News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @12:37PM (#33438656)
This such a short-sighted move. It might curb China today, but tomorrow they will have developed their own domestic technology and the US will no longer have anything to sanction. It also stops Western companies' ability to grow.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by melling on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @12:48PM (#33438846)
Yes, but this will accelerate total R&D. Consumers will benefit because more competition means better products at lower prices.

The same will happen for AI (machine learning).

The United States wouldn’t have gone to the moon in the 1960’s if it weren’t for The Soviet Union.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by mantas on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:44PM (#33439938)
Mindless consumers? Yes. Citizens? Not so much. There’s so much more to life than better product at lower price.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by godelski on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:04PM (#33440312)
IP theft doesn't really promote competition that way because the one that steals the technology gains all the advantage. They don't have to recoup their costs and by default have lower margins. That's impossible for the original creator to compete against.

IP protectionism on the other hand does promote competition[0]. If an inventor is able to create and market a successful product than competition has to invent their own versions. Not through theft, but through innovation. This will mean they do things differently. It also means they will NEED to gain some edge (either reduced cost or higher utility or different niche).

While there was a lot of theft in the space program, it wasn't the same as it is today with the current situation. The supply chain issues mean that innovation still had to occur. The current situation is more like you subcontract a company to manufacture parts for you and then that company says "thanks for the instructions, we'll now just sell our own." There's no innovation pressure in this framework.

[0] Too much protectionism also does hurt. If intellectual rights are provided for too long than a technology that has failed to properly be marketed by the creators is lost to society. Similarly, too broad of protection can also hinder competition. But there is a sweet spot which gives inventors the first rights and isn't too broad. This promotes competition.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by djohnston on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @12:54PM (#33438989)
Western companies don't grow in China. At best they get tenuous access while their IP is blatantly stolen to favor a domestic successor. The idea that western companies have anything to gain operating in China is naive IMO.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:33PM (#33439762)
True for manufacturing; probably less true for services.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by mathverse on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:38PM (#33442610)
What services are even allowed to operate in China?
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:13AM (#33450431)
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by rasz on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:08AM (#33447612)
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by paganel on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:33PM (#33440761)
VW gets 40% (or thereabouts) of its revenues and profits from China, VW is a quite big Western car group.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by kelnos on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @03:45PM (#33441899)
They get revenues in the short term, but in the long term they get copied and closed out.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by fomine3 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @05:04AM (#33448612)
But even if VW won't do, other western/Japanese competitors do the same thing. So let's get revenues in the short term
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by satonakamoto on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:03AM (#33490278)
"short term" More than 30 years now.And how long can be called "long term" for an company?
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by contingencies on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:13PM (#33443000)
This is a bit harsh. While I agree the situation is imperfect and declining, there are still some great aspects to the Chinese market, such as size, mobile payment penetration, speed of the supply chain, prevalence of hardware fabrication partners, and open industrial culture. Smart companies can leverage these elements.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by friedman23 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:01PM (#33439152)
The lure of access to the Chinese market has been used and western leaders now realize it's a lie. The one sided cooperation with China is wisely being ended, if the Chinese government wants any technology or resource going forward it will have to be completely grown from within. But here's the kicker, why would any Chinese citizen go and start a company? All it means is you have a massive target on your back for one of the political elite to swoop in and take what you've built. Why would you work towards building a massive company like Jack Ma did when the reward is being tortured and disappeared when you step slightly out of line?

So the best and most ambitious minds in China will go into politics or leave the country.

Throw in the coming demographic collapse I think China's peak is behind us.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by dirtyid on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:23PM (#33444917)
PRC still huge market for many multinationals, access is there for those who play ball. If anything PRC willing to reserve market share for foreign companies to maintain relations, i.e. no reason Nokia/Ericsson should have 5g contracts in PRC but they do.

As for PRC talent, no bamboo ceiling and increasing mccarthyism targetting PRC individuals big perk. Most people are happy being mere millionaires than billionaires. And even billionaires fine if you don't go full retard like Ma and try to challenge state regulators. Best of PRC minds are staying in PRC, this isn't the 80s-00s when PRC was sending their best as state initiave to be educated abroad, most of the students going to west now are those with some English proficieny but can't hack it in gaokao. There's a reason why more and more sea turtles are returning to PRC for better prospects. Or why US has to literally sanction Chinese Americans from working in PRC semi.

Plus PRC high skill demographic divident, the kind that drives innovation + high tech, high value development is just starting. The greatest pool of high end talent in human history is being churned out as we speak despite broader demographic decline that only makes PRC more resource independant. PRC won't peak for another 20 years, by then they will likely have sufficiently caught up in most advanced sectors to start eating the west's lunch. The convergence will be PRC closing gap which will erode western dominance by denying PRC market and wrestling shares from emerging economies fine with cheap PRC exports at the expense of west.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by friedman23 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:32PM (#33445572)
> Most people are happy being mere millionaires than billionaires

It's not about money. Creating a new technology or business is like giving birth and if you are based in China, Xi and his friends can come and rip the baby out of your crib. It doesn't matter how successful or high profile you are, some communist party leader can and will rape you, figuratively and literally (See Peng Shuai).

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by dirtyid on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:56PM (#33445831)
Of course it's about money.

People take chance if reward offsets. And it's easy money if business aligns with state interests, with Ma being properly fucked over after being warned many times when his ponzi lending proposal scheme. Because prospect of stupid amount money made his brain go dumb dumb and think it was fine challenging regulators. See how PRC hard tech jobs that 5year proposal is prioritizing is seeing explosion in compensation and opportunities when cracked down sectors of soft sci aren't. In which case Xi and his friends come over and give you personal handjobs along with bags of of state subsidies.

Or as if sexual harassment meaningfully impacts competitiveness US business enviroment. Or that sports star is a business leader now? That's like saying kpop / jp idols / hollywood will fail because you can fuck your way to success. As if fucking way to top is CCP exclusive trick.

The fact of the matter remains, more high skilled PRC nationals are staying or returning to PRC than ever to work in well compensated PRC industries where there aren't bamboo ceilings and with recent developments like China initiative, less targetted political prosecution. At least in PRC you get fucked for doing too well, and raped to get ahead, vs in US where PRC nationals are increasingly being fucked and kept down due to whims of domestic politics. Again, PRC is so alluring for Chinese Americans that US has to literally sanction and start kangaroo courts to scare folks from working in China.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by throwaway6734 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:09PM (#33439309)
All they need to do is slow china down enough for their inevitable demographic collapse
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by filoleg on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:12PM (#33439363)
> It might curb China today, but tomorrow they will have developed their own domestic technology.

You believe it is a short-sighted move, because you only considered those two options, without considering the third one (which is much closer to the current reality than those two).

As others have pointed out, it isn't a choice between "let China develop their own domestic tech on their own by making the US pull out" and "let the US companies grow by developing their stuff in China".

It is a choice between "let China develop their own domestic tech on their own by making the US pull out" and "let China develop their own domestic tech even faster and with a higher chance of success, by allowing them to openly steal the tech developed in China by US companies, all while with China kneecapping and maintaining the de facto power over those US subsidiaries located in China".

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:21PM (#33439530)
> allowing them to openly steal the tech developed in China by US companies

The sanctions have no real impact on industrial espionage and the like.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by filoleg on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:33PM (#33439749)
Yeah, but it is much easier to conduct industrial espionage when the company you are trying to steal tech from has a physical subsidiary on your territory, and when they are legally required to be under oversight from one of the party people officially assigned to "oversee" that subsidiary.

I have no illusions that the industrial espionage will stop entirely as soon as the US pulls out of China. Even without pulling out, FBI and DOJ routinely catch their spies attempting to steal the tech red-handed from within the US territory.

I imagine that after the US pulls out, industrial espionage efforts of China from within the US territory will only increase, as their previous main avenue for that (aka the US subsidiaries located in China) ceases to exist. However, doing so makes things more difficult, risky, and expensive for them, thus slowing down the rate of gains from industrial espionage.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by thatguy0900 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:29PM (#33439673)
You're saying the level of character is Chinese espionage is the same between a factory in the US and a factory in China mandated to have ccp personnel as emplyees?
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by rsj_hn on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:52PM (#33440100)
No, but companies are not shipping their ASML machines to china. US firms are already aware of this and avoid sending the secret sauce to China, they use china for final assembly, production of lower value components, etc.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by rsj_hn on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:50PM (#33440059)
This is downvoted, but really too mild. The idea of the chip curb is to force China to develop domestic replacements, which will cause industrial espionage to go up. When you declare economic war on a nation, you can expect them to ramp up spending on industrial espionage quite a bit. Not sure why this is so controversial.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by mrcheesebreeze on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:56PM (#33440172)
furthermore they tend to push harder against sanctions when they happen.

many of the most well known sanctioned nations (north korea, iran, turkiye, etc.) have just made their own stuff to varying degrees, based on how much they aren't allowed to buy.

furthermore bigger nations like china can fire back hard if need be.

we saw how europe's sanctions against russia were met with gas denial.

all in all, sanctions usually don't do much outside of wartime other than piss off the target of said sanctions, and actually push them to rely on you less.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by lovich on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:03PM (#33440296)
Why is the fact they spend more hand waved away as not an affect? Forcing them to spend more in one area lowers their ability to spend in other areas, warfare since the industrial era has been about logistics and who can put produce the other side
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by rsj_hn on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @03:18PM (#33441472)
Two issues:

1. In the case of china, we are forcing them to spend more on very high tech, strategic investments, effectively accelerating their march up the value chain.

2. It's true that there is a cost in the extra R&D spending, but there is also a cost in the lost revenue of western chip makers. NVIDIA is going to take a bath -- that will cut into their R&D budget, etc.

So we are also imposing costs on our own R&D spending while accelerating the R&D spending of our adversary - and let's just admit that China is an adversary.

This is a very strange departure from how these types of trade wars have been historically waged. Normally if you want to hurt some countries' industry and help your own, you put a tariff on their stuff and you subsidize your stuff. E.g. make it harder for China to sell their cars here and easier to sell your cars there. You encourage more exports and discourage imports.

What we are doing now is making it harder to sell our stuff there, but no tariff on the importation of Chinese chips into the U.S. So we are discouraging exports without blocking imports. And this policy is supposed to hurt China and help the US, which I find completely baffling.

This is, unfortunately, par for the course with sanctions mania, where the only policy lever we appear to have with anyone is sanctions. These sanctions are economically disastrous for the US and for Western nations generally. The only thing I can think of is that because we don't see the impact when we sanction small nations such as Cuba, we think there will still be no impact when we sanction big economies. But there is an impact, and future economic historians will look on this period of sanctions as being far more economically suicidal than the mania on trade barriers. Because a sanction is just a one way trade barrier -- directed only at yourself and your own industry.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by brookst on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @03:32PM (#33441672)
Are you suggesting that, before these sanctions, China was not putting 100% effort into industrial espionage because they had access to all of the tech, but now that they have less access they will be more invested in industrial espionage?

That seems kind of backwards to me. My read of the sanctions is that intelligence indicated that the presence of this tech was accelerating China's (largely espionage-based) development, so the policy answer was to reduce access to the tech.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by Alupis on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:43PM (#33440904)
They absolutely do. Companies won't be able to operate facilities within Chinese territory for the Chinese government to steal tech from. That will curb the overwhelming majority of the "espionage" taking place today... and will force the Chinese government to seek alternative ways to gain the technology (such as spies on US soil, which falls under the FBI's purview).

I can't reference this story[1] enough. The Chinese government literally stole ARM China right out from underneath ARM's nose. This sort of brazen technology heist won't be possible given sanctions.

[1] https://www.semianalysis.com/p/the-semiconductor-heist-of-th...

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by JPKab on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:21PM (#33440545)
You're exactly right in this comment.

A lot of the commenters in this thread appear to be completely unaware of how massive of a shift has occurred with the dictatorship of Xi Jinping.

Xi is not Hu Jintao (whom he had marched out of the CCP Congress in public view for maximum humiliation). He is not only a dictator, but also deeply insecure. This isn't another highly competent "engineer turned leader" like his predecessors. Xi is a thoroughly mediocre, lifelong political creature. He has consolidated power to the greatest degree since Chairman Mao, and has turned the CCP into a cult of personality.

He is running the Chinese economy off a cliff, meaning that China's ability to develop the tech domestically is cratering. It's hard to emphasize how different China is than before 2012. If a leader like Hu Jintao was running China, they would be able to develop this tech relatively quickly. But Xi? Everything he micromanages turns to shit.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by 8ytecoder on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:26PM (#33440622)
For anyone interested in a more detailed account - check out the podcast “The Prince” by The Economist.
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by dontlaugh on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:11PM (#33444151)
Hu is old, he needs help to walk. He was helped in and out and even returned later. Likely he needed a loo.

If you believed such a ridiculous notion, what else do you believe that is false?

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by m000 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:24PM (#33440590)
> by allowing them to openly steal the tech developed in China by US companies

What tech would that be?

Btw, China has already surpassed USA in scientific output [1]. Putting their research in applied use is just around the corner, and believing that they can't do it is just wishful thinking.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of...

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by mostlysimilar on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:27PM (#33440654)
How much does the quantity matter compared to the quality, and is there a way to assess the relative quality?
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by DiogenesKynikos on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:16PM (#33497272)
The journal Nature tries to measure overall scientific output of institutions and countries, based on numbers of articles published in high-quality journals. China has passed the US for the first time in the last few months: [0]. It's not a perfect measure, but it gives you an idea of how rapidly things have changed.

Another indicator you can look at is R&D expenditure as a percentage of GDP. China hasn't caught up with the US yet, but it has been steadily ramping up: [1].

0. https://www.nature.com/nature-index/country-outputs/generate...

1. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GB.XPD.RSDV.GD.ZS?locat...

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:38PM (#33440830)
Sure, then why worry about sanctions?
Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by ericmay on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @03:02PM (#33441239)
This doesn't measure impact of these scientific papers though, neglects US corporate and private research that doesn't get published and cited through the same means, and we have no measure of the relationship between publishing of scientific papers and "whatever we think that will accomplish".

Also there's no information from that link on who is citing these papers. Maybe it's circular citations.

Seems like a poor measure without further information.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by publicola1990 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:52PM (#33441078)
Also does the move going to negatively impact US businesses and possibly US consumers. Ultimately these measures are restrictions on what US companies can do. These restrictions are going to affect their existing/potential revenues.

So what the US companies get in the bargain with the US Government to offset their lost revenues due to this measure seems unclear.

Re:U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs by ren_engineer on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:53PM (#33441094)
if basic security doesn't work, why do people bother with passwords or basic cybersecurity measures? Most crimes are done on soft targets, even making things slightly difficult is enough

Common sense says that making espionage even slightly harder has fantastic results, look at how restrictions on nuclear technology have been successful at preventing proliferation for decades. North Korea only got their nukes after the US lifted sanctions under Clinton for a few years and China helped them