As far as speed, even for simple stuff the real time formatting gets in the way constantly compared to just writing text in a latex file.
(I am aware of the difference between LaTeX and TeX; I likely haven't used TeX directly but the comparisons here should still work fine.)
There is a huge difference in workflow between generating a document from a complete code file and iterating on a final result with incremental tweaks. That is why I cannot use Acrobat, Word, Google Docs, etc. for creating papers that I would use LaTeX for. It is just not the same, and it is not the workflow I desire.
But once the text is done, it's really nice to work with, and you never "accidentally break the whole document by adding a table" - at least not irrecoverably.
Also, pushing figure around to nice places can be so frustrating that people settle for less than perfect layout.
Does it generate diffs/patches that ultimately can be used to reconstruct the document? Can I take a document and apply a patch and get exactly the same as you get? Can I reorder and edit patches? The answer is no.
Does Acrobat have any typesetting capabilities? I thought another app did that and just finalised through Acrobat.
But they are life-savers when that's your situation.
Another pro is that I can use git for tracking changes
Here's what it looks like if you're interested: