More mining does not provide more coins, only increased fuel burnt per coin.
So in total for society, we are burning fuel for nothing in return in aggregate. And let’s be honest - a majority of these coins aren’t going to “citizen crypto miners”, they are typically going to huge scale crypto farms so it’s hardly spreading the wealth.
But apparently people agree with the >$600k/hour costs [1] it takes to process Bitcoin transactions.
This cost is taken from the Bitcoin price (via miners selling) and from transaction fees.
Therefore, they must think they are getting at least that much value out of the system.
The specificity of this law exposes the corrupt interests that have captured the politicians (i.e. Big Oil).
If people are willing to trade this, it must be valuable and also thus must be worth more than the environmental damage being caused.
But it should be fair across all industries.
My hypothesis is: special laws betray special interest - here, Big Oil still wants most of the world to pollute, but Big Banks want Bitcoin out of the picture.
I think this is at the heart of the difference in opinion - if the free market efficiently determines the best use of resources.
My personal view is that it often doesn’t, and that where it doesn’t that the government should sometimes intervene.