power plants.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:27AM (#33732383)
I did. It does not answer my question. Why not ban or penalize the cause of the pollution, rather than a customer of the power company?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by PM_me_your_math on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#33732529)
Because then someone would have to hold China to account, and too many US politicians are in China's pocket.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by marcinzm on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:51AM (#33732684)
This is about crypto-mining operations that are running power plants that would otherwise not run. So to your point they are in fact banning the source of the pollution which is fossil fuel power plants. You're still free to pay market rates from the grid for your crypto-mining operations.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:00AM (#33732798)
> that are running power plants that would otherwise not run

No, it says "that are operated through electric generating facilities that use a carbon-based fuel".

How is using the grid not banned? Does grid energy not use carbon-based fuel?

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by marcinzm on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:13AM (#33732988)
No, a letter summarizing a law says that, the law itself says:

>Section 2 places a moratorium on air permit issuance and renewal for an electric generating facility that utilizes a carbon-based fuel and that provides, in whole or in part, behind-the-meter electric energy consumed or utilized by cryptocurrency mining operations that use proof-of-work authentication methods to validate blockchain transactions.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:59AM (#33732787)
> It says the ban is specifically on crypto-mining that uses fossil fuel power plants but allows it using other power plants.

https://dilbert.com/strip/2006-02-19

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by BlueTemplar on Thursday November 24, 2022 @01:29PM (#33734661)
Methane is not as fungible though, there's a significant cost to move it, especially via liquefaction.

Also, as the price of oil goes down because Dilbert (et al.) refuse to buy it, the marginal oil producer (probably US tight oil, ironically, since about 2006) gets priced out of the market, resulting in a decrease of production.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:26PM (#33739156)
Electrical power is far more fungible than oil is.

If you have a disfavored sector of the economy that isn't allowed to use electricity from fossil fuels, and a favored sector that is, the effect on how much electricity your economy consumes from what sources will be zero until the amount of electricity needed by the disfavored sector exceeds total non-fossil-fuel-based production.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by BlueTemplar on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:31PM (#33747533)
No, most of the economy is far more disconnected electricity-wise. And consider what kind of infrastructure it would take to be able to send electricity between, say, Spain and New Zealand !
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by Cthulhu_ on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:28AM (#33732397)
No, but it's a contributing factor, using up all the power consumption of a small country. Turn off crypto mining, they can turn off a few dozen fossil fuel plants.

But it's a variant of Parkinson's Law in action; new energy production is gobbled up by whatever industry. We're building huge offshore windmill farms, but their capacity is bought up by datacenters.

We don't need more green energy per sé; we need to reduce consumption wholesale.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by xiphias2 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:14AM (#33732192)
Other industries are not competing with the central banking system.

It's not the first time new currencies were made illegal, actually it is expected.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by eloff on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:22AM (#33732309)
Cryptocurrency isn't very useful as a currency, so it doesn't compete with fiat currencies. You can't use it to buy things, apart from illegal things. The exceptions are fringe uses only.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by xiphias2 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:35AM (#33732486)
This is a plain lie. I'm buying most of my things with Bitcoin (using the lightning network).

I'm offended by people saying that I use it for illegal things, just how I don't suppose a person is a drug dealer just because there's trace cocaine on the money he or she uses.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by eloff on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:45AM (#33733336)
Do tell how you pay in a store or restaurant with Bitcoin. Are you just a weirdo who doesn't leave your mom's basement?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by xiphias2 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @02:41PM (#33735402)
As a digital nomad most of my travels (the expensive part of life) are with travala.com and cheapair.com.

Also I use Binance debit card for payments, they autoconvert to the currency that the country needs.

Of course I use fiat currency accounts as well, I didn't say that, what I wrote is by Bitcoin payments are not illegal.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by eloff on Thursday November 24, 2022 @06:06PM (#33737233)
I've never heard of a binance debit card before, that's very interesting. Don't you feel like you're getting screwed by the conversion lately? Bitcoin is so volatile to use as a currency.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by xiphias2 on Friday November 25, 2022 @01:43AM (#33739903)
Not really, I bought it a long time ago (2013) and I understand that volatility is the price I pay in my life for having a currency that's super hard to print more of.

Right now I'm on a smaller budget than before, it's no problem for me.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:19AM (#33732263)
Well then, is the Governor acting on behalf of the Federal Reserve? Why is this reason not mentioned, and instead, environmental issues are raised?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by datadata on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:25AM (#33732352)
To be fair, the ban is for crypto mining that uses fossil fuels only. But I completely agree with your point that it should just be a ban on fossil fuels.

More generally it is troubling that the ban implicitly is an attack against general purpose computing. There is a policy that only certain programs get to use energy sources. Even those who want to kill crypto currencies should think about the downstream consequences of this policy, and what else it could be applied to next.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:41AM (#33732569)
> More generally it is troubling that the ban implicitly is an attack against general purpose computing.

ASICs that mine Bitcoin are _anything but_ a general purpose computer. It's like saying "banning coal rollers is an affornt against general transportation". I personally would be pretty okay if the ban was against Bitcoin mining ASICs instead, knowing that it does nothing to restrict any other computing freedom.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by datadata on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:51AM (#33732686)
The ban is not specifically for bitcoin with asic mining, but for all "proof of work" operations. You are right that most bitcoin hardware is not general purpose computing hardware, but I would still defend the liberty of a business to optimize their hardware for whatever their compute objective is.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:00AM (#33732809)
What about rolling coal [0]? Do you support vehicle owner's right to modify and optimize their vehicle for whatever their objective is? Or do you think computation is somehow magical and thus different?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by roland35 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:12AM (#33732167)
Other industries use energy to produce useful things.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dmarcos on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#33732330)
Problem is that usefulness is not universal past essential things. I’m sure we can find many things you find wasteful that I consider useful and vice-versa.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by roland35 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:26AM (#33732363)
Having a bunch of computers that don't trust each other all performing random calculations to find a specific hash and then add a small block of data to a globally duplicated append only data structure that processes about 7 transactions per second is pretty useless.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dmarcos on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:37AM (#33732523)
Why do you think is designed this way? Some think that proof of work is essential in order to have a monetary system that it’s really hard to corrupt hence essential for them. Search for thermodynamically sound money. I’m sure proponents would be open to alternative designs if desired properties are retained.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by woodruffw on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:44AM (#33732606)
“Hard to corrupt” is not the choice of phrase I would use, given the last month of cryptocurrency news.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dmarcos on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:54AM (#33732722)
An irresponsible centralized exchange crashing doesn’t challenge the fundamentals of the bitcoin protocol.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by woodruffw on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:08AM (#33732922)
Sure. It just belies motives and incentives that I don’t want anywhere in my society, much less near fuel-burning power plants.

Similarly: nothing about forbidding the use of fossil fuels challenges the fundamentals of the Bitcoin protocol. It’s merely been promoted to the same regulatory status as “burning tires in your backyard for heat.”

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by danuker on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:29AM (#33732411)
I agree with you here. Which is why I use Bitcoin Cash instead.

But I believe people should be free to waste/risk their money in general.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by roland35 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:33AM (#33732462)
That's all fine, except in this case there are some extreme externalities unfortunately. We are all going to pay the price in the long term for this environmental waste. Sometimes regulations are required to protect a shared resource.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by polygamous_bat on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:43AM (#33732594)
I don't think I should be allowed to buy all the used tires and burn them on my backyard in an open flame next to the local middle school, even if it is my money and my backyard. What do you think?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by ericd on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:59AM (#33732784)
You (and everyone else quoting low transactions per second figures) seem to be ignoring the parts above BTC that just use it as a net settlement layer, but allow for large numbers of transactions for almost no marginal energy usage per transaction. Lightning wouldn’t be able to do all those transactions without BTC providing that security.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by roland35 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:14AM (#33732991)
The only thing crypto needs is another layer of crypto! I'm sure there is another crypto layer that provides FDIC insurance, fraud and loss protection, physical offline methods of payment, etc etc...

All it serves to do is create more techno-babble that confuses 99% of the population which has no ability to actually understand what the technology actually is and does. So scams fill the void

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by dmarcos on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:54AM (#33733449)
Bitcoin like any other protocol has certain characteristics and tradeoffs. The traditional monetary system is layered too (credit cards is one of the consumer facing ones). Layered architectures are found everywhere. See the Web: IP, TCP, HTTP. Any concern about those? Do you think a protocol that does it all would be better or even possible?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by slowmotiony on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:36AM (#33732501)
Who decides what is useful? There's gotta be millions of people playing video games on their 600W RTX builds - how about we ban it as they're obviously not producing anything useful?
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by ericd on Thursday November 24, 2022 @11:01AM (#33732818)
If instead of picking on specific uses of power, we put a price on carbon that allowed us to remove the carbon, most people won’t find it worthwhile to run 600W PCs either.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by geysersam on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:13AM (#33732181)
Because some uses of fossile fuels are more important than others.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by scld on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:22AM (#33732315)
Because pollution is an easy way to jam through otherwise onerous regulation.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by davedx on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:15AM (#33732208)
I guess one argument is bitcoin mining could run when there's excess renewables capacity, and we should save baseload power generation from e.g. coal and nat gas for consumers that need it 24/7 like residential, hospitals, airports and the like. This is quite a heavy handed approach indeed, but yeah it is at state level. Maybe a more nuanced Federal level action is necessary.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by zdragnar on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#33732334)
The problem isn't the perfect regulation, the problem is enforcement. Without a grid so smart that the meter knows that a plugged in device is mining specific types of cryptocurrency, the regulation is worthless.

A blanket ban is much easier to enforce, even if "easy" in this context is basically impossible.

Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by mavhc on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:33AM (#33732460)
No need to ban fossil fuel burning, just tax all pollution at the level required to clean up said pollution, then use that money to clean up the pollution.
Re:Proof of work is temporarily illegal in New York by toolslive on Thursday November 24, 2022 @10:13AM (#33732172)
Indeed. It can be seen as a battery: Superfluous solar power ? Mine! Not enough electricity ? Sell mined coin to buy electricity.