News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by bee_rider on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:09PM (#33555584)
> He wants answers that get down to the fundamental laws of physics. One thing he understands really well is the physics of the rockets. He understands that like nobody else. The stuff I have seen him do in his head is crazy.

This seems like a weird thing to highlight, to me. Like, I don’t know anything about rockets, but we all know a bit about CPU design here, right? If someone said that Tim Cook really knew his stuff and wanted answers about the M1 that got down the the fundamental laws of physics, we’d probably say — well, that’s pretty stupid, right?

You’d have to talk about thing like pipeline stages, decoder width, memory bandwidth, branch prediction — obviously these parts have to follow the fundamental laws of physics but that isn’t really the interesting part. Fundamental physical limits aren’t the bottleneck yet.

Maybe rockets science is just much easier but that seems surprising to me, given the expression.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by Animats on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:22PM (#33555726)
"This seems like a weird thing to highlight, to me."

Classic NASA. Read Gene Kranz's "Failure is not an option".

In rocketry you're usually up against physical limits. You need materials near the limits of physical strength and temperature resistance. You need fuels near the limits of energy density. And still you're launching with a payload to destination that's maybe 5% of the mass, if you're lucky. Which is why rocketry has to obsess on weight reduction.

If fuels were 2x as powerful, or gravity was 1/2 as much, this would be easy. A spacecraft would have the weight budget and safety margins of an airliner.

If earth's gravity were somewhat greater, you'd never make it to orbit with chemical fuels.

This is the tyranny of the rocket equation.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by bee_rider on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:56AM (#33560250)
But the most interesting thing about his rockets, that they land, which enables a totally different economic proposition, is in direct defiance of this sort of physical limitations first way of looking at the problem. It would clearly be more efficient fuel-wise to not do a controlled landing, right?
Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by Animats on Friday November 11, 2022 @11:54AM (#33563240)
Yes, and that costs some payload. That tradeoff is right up against the limits of what's physically possible. How Space-X does landings is quite different than most VTOL landings, which are slow and careful. The boosters approach fast, and then blast at 2G just before landing. Fuel is spent almost entirely to get rid of kinetic energy, not to fight gravity while hovering. That rather drastic solution makes it possible.

I'm not a huge Musk fan, but he does seem to get the physics of rocketry.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by nerderloo on Friday November 11, 2022 @12:20AM (#33557557)
Market disruption is the key difference. We now know how CPU operate and it's almost taken as a commodity.

Before Telsa, nobody thoughts electric cars were ready for road. Before SpaceX, I don't think anyone tried reusable rocket thingy. The thing is when you come up with a radically new idea, you have to know enough about it to convince others to work on it.

Steve Jobs knew enough about computer(and general idea of programming) to sell it, and Bill Gates was once a good programmer. Intel, nVidia founder were also chip engineers.

Re:Musk’s First Email to Twitter Staff Ends Remote Work by theonething on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:32AM (#33558447)
It seems to me to really understand rock science, you need to know physics.

As you state, that is not the case for CPU design.