News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by tyleo on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:13AM (#33531843)
Why are they useless? I grew up in an area with tornadoes and when one came ripping through my childhood suburb and destroyed some houses I was happy to have forewarning.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:23AM (#33531974)
> Why are they useless?

I can’t speak to tornado alerts, but the Amber Alert child alerts were becoming excessive and useless in my state.

I was getting alerts from many hundreds of miles away. Other times they’d forget to put relevant information in the first alert so they’d send several more to follow up. When we finally got a series of multiple Amber alerts in the middle of the night, most of the people I know turned them off.

The system may have started with good intentions, but it was mismanaged and abused so much that it became useless.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by paiute on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:39AM (#33532204)
I made an effort to look them all up for a while, almost all of them are custody disputes and the child isn't in real danger. I mostly ignore them now. We did have a girl nearby that was actually missing and they couldn't issue an amber alert because it didn't meet the criteria. It took them a few days to decide to issue one in exception to the criteria and within that day the girl was found (due to the amber alert).
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by mrguyorama on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @01:26PM (#33535802)
The vast vast majority of "child kidnappings" are just a divorced set of parents bickering, or one parent ignoring court orders and trying to just run away with the child.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by giantg2 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:38AM (#33532190)
Like most government websites I've used, they're junk with no thought to UX.

Maybe go with the UX best practice of allowing the user to choose how they want to be alerted? Is that so hard? Government can't get basic shit like this right, I wonder how they're handling the rest of it...

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by nells on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#33532020)
> The system may have started with good intentions, but it was mismanaged and abused so much that it became useless.

The government in a nutshell

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by armada651 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:30AM (#33532084)
These HN comments get so tiring. Yes, I'm sure everyone would be better off if only countries were managed like a tech startup.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by mvdwoord on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:39AM (#33532210)
False dichotomy much?

It should be possible to improve policies without introducing dependencies to crappy JavaScript frameworks.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by nells on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:36AM (#33532176)
I’d rather they didn’t get managed at all ;)
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by jerf on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:31AM (#33532097)
"When we finally got a series of multiple Amber alerts in the middle of the night, most of the people I know turned them off."

To be honest I wonder if the people in charge were starting to get a kick at waking up so many people, or if they were engaging in some sort of malicious compliance, e.g., maybe the people responsible for sending the alerts out are also pretty pissed off at being woken up to send them out. The stated reason for them existing leaves no room for there to be any reason to be sending these out at 3am, if neither the abductee nor the putative abductor were known to be nocturnal.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:48AM (#33532321)
I suspect it's all automated, and since the vast majority are custody issues, there's probably something like "you were supposed to hand over your daughter by 10 PM, but we don't count it as late until after midnight, and THEN your ex-wife has to call and complain, and by the time it's in the system it's 3 AM, and the system automatically sends the alert".

And then they don't even send another alert saying she was found safe and sound sleeping at her dad's house.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by palmscenter on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:50AM (#33533316)
There is nothing automated about originating those alerts. The actual procedure for transmitting the alert is manual. The incident has to meet state criteria including likelihood of harm to the child, criminal activity, information about the vehicle and other facts.

A missing child in a custody dispute alone is rarely enough to trigger an alert.

One of the leading types of child abductions leading to alerts is vehicle theft with a child in the vehicle. Not a custody dispute.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by autoexec on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @04:28PM (#33538130)
> One of the leading types of child abductions leading to alerts is vehicle theft with a child in the vehicle. Not a custody dispute.

"The vast majority of child abductions are carried out by a relative or close acquaintance of the victim, often a divorced parent who was not granted custody... about 20 percent involved a kidnapping by a stranger or slight acquaintance of the child. In the other 80 percent of cases, the youngsters were taken by a relative (most often a parent) or an acquaintance (frequently a babysitter)."

source: https://psmag.com/social-justice/amber-alerts-largely-ineffe...

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by EE84M3i on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @06:23PM (#33539644)
Are there any stats available about the breakdown for the subset that get amber alerts?
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by autoexec on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @06:32PM (#33539729)
Sorry, my fault for combining sentences! it was 80% of the amber alerts they studied.

"Presumably because of that need "to make an intuitive, rapid decision," as Griffin puts it, AMBER Alerts often turn out to be false alarms. Of the alerts the UNR team tracked, about 20 percent involved a kidnapping by a stranger or slight acquaintance of the child.

In the other 80 percent of cases, the youngsters were taken by a relative (most often a parent) or an acquaintance (frequently a babysitter). While such incidents can be traumatic to both the child and the custodial parent, they are routinely resolved peacefully."

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:00AM (#33532506)
> To be honest I wonder if the people in charge were starting to get a kick at waking up so many people, or if they were engaging in some sort of malicious compliance

I doubt it. The messages were just incremental additions of information as it was added: First message had something about the area. Second message had the color of the vehicle. Third one added another detail or a correction or something, I can’t remember.

I just remember that everyone in my local office was visibly tired the next day and we all shared the information to turn the alerts off.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by registeredcorn on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:46AM (#33532309)
>I was getting alerts from many hundreds of miles away.

Isn't part of the issue that when a child is taken, the assumption is that the kidnapper will immediately flee the area? I think hundreds, plural, might be excessive, but it wouldn't be unreasonable to notify people within a certain distance based on high speed and how much time has passed; maybe 50-100 miles?

I can see getting annoyed at multiple messages, but it's also important to remember that working with time sensitive emergency services is a extraordinarily difficult thing. It's like, everything is important all at once, and your mind can only process it all so fast. It's extremely time sensitive, and if you mess up any of the details, you are directly delaying the proceedings.

I haven't had to issue anything like an Amber Alert, thank God, but I did have to relay some information from a victims family to a supporting organization, and basically screwed it up the first time around. I ended up having to end the call with the family, call the organization to see what they needed, call the family back, then call them again with the relevant details. It was an incredibly brutal thing. You can feel the rawness of the emotion through the phone for the people. In my own experience, like, I could hear people crying and screaming in the background. It's this insanely personal moment for them, but you kind of have to force your way in the middle of it to make something happen. The person who I started off with had to hand the phone over because they thought they were about to pass out. It's really a very difficult to communicate in the midst of a crisis.

Anyway, I'm not sure which area you're in, but from my own experience, the very few times I've gotten one, it was always very succinct and clear. Child's name, description of their clothes, make/model/license plate of car, which direction they were headed, and when it happened.

I certainly don't blame you for turning off the alerts, or for being annoyed at the emergency services. The point wasn't to finger wag or whatever, it was just to say that it's extremely difficult to do, let alone do well.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:52AM (#33532386)
The problem is that very few are actually "stranger danger" kidnappings; they're almost always custody disputes. And if you live anywhere near a major city, you will get them relatively often. If there was a way to turn off "parent kidnappings" and leave the rest on, I'm sure most people would take it.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by palmscenter on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:53AM (#33533376)
It doesn't matter whether the cause is a custody dispute or something else. Custody disputes of themselves do not meet the criteria for AMBER alerts. Danger to the child and criminal activity are among the criteria that have to be met for the alert to be sent.

States vary as to how effectively they run their alerting systems, and how well they follow best practices, but that is ultimately an issue for the voters.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by registeredcorn on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @11:49AM (#33534269)
Although I agree with the premise you are making, that many Amber Alerts are regularly caused because one of the parents takes the child without authorization, it is important to remember that sexual and physical violence, including murder, is more likely to be committed by someone known to the victim rather than a stranger. The perpetrator is largely immaterial. To suppose that a child is therefore somehow in less danger because they were taken by a parent does not appear to make much difference, based on my rudimentary understanding of things. A parent who is prone to stealing a child to "get revenge" on the spouse is one who is willing to harm and abuse their own flesh and blood as part of a revenge plot.

In my own assessment, I classify that person to be dangerous. A stranger takes a child for an unknown reason. A parent takes a child, willingly harming the child physically or mentally in hopes of doing harm to a person they hate. I would assume they are willing to do far more than mere mental harm to the child, if it means "winning" the fight. I don't have any data to back that up, and it's entirely possible I'm wrong. I just don't see an Amber Alert being raised because a parent took the child to be any less serious than if a stranger took the child.

I would imagine that some number of Amber Alerts are a kind of "false positive", something like failing to drop a child off on time (out of gas, severe traffic, etc.) and their phone dying, turning into a big ordeal, but I just wouldn't discount the situation just because the suspect is a parent. Maybe that shouldn't meet the threshold, but I just personally don't see it as being a big enough nuisance to be bothered by it. Again, it is easy for me to say that though, since I don't get those sorts of alerts very often, maybe 2 to 3 times per year, if that.

I do also completely agree though, that as it relates to headphone usage it should be changed. I think that if you are listening on your headphones, it shouldn't come through your headphones at all. Just play the noise on the phone speaker - it'll probably still draw the users attention. I might be asking too much though, as there was that 911 bug [1][2] a while back.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29492884

[2] https://old.reddit.com/r/GooglePixel/comments/r4xz1f/pixel_p...

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by landemva on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @05:39PM (#33539100)
Beyond the nuisance factor, there is literally nothing helpful I can do. I turned the alerts off. And I turned off the earthquake/tornado alerts.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by registeredcorn on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @07:58PM (#33540700)
I mean, you could call the police if you see someone matching the description given.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by kawfey on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:15AM (#33532745)
I agree, insofar that the integrated cellular emergency alert system is not good. I disabled all but presidential alerts (which should theoretically never happen until ICBMs are flying over our heads, except that one time in Hawaii), and signed up for City/County EMA texts for weather and hazards warnings. I also have a weather radio sitting in the corner with SAME alerts enabled.

Sure, that might not work well when I'm on travel, but when I'm on travel I'm typically in places with a ton of built-in mass notifications systems (airports, metro & train stations, roadside state DOT banners) so I don't feel I'm missing out.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:18AM (#33531892)
We get them every single time a thunderstorm sniffs at anything in the tricounty area.

There may be a way to turn off the "Watch" alerts and still keep the "we are gonna die" alerts. The one time we got the green sky of doom the phone did explode in a way not normally seen, so I assume they know something about crying wolf.

As for amber alerts being useless - something like 90% (?) of the time it's a custody dispute where one parent hasn't returned the kid at the appointed time.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by js2 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:54AM (#33532407)
I have a weather radio in our bedroom with only two alerts enabled: tornado warning (not watch), and the nuclear power plant 6 miles away just had an incident, whatever that’s called. Weather radio alerts are very granular and most radios will let you configure just the ones you want to hear.

https://www.weather.gov/nwr/eventcodes

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:20AM (#33532821)
It's always fun to watch the new people near the plant when the emergency alert warning system is tested. Most people do NOT expect a "voice of God" to start yelling at them out of nowhere, even if it is only a test.

Once you know about them, they're relatively easy to spot (look in areas near power plants, downstream of dams, etc).

You can find some here and use them as ringtones!

https://www.whelenmassnotification.com/recorded-message-libr...

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by EE84M3i on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @06:25PM (#33539676)
By "voice of god" do you mean an outside PA system (like air raid sirens)? I didn't know that they had these anywhere in the US other than for tornados.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by palmscenter on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:55AM (#33533399)
I know of no state in the USA where a child not returning on time is enough to trigger an Amber alert.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by sidewndr46 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:24AM (#33531985)
I live in Texas. I get Amber alerts for missing children that are 8 hours of interstate driving away from me. That's completely useless.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#33532112)
Every single person I know in the NYC area turned off amber alerts in 2013 after being woken up by this one in the middle of the night:

https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2013/07/ambert-alert-phone-4...

Even older parents called their kids to find out how to make sure it does not happen again.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:54AM (#33532403)
It didn't help at all that phones suddenly had this feature and defaulted to ON (for awhile you couldn't turn off Amber alerts without turning off "They just launched the nukes, kiss your ass goodbye" alerts).
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by sidewndr46 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:00AM (#33532492)
If we're discussing uselessness, I'm pretty sure warnings of impending war are the peak of this. They've actually killed someone in Hawaii. Let me live my final moments in bliss without worrying about that kind of stuff.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by gedy on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:33AM (#33532138)
Same in California, and the ones I've received were custody battles between parents...
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by palmscenter on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @11:11AM (#33533665)
A child was abducted, and in some cases - as happened just a few days ago - the noncustodial parent threatens to kill the child. And does. The fact that the abduction involves a custody dispute is only one of the factors that goes into the decision to send an alert.

Many abductions are vehicle thefts where the thief takes off without noticing or caring that there is a child in the car.

In one recent case, the thief threw the baby out the window into a ditch. Citizens who received the Amber alert found the child.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by sidewndr46 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:16AM (#33548676)
Almost everyone owns a phone. Amber alerts go to all phones by default. It is therefore statistically unremarkable that "Citizens who received the Amber alert found the child". It's akin to the observation that they were all born after the Civil War. It has no relevance.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by throwaway09223 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:19AM (#33531904)
You can get the same alerts via a non-broken (non-regulated) channel. There are apps for that.

The government mandated stuff just needs to be turned off because it's broken.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by kayodelycaon on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:28AM (#33532060)
Some areas have weather patterns where warnings are frequent, but actual damage is rare. Cincinnati is like this from personal experience. We get far more injuries and damage from high winds and ice than tornados.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by Kye on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:39AM (#33532213)
If you live in the path of water coming through the air from the Gulf of Mexico, you're in popup thunderstorm country. These confuse prediction systems, so you end up with warnings all day, every day for large parts of the year.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by mrits on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:20AM (#33531915)
I have amber alerts disabled but still receive weather emergency notifications. Which makes sense. Perhaps it works differently in different states?

In Texas my iPhone has this alert granularity: AMBER Emergency Public Safety Test

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:24AM (#33531995)
There's WATCH and WARNING and (unnamed) - some locations just send everything WATCH and above (some even send ADVISORY which is incredibly stupid).

If the local government is sane, they send WARNING and (unnamed) only - (unnamed) being the YOU ARE ALREADY DEAD MAKE YOUR TIME notices.

Then if you want WATCH you set your weather app to notify you on those.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by whacim on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#33532015)
May also differ by OS. I'm on Android and have options to disable four or five different types of alerts.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by RegnisGnaw on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:30AM (#33532979)
Depends on where you are. In Canada, our system sends everything as "National/Presidential Alerts". We don't use the different levels at all. So AMBER Alert, Weather Alert, etc are all Presidential/National Alerts.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:48AM (#33533280)
Does Canada even have a president?
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by palmscenter on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @10:57AM (#33533434)
Canada doesn't have a president, but until it passes a law that requires phones sold in Canada to have Canada-specific features in the alert display, it will say what it says in the USA. And in USA the Presidential Alert is switching to National Alert.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by nonameiguess on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:31AM (#33532099)
If you live in a place prone to tornadoes, there should be real citywide outdoor tornado sirens that you'd hear from miles away. Also sending it to your phone doesn't add much unless you're a recording artist in a soundproof studio.
Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by bombcar on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:57AM (#33532456)
I was actually surprised how well a modern insulated house blocks the siren. We have one that is on a hill a mile away (there's a second but I don't think I've ever heard it) and it's hard to notice inside (they run a check every month).

It IS fun to get the weather warning and then run outside and hear the air-raid siren begin to warm up.

Re:Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume o... by weird-eye-issue on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:23AM (#33531971)
Amber alerts are not related to tornadoes