News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by millzlane on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:59PM (#33378495)
They both corrected the articles after 3 hours. Gotta give credit where credit is due. But it shouldn't scare you that peoples lies are taken at face value. We see it everyday. Hell some politicians are lying right your face.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:06PM (#33378571)
Journalists are supposed to have more credibility than your friend's gossip though...

While retracting and/or correcting the articles is a step towards journalistic integrity, it should be very troubling these articles were published in the first place.

After all, how many people bother to go back and review past articles just on the off chance some piece of information was corrected? None...

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by yeuxardents on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:09PM (#33378596)
Honestly it troubles me that anyone believes 'journalists' from any of the major corporations have _any_ credibility, even going back to the 1990s with censorship of stories have been rife within the corporate 'journalism' industry. There are very few journalists that deserve real credibility.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:28PM (#33378785)
Journalists should not be afforded legal protections for publishing un-verified, demonstrably false information.

We need a system where it's dangerous to not thoroughly vet your story before throwing it over the fence.

Currently, they just say "oops" and move on like it never happened... but the damages caused to the public and it's discourse are permanent. The past decade has shown us that much at a minimum.

Years from now folks will still howl about Musk marching loyal twitter employees out the front door with boxes full of their belongings... despite it being completely untrue. Heck, there are still folks that feverishly assert the "OK" sign is racist...

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by nradov on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:35PM (#33378837)
Journalists don't have any special protection under US federal law for publishing false information. Anyone can sue them for libel. Although it's difficult for plaintiffs to win such cases, regardless of whether the defendant is a journalist or anyone else.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:42PM (#33378884)
It does not need to be libel to be permanently damaging to the public.

The "OK" sign as a symbol of "white power" is a great example - nobody's reputation was tarnished directly by the reporting... but the entire story was made up and never true. Yet, there's folks today that insist it truly is a symbol of "white power".

Libel is also notoriously difficult to establish grounds for, and be successful with a lawsuit. Intent is difficult to prove - yet I would assert a journalist that does not thoroughly vet their story before publishing has a malicious intent, even if it was indirect.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by nemothekid on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:51PM (#33378973)
>The "OK" sign as a symbol of "white power" is a great example - nobody's reputation was tarnished directly by the reporting... but the entire story was made up and never true. Yet, there's folks today that insist it truly is a symbol of "white power".

This is strange - the OK symbol was definitely co-opted by white nationalists; it started as a "media troll", then people started to do it non-ironically. It served it's purpose and to say it was "never true" is at the very least controversial. I had personally seen it spread on /pol/ months before it got any mainstream coverage.

While I believe the story may have been overblown, I think it stands it would be very difficult to sue a journalist that this was libel or even untrue. At the very least the memes had to have started from somewhere and that posing with the ok symbol wasn't a particularly popular thing to do until after the memes were created.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:14PM (#33379189)
It started on 4Chan as a deliberate "watch us make the media go nuts" joke... and it worked.

Today, here you are asserting it actually has an alternate, nefarious meaning. It doesn't, and never did.

It became a meme because of how ridiculous of an idea it was.

I think you're proving my point. Retractions and corrections do not work. Published stories have enormous weight, yet modern journalists don't seem to be aware of, or do not care about, the potential harm they can do. It's just a race to publish first - truth be damned.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by nemothekid on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:46PM (#33379452)
>It started on 4Chan as a deliberate "watch us make the media go nuts" joke... and it worked.

The disagreement then you and I have is that just because it was an "epic troll" doesn't make it any less serious. To me the fact that it's supposed to be a "joke on the media" is the point - it provides plausible deniability. That's the entire point of using the OK sign; Plausible deniability.

You could go on 4chan and found hundreds of pictures of guys posing with the ok sign, but you'd have to be really naive to think they didn't know what they were doing. A bunch of open white nationalists all adopted the same symbolism at the same time, but I'm supposed to pretend that the symbolism isn't being co-opted?

To be fair, I don't think it was ever the case that Trump or many high ranking officials used the OK symbol as some dogwhistle (Trump has always spoken with his hands), but to pretend it was never true is completely false. May journalists have blown the thing out of proportion? Sure, but that isn't libel and you can't sue someone for mistaking the growth of a trend.

>I think you're proving my point. Retractions and corrections do not work.

I am not someone who came to this conclusion from reading a New York Times article. I've spent a lot of time on 4chan in my teenage years and have kept the site at an arms distance. It was very clear to me what the gesture meant. I remember the threads, and I remember seeing the image the ADL now uses when it was first posted on there. To pretend that 4chan isn't full of white nationalists is bonkers. It's like saying the swatstika never meant anything other than spirituality. Their stated reasons for co-opting the symbol doesn't change the fact they co-opted it.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @08:09PM (#33379606)
Jim says: Some people like to bathe in mayonnaise.

Bob says: It has been reported some people like to bathe in mayonnaise.

Is Bob wrong here? Yes, because Bob didn't verify the information as being factual. Bob might as well have just made it all up himself... it would be no worse. Quite a silly example, but I hope you see the point.

4Chan made up the "OK" symbol story. The media ran with it doing zero research or verification. Then, sometime later people starting meming the symbol because it's laughably absurd.

That does not make it a "co-opted" symbol and does not give it any additional meaning other than literally meaning "OK". It really does not matter if you can find some example of some full fledged level 47 paladin super dragon KKK guy in white robes that made that symbol once because it was funny - it still does not mean "white power" for crying out loud. There is no reality where there is a KKK meeting (or whatever) where they gather around and flash "OK" signs to one another. Real life isn't a corny 70's comedy.

You've been had, very badly, and are really hammering my point deeper and deeper. The media needs to be held accountable for publishing unverified and/or untrue stories because they are extremely damaging to the public.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by belltaco on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:49PM (#33390859)
What about the white nationalist that killed 49 people in cold blood flashing the symbol in court? Is that funny to you as well? At what point does it become an actual symbol used by white nationalists to signal white nationalism and racism?
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by nemothekid on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:21PM (#33408004)
>It really does not matter if you can find some example of some full fledged level 47 paladin super dragon KKK guy in white robes that made that symbol once because it was funny - it still does not mean "white power" for crying out loud.

You and I just have very different levels of tolerance when it comes to in-group signifiers. You can are carry water for these white nationalists, but the whole "it's just little joke" cover is on purpose. It provides a cover of plausible deniability. Wikipedia has a list of white nationalists using the symbol while shooting up mosques but I assume the bullets were made up by 4chan as well. How many white nationalists have to use the symbol while committing hate crimes before it's no longer media sensation?

>There is no reality where there is a KKK meeting (or whatever) where they gather around and flash "OK" signs to one another. Real life isn't a corny 70's comedy.

I never implied this and you trying to reduce racism to cartoony levels of seriousness that you might see in a film.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:23PM (#33413397)
What clothing were they wearing? Perhaps jeans and shoes are racist now too...
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by 18pfsmt on Friday October 28, 2022 @08:24PM (#33379682)
People say Twitter is not real life, then you proffer 4chan as real life.

Touch grass, my friend.

I went from pharma research (my degree) to tech to the restaurant world. We use lots of hand gestures because the environment is loud. The hispanic guys I work with give me the bird all the time (kitchen crew), and nobody takes offense.

You want to believe, and that is clear.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by andrew_ on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:19PM (#33379221)
you've been captured by the spin. as a sibling comment points out, it was a joke from the get go, and everyone was is on it except for those who wanted it to be true.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by nradov on Friday October 28, 2022 @10:36PM (#33380449)
That's a very abstract and subjective concept of damage. What are you proposing exactly?
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by _jal on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:02PM (#33379077)
> Journalists should not be afforded legal protections

They have no special protection.

> need a system where it's dangerous

You want to destroy free speech, then. Any policy covering journalists would equally apply to everyone.

> assert the "OK" sign is racist

Are you asserting it wasn't used by trolling white nationalists? Or do you mean that the intent was trolling, rather than something "sincere"? Or something else?

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by Alupis on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:21PM (#33379238)
> They have no special protection.

Yes they do. How often are journalists successfully sued for damaging stories that turned out to be untrue and unverified?

> You want to destroy free speech, then

It has never been ok to harm someone else with your speech. People lose careers, lives and more over unverified stories.

> Are you asserting it wasn't used by trolling white nationalists? Or do you mean that the intent was trolling, rather than something "sincere"? Or something else?

There is no assertion, it is fact. This story was made up by 4Chan to provoke the exact response they got... and then young folks started meming with the sign because of how ridiculous it is.

There are still folks, however, that truly believe there were troves of actual white supremist roaming the streets flashing "secret" symbols to each other and giggling... Come on, say it out loud and try not to laugh.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by aeternum on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:12PM (#33379176)
It has been an issue since the invention of the printing press. Benjamin Franklin himself published fake news about Indian tribes scalping the settlers in order to convince the colonists to take action against them.

https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Franklin/01-37-02-01...

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by User23 on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:22PM (#33379245)
He wrote in his Autobiography that propaganda was the primary reason to own a newspaper.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by drekipus on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:09PM (#33378602)
I think half the population has already long-ago lost trust in media and journalists, and now the other half is catching up.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by trendroid on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:50PM (#33378955)
For some reason many of these people that lose trust in traditional media immediately start trusting "independent media" on YouTube that happens to agrees with their views or ways of seeing the world.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by encryptluks2 on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:34PM (#33379350)
Yes, because the education system failed them and taught them to blindly trust in the media and so when they lose that they go to the opposite end of the spectrum. Some of them will come around and find some middle ground, and others will be be content in spewing misinformation as long as it makes them feel better.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by kdkdjdsj on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:13PM (#33379182)
Idk, show of hands: who thinks Brian Sicknick was killed with a fire extinguisher?

Who thinks there is a tape of Donald Trump pissing on a prostitute, or that he was caught communicating with Alfa Bank, or

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by User23 on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:26PM (#33379282)
I trust broadly corroborated video evidence. For example I know that the “mostly peaceful protests” were anything but from watching videos filmed by diverse sources.

The Internet and ubiquitous cameras really have revolutionized our ability to see what’s actually going on.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:29PM (#33379301)
> Journalists are supposed to have more credibility than your friend's gossip though

For what is essentially a pop culture scoop, three hours seems like a fine trade-off between accuracy and timeliness.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by taylodl on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:16PM (#33380653)
Are people paying for credibility? Hate to break the news to you (ha!) but the news you’re going to see the most is the news that sells the best. It’s all about those Benjamins. You can’t expect good things from a society that has compromised all its ideals and prostrates itself for money. Certainly not journalistic integrity - unless it sells. Which it doesn’t.
Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by thrown_22 on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:19PM (#33378709)
People still think that police were murdered by the protesters on Jan 6 two years after being told that every police officer who died on that day died from causes that had nothing to do with the protestors and everything to do with going up a flight of stairs under the influence of donuts.

It's not good enough to print a retraction which no one sees and pretend it's solved the problem of spreading lies.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by bhaney on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:44PM (#33378909)
> They both corrected the articles after 3 hours

Because they got caught. How long would those articles have remained up if nobody else had done the journalists' investigation jobs for them and then reported the incorrect story? Would the journalists who "broke" the story ever have bothered to verify it themselves? Would they have issued a correction at all if it didn't quickly become public knowledge that the story was fake?

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by jwond on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:45PM (#33379441)
I don’t think they are really due any credit for correcting misinformation that they shouldn’t have published in the first place.

I understand news outlets are all in a rush to be among the first to cover these trending stories, but in my opinion that is not a valid excuse for failing to verify basic facts prior to publication.

Re:People are pretending to be laid-off Twitter employees ca... by cocoricamo on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:12PM (#33379945)
Yeah, it's scary.

It was obvious the guys were trolling. Last names "Ligma" and "Johnson" very over the top statement holding a Michelle Obama book.

The journalists were either too focused on getting the scoop and fooled themselves into believing what is clearly a ruse or they knew and went along with it because it generated views/clicks.