News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @04:59PM (#33554069)
I suspect this is the real problem.

Stupid people with money can look like they are clever because the layer of people immediately underneath them actually wields the clue stick.

Stupid people with no money look stupid because they can't afford the layer of clever people underneath them.

Clever people are either abstracting the liability via stupid person in the layer above them or don't need that kind of shit in their lives and are just getting on with designing and building products with the other clever people around them.

Edit: I'd just like to note that I am recognising the work that Tesla and SpaceX engineers and staff do which the PR baboon up the top somehow gets credit for every time.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by joshstrange on Thursday November 10, 2022 @05:49PM (#33554735)
Yep, it's a whole class of equating X thing with being "virtuous" (or similar). Your height, your sex, your weight, your hairline, your income/savings, etc. It's uncomfortable to talk about or admit but people regularly take controllable (or uncontrollable) traits and assign value to them even though it doesn't have any actual bearing.

"Oh that billionaire did something that seems odd/crazy to me? Well he must know something I don't else how would be be a billionaire!" - Yeah, that's not how things work. What's the line? "Past performance is not indicative of future results", paraphrasing it: "Past advantages are not indicative of future results". Very, very few "self-made million/billionaires" are anything of the sort. I'm not saying their lives have never been hard or that they have never worked hard at something but I think you'd find that, at scale, most people would succeed if put into that position (from birth, which is why this is near-impossible to prove).

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @05:55PM (#33554805)
Indeed. My father said it this way, rather well: there are many more failed assholes than successful assholes. Do not attribute success to being an asshole.

Incidentally he was a failed asshole. All his staff deserted him and watched his business burn to the ground. Perhaps ironically a big fan of Musk too.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by selcuka on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:49PM (#33555972)
> Indeed. My father said it this way, rather well: there are many more failed assholes than successful assholes. Do not attribute success to being an asshole.

I don't know. There are also many more failed nice people than successful nice people. We don't have hard stats, so the success/failure ratio for assholes could actually be higher.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @08:12PM (#33556141)
That’s why I’m an asshole/nice centrist :)
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by fallingknife on Thursday November 10, 2022 @05:59PM (#33554857)
> most people would succeed if put into that position (from birth, which is why this is near-impossible to prove).

It's actually very easy to disprove. There are 22 million millionaires in the US. There are 720 billionaires. That gives you a 0.003% chance of going from millionaire tier to billionaire.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by joshstrange on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:18PM (#33555051)
I don't believe that actually is what I was talking about or that you can use those numbers in the way you are. Your success in life is made up of a lot of different and hard to quantify or even qualify things. I'm talking about being able to go back in time knowing what X person has accomplished and replacing them with Y number of people doing different "runs through life". I'm postulating that the majority of them would end up in very similar positions at the end. Also it's impossible since even if we had the ability to do this (outside a simulation... maybe) the ethics of it are all wrong. Heck if you could actually simulate it there would still be ethical ramifications. If you can simulate full human consciousness how can you ever, ethically, turn off the machine or subject people to even simulated pain/poverty/sickness/etc? I digress.

Those numbers don't indicate your chance of going from millionaire to billionaire. How many of those millionaires became millionaires later in life instead of being born one? How many of those billionaires started as millionaires? You'd need instead a study of hundreds of billionaires that started as millionaires then compare them the the number of "peer millionaires" that were born around the same time. Even so it's the "experiment" I'm proposing. Maybe I should have left millionaires out of it completely because even though we throw around things like "millionaires/billionaire" they are very different. You can be a millionaire from your 401K, your 401K will never make you a billionaire (unless inflation really gets out of hand).

For myself it's very easy to look at all the advantages I've had in life and see how they led to the "success" I have today. I have/have had friends/coworkers who I perceive as being just as hard working, just as smart, etc as me who aren't doing as well due to not having the same advantages, I see the opposite as well.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by triceratops on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:10PM (#33557227)
> You can be a millionaire from your 401K, your 401K will never make you a billionaire

Fun fact: Peter Thiel's IRA made him a billionaire.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by mistermann on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:46PM (#33555339)
> Yep, it's a whole class of equating X thing with being "virtuous" (or similar). Your height, your sex, your weight, your hairline, your income/savings, etc. It's uncomfortable to talk about or admit but people regularly take controllable (or uncontrollable) traits and assign value to them even though it doesn't have any actual bearing.

Reality can be hallucinated in either direction.

What it actually "is" here, is unknown. But the mind seems to abhor a vacuum so secretly fills it with simulated data. Presumably this had some historic evolutionary benefit, but whether it is still a benefit in 2022 seems questionable.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by jackmott42 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @05:57PM (#33554824)
It would be a remarkable bit of luck that Elon stumbled into both Tesla and SpaceX, took on the role of lead rocket designer at spaceX, built both companies into unlikely leaders in their industry with powerful people trying to crush them all the way, while being a total idiot.

A similar but more charitable theory is that Elon is very good at leading a company to build actual hardware that has to solve hard physics problems. At twitter the primary challenge is managing people, and he is autistic and has no idea how to do this. He has no idea how normal people experience or use twitter, no idea how his tweets are felt by people, no idea how his employees feel about him etc.

all of these are things that don't matter when building a rocket or a car, while understanding people and politics is the ONLY thing that matters at twitter.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by joshstrange on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:24PM (#33555113)
> It would be a remarkable bit of luck that Elon stumbled into both Tesla and SpaceX, took on the role of lead rocket designer at spaceX

If Elon can understand even half of how "his" rockets work I'd eat my hat. I'm not talking about in layman's terms, I'm talking about the actual science that goes into it. Same deal with car design. I'll give Elon props for having a vision and pushing it forward but let's not say ridiculous things like "lead rocket designer at spaceX". That's like thinking Tim Cook could write a line of Swift if his life depended on it or that Zuck knows more than a surface level of how FB's tech works. I don't exactly begrudge them for that (I won't get into profit sharing, or the lack there of at most companies) but let's not pretend that Elon is himself coming up with revolutionary ideas. Putting his money behind this is laudable, at some level, but he didn't invent these things any more than Steve Jobs "invented" the iPhone.

We here on HN should know better than most how "worthless" an idea is on it's own. It's about execution. And Elon gets props for his execution (in this case hiring people who did the real work) but he shouldn't get all the credit for the work of the actual engineers.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:44PM (#33555314)
> If Elon can understand even half of how "his" rockets work I'd eat my hat.

Bon appétit!

> When I met Elon it was apparent to me that although he had a scientific mind and he understood scientific principles, he did not know anything about rockets. Nothing. That was in 2001. By 2007 he knew everything about rockets - he really knew everything, in detail. You have to put some serious study in to know as much about rockets as he knows now. This doesn't come just from hanging out with people.

Robert Zubrin - aerospace engineer

> Elon is brilliant. He’s involved in just about everything. He understands everything. If he asks you a question, you learn very quickly not to go give him a gut reaction.

He wants answers that get down to the fundamental laws of physics. One thing he understands really well is the physics of the rockets. He understands that like nobody else. The stuff I have seen him do in his head is crazy.

He can get in discussions about flying a satellite and whether we can make the right orbit and deliver Dragon at the same time and solve all these equations in real time. It’s amazing to watch the amount of knowledge he has accumulated over the years.

Kevin Watson - Head of Avionics, Launcher

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/k1e0ta/eviden...

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by joshstrange on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:55PM (#33555421)
Fair enough, I stand corrected. I guess I expected more from someone who is actually an engineer. Like to be smart enough to see WFH isn't some evil thing (and if instead it's a move to get people to leave on their own then he is just an asshole, I mean he is a well established asshole/troll, it would just further cement that legacy).

My hat is old and pretty gross though so instead I hope you'll accept a donation to the EFF: https://cs.joshstrange.com/xVwcRY

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:31PM (#33555812)
Hat's off (ha!) for your admission. When encountering the same scenario on Reddit, people there invariably just double down in the face of undeniable facts. A donation to the EFF is more than enough. I was actually going to just let you off the hook based on your honest response and strengthening my faith in HN:)

As for WFH, for some perspective, Apple, Google (and others) asks their employees to come back to the office this year. Is management there stupid too? I think a more nuanced view is there are significant pros and cons to WFH and Musk decided that the cons outweigh in this case.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by joshstrange on Thursday November 10, 2022 @08:01PM (#33556054)
> Apple, Google (and others) asks their employees to come back to the office this year. Is management there stupid too?

I do and I've consistently voiced that opinion no matter the CEO/company. I don't think they think it is stupid, I know they have their reasons. I disagree with their reasons, I think there is more at play than only logical thinking on this point (real estate, asses in chair, etc), and I think it's shortsighted. WFH is an amazing perk and while I get not everyone wants it there are a large number of people who do and to cut off that entire group is incredibly short-sighted.

It's fine though, I'll never work for any of those companies, I have zero desire to do so, I much prefer smaller companies that understand WFH. Though I'd make 1 exception I think, for Apple, to gut and replace App Store Connect/The Developer Portal or at least have better feedback/errors/displaying the current state (which is a common complaint I have with Apple when their software needs to talk to server, the feedback is always lackluster or non-existent). Those websites look broken and/or are confusing/vague way too often. At least the Google Play dev console is so busy and incoherent that you'd not notice most issues. Though props to the Google Play devs for making apk/aab upload/release errors as confusing as possible in most cases :chefs-kiss:

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lazyasciiart on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:12AM (#33557516)
Apple at least has always been bizarre about work conditions and anti-WFH, so that seems expected.

It seems optimistic to think that Musk made a careful decision based on nuanced factors that just happened to have exactly the same outcome as every other company he owns.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by seadan83 on Friday November 11, 2022 @02:46AM (#33558226)
In Elon's case, and WFH, it is really hard to know whether he is trying to prove a point or if he has "playing 3d chess" decision making going on

The man loves proving a point, and "covid is stupid" is one of them

So, very ambiguous whether this is a reasoned move or or something more emotional and ego driven

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @02:58AM (#33558292)
I don't think he's trying to prove a point or play 3D chess. I think it's much simpler. He's basing his decision on his beliefs about and experience with in-office vs WFH. He believes in-office is more productive.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by seadan83 on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:31PM (#33566386)
I would postulate the belief in-office is more productive is somewhat akin to 3d chess. AFAIK the data is mixed and I've seen some data that suggests WFH is more productive (but the jury certainly still seems TBD on this debate)
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:29PM (#33555789)
Having worked with a lot of intelligent engineers (mostly EE) I would suggest that they are no more capable of making rational business decisions than anyone else.

The only thing I really took from the experience is to learn from other people’s mistakes because it hurts less than learning from your own.

My take home is that you should use a proper decision analysis framework for issues like this to test your own biases, reasonings and criteria. Sometimes your conclusion is not what you expected. Much pain saved.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by stephen_g on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:17PM (#33556930)
It's not an intelligence thing (yes, he's not a genius but that's not to say he's not very intelligent and has some deep technical knowledge in some areas) - I think the thing is that Musk has generally demonstrated poor judgement and low ethics in many areas (think Solar City acquisition, tweets leading to SEC legal action, Thai cave diver slur, some of the cryptocurrency stuff, now this whole Twitter thing, etc.).

People expect intelligence to lead to good judgement but I'm more and more convinced that (assuming a decent baseline of intelligence) they're fairly separate and unconnected things.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by agumonkey on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:08PM (#33568491)
Rest assured, it's very confusing to see him act so stupidly with this twitter event. I have difficulties wrapping my head around the spacex-smart vs twitter-fool contrast. I guess he doesn't use the same part of his brain on these two topics.. i'm sure he was sharper because tesla/spacex were hardscience dreams of his, whereas twitter is just "i've succeeded twice, let's just handwave that thing"
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lupire on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:06PM (#33555555)
Guys who works at a company where Elon fires productive people who say a wrong word in an elevator ride, say Elon is as great as Elon thinks he is.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:40PM (#33555893)
This is the kind of response I expect on Reddit not here. To me it is indicative of being influenced more by personal by bias than facts and rationality.

To answer your point though, Zubrin does not and never has worked for any of Musk's companies. Watson did work at SpaceX 8 years ago, but works somewhere else now so he has nothing to lose or gain from Musk.

And here is an account of a top NASA engineering official's interactions with Musk who also has never worked for Musk.

> He dispatched one of his lieutenants, Liam Sarsfield, then a high-ranking NASA official in the office of the chief engineer, to California to see whether the company was for real or just another failure in waiting.

Most of all, he was impressed with Musk, who was surprisingly fluent in rocket engineering and understood the science of propulsion and engine design. Musk was intense, preternaturally focused, and extremely determined. “This was not the kind of guy who was going to accept failure,” Sarsfield remembered thinking.

Throughout the day, as Musk showed off mockups of the Falcon 1 and Falcon 5, the engine designs, and plans to build a spacecraft capable of flying humans, Musk peppered Sarsfield with questions. He wanted to know what was going on within NASA. And how a company like his would be perceived. He asked tons of highly technical questions, including a detailed discussion about “base heating,” the heat radiating out from the exhaust going back up into the rocket’s engine compartment—a particular problem with rockets that have clusters of engines next to one another, as Musk was planning to build.

Now that he had a friend inside of NASA, Musk kept up with the questions in the weeks after Sarsfield’s visit, firing off “a nonstop torrent of e-mails” and texts, Sarsfield said. Musk jokingly warned that texting was a “core competency.” “He sends texts in a constant flow,” Sarsfield recalled. “I found him to be consumed by whatever was in front of him and anxious to solve problems. This, combined with a tendency to work eighteen hours a day, is a sign of someone driven to succeed.” Musk was particularly interested in the docking adapter of the International Space Station, the port where the spacecraft his team was designing would dock. He wanted to know the dimensions, the locking pin design, even the bolt pattern of the hatch. The more documents Sarsfield sent, the more questions Musk had.

“I really enjoyed the way he would pore over problems anxious to absorb every detail. To my mind, someone that clearly committed deserves all the support and help you can give him.”

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/k1e0ta/eviden...

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @04:54AM (#33558827)
Not parent nor have I contributed to this thread in anyway beside this post, but I have to say for someone who so easily accuse others of having personal bias you seem to be really deeply invested into proving how great Elon is. Your messages in this entire subthread add essentially nothing beside quote without context about how great and smart Elon is.

In an era where online manipulation is becoming ubiquitous, when talking about someone who has a clear ego issue and the desperate need to be seen as awesome (to the point he has several cases of acting against his best interest just to protect his ego, across several companies), and in the context of that person acquiring one the platform most forward in the whole social media space that pushed those issues forward... I find that interesting.

I am not accusing you of anything, I'm merely saying your messages have the opposite result on me than the one you intend.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by panick21_ on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:39PM (#33563929)
Many people who are in fact awesome have egos. Anybody who follows sports knows this.

Elon as a person certainty has lots of flaws, but he is also quite clearly really good at a lot of things people who try to downplay that and claim its all 'luck' or 'failing upwards' usually just don't like his personality.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:40PM (#33564847)
> Your messages in this entire subthread add essentially nothing beside quote without context about how great and smart Elon is.

That's not true. I invite you to read my messages again and not that I've made 5 comments, all of them timestamped before yours, and only in 2 of them have I referenced quotes.

> add essentially nothing beside quote without context

A commenter claimed that Musk did not understand rocketry. I supplied quotes from industry experts declaring the opposite. What more context is needed?

I'm not a fanboy and have anything invested in proving how great he is. Personally, I think he can be a big jerk at times and at others brilliant. The issue I'm trying to address that I see over and over again are the false claims that Musk has no idea what he is doing technically and steals credit from the engineers he hires.

When I see a ubiquitous false claim that is easy disproven in 3 minutes with a Google search and copy and paste, then why not? I believe HN is a place where truth and reason are valued and misinformation corrected, so I think my comments and references have been valuable in that respect and apparently so do the 30+ people that have upvoted my first comment with the quotes even though they are "without context."

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lupire on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:21PM (#33566273)
I believe is Musk is as technically skilled and capable as the average or above average engineer, and certainly as the above average billionaire. I believe he can read up on things and carry on intelligent conversations. I believe he can impress people who aren't used to strangers even trying to understand technical issues.

I don't believe he is solving any substantial technical problems at SpaceX or "designing rockets" himself.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @04:25PM (#33567077)
> people who aren't used to strangers even trying to understand technical issues.

Do you think this describes Zubrin, Watson, Sarsfield or the other experts in the reddit post I referenced?

> I don't believe he is solving any substantial technical problems at SpaceX or "designing rockets" himself.

Thanks for sharing your belief. What would be interesting and add more to the discussion is if you shared the basis for your belief. Perhaps you'll teach me something I didn't know and I can recalibrate my knowledge about Musk's expertise or lack thereof.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:34PM (#33568242)
Also, the reason I suspect personal bias in the comment I replied to us because of how low effort and fallacious it was.

They claimed the people I referenced were Musk's employees and therefore said those things to kiss his ass get to get on his good side and avoid being fired.

This so blatantly false and easy to disapprove. Most of them weren't ever employees and none of them are current employees of Musk. When someone grasps at falsehoods like this in an attempt to discredit others, it naturally raises suspicions as to their motives.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by bee_rider on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:09PM (#33555584)
> He wants answers that get down to the fundamental laws of physics. One thing he understands really well is the physics of the rockets. He understands that like nobody else. The stuff I have seen him do in his head is crazy.

This seems like a weird thing to highlight, to me. Like, I don’t know anything about rockets, but we all know a bit about CPU design here, right? If someone said that Tim Cook really knew his stuff and wanted answers about the M1 that got down the the fundamental laws of physics, we’d probably say — well, that’s pretty stupid, right?

You’d have to talk about thing like pipeline stages, decoder width, memory bandwidth, branch prediction — obviously these parts have to follow the fundamental laws of physics but that isn’t really the interesting part. Fundamental physical limits aren’t the bottleneck yet.

Maybe rockets science is just much easier but that seems surprising to me, given the expression.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by Animats on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:22PM (#33555726)
"This seems like a weird thing to highlight, to me."

Classic NASA. Read Gene Kranz's "Failure is not an option".

In rocketry you're usually up against physical limits. You need materials near the limits of physical strength and temperature resistance. You need fuels near the limits of energy density. And still you're launching with a payload to destination that's maybe 5% of the mass, if you're lucky. Which is why rocketry has to obsess on weight reduction.

If fuels were 2x as powerful, or gravity was 1/2 as much, this would be easy. A spacecraft would have the weight budget and safety margins of an airliner.

If earth's gravity were somewhat greater, you'd never make it to orbit with chemical fuels.

This is the tyranny of the rocket equation.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by bee_rider on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:56AM (#33560250)
But the most interesting thing about his rockets, that they land, which enables a totally different economic proposition, is in direct defiance of this sort of physical limitations first way of looking at the problem. It would clearly be more efficient fuel-wise to not do a controlled landing, right?
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by Animats on Friday November 11, 2022 @11:54AM (#33563240)
Yes, and that costs some payload. That tradeoff is right up against the limits of what's physically possible. How Space-X does landings is quite different than most VTOL landings, which are slow and careful. The boosters approach fast, and then blast at 2G just before landing. Fuel is spent almost entirely to get rid of kinetic energy, not to fight gravity while hovering. That rather drastic solution makes it possible.

I'm not a huge Musk fan, but he does seem to get the physics of rocketry.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nerderloo on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:20AM (#33557557)
Market disruption is the key difference. We now know how CPU operate and it's almost taken as a commodity.

Before Telsa, nobody thoughts electric cars were ready for road. Before SpaceX, I don't think anyone tried reusable rocket thingy. The thing is when you come up with a radically new idea, you have to know enough about it to convince others to work on it.

Steve Jobs knew enough about computer(and general idea of programming) to sell it, and Bill Gates was once a good programmer. Intel, nVidia founder were also chip engineers.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:32AM (#33558447)
It seems to me to really understand rock science, you need to know physics.

As you state, that is not the case for CPU design.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:00PM (#33555485)
Stupidity is not necessarily a lack of intelligence, but also a lack of common sense. He's clearly intelligent. Some of the most intelligent people I've ever known are quite frankly the most stupid and dangerous with actions conceptually and verbally.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nobleach on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:08PM (#33555573)
Actually Zuck has a tremendously strong understanding of how his system works. He used to geek out explaining pieces of it. Obviously it's grown but let's not let our personal feelings (for someone we've likely never met) cloud reality.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by jodrellblank on Thursday November 10, 2022 @08:00PM (#33556047)
> or that Zuck knows more than a surface level of how FB's tech works

How about in 2016 where he built an home control AI and iPhone app with voice recognition for it using Facebook tech?

"I had to reverse engineer APIs for some of these to even get to the point where I could issue a command from my computer to turn the lights on or get a song to play."

"As the CEO of Facebook, I don't get much time to write code in our internal environment. I've never stopped coding, but these days I mostly build personal projects like Jarvis. I expected I'd learn a lot about the state of AI this year, but I didn't realize I would also learn so much about what it's like to be an engineer at Facebook. And it's impressive. My experience of ramping up in the Facebook codebase is probably pretty similar to what most new engineers here go through. I was consistently impressed by how well organized our code is, and how easy it was to find what you're looking for -- whether it's related to face recognition, speech recognition, the Messenger Bot Framework or iOS development. The open source Nuclide packages we've built to work with GitHub's Atom make development much easier. The Buck build system we've developed to build large projects quickly also saved me a lot of time. Our open source FastText AI text classification tool is also a good one to check out, and if you're interested in AI development, the whole Facebook Research GitHub repo is worth taking a look at."

https://m.facebook.com/notes/mark-zuckerberg/building-jarvis...

(You can argue that's still "surface level because he didn't build those things" but it won't be a very interesting argument)

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:03PM (#33554898)
This is true. The answer is actually that he's a liar / marketer.

Colonise Mars? It's never going to happen. But you'll win defence and commercial contracts on the way as a side effect.

Saving the future with electric cars? It's never going to happen. But you'll sell a lot of luxury cars as a side effect.

Saving free speech with Twitter? It's never going to happen. But you'll pacify the SEC dogs snarling at your door after you fucked up.

His pitch is changing the world. His reality is not really improving it measurably.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by kristianc on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:52PM (#33555397)
> This is true. The answer is actually that he's a liar / marketer.

People who have a hard time understanding and empathising with other people tend to make extraordinarily bad marketers, actually.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:53PM (#33555409)
He's learning that right now.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by crmd on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:33PM (#33555205)
Elon Musk is a lead rocket designer like Donald Trump is a real estate magnate.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by panick21_ on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:41PM (#33563951)
Who was lead engineer on Falcon 1?
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:48PM (#33555359)
> Stupid people with money can look like they are clever

I get it, some people hate Elon’s guts and equally hate Elon fans. I also think that it’s pretty well established that he has a range of character flaws that really hurt him and threaten his future success. However, anyone who insinuates that Elon is stupid needs to establish how a genuinely stupid person could found two successful dot coms and then hire all the brilliant engineers that have made his subsequent companies so successful against such odds and become the world’s richest person. Luck and debatable opinions about his alleged wealthy upbringing cannot explain this. Even assuming all the highly debatable opinions about his technical contributions any reasonable observer must admit he is at least a genius at hiring the right people to achieve his vision and then avoiding getting in their way enough to make enormous inroads and sell it all brilliantly. I am far from an Elon fan but I couldn’t hope to achieve 5% of what he has.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by stormbrew on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:02PM (#33555502)
If someone wins the lottery, does that mean "they're a genius at picking numbers?" How many people with musk's starting wealth have started businesses? Do you think every single one of them is less of a genius than he is?

Musk's success story is just anecdata, as almost all wealth stories are.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by ckw on Thursday November 10, 2022 @08:26PM (#33556221)
If someone wins the lottery repeatedly (Zip2, X.com/Paypal, SpaceX, Tesla, Neuralink, The Boring Company) I'd entertain the possibility that they weren't just 'picking numbers'.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nsonha on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:23PM (#33556596)
only Paypal & SpaceX though, the rest may fail, Neuralink & The Boring Company are merely hype at this point. Tesla will face a lot of competition in years to come and now it has no novelty factor.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:42PM (#33556728)
> Tesla will face a lot of… in years to come

Every hitherto successful enterprise might fail due to future conditions but Tesla getting us from essentially zero to a competitive mass produced electric car market is already a historic achievement.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by seadan83 on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:20AM (#33558397)
Isn't the Chevy volt or the Prius the cars that went from essentially zero to mass production?

Curious about this claim, Tesla introduced the model S and in 2012 it was roughly 25% of the EV market (22k of about 90). For the next two years, EV sales doubled while tesla sales grew by 50%. The next year tesla and overall ev growth by went up by about 50%

Source: https://backlinko.com/tesla-stats and googling "how many EVs sold in year X"

Is going from 70k ev to 90k the same as going from zero to mass production? It was for tesla (very much so), but not the overall EV market. Then selling 30k put of 180k the ne xt year, seems like the scaling up is not complet6due to tesla. Though tesla recently is pushing about 2/3 of EV sales and recently was at 75% (source => googled: percent EVs sold in 2022 by brand)

The idea single handedly brought about the EV industry seems not to be supported by this data. Namely the growth in EV sales outpaced the growth of Tesla sales and in this early days Tesla was not an overwhelming percentage of the market (though recently it is).

My inference here is Musk had good timing for market fit, he made a lot more people aware of EVs (cultural change), and he scaled up production to a high mark recently achieved. All of which is commendable. Though the comment of "zero to nothing" applies (from what I see) only to Tesla itself and not the broader EV market (which is still quite an achievement, and the actual broader impacts are as well)

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:47PM (#33568359)
> Isn't the Chevy volt or the Prius the cars that went from essentially zero to mass production?

The Chevy volt never got up to mass production territory as they never broke 25000 per year [1] whereas >100,000 model 3 and model y are each being produced per quarter. [2] That's a respectable mass production volume if not record breaking amongst all cars. The Prius is a hybrid car so it's not in the same category.

> Tesla introduced the model S and in 2012 it was roughly 25% of the EV market (22k of about 90)

The Model S and X are not mass-production models.

> Is going from 70k ev to 90k the same as going from zero to mass production?

They increased the number of EVs produced to truly mass-production volume. The difficulty going from a few thousand per quarter sold at a high price to >100,000s sold at an affordable price is a huge leap.

1. https://gmauthority.com/blog/gm/chevrolet/volt/chevrolet-vol... 2. https://cleantechnica.com/2022/10/02/tesla-quarterly-sales-c...

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by seadan83 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @03:27PM (#33576692)
The tesla sales numbers also include their hybrid offerings?

I suppose it is a matter of opinion whether 25k constitutes "mass production" or not.

Seemingly Tesla did not break that threshold for 5 years. The OP I took to imply that tesla drove production of _all_ EVs from roughly zero to large scale. The data I'm seeing still does not support that claim. Within Tesla, yes, but globally, no.

Eg: While significant, tesla was not more than 20% of global EVs sold (in recent years) [1].

Tesla's are still expensive too? 2023 models look to start at $70k to $110k

It's not clear to me where our apples are turning into oranges since the different delivery numbers do not line up (perhaps hybrid vs not, perhaps pre-order and sold vs built - not sure)

Regardless, the [2] citation says of the response above states: "Clearly, the production and sales ramp in the second half of 2018 is the first big, noticeable bump in Tesla’s output."

The time frame is very significant as it alludes to whether Tesla was the reason for EV growth from zero, or if they are a significant (but not sole) part of a larger trend.

Quick google has 3M EVs sold in 2019, compared to tesla selling 10% of that. The rest of the car industry was not dormant.

I do agree though that going from 1k's to 100k's is a big leap. The fact it is in the same general ballpark as F150s is remarkable. The rub though is that happened over 10 years, mostly over the last 5 and during a period where absent tesla there was still very strong YoY sales growth of EVs

In sum, is Tesla the birth of EVs? No, but it is nonetheless a significant and remarkable part.

[1] https://www.ev-volumes.com

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by andrewem on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:37PM (#33556685)
Without commenting on the others, the Wikipedia article for Neuralink seems to say it’s taken a ton of funding but failed to make any big improvements in the science or technology, and without even reaching initial human trials. The Boring Company built “a single-lane underground roadway less than a mile long, driven by conventional Tesla automobiles, constructed at a total cost of $48 million” (see the Wikipedia article for it).

I don’t see how either of those can be considered winning the lottery, to use your phrase.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:44PM (#33556740)
Ok he only won the lottery four times in a row then. The chances of doing that is utterly minuscule.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by xdfgh1112 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:13AM (#33559331)
Thanks for your contributions btw. I don't like Musk, but suggesting he is talentless or just lucky is asinine Reddit-level commenting and it's good to see it called out.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by panick21_ on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:49PM (#33564082)
Neuralink is trying something that amazingly difficult and many medical companies, specially those working in something as complex as operating on the human brain are not expected to launch a product within a year or two.

> The Boring Company

The Boring company if sold today would likely make more money then most lottery winners get.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by wstuartcl on Friday November 11, 2022 @11:15PM (#33569882)
Maybe, but who is in the market for a parking lot?
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by stormbrew on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:50PM (#33556770)
Winning the lottery once increases your ability to win it in the future because you can (if you want) buy more tickets. Success creates conditions for more success in pretty mundane ways.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by kortilla on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:50PM (#33557129)
If someone wins the lottery 4 different times buying only like 10 tickets in their whole life, you better fucking believe something special is going on there.

>How many people with musk's starting wealth have started businesses? Do you think every single one of them is less of a genius than he is?

Who are you talking about? Tesla and SpaceX dominate the markets they operate in. He didn’t take some family wealth and just maintain it with a business. He grew multiple companies from sub million dollar values to hundreds of billions.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by stormbrew on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:46AM (#33557688)
> buying only like 10 tickets in their whole life

Did he reset his wealth, connections, etc. between each of those 'tickets'? No. Each one was built off the previous success. Without paypal there is no tesla (or at least not involving him). Without tesla there is no spacex. These are not independent events in the way that lottery ticket wins are. The analogy is not perfect, but the way it falls apart is not favourable to your interpretation.

And we will never know if those companies would have succeeded or been created without him. We can't test the counterfactual. His success is only evident in hindsight and the only proof that it's somehow unique to him is the fact that it happened.

> Who are you talking about? Tesla and SpaceX dominate the markets they operate in. He didn’t take some family wealth and just maintain it with a business. He grew multiple companies from sub million dollar values to hundreds of billions.

The claim here is that Musk is uniquely intelligent and that somehow explains his outsized success. That implies the people who don't have his success are not as smart as he is.

Unless... perhaps... there's more to this than intelligence or hard work.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by kortilla on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:09AM (#33558341)
> Did he reset his wealth, connections, etc. between each of those 'tickets'? No.

More or less yes. Read up on how close spacex and Tesla came to imploding at the same time.

> Without tesla there is no spacex.

You’re confused about the timelines there.

> These are not independent events in the way that lottery ticket wins are. The analogy is not perfect, but the way it falls apart is not favourable to your interpretation.

Again, you think it was just PayPal doubled down to Tesla, which then somehow turned into a war chest for SpaceX or whatever. Tesla and SpaceX happened in parallel, spacex didn’t get help from Tesla, and both ran out of money from PayPal.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by panick21_ on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:47PM (#33564052)
> Did he reset his wealth, connections, etc. between each of those 'tickets'? No.

So because he once made 23 million. Making 23 billion $ is not impressive?

> And we will never know if those companies would have succeeded or been created without him.

Tesla had his money but not his leadership and was run straight into the ground. Musk took over and now its making almost the same amount of money as Toyota.

> Without tesla there is no spacex.

What? This isn't accurate.

> And we will never know if those companies would have succeeded or been created without him.

There is a long history of rocket startup before and after him. And non are SpaceX. Most failed. Beal Aerospace being a good example. There was a company called Rocketplane Kistler that could have been SpaceX but failed.

So yes, we do have quite a bit of evidence that starting a successful space company is incredibly hard even with quite a bit of money behind it.

> Unless... perhaps... there's more to this than intelligence or hard work.

And perhaps you need to reverse your thinking and realize that huge success without hard work work, intelligence is very unlikely even if some luck is also involved.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by stormbrew on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:15PM (#33564495)
> And perhaps you need to reverse your thinking and realize that huge success without hard work work, intelligence is very unlikely even if some luck is also involved.

I said none of these things you're reading in to my argument.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by rot13xor on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:06PM (#33555553)
Being smart in one field doesn't translate to being smart in another field. For example, Steve Jobs making medical decisions, doctors making investment decisions, bankers making tech decisions.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by frankzinger on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:15PM (#33557263)
> Being smart in one field doesn't translate to being smart in another field.

Yes but the topic is "Is Elon Musk stupid?"

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by AdityaSanthosh on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:26AM (#33559414)
Stupid than the average person in making a purchasing decision
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:01PM (#33568434)
> Stupid than the average person in making a purchasing decision

I would wager that anybody widely regarded as a genius has a decent sized rap sheet of stupid crap they pulled. So "made stupid impulsive buying decision" is great evidence for impulsivity and hubris, not "stupid."

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lupire on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:03PM (#33555515)
He's an investor- patron, who got extenely lucky in the dotcom boom. He pays people to build good businesses, and he (was) good at personal-brand marketing.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by deciplex on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:40PM (#33555894)
what do you mean "alleged wealthy upbringing" is this point contested somehow?
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lazyasciiart on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:15AM (#33557533)
Absolutely. Plenty of people believe that Musk came from nothing.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by kamaal on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:59AM (#33562428)
Pretty much anybody writing on this site, is privileged(by world standards) by very definition.

Chances are you are the 'Elon Musk' for lots of other people out there.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by lazyasciiart on Saturday November 12, 2022 @02:01AM (#33570779)
What, they argue over whether I came from nothing? I doubt it.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @06:57PM (#33555456)
Honestly, why couldn't you achieve it? Your point is self-deprecating.

I couldn't because my goals and ethics do not align with the same outcome not because it's impossible.

[dead]
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by 7sidedmarble on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:38PM (#33556696)
Counterpoint: most people who are incredibly smart or incredibly hard working or even both, are not incredibly rich.

Musk is clearly an intelligent person in so far as your average person is not really interested in rocket science, or capable of running a business, but I hesitate to attribute his becoming the richest man on earth to his incredible intelligence. I think it should be evident that success in capitalism relies on a huge combination of factors.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:50PM (#33556771)
> it should be evident that success in capitalism relies on a huge combination of factors.

I’ll be happy with the discussion if a single Elon hater admits that regardless of anything else Elon is not actually stupid. You cannot be actually stupid and do what he has done it is totally beyond any reasonable interpretation.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by bigbacaloa on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:38AM (#33557939)
I know lots of highly successful charlatans in areas that require being smart but who are basically unethical fools. I'm talking about scientific researchers and engineers. People with 300 grange papers running a research institute who have never published an original thing in their lives.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nyokodo on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:17PM (#33568556)
> but who are basically unethical fools

Putting aside that these "unethical fools" would have to be at least really good grifters, politicians, and other synonyms...to make the analogy more accurate I'd wager these alleged charlatans didn't serially found multiple research institutes, run them concurrently in some cases, that are producing ground-breaking real-world results some of which their contemporaries said was essentially impossible (e.g. landing an orbital booster). Elon is either a genius in some manner, be it the greatest grifter in history or something, or Zeus is rigging the wheel of fortune in his favor for some reason. I'm not a big fan of the Zeus theory.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by aerostable_slug on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:06PM (#33555563)
No, it's because you weren't as smart. Sorry, but if you were, you'd be the richest person in the world, goals and ethics be damned.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by gw98 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:14PM (#33555639)
Why would I want to be the richest person in the world? Sounds like a load of hassle which would compete with the things I value.

None of my family even know what my financial situation is! Nto even the kids.

[dead]
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by kelnos on Thursday November 10, 2022 @08:52PM (#33556384)
> His only real skill is taking credit for things other people do.

I feel like a lot of people don't know that Musk didn't actually found Tesla, despite his made-up "founder" title.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by panick21_ on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:04PM (#33564320)
This is one of those 'gatcha' arguments.

He was about to found an electric car company. He then got information that there were 2 guys in the Valley trying to build an electric car company. They had only minimal investment (personal, family) and their fund-raising was hitting a wall, nobody was investing and the company was basically dead men walking. Tesla was basically 2 guys with business plan, and the business plan was a pretty vague idea about building an electric street car.

Instead of just ignoring that, putting his money in his own company and essentially 100% dooming Tesla, he got together with them, funded them and brought incredibly important people like J.B. with him.

People now use this as a negative, but seems to me not just ignoring them, and dooming them to bankruptcy and starting his own company was a pretty nice. Its not like Tesla was far enough in development that their technology was a must have. Tesla was founded based on a lot of false assumptions.

He even allowed one of them to lead the company for the next couple of years until Tesla had been run straight into the ground, only then replacing the CEO.

Ok later he insisted the he and J.B. were founders as well and that what people don't like. But the reality is without him and J.B. Tesla was doomed and for the history of Tesla Musk and J.B. are far more relevant then the original founders.