News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by H8crilA on Saturday November 19, 2022 @08:54AM (#33670049)
All in all it's good to see the market react by cutting consumption. You may hate this post but the reality is that it's the only way forward, subsides will only increase the price without doing anything about the problem.

Also, not many people realize this, but the problem isn't caused by the war. If you don't believe me then open an inflation chart of your country of choice and try to spot any change to the shape of the curve around Feb 2022.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by Frost1x on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:06AM (#33670141)
If you think it's good to cut consumption, it seems like we have a lot of other places to reduce energy consumption outside of more basic necessity energy usage, like heating people's homes.

This perspective just externalizes side effects of all sorts of unequal societal resource allotments and paints the problem contributor as the average person. It's akin to blaming climate change on your average person when the biggest contributors aren't your typical person whose biggest crimes might be driving to work, taking an occasional mass shared flight, or ordering something on Amazon. Or plastic waste on consumers not recycling. There's lots of these blame deflecting trends from industry.

In the long term, you might be correct that we need to reduce energy expenditure (although birth rates could change this picture), but I'd say we have a lot of other low hanging wasteful consumption fruit that we should fix before having people shiver to stay warm in their homes.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by jason-phillips on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:38AM (#33670456)
> paints the problem contributor as the average person

I'm confused, it's not?

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by gruez on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:24AM (#33670320)
>It's akin to blaming climate change on your average person when the biggest contributors aren't your typical person whose biggest crimes might be driving to work, taking an occasional mass shared flight, or ordering something on Amazon

Who's the biggest contributor then, corporations? If I order something from amazon, which causes emissions to be created because of the delivery truck, is that amazon's fault and not mine?

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by bmj on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:34AM (#33670414)
I believe corporations are effectively supporting campaigns to push the burden of climate guilt on consumers. That isn't to say that the average citizen shouldn't be aware of (and seek to change) their patterns of consumption, but if most people are too busy scrupulously examining whether reusable shopping bags are better for the environment than plastic, well, no one notices the massive effect that global consumer product shipping (facilitated by Amazon) has on the environment.

That said, environmental scrupulosity is a thing. Would it be better for the environment if I didn't buy stuff from Amazon, and maybe just bought locally made goods and food? And maybe I shouldn't buy new clothes, but just continually repair what I have? And maybe I shouldn't use computers or smartphones because the raw materials are damaging to extract from the Earth?

But, to answer your question, I think we can most effectively blame an economic system that rewards continuous production and consumption, with emphasis on disposable, rather than repairable, items. Amazon helps facilitate that with free shipping and impossibly low prices. Yet, instead of asking us, as consumers, to reexamine our habits of consumption, we are asked to feel guilty about how much we recycle, or how much we drive. I could not own a car, and walk everywhere, but if I purchase nearly everything I need from Amazon, I suspect my "environmental impact" is no different from a person who drives to work everyday.

[Edit: formatting]

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by gruez on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:47PM (#33673882)
>but if most people are too busy scrupulously examining whether reusable shopping bags are better for the environment than plastic, well, no one notices the massive effect that global consumer product shipping (facilitated by Amazon) has on the environment.

This feels like a non-issue to me. If you're the kind of person who's "scrupulously examining whether reusable shopping bags are better for the environment", I doubt you're going to forget that ordering stuff from amazon involves a ship traveling half way across the world.

>But, to answer your question, I think we can most effectively blame an economic system that rewards continuous production and consumption, with emphasis on disposable, rather than repairable, items.

But is the economic system actually incentivizing disposable stuff in particular, or is it incentivizing producing what consumers want? The fact that amazon is strewn with "reusable" variants of everything imaginable (eg. reusable straws, reusable bags, reusable k-cups) makes me think it's the latter.

> Amazon helps facilitate that with free shipping and impossibly low prices.

Maybe the prices are indication of something? For something like straws, it might actually be better to manufacture 1 gram worth of plastic and ship it across the world, than it is to wash/sanitize a reusable straw which also involve labor and resources (eg. hot water).

>we are asked to feel guilty about how much we recycle, or how much we drive. I could not own a car, and walk everywhere, but if I purchase nearly everything I need from Amazon, I suspect my "environmental impact" is no different from a person who drives to work everyday.

I don't understand what you're trying to say here. If you don't own a car, then presumably you're not driving to work. If you don't driving to work, that's one less thing that's contributing to environmental impact. Of course, if you're ordering stuff from amazon rather than going to a store, that loss might be offset by your amazon deliveries, but I suspect that you're still coming out ahead. The fact that the alternatives have environmental impact as well shouldn't come as a surprise either. After all, maintaining a first world standard of living is going to have some environmental impact associated with it, and it's unreasonable to expect otherwise.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by moring on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:33AM (#33670398)
As an individual, I don't even have knowledge, let alone control about the energy consumption over the production process of things I order. It won't improve anything to put responsibility for that consumption on the buyer, at least not without significant changes that could better be solved by putting an appropriate price tag on consumption.

And that last part doesn't just mean to make things more expensive, which causes inflation and doesn't really make things more expensive. It means to reward saving energy compared to other costs.

Asking who is to blame is -- suprise! -- not solving anything.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by gruez on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:39AM (#33670465)
>As an individual, I don't even have knowledge, let alone control about the energy consumption over the production process of things I order. It won't improve anything to put responsibility for that consumption on the buyer, at least not without significant changes that could better be solved by putting an appropriate price tag on consumption.

But at the end of the day, the buyer is always right. It's easy to abdicate responsibility of production based carbon emissions to the producers, but if your buying choices actively disadvantage producers with lower carbon emissions (eg. because they cost more and you only care about costs) why would you expect producers to do anything about it?

>It means to reward saving energy compared to other costs.

Isn't there already an incentive to save energy? It's a cost, so businesses are already incentivized to save energy wherever they can. Higher prices incentivizes that even more.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by willnonya on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:17AM (#33670859)
The original comment wasn't about assigning blame but allowing market forces to work to balance supply and demand.

The prices are how you, as an individual, gain knowledge about the energy market. Prices are high and demand out straps supply. Prices are low and supply is higher than demand.

Subsidies distort this information.

This isnt to say it's good that people can't heat their homes but it's the only way to balance these markets.

Any solution that focuses on the consumer side relief rather than improving supply will only exacerbate the situation.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by politelemon on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:57AM (#33670642)
It is strange to assume an either/or, which is an unhelpful polarising stance to take. The answer can be both.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by SkeuomorphicBee on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:15AM (#33670839)
The corporation have the decision making power over the emissions. Knowledge of emissions is abstracted away by this middle man, and the relevant decisions are already made by the time the product is available to the customer, leaving the customer with only the binary fake decision of buying-in to all hight emissions decisions of the corp, or going without.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by yucky on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:20AM (#33670874)

    > Who's the biggest contributor then, corporations?
The US military.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by shagie on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:12AM (#33678496)
> > ... or ordering something on Amazon.

> Who's the biggest contributor then, corporations? If I order something from amazon, which causes emissions to be created because of the delivery truck, is that amazon's fault and not mine?

It's even a harder question than that. Sure, Amazon is the one responsible for scheduling the emissions... but when you take into account the overall emissions of a purchase then it gets more interesting.

---

https://ctl.mit.edu/sites/default/files/library/public/Dimit...

> Results are shown for the buying process of a toy, for customers living in an urban area. Figure 1 shows the carbon footprint of online and traditional shopping, when only the purchase step and the appropriate return rate are considered. The Cybernaut tends to have a lower environmental impact than the Traditional Shopper, as long as he does not use speed delivery.

> ...

> The Cybernaut’s carbon footprint is almost two times smaller than a Traditional Shopper. In fact the main component of the Traditional shopper is the customer transportation, whereas Cybernaut‘s emissions are linked to a parcel carrier, who uses an optimized delivery process. The freight transportation has a bigger impact for the Cybernaut since the item is packaged individually, which increases packaging weight and volume, and the linehaul distance of online warehouse is bigger than a traditional one. The packaging is the main component of the Cybernaut’s carbon footprint.

---

The box that you get from Amazon is the largest part of the carbon footprint for the online shopper, but it is still much less than the traditional shopper driving to buy an item in a store. The difference between an individual driving to the store and parcel delivery is akin to similar arguments for solo commuters vs taking public transportation - the bulk transportation of items or people is better.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by sokoloff on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:14AM (#33670225)
Many (most?) of these things are not either-or. I can stop watering my lawn in a drought and ask industry to improve their water efficiency.

I can turn my thermostat and flow temps down a few degrees and expect companies to reduce unused lighted in their offices on nights and weekends.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by jkepler on Saturday November 19, 2022 @11:51AM (#33671789)
Rather than reducing birth rates (which would mean less creative problem-solvers to care for the climate and the broader natural world and human cultures), in the long term we ought to increase energy production. Abundant affordable energy, produced sustainably, will help everyone, especially the poor.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by hiq on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:38AM (#33670460)
Most market-based solutions have to be looked at carefully to make sure they don't just translate into more inequalities.

Food, shelter, education and other basic needs are supposed to be taken care of in developed countries (by definition) in the 21st century. Just leaving it up to the market means that poorer people won't have these needs fulfilled, and we can't pretend that it's just fine and so be it.

Maybe energy prices should be proportional to your wealth, like fines in some countries.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by bgorman on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:45AM (#33670524)
In the US, we have government programs to educate, feed and house the needy. None of these programs have solved the problem.

Public education in particular sees very bad outcomes for poor students. It is time to privatize.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by willnonya on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:44AM (#33671153)
This is a strange take on what defines a developed country. Moast developed countries can meet these needs but that isn't what makes them developed countries.

The idea to make energy cost proportional to wealth is also bizarre. The first problem with it is how will you determine wealth? The second problem is how will you determine need? The goal is to provide according to need while taking according to ability, right?

This has been tried many times in many ways and inevitably results in more inequality and a lower standard of living than allowing market forces to balance supply and demand based on economic signals.

You're conflating markets with inequalities and implilying a causal relationship when the market is simply the scale in the middle attempting to balance consumption with economic contribution.

It's almost ironic that markets are the way in which you can achieve this Marxist ideal.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by hiq on Saturday November 19, 2022 @12:54PM (#33672642)
> that isn't what makes them developed countries

What does then? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Developed_country mentions quality of life, aren't basic needs part of that?

> how will you determine wealth?

Some countries have wealth-based taxes and so have apparently answered this question, so that can be a starting point.

I don't understand your point about markets solving inequalities on their own. If energy is expensive, poor people don't have heating, rich people do. Are you saying that's just fine?

Also not sure what the Marxist ideal is, is wanting poor people to have heating a Marxist ideal? I'm honestly confused by your comment.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by Denvercoder9 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:21AM (#33670289)
> If you don't believe me then open an inflation chart of your country of choice and try to spot any change to the shape of the curve around Feb 2022.

That's not how it works. It takes time for price increases to propagate through the supply chain. Utilities usually contract their gas months ahead, so if the prices for natural gas increased in February due to the war, the increase in consumer prices wouldn't have happened until months later.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by H8crilA on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:51AM (#33670580)
We've already had those "months later", it's still roughly a straight line since some time in 2021 that might have broken recently.

Again, I recommend just opening it and looking at it.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by kasey_junk on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:22AM (#33670902)
Can you link to whatever chart you are referencing?

Because every chart I’ve looked at shows both a big jump in heating oil future prices, and more importantly, volatility starting at the end of February.

That is completely consistent with what you would expect, the war roiled energy markets and consumers are now paying the price.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by Denvercoder9 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:56AM (#33671270)
The chart for my country show both an obvious jump from February to March and from June to September: https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/visualisaties/dashboard-economie/pr...
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by red_trumpet on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:01AM (#33670105)
> If you don't believe me then open an inflation chart of your country of choice and try to spot any change to the shape of the curve around Feb 2022.

In Germany, inflation did hike up in March [1]. The Russo-Ukrainian war started on February 24th, so February's inflation is not that much impacted.

Sure, inflation was already high before that. But I'm pretty sure the war increased the problem.

[1] https://tradingeconomics.com/germany/inflation-cpi

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by H8crilA on Saturday November 19, 2022 @11:51AM (#33671802)
Zoom out a bit more. Part of the same trend.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by kasey_junk on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:05AM (#33670136)
https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/future/ho.1/charts?mod...

Front month fuel certainly shot up around February.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by realgeniushere on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:12AM (#33670202)
That’s not how any of this works. 1) Weird to check the inflation charts when you can just check the price of oil and natural gas. They have moved considerably due to the war. 2) Natural gas is not a perfect long term market. It’s a consumable that has to travel through the supply chain and then be consumed in a short amount of time. 3) No reason to expect a massive shift right at the beginning of the war. No one expected the war to drag on this long. No one expected the West to double down on sanctions so dramatically. No one expected Nordstream 2 to get blown up and foreclose Germany’s options. 4) Inflation has many many causes. A major pandemic, a decade and a half of printing money like never before, political trouble in the US, and now a twitter-driven suicidal sanctions regime.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by sokoloff on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:35AM (#33670421)
Inflation charts often exclude food and energy specifically because of the volatility in those categories. To the extent the Russian invasion spiked those, it may not show up in a “core inflation” chart.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by wiseowise on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:26AM (#33670338)
> All in all it's good to see the market react by cutting consumption.

People are freezing and you consider this good? Why?

> You may hate this post but the reality is that it's the only way forward, subsides will only increase the price without doing anything about the problem.

Which one?

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by lozenge on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:14AM (#33670227)
Inflation measures an increase in prices, so if the price of fuel rises, then it will, mathematically, cause inflation to go up. The price of any good that is delivered using fuel also goes up, which again causes inflation to go up.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by realgeniushere on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:14AM (#33670219)
You’re so close to openly admitting it. Just say it. The ultimate goal is to make it so only the rich can afford comfortable home heating, privacy, transportation, and travel, while the lower and middle classes pay the price for this climate religion.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by joxel on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:15AM (#33670234)
I'm glad your name is realgenius, because I wouldn't have been able to tell by your comments.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by yucky on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:21AM (#33670892)
Not the person you're responding to, but they have a point. If it's not the main goal, are you saying it's just a happy coincidence?
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by DoctorOW on Saturday November 19, 2022 @08:57AM (#33670069)
It sucks because there's ultimately far more efficient ways to heat a home and the only reason they're not implemented is to try to force greater consumption.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by sokoloff on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:19AM (#33670267)
It’s not the only reason. I’m literally a mechanical engineer (by degree, not trade) and tried to get an air-to-water heat pump to replace my aging gas boiler.

Only one firm in the area could even quote me on one, tried to talk me out of it at every step, and gave me a quote that reinforced their sales pitch. It was literally never going to payback over a combi, which dozens of companies would be happy to install.

So, a fresh combi boiler sits on my wall (which is a good improvement over the old), but it also means that I don’t entertain the question again for another 15 years.

I was among the top 0.1% aware, educated, and motivated potential customers of a heat pump and it couldn’t happen.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by Brigand on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:35PM (#33673158)
Which region of the world do you live in? Also air-air and air-ground were not an option? These are more readily available.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by sokoloff on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:06PM (#33673459)
Cambridge, MA, USA.

Anything-to-air wasn’t going to work visually or for occupant comfort. I don’t want refrigeration linesets strung all over the outside, warts on a wall in each room, and after all that having less comfortable heat than hydronic. (On the plus side, it would give AC “for free” [in capital costs].)

Ground source was my first preference. I’m on a pretty small city lot and the well cost meant for an even longer payback period than an air-to-water heat pump.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by chii on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:33AM (#33670405)
one should not be heating the home, but the person. Have thermal underwear, or even one of those heated clothing (may be even battery powered).

Use an electric blanket, and wear an extra layer. This will use far less energy, than trying to warm up all of the air inside the home.

Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by realgeniushere on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:43AM (#33670505)
Let them wear coats, said the out of touch queen of the freezing peasants.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by jason-phillips on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:47AM (#33670536)
Great strategy to coax those intractable WFHers into the office.
Re:'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off the... by vinyl7 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:12AM (#33670806)
Reject modernity, return to monke