News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by damagednoob on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:04PM (#33510612)
I don't understand poverty statistics. With this news, the UK now has more people living in poverty than India (16% vs 22%?). If it is valuable to judge poverty on relative income, you would think the rational course of action would be mass immigration from the UK to India but that is clearly not the case.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by DimitriPetrova on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:18PM (#33510874)
Apparently the Multidimensional Poverty Measure is defined as;

An index that captures the percentage of households in a country deprived along three dimensions of well-being – monetary poverty, education, and basic infrastructure services – to provide a more complete picture of poverty.

There's also the Multidimensional Poverty Measure which has an alternate definition

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by jimbokun on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:52PM (#33511383)
But is there a greater percentage of people in UK deprived along any of those dimensions?
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by ClumsyPilot on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:18PM (#33511782)
Uk has 4.1 million children in poverty, or 30%. It now more food banks than macdonalds.

Poorer counties often have large families, government programs for food distribution and many people growing their own food.

You might have empty bank account but you will have something to eat and some roof over your head, even if you are crashing at family place or it's illegal construction on a land thats not technically yours.

If you are poor in London you will just starve and freese to death

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by jialutu on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:33PM (#33511994)
> Uk .... now more food banks than macdonalds.

Holy cow! I just checked this fact and it's true! https://fullfact.org/electionlive/2019/dec/9/food-banks-more... That said, it shouldn't be a suprise since there are food bank donations everywhere these days. Truly depressing.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by thorin on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @06:45AM (#33518132)
This is sad, but basically every supermarket and corner shop has something like a foodbank by the door and I guess it would be included in these stats so not surprising. Also people with housing can survive in way colder conditions than they might think. It's a shame that all the wealth has been hoovered up from them by the upper classes and big businesses. Every time I see something about cost of living in the UK I think about whenever I want to do anything: theme park, attractions, hotels, restaurants everything is packed with people spending obscene amounts of money, loads of new cars around etc. It's truly a 2 tier system now and I guess in the US also?
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by deathgripsss on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:03PM (#33511568)
It must be relative to that nation. From my experience the UK IS becoming an incredibly segregated nation along economic lines. I don't find it hard to believe that 22% of the populace are in relative poverty. This is very different from absolute poverty, of which I'm sure India has a higher percentage.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by formerkrogemp on Monday November 07, 2022 @05:19PM (#33513378)
Three cheers for Brexit and Tory rule I suppose.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by peterashford on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @02:07AM (#33516638)
I don't know why you're being downvoted. UK has been under Tory rule for most of the last few decades. Its hard to see why they shouldn't be held responsible for UK's fortunes
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by bparsons on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:37PM (#33511161)
These are two very different definitions.

The international definition of extreme poverty means living on less than $1.90 a day. It is the basic ability to survive.

The domestic poverty threshold definition in the UK is whether or not you are able to maintain a fairly stable middle class standard of living.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by renewiltord on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:19PM (#33510896)
I think that's just a measure that is meant to vary over time for a single state rather than vary over states for a single time. India struggles with problems of feeding, sheltering, and hygiene for its population.

Ultimately, the purpose of that statistic for the state to be able to tell whether its policies are working. The state, therefore, must construct measures that show progress when it makes progress and show regress when it makes errors. A measure that ultimately shows 0 progress even when real progress is made, is not that useful to the state.

A data nerd may want to normalize definitions (I certainly do and the MMR and IMR measurements are ones I find particularly annoying) but ultimately a state measures for its own purposes and not mine.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by Shoue on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:16PM (#33511752)
Relative measures are important because it's an indicator of how fairly domestic resources are being allocated. You can be a poor country but have resources fairly allocated among the population, and you can be a rich country and have resources unfairly allocated among the population. It's a good indicator of how well people at the bottom are being taken care of, and the ideal scenario is a rich country with low income inequality, which the Nordic countries are probably the best examples of.

You can use measures that are less country-specific like the Gini coefficient and UN R/P to measure domestic inequality between countries:

The UK has a Gini coefficient of 35.1, a UN R/P 10% of 13.8

India has a Gini coefficient of 35.7, a UN R/P 10% of 8.6

For reference, Norway has a Gini coefficient of 27.7, and a UN R/P 10% of 6.1

(higher = more inequality)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by Neil44 on Monday November 07, 2022 @04:08PM (#33512477)
That is very interesting. But I think the answer to the parents question about why people are not boarding rubber dinghies from the UK to India is that in absolute terms poverty is not the same in the two countries.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by mym1990 on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:21PM (#33511810)
Have you been through the process of emigration before, especially as a person in poverty? You make it out to be like just packing up a suitcase and setting up in a cushy new place, the reality is so far away from that.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by bergenty on Monday November 07, 2022 @04:18PM (#33512617)
I don’t know the answer but I’m sure they’re defined differently. Poverty in India means making less than $1.90 dollars a day. By those standards the UK would have zero poverty so their numbers are clearly self defined at a much higher standard than the UNDP global standard.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by advisedwang on Monday November 07, 2022 @05:14PM (#33513325)
> With this news, the UK now has more people living in poverty than India (16% vs 22%?)

The severity of poverty in rich western nations is easy to underestimate. There are people in the UK who are underfed, can't afford heat, have to work multiple jobs etc. This kind of poverty does look different than poverty in India - better in some ways, but worse in others - but it is still poverty.

The data on relative poverty is hard to trust, but we also can't trust gut feelings about which countries "must" have more poverty. Perhaps it is true that UK does have a higher fraction of people in some kind of poverty.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by Matticus_Rex on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:04PM (#33515129)
In what ways does poverty in the UK look worse than poverty in India?
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by cuteboy19 on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:05PM (#33515140)
You won't freeze to death without heating
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by dan_mctree on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @07:10AM (#33518262)
Poverty in the west is often of a different kind than in India. Deep poverty in India can look living in self build house in a slum, with no or low and irregular income most of which goes straight into food and necessities.

Deep poverty in the west often looks like having a stable income and roof, but being completely overwhelmed by high unavoidable static costs such as rent, health insurance, loan paybacks, etc. Of course this style of poverty is also present in India

They're different kinds of experience. I suspect the former is more dangerous, scary and unpleasant, but the latter is more depressing and suffocating.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by Matticus_Rex on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:39AM (#33520975)
It's more depressing and suffocating than extremely high rates of malnutrition, less educational and institutional access, a stricter class system , having to cook with fuels like dung, poor sanitation, awful maternal health? Color me skeptical.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by dan_mctree on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @04:48PM (#33524760)
Malnutrition is common in the west too, though it more often takes the form of unhealthy overeating. Lack of physical exercise and lives lived inside also contribute to poor every day health. You're right that sanitation and maternal health are better in the west, but those are things that tend to outright kill you if they get to you. The western style health issues are more constant and boring, leading to a different type of suffering.

Likewise with the institutional access and class system, the west has a more sort of guaranteed based level of societal support. But in India, chances are larger that you'll have a more local social support group of family and friends. In comparison the west is often much more isolated and lonely

Obviously I'd still prefer being poor in the west, but I think it's reasonable to say we also have forms of suffering here that are different in kind and sometimes worse than in India

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by advisedwang on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:45AM (#33521087)
I understand those in poverty in India are typically still part of a religious, family or social community. In the UK those in poverty are often completely isolated.

Sometimes community can provide a safety net, but even a community so poor that it can't help materially is better for, e.g. mental health.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by BurningFrog on Monday November 07, 2022 @05:58PM (#33513739)
Discussions about poverty is usually confused by the two competing definitions:

- Absolute Poverty: If you have less than $X/day, you are poor. This measures living standards.

- Relative Poverty: If you're in the bottom x%, you are poor. This measures status.

Without knowing anything, it sounds like this measurement is more on the Relative Poverty side.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by mrits on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:58PM (#33514287)
I don't understand how relative poverty can improve.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by sdsd on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:13PM (#33514405)
Via more equal outcomes. An egalitarian society might have the same net wealth as a stratified society, but with less relative poverty.

Of course, the bottom x% is what it is - but if you create margins or classes then it works different - ie, the % of people who are making x% less than the median or average or whatever.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by deelowe on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:50PM (#33514654)
It would just be a tighter distribution of income.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by missedthecue on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:54PM (#33515405)
Having fewer middle class people and wealthy people flattens the income curve. Not great for society, but your relative poverty statistics would improve. Otherwise, yes, every ladder has a bottom rung.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by peterashford on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @01:58AM (#33516599)
less inequality?
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by JamisonM on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:35PM (#33514566)
This is an incorrect definition of relative poverty as on that basis then number of people in poverty will never change - no one interested in serious analysis would use such a definition as it is not useful.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by BurningFrog on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:47PM (#33514639)
I agree with your critique, but you still see it being used a lot. There is plenty of unserious analysis around...

The better version is people living under x% of the average living standard.

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by JamisonM on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:57PM (#33514700)
I have not seen such a definition in the wild myself.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by mayama on Monday November 07, 2022 @11:04PM (#33515761)
This is based on multidimensional poverty index(MPI), developed pretty recently. It is a mix of both absolute and relative poverty. Though MPI is used mainly in developing nations.

> This figure considers both the proportion of the population that is deemed poor, and the 'breadth' of poverty experienced by these 'poor' households, following the Alkire & Foster 'counting method'.[1] The method was developed following increased criticism of monetary and consumption based poverty measures, seeking to capture the deprivations in non-monetary factors that contribute towards well-being. While there is a standard set of indicators, dimensions, cutoffs and thresholds used for a 'Global MPI',[2] the method is flexible and there are many examples of poverty studies that modify it to best suit their environment. The methodology has been mainly, but not exclusively,[3] applied to developing countries.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multidimensional_Poverty_Index

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by yboris on Monday November 07, 2022 @08:44PM (#33515008)
Here is an interactive data visualization comparing incomes within and between countries:

https://income-inequality.info/

All incomes are in PPP (purchasing power parity) dollars, so you can see that living at the US poverty line of $11k/year places one at about 85th percentile (having more income than 85% of the world's population).

You can see the code for it on Github as well: https://github.com/whyboris/Global-Income-Distribution

Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by kumarvvr on Monday November 07, 2022 @10:13PM (#33515512)
You either compare absolute numbers or pure percentages. Not both in the same sentence.
Re:India lifted 415M out of poverty in 15 years, says UN by fooker on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @04:17AM (#33517394)
>I don't understand poverty statistics.

It is a relative thing..

You need a significantly higher amount of money in the UK to have a lower middle class lifestyle.

In India (and most other third world countries), that is readily achievable because of low living costs.