If you take a scissor to a reproduction of a piece of art you have not created yourself (and for which the protection timeframe has not ended yet), create snippets, and rearrange them, this can be considered an Urheberrecht violation[1]. No one would consider doing the same to a newspaper the same.
[1] The distinction here is relevant: German copyright is not like US copyright - it can't be sold away, you can only license out individual derived rights, and it also allows for protection against "abuse of a work", e.g. doing something with it the original creator disapproves of[2]. If that always applies to the removal of ads has not been decided in a final decision.
[2] "The author has the right to prohibit any distortion or other interference with his work that is likely to jeopardize his legitimate intellectual or personal interests in the work." Art 14 UrhG
In answer, I should probably invoke accessibility laws, asserting that ads make my blood pressure rise and induce vomiting.
Also, since parodies have been deemed fair use since about forever, what I’m reading is fine parodies, which are exactly the originals except they don’t have ads.
Also, good luck with that clause against Links, Lynx and Dillo.
Isn't it? https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__51a.html
That seems absurd. I just reject their request to fetch some _additional_ information, I don't modify the "text of their request" as such. If that breaks their sites (as it usually does), that's their problem - not mine.
I had a neighbor who was sent an invoice, he had cancelled his internet connection 3 months ago and was later told they need a cancellation request in writing. so he sent an equivalent invoice to them asking for rent for their modem which was consuming place in his house. he did not have to pay in the end.
It's the same reason US privacy regulation is doomed to failure unless it frames consent the same way the GDPR did. Not merely as something that can be given once (and then vectoralized and sold), but rather something that needs to be given on an ongoing basis and can be withdrawn at any time.
A bit more nuanced: not loading in the ad on a news site is akin to ripping out and throwing away the subscription card in the magazine. The contents of each might be subject to copyright, but that doesn't invalidate my right to separate them once delivered to me.
Copyright is about distribution.
"A work consisting of editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications, which, as a whole, represent an original work of authorship, is a “derivative work”."
Suppose it's true and that they are copyright holders for all these ads (they are not). Now, when the publisher gets a newspaper out, the content is just as they wanted. But when I take that newspaper home and decide to tear out a page or whatever fragment of it, it's none of their business. The filtering is being done locally, EasyList is not publishing an adless version of their websites.
This exact thing happened with Nintendo decades ago, and it turned out to be a nothing burger.
Here's a short update on what happened since then:
1. DMCA takedowns did not destroy ad blocking (thank god), but there were a couple more times when it was tried, nothing huge though.
2. Streisand effect is a thing and the domain in question was blocked by everyone and everywhere. There was even a special filter list and later a browser extension which only purpose was to block such domains. It got some traction but later got abandoned: https://github.com/paulgb/BarbBlock. If something like that happens again I am pretty sure it can be revived very quickly.
3. The corporations still try different angles to prohibit ad blocking. The last example I know about is something like this: Axel Springer claimed that the web page and all its content (including subrequest) and ads is subject to copyright law. So when you modify the web page with adding new styles or blocking a web request you violate the copyright.