News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Rankings by soapboxrocket on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:56PM (#33642850)
He's got Granny Smith in the shit category, and this just reminds me of a funny story about dogs!

We had two corgis and my wife made all their meals by hand. Part of their diet was apples, but we found one of the corgis would almost always eat around the apple (usually just a cheap red apple) pieces and leave them for the other dog. Then one time Granny Smith apples were cheaper at the grocery store so that is what we purchased and provided. He ate them up!

Turns out the dog just didn't like the sweeter apples and wanted the tart tang of a good Granny Smith.

Re:Apple Rankings by KyleBerezin on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:15PM (#33644105)
My dog seems to prefer apples based purely on their crispiness.
Re:Apple Rankings by horsawlarway on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:20PM (#33644173)
Honestly - I think this list prioritizes basically just "sweetness" and "crispness" (despite his claimed categories) which is fine - those are generally appealing things for eating. That said - many of the apples in the "shit" category are fucking delicious.

There are days when I want a sweet, crisp apple, and there are days I have a serious hankering for a good ol' granny smith.

Even the classic Red Delicious - which gets a really tarnished name in current pop culture is actually a damn good apple... soft, slightly chewy, sweet - but not too sweet, a little hint of bitter in the skin - it's just a different experience than the super sweet, juicy apples that start to just taste like apple juice.

Then again - I really like apples, and I'm vaguely suspicious that the site maker just likes sugar water.

Re:Apple Rankings by skyyler on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:57PM (#33644704)
You might find this breakdown of popular american supermarket apples (in the context of pie):

https://www.seriouseats.com/the-food-lab-what-are-the-best-a...

Re:Apple Rankings by appleflaxen on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:25PM (#33645126)
That list is incomplete without honey crisp being listed
Re:Apple Rankings by johnbcoughlin on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:53PM (#33645499)
Without having tried it... honeycrisp would be very likely to make a terrible apple pie due to too much water and sweetness.
Re:Apple Rankings by ceejayoz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:16PM (#33646672)
A waste of money, too. They're 3-4x as expensive as the other apples here.
Re:Apple Rankings by ishjoh on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:24PM (#33645120)
I love Golden Delicious apples. To me they are the standard of what a green apple should taste like. Crisp and tart, truly an amazing apple. Rating on this site was a 33. I suspect you're right that sweet was the highest priority.

I also really like HoneyCrisp but I would rate it in the 70s, not the 90s.

Re:Apple Rankings by droopyEyelids on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:37PM (#33646132)
A golden delicious is neither crisp (mealy) nor tart (bland, watery)- are you thinking of Granny Smith?
Re:Apple Rankings by nl on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:57PM (#33646425)
> I love Golden Delicious apples. To me they are the standard of what a green apple should taste like.

Nor are Golden Delicious' green, so I guess they do mean Granny Smith

Re:Apple Rankings by mpol on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:05PM (#33647240)
Down here in the Netherlands most Golden Delicious are green, only seldom are they yellow. Mealy is when they are not saved well, more often they have a bit of bite. And juicy they are. It might differ per region.
Re:Apple Rankings by derac on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:39PM (#33647596)
I've had some spectacular Golden Delicious apples. I hypothesize that these otherwise mealy apples in the right condition have a soft pearish texture rather than a crisp cucumber-like one, but it is a fragile structure that degrades more rapidly.
Re:Apple Rankings by nine_k on Thursday November 17, 2022 @08:06PM (#33648428)
It very much depends on when and where you buy them.

Fresh, these are superb. After a week on a shelf, they get soft and a bit bland.

Re:Apple Rankings by jacobr1 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:40PM (#33645332)
> Even the classic Red Delicious

You are right about the flavor profile - but Red Delicious gets its bad rap from being mealy.

Now that might be due to historical transport and storage practices during the era when Red Delicious reigned supreme, in which case it is indeed a bad rap. But for me crispness is king and I remember eating mealy red delicious apples at school lunch and hating them. I had no problems with the apples my mother bought which were all sorts of non-Red-Delicious varities.

Re:Apple Rankings by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:05PM (#33646523)
I used to like red delicious as a kid and my perception is that they got worse over time. I still like the other apples I ate as a kid. So I don’t know if this is all in my mind or not.
Re:Apple Rankings by telchior on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:49PM (#33647067)
You're probably right, not sure how old you are but growers kept selectively breeding solely for appearance up to (I think) the 2010s.
Re:Apple Rankings by nine_k on Thursday November 17, 2022 @08:05PM (#33648408)
Appearance and shelf life. That's how an apple attracts a buyer on a store shelf.

Once you've bought grocery in a store, you're not going to return it if it's so-so but not outright dangerously rotten. And your choice of large stores nearby is limited, so you're not going to stop going to that store.

Re:Apple Rankings by throwaway675309 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:26PM (#33645978)
Even assuming the flavor of red delicious was at all palatable in any sense of the word, it's impossible to get past the fact that they have the tepid texture of water soaked pile of corrugated cardboard. I think you may be an outlier.
Re:Apple Rankings by shirleyquirk on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:31PM (#33646867)
They are, I was shocked to discover, delicious and crisp, but you have 30 seconds to eat them after picking before they turn into the horror you describe so eloquently.
Re:Apple Rankings by NBJack on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:54PM (#33647120)
This is most certainly the real culprit. There are undoubtedly markets where the Red Delicious lives up to its name. The rest of us end up with whatever freshness roulette is played by the local supplier; while I too have occasionally eaten a 'good' one, the number of times I end up with an abomination in my taste buds far outweighs it.
Re:Apple Rankings by Blackthorn on Thursday November 17, 2022 @07:56PM (#33648328)
Yeah, I even bought one from a local farmstand to see if they really were better fresh. Nope.
Re:Apple Rankings by olyjohn on Thursday November 17, 2022 @08:07PM (#33648437)
First apple I looked up was Red Delicious, just to see if they're ranked as badly as I think they are. "Coffee Grinds in a Leather Glove" is the tagline for that apple!
Re:Apple Rankings by nl on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:02PM (#33646485)
I love apples - even blogged about them once.

I agree with the assessment of Red Delicious - it's just garbage. Being fed them as a kid put me off apples for years. I don't mind the taste of them when cooked or something, but the floury nature of them when eaten fresh is just horrible.

I'd be interested in what you think of Jazz apples? To me they are somewhat similar to Red Delicious in taste but the crispness (is there a more crisp apple? I don't think so) makes them a much better experience.

Re:Apple Rankings by horsawlarway on Friday November 18, 2022 @09:15AM (#33655000)
Eh - I think the Red Delicious is a complicated apple. It's also hard to accurately judge because for a long time - it was one of the most propagated apples out there, and sadly - time matters a lot for this one. So unless you know they're coming from somewhere very close to you, it's probably too old for hand eating (although I still do it - I don't hate the texture).

It doesn't go bad quickly, but it certainly loses a lot of its luster very quickly off the tree. It gets progressively more mealy the longer it's been stored.

Which... is the second point - older Red Delicious don't make great hand eating apples because they've lost the texture appeal, but they make a really important part of things like apple tarts or pies. I certainly wouldn't recommend only a red delicious pie - since you basically end up with mush, but they really help hold together a pie when mixed in with other apples. I personally love a pie with 1 red delicious, 1 granny smith, and then 4 filler apples (honey crisp is easy to find and tasty - but I actually prefer Rome, since they're not as sweet).

Cut the Red Delicious and Granny Smith up more finely than the other 4, so they mix in well. A lot of recipes say things like "no mushy pies!" but that's not really right - what they mean is that the whole pie shouldn't just be mush, but having a little mush in there is critical - otherwise you end up with apple bricks between layers of pie crust, and it's just really lackluster. That Red Delicious in there is going to help soak up some of the water coming out of the other apples, and give a nice contrast to the firmness/tartness from the granny smith. Then the filler apples are there for sweetness/apple flavor.

Long story short - I've talked myself into making another apple pie this weekend...

Re:Apple Rankings by BoorishBears on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:28PM (#33647494)
The second to the top apple is listed for tartness isn't it?
Re:Apple Rankings by jonahx on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:59PM (#33644750)
Came here to say that this invalidates the entire list!

Great to see this as the top comment!

Re:Apple Rankings by Karawebnetwork on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:29PM (#33646023)
Red Delicious 25

Granny Smith 53

McIntosh 45

Cortland 24

Either I have never had a good apple or there is something off with this list and the review. Could it be they are using imported or out of season apples?

The comment section for Cortland is savage and honestly I agree with a lot of it.

Re:Apple Rankings by Derawk on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:27PM (#33646816)
Red Delicious was described as "mealy", which sounds like an out of season apple. The science behind long term storage of apples made it really common to have edible apples all year round but when critiquing you've got to take freshness into account.

This site has a comedy bend but with all the interest I'd love to see it embrace a rotten tomatoes kind of style (the critics vs. the masses).

Re:Apple Rankings by batiudrami on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:57PM (#33647783)
Every golden and red delicious apple I’ve ever had I would describe as “mealy” though. In Australia we don’t get many of these varieties but Pink Lady is my favourite so I’m tentatively happy to back this list in.
Re:Apple Rankings by Blackthorn on Thursday November 17, 2022 @07:57PM (#33648340)
I've had red deliciouses direct from the farmstand and they're mealy. They really are just bad.
Re:Apple Rankings by TylerE on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:49PM (#33649330)
Nothing says delicious like having to put that in the name, right?

Actually powerful people don’t go around saying how powerful and important they are. They don’t need to.

Re:Apple Rankings by mark-r on Friday November 18, 2022 @12:01AM (#33650575)
I've found that to be a universal truism in marketing. If your product is missing some important attribute, put it into the name. The power of suggestion overcomes reality. The Red Delicious apple is the very product that hammered this home for me.
Re:Apple Rankings by swasheck on Friday November 18, 2022 @05:14PM (#33663155)
apparently the red delicious was selectively bred for appearance over taste and texture according to an article (which i cannot find) i read a few years ago (and somehow retained this information).

now the darlings are, apparently, pink lady and honeycrisp, which are both excellent apples.

Re:Apple Rankings by LilBytes on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:32PM (#33646879)
I suspect the author of the website has no time for tart apples, seems there's a bias for sweetness.
Re:Apple Rankings by cvwright on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:22PM (#33649046)
I suspect the author has a sample size of one for some of these varietals. Some of these descriptions are… off.
Re:Apple Rankings by cvwright on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:21PM (#33649035)
That’s only because you have terrible taste in apples. :)

Seriously though, who rates Braeburn at 73 and Cortland at 24? They’re really not that different if you get them fresh.

It sounds like they found their test Cortlands in a wet bag behind a dumpster.

Re:Apple Rankings by matwood on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:00PM (#33644771)
Dogs are as unique as people :)

All 3 of my dogs love love love bananas. To the point where they can be dead asleep and they wake up from the sound of peeling the banana. My guess is they all would have preferred the sweeter apples over the tart ones.

Re:Apple Rankings by jamiek88 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:32PM (#33646073)
I had a dog who loved watermelon. She was a (rescue) pug too so you can image the mess she made of that.

Even on her deathbed, literal hours before crossing the bridge, she still managed a little.

(Wow, I’m 45, it’s been nearly 5 years and I suddenly started crying after writing that. Goddamn I miss that dog. RIP Lucy.)

Re:Apple Rankings by matwood on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:13PM (#33646624)
No explanation needed. We have 3 frenchies - also rescues. People get them, realize their vets bills are insane, and then dump them off. They are also a big breed in puppy mills that get shut down. We have spent an inordinate amount of money on frenchies over the years (we've had 5 - not at the same time, but 2 died prematurely from health issues), but these dogs didn't chose be here, and deserve a good life.
Re:Apple Rankings by LilBytes on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:35PM (#33646908)
You're both doing incredible work. It's heart breaking losing a dog, it's raw for me now currently I'm still in the crying-almost-daily-stage.

Not too dissimilar to me, though I don't often go breed specific but age. I've foster failed a few dogs in the last two years. I lost my recent foster fail Buster on the 2nd of November and I only got him back from the crematorium yesterday. It's been a rough few days, this home has only ever been a home with Buster in it and it's been dreadfully empty with his passing. I cry every day I see something that reminds me of him.

Baby gates that stop him going up and down stairs because of his artiritis. His dog beds in each room. Food bowls. His blankets. Coming home or getting out of bed and him not being there to howl at me. It's truly dreadful.

Buster was 14.5 years old when he passed and was 13 yo when I got home. The day I picked him up I had no idea he was his age, didn't believe it. He was a Husky X Boxer so I could only imagine what he was like as a puppy considering his appetite for movement at 13 yo when he was effectively 100+ in human years.

https://imgur.com/gallery/WtLy4ZN/comment/2279131045

I want to wait a while before fostering or adopting again but... I'm getting warn down by all the dogs that are needing a home from the groups I volunteer and donate to. I'm doom scrolling dogs in need daily.

Re:Apple Rankings by jamiek88 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:49PM (#33647061)
Oh lilbytes,

My heart goes out to you.

I know exactly how you feel my only advice is to do your best to let those feelings come. Wallow a little. Feel and experience your grief.

Locking it away doesn’t work and the tears will become fond smiles in time.

Wishing you peace.

Re:Apple Rankings by matwood on Friday November 18, 2022 @08:53AM (#33654667)
I'm so sorry. I feel for you and don't have any advice to give. Reading your post and looking at the pictures of Buster have me tearing up.

I've often wondered what makes our bonds with dogs so tight. I often joke with my partner that I wish she looked at me like one of our dogs does.

It's a reminder to show the people and animals around you how much you care about them everyday.

When you're ready, the next dog that finds you will be lucky find a person who cares so much.

Re:Apple Rankings by swyx on Thursday November 17, 2022 @05:27PM (#33646813)
you can listen to him rant about the Granny Smith at the end of this interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zohlRKE49wo pretty funny

“Granny Smith apple”

“Oh boy... Alright you just made a mistake”

Re:Apple Rankings by josefdlange on Thursday November 17, 2022 @07:22PM (#33648021)
I have a corgi and that tracks for me. To people who don't have corgs, they're sweet kind friendly cute delicate beautiful creatures. The those of us who have been blessed with corgs in our lives, we know they're really the Frank Reynolds of dogs. And I love my corg for it. She's a trash dog, a scrappy little scamp, and knows that everyone else she meets will never, ever know it.
Re:Apple Rankings by jojobas on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:24PM (#33649063)
All of their top picks are red, and the two I've tried are too sweet and bland at the same time.

I'll pick a Granny Smith any day over any red apple, the authors of this "ranking" appear quite arrogant in their pretentiousness.

Then again, I eat lemons whole so what do I know.

Re:Apple Rankings by TylerE on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:50PM (#33649341)
Their 3rd highest rated apple is incredibly sour.
Re:Apple Rankings by jojobas on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:23PM (#33649676)
Seems to only be available half a year from now where I am, will try to remember.
Re:Apple Rankings by reportingsjr on Friday November 18, 2022 @08:13AM (#33654075)
I absolutely love sour foods, to the point of drinking straight up lemon juice when I was younger. I eat a granny smith apple probably every other day, and the more sour the better. Yet, my S.O. recoils at the thought of eating granny smiths. I wonder why people have such varied responses when it comes to sour foods.
Re:Apple Rankings by fennecfoxy on Friday November 18, 2022 @10:55AM (#33656538)
Also Braeburn is mediocre?!?1