In this particular case, it's specifically designed to make you VERY uncomfortable, to show what could be if we're not vigilant. Pushing it in peoples faces makes it into a kind of inoculation, hopefully preventing it from actually happening.
I feel like that's the most common time for you to satire a culture. You know all the intimate details.
Yoking a human brain to perform tasks that only a human can get right, but not having to pay them, a basically get to use them like software.
About the only thing keeping this from becoming a reality is it probably costs more in labor to maintain the bodies than to just have desperate people perform the same tasks for extremely low pay.
You should think about solving these problems in the real world, not a fantasy cyberpunk dystopia.
They've been used repeatedly in real life. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Brian_Douglas_Wells is probably the most famous example, but they've been used even more recently by ISIS
I’ve seen it essentially everywhere, including working in defense briefly. A dark sense of humor reflects actually thinking about the the more complex aspects of the work you do.
What’s being satirized here? The whole write up is basically a love letter to Sword Art Online.
If I made a game that shocked the players like in Never Say Never Again (which I have thought about doing multiple times since I was a kid), it wouldn’t be a satire. It would just be a thing.
Satire has a message. It has a target. What’s the target here?
Clearly satirical
Ukraine wouldn't exist if not for modern weapons systems.
If you love your peaceful life, you have war machines to thank.
America is secure, as is Western Europe, due mostly to terrifying war machines.
Keeping us all safe and at peace is something some might regard as truly noble.
I don't build weapons systems, but I would if I had the opportunity. It'd beat the shit out of predatory adtech and addicting kids to algorithms.
Moral questions aside, inertial navigation and guidance, fuze design, radar, multispectral optics etc are wildly more interesting problems to solve than "how do I hook whales for $700 in this shitty iOS game?"
Maybe we'll see a influx of new minds in defense now that Facebook and friends seem to be falling apart and firing everyone.
Maybe it'll make us all safer, happier, and richer (because war destroys wealth, and weapons can avert it entirely).
Palantir, Anduril. Does PL work in Thiel’s orbit, maybe connected at FB?
Was Tolkien right leaning himself, I would be surprised by that but I honestly don’t know.
Yes, but the small-c conservative Catholic sort of right-wing. He would have hated reactionary modernists like Thiel.
So he would hate Thiel and Luckey for their technology and control, who is like Sauron and the Orcs. Maybe more on Luckey, since Virtual Reality would be a horror show from a traditionalist mind, anyway.
But it's fine, since the entire point of the Sagas for Anglo culture is for the people in it to twist it the way they want to, after all.
I don't know Palmer beyond this blog post and having googled him after being baffled by the tone. I don't dislike him and I don't know his politics.
I would have loved to have heard one of the many beautiful stories he mentioned, and I was particularly confused by seeing the lovely wedding photos at the end. It made me question whether it was satire but I don't think it is.
No, most engineers here are perfectly fine building highly addictive apps that are only slightly removed from slot machines and targeting them at children.
> The concept itself is not novel
Actually building it is very novel.
> It's explosive charges strapped to an helmet with a detonator
That is triggered when you lose a video game.
> the form is not particularly appealing or interesting
Given the amount of engagement and discussion it's generating I think you are clearly wrong.
I guess if someone thinks it's art then it's art, and I don't say that to denigrate it. I'm not the authority on what is art or not.
I just don't get the the casual tone, the seeming lack of intent, and the deathly severity of it. It makes no sense to me.
Why act like this? It accomplishes nothing aside from grafting a hostile tangent onto a conversation. You may be correct coincidentally, but the parent's opinion, as written, presents nothing to justify making such an uncharitable leap out loud. I read the parent comment and sympathized with them before I even realized the subject was Palmer Luckey.
How does that make it better? Would you personally want to release such a product?
Proof of a comment a year ago referencing a relatively niche post of his to demonstrate I like the guy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28678205
You misspelled his name, though. I wonder if you actually care about his work, or if you're just flaming.
This is an odd statement. No one mentioned politics but you, and now you’re accusing the OP as being somehow disingenuous.
Don’t be that guy. We don’t like that behavior here.
Should definitely get that checked.
If there is ANYTHING you have learned about tech CEOs from the past decade, surely it's that they're not really uniformly super smart, many are socially awkward and don't know how to speak or write so that it lands and that they're petty and silly like the rest of us. They're not some hand-rubbing, moustache-twirling villain who enjoys wanton acts of evil. They're the mundane, bureaucratic kind of evil you can find in any company.
That being said, on rereading it, it was probably fictional, just oddly written and with a context that makes the satire a bit odd to me.
To spoil a bit, it’s a mixed bag and he isn’t the horrible villain you’d expect. Arguably the main characters have a lot of sympathy for what he created and half forgive his atrocities.
To dig a bit more, I think this ambiguity resonated with many people who would give up their current life if they could live a new (hopefully better) one in a different world (they keyword being “isekai”). Most of the isekai genre is super fluffy fantasy, and SAO sits at the border of somewhat plausible if science could advance at a crazy pace.
For many, even living in a world with well defined rules and somewhat of a fair (albeit deadly) meritocracy would be a lot more bearable than their current situation. I don’t expect Palmer to be in that boat, but he also seems to be more on the tech bro side, so who knows ?
You are right to be uncomfortable, I am too, and it’s I think a pretty important aspect of how some people view the world in this day and age.
It's not technologically challenging nor does it have beautiful craftsmanship, like some homemade guns. I really don't get it.
It reminds me of the suicide helmet, made of iron surrounded by shotgun shells. But that was something chilling and impressive both in intent and form.