News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by highwaylights on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @03:49AM (#33432465)
They also don’t care about locking you permanently out of your own e-Mail with no warning, for no reason, with no recourse.

Honestly - there are far better options out there. They’re not in anyway a responsible enough business to manage an e-mail service. It’s run more like a hobby project than critical infrastructure.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by mr_mitm on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:25AM (#33432695)
What are those better options that HN likes? I just switched all my accounts to protonmail, but stories like this make me want to reconsider. The fact that they won't allow me to set up a forwarding rule in case I want to switch again doesn't help.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by mostafah on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:36AM (#33432781)
I’ve been a Fastmail user for about a decade (I just checked; wow!) and am very, very happy with them. I wish more companies were like them. The service is very reliable, the product is great, their support is amazing and very kind. A lot of companies get distracted by big pivots and hyper-growth ideas, while companies like Fastmail focus on doing their main job very well.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by vr46 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:26AM (#33433641)
Today I've just given up on Protonmail, the Bridge is a POS. When things were reliable, I was ok to jump through hoops in maintaining a separate app, but I cannot be bothered any longer. Just set up a Fastmail account to see what it's all about.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by BluSyn on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:31AM (#33432735)
FWIW, I went from gmail -> protonmail -> fastmail, and have been very happy with fastmail.

protonmail is great as a secure disposable email, but as a go-to daily email service I found it too difficult to manage. Hard to use other email clients due to requiring this bridge, and their mobile apps and web guis are just not up-to-par with other offerings. Being able to use any frontend on mobile (and not deal with complicated proxy setups) was my biggest issue.

Using a custom domain has made the switches easier, as I don't have to tell anyone to update their contacts or worry about forwarding. Just exporting/importing, change some MX records, and I can switch providers any time.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by tikkabhuna on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:50AM (#33433372)
I did the same thing. Custom domain with Protonmail. Ended up frustrated that I couldn't set up forwarding rules and alike. I realised I didn't need the privacy as much as I needed features.

Swapping from Protonmail to Fastmail was super easy. Exported all my email, imported into Fastmail, and swapped over the DNS records. Took me a couple of hours in between other tasks.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by Toutouxc on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:28AM (#33432721)
First of all, bring your own domain. That way you can just point the same address elsewhere if you need to switch again without having to deal with forwarding.

edit: As mentioned by a sibling comment, my email is currently on Fastmail, zero problems.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by mr_mitm on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:32AM (#33432747)
Sounds reasonable. Any gotchas there? I already read that vanity TLDs are bad, obscure countries' TLDs are bad, and even .eu may be unstable. Which are good services that can sell me an .org or .de domain for a fair price?
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by akvadrako on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:39AM (#33432800)
Obscure country TLDs are fine. I've been using https://doubly.so for a decade and never had trouble with emails.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by severino on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:35AM (#33432776)
> and even .eu may be unstable

Do you mean you can lose your domain if your country leaves the EU, or are you talking about other issues?

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by mr_mitm on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:42AM (#33432817)
Yes, that's what I had in mind, I may be wrong though. Did any Brits have issues with eu domains after Brexit?
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by c12 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:49AM (#33432879)
Yes, but that was due to Brexit.

.eu domains may only be registered to a person or entity that exists within the EU. As soon as Brexit crystallised any British person or entity owning a .eu domain was unable to renew it unless they had an address they legally occupied within an EU country.

I know a few companies who rented a small amount of office space in France so that they could retain their .eu domain.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by severino on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @11:26AM (#33437391)
I guess you can get a .eu domain for ten years. So that could be an option to make sure you have enough time to shift to another domain should your country leave the EU too. Assuming, well, that the EU won't take it away from you before the expiry date just because you lost your EU residence.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by c12 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:44AM (#33432836)
I have heard people say "vanity TLDs are bad" but never experienced it myself.

I have email addresses at .co.uk, .digital and .social never had deliverability issues with sending or receiving.

When I worked at a large (100m emails/wk) email service provider the key thing was sending IP reputation followed by things like DKIM and SPF DNS records on the sending domain.

IP reputation would be an issue if you self hosted your email, but using a reputable provider such as tutanota and fastmail should pose no issue.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by infinita740 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:55AM (#33434262)
It's a single data point but a friend of mine had an outage with ".online" in switzerland.

We resolved it by pointing clients to use google dns.

Never had similar problems with .com

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by jrootabega on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:48AM (#33432877)
Speaking from personal experience, if you have to spell your domain for people, you will regret it!
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by formerly_proven on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:50AM (#33432888)
inwx + mailbox.org
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by UweSchmidt on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:03AM (#33433003)
I wouldn't go for the cheapest price, I'd go to some established place in your jurisdiction with a wider product range and size, that targets small businesses. You have a chance to get some useful hotline, and things can be 'integrated' and are more likely to work, i.e. host your website - book the domain example.com - book a managed nextcloud and have it be at cloud.example.com etc.

Their email service is likely to have some credibility from the global anti-spam force. They probably have the budget for best practices and reasonable security. As you mention .de domains: The online legal text generators for Impressum/Datenschutzerklärung are likely to have the correct text fragments to use for larger vendors. Overall they just have to uphold some level of reputation I hope.

Example: ionos.de

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:51AM (#33432900)
Fastmail user here with custom .org domain. Works great; Fastmail app and web. Very satisfied.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by gary_0 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:59AM (#33432968)
HN thread discussing Fastmail experiences: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31989061
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by jamil7 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:16AM (#33433114)
The only hesitation I have with switching now is Fastmail being based in Australia.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by creata on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:32AM (#33435477)
Why? They aren't offering an end-to-end encrypted service, so as far as I know Australia's laws aren't much worse than, say, the US' laws in this regard.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by Eumenes on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:24AM (#33433626)
I don't need a custom domain anymore and I find it trivial to change email addresses. I can use 1password to locate accounts, easily migrate, apply a tag, and work through the change over a few hours. I typically change email every 2-3 years and it serves as a good way to review security settings/change passwords. Modern email providers have mailbox porting tools, and they work fine. I use to like having a domain, but dunno, for a privacy nut, seems more secure to not use one.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by return_to_monke on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:31AM (#33433677)
I don't think the hard thing is switching emails. The difficult thing is telling everyone about the fact that you switched.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by severino on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:50PM (#33440057)
> I use to like having a domain, but dunno, for a privacy nut, seems more secure to not use one.

Care to explain which are those concerns about privacy that you may find when owning a custom email address? Thanks in advance.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by Eumenes on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:39PM (#33442616)
I was being a bit pedantic but ... a domain registrar could be an attack vector, its not as anonymous as something like proton/tutanota, not beholden to ICANN, if you use an alias related to your domain it could be tied to you. If I give up the domain in the future, it could be used against me in a social engineering way.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by gobip on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:27AM (#33432712)
HN is hooked on fastmail which is a great provider to be honest. Have a look at mailbox.org which is in business since the 90s too. Avoid the privacy trending providers promising you to encrypt your emails.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by akvadrako on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:40AM (#33432801)
I second mailbox.org. Didn't want to use fastmail since it's based in Australia instead of the EU.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by twleo on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:29AM (#33433197)
FastMail takes on PGP is very reasonable.

https://fastmail.blog/advanced/why-we-dont-offer-pgp/

I don't believe the encryption/key management from a company.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by twleo on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:27AM (#33433185)
I uses FastMail after I discover this serious issue about Proton. I would say it work flawlessly and their web mail client is super fast; even faster than Gmail.

Besides, FastMail exists before Gmail and the people in FastMail are active standard protocol developers like IMAP and recently JMAP (a modern mail protocol will replace SMTP/IMAP, FastMail as a reference implementation), which is good because at least I know they understand the protocol and implement it by themselves.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by Semaphor on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:09AM (#33434413)
> even faster than Gmail.

It’s really fast, but come on, that’s one low bar to jump over. Gmail is the electron of mail interfaces.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by RealStickman_ on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:49AM (#33433366)
I've switched to mailbox.org. They allow boring old IMAP/SMTP (that's good) and are EU-based.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by uselpa on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:55AM (#33433415)
Same here, mailbox.org with custom .eu domain. Very reliable.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by andrewmi on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:12AM (#33433535)
I'm a happy customer of Zoho Mail
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by MrBuddyCasino on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:12AM (#33433539)
Anyone has experience with hey.com?
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by benhurmarcel on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:44AM (#33434187)
I tried it for a year.

I'm quite positive on it, nice interface and unique useful features, and it's reliable in my experience. However you have to be ok with its particularities, mainly that it doesn't have IMAP, and it's expensive.

Ultimately it's for people who love their unique interface/features, and don't mind paying so much for email.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by worble on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:18AM (#33433576)
Happy user of Migadu here, mostly because they let you bring as many domain names as you want and just charge usage.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by wccrawford on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:40AM (#33433736)
I've been using Purelymail for quite a while now and I've been happy with it.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by alpaca128 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:22AM (#33434556)
I personally use mailbox.org for years now. Granted, I don't have remotely the usage mentioned in the linked issue and I know users that aren't very satisfied with features like the integrated office webapp, but it does everything I need (emails & calendar sync) and I haven't found a reason not to trust them.

Originally my reason to choose them instead of Protonmail was that Protonmail only works with their official client, which is a far too limiting dependency in my eyes.

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by waynesonfire on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:25AM (#33432701)
Yep, I encountered this and will not renew the service next year as a result.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by gobip on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:25AM (#33432700)
What would you recommend? I'd recommend fastmail or mailbox.org
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by jrootabega on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:45AM (#33432850)
I think it's worse than that - they are well into the stage of growth where privacy and reliability are just marketing deceptions. Some other recent data points:

- They suddenly weakened a privacy setting, and even exposed some client IPs for good measure. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33375424

- Yesterday they decided to throw up a big modal advertisement for a bulk plan at login, even to paying customers. Note that they chose NOT to do this for the aforementioned privacy-weakening change. - https://old.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/yj5m59/pm_visio...

Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by OneLeggedCat on Thursday November 03, 2022 @01:41AM (#33447436)
That changed setting should have been a huge story. I've paid for ProtonMail for like 6 years now, and this was the most disappointing thing I've dealt with.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by jrootabega on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:12AM (#33449832)
Thank you; it's frustrating that this isn't being covered more widely, but good to know that there are people who see the problem. If nothing else, don't give up trying to inform people!
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by ClawsOnPaws on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:08AM (#33433045)
Randomly, I get locked out of my Protonmail webmail interface by an hCaptcha. This in itself isn't a problem. The problem starts because I can't actually see the captcha images. So in order to get at my email, I have to provide hCaptcha with a third party email which isn't protonmail, and enable third party cookies and/or install a browser extension for them to set an "accessibility cookie" to get past the captcha. And, well, nobody wants to do anything about that either. I'm sorry, but that doesn't seem reasonable to me.
Re:Protonmail can delete the wrong email and nobody cares by ThePowerOfFuet on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:19AM (#33435276)
You should investigate what's blocking the images, as that is the true source of the issue.