But that's all obvious nonsense.
Perhaps. But "making sense" is generally not a priority for the law. And taking such a stance might be pretty useful, on the PR/politics side...
Making sense is usually a priority for the judges that run the court cases that define what the law is/means.
Making sense is a high priority for legal arguments. You may be unfamiliar with the context in which things are meant to make sense though.
You don't even need to make up a reason. I'm visually impaired in a way that has substantial cortical visual impairment, issues with movement, and issues with crowding. Ads are genuinely an accessibility problem for me and people like me.
I don't modify the page, I just ban the browser to fetch some domains. Try banning hosts file usage, Axel Springer.
Also, good luck with that clause against Links, Lynx and Dillo.
It's German law being discussed. Germany doesn't have a fair use element to their copyright law, just some specific exemptions. Parody isn't one of them.
> just some specific exemptions. Parody isn't one of them.
Isn't it? https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__51a.html
Re:Ad blocking is under attack
by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:13AM
(#33357716)
This isn't a fair use issue. It's a matter of property rights. If they don't want people choosing what code executes on their computer they need to abandon open protocols designed to permit that.
In answer, I should probably invoke accessibility laws, asserting that ads make my blood pressure rise and induce vomiting.
Also, since parodies have been deemed fair use since about forever, what I’m reading is fine parodies, which are exactly the originals except they don’t have ads.