News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by borissk on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:04AM (#33288751)
If one way or another Starlink starts providing precise positioning data it will turn their satellites into a valid military target in case of a war. E.g. if China invaded Taiwan, they may take down the part of the constellation that passes over China (if they can cheaply mass produce and launch interceptors).
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by s1artibartfast on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:12PM (#33289623)
Starlink already is a valid military target in time of war.

Also, the way the orbits are established and the fact that Taiwan is roughly equatorial, I thin every satellite eventually passes over it. Starlink is not geostationary

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by aredox on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:25AM (#33289009)
They could easily saturate the whole LEO where starlink operates with schrapnel - and any damaged sat would add more schrapnel, as described by the "Kessler syndrome".
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by audunw on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:17PM (#33289693)
That would be quite dumb. Whatever you put in that orbit will decay within a few years.

Given the current situation, USA/SpaceX is in a far better position to quickly repopulate LEO with satellites when the debris has fallen down. In that case, they may send up satellites armed with weapons that can shoot down anything being launched into orbit to create debris again.

I don't think entering into that kind of conflict with USA is a winning proposition for China unless they have their own Falcon 9 or Starship-like rocket.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by outworlder on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#33290733)
> In that case, they may send up satellites armed with weapons that can shoot down anything being launched into orbit to create debris again.

What happened to the outer space treaty?

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:47PM (#33290897)
Ripped up as soon as you started intentionally trying to create Kessler syndrome...
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by gojomo on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:50PM (#33290938)
In some hypothetical hot conflict where a major belligerent nation had already started taking down satellites and/or polluting orbits, the treaty will have already become a 'dead letter'.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by Rebelgecko on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:02PM (#33293004)
As long as they're not using nukes I don't think compliance with the OST would be an issue
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by TMWNN on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:21AM (#33296475)
Let me guess: You're one of those people who said that the US Space Force "violated the treaty" because it "weaponizes space", right?

The treaty bans weapons of mass destruction in space. It does not ban military activity in space at all.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:09PM (#33291157)
> Given the current situation, USA/SpaceX is in a far better position to quickly repopulate LEO with satellites when the debris has fallen down

It's far cheaper to heft tens of thousands of ball bearings into orbit vs a single satellite. You can give them a nice spread so you have a space shotgun that ruin an orbit for years at a time. The decay is a bonus to the attacker[1] because they can a go all out during wartime, without impacting their long-term space-faring program.

1. The decay also allows the same armaments to cover a larger vertical slice of the orbit.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by basementcat on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:31PM (#33291432)
You mean like Project West Ford? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_West_Ford
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:32PM (#33293689)
I was thinking having the projectiles being aerodynamic may increase decay time, then realized you can have the launch vehicle use solar power to fire the metal spheres using a railgun mechanism. This way, you can get vastly larger areas of denial by firing at an angle perpendicular to that of travel. You can have an every-shifting debris field if you fire 2 ball-bearings (port and starboard) every 10-50 meters to make that entire altitude unusable[1] - not just a specific orbit.

Edit: 1. The perigee and apogee will differ for projectiles fired from port or starboard based on launch vehicle inclination and the resulting relative speeds to earth. It would be a nightmare to track and avoid the resulting mess.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by vineyardmike on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:43PM (#33292827)
> USA/SpaceX is in a far better position to quickly repopulate LEO with satellites when the debris has fallen down

Until china threatens musks other factories and he voluntarily decided that defense isn’t a good business for SpaceX. Or maybe he’ll do what he did with Ukraine and advocate for china just to end the war (probably due to business risk of Tesla et al).

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by simondotau on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:22PM (#33294001)
Tesla might be the most profitable business Musk is involved in, but SpaceX is nearest and dearest to his heart. It’s worth more to Musk than one factory which, after Berlin and Austin finish ramping up, will represent just one quarter of their global factory capacity.

IMHO, I think would be more likely that Musk would divest his entire ownership of Tesla than do anything which would compromise the long-term mission of SpaceX.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by pencilguin on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:10PM (#33294286)
Do you think you know the long term mission of SpaceX? It certainly is not colonizing Mars, no matter what Elon claims. Nothing SpaceX is known to be working on is anywhere close to adequate for that.

My own guess is it is to get the US military dependent on him. Then he can write himself billion-dollar checks. NASA is just for practice.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by vineyardmike on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:58AM (#33296380)
I don’t think he’d have that luxury. Especially not if a situation snuck up as they often do in war. Not that I think any of this is likely.

25% of their factory output is a lot. Sure it’s an amount that won’t leave the company in ruin, but it’s a lot. Teslas growing stock price basically funds all of spaceX so divesting is unlikely.

Realistically, SpaceX filled the mission musk had. It proved that space is viable with better tech. They’re really beholden to the government and he won’t be able to shake that.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by simondotau on Saturday October 22, 2022 @07:44PM (#33303239)
It is simply wrong on the evidence that Tesla’s stock rise funds SpaceX. It is a profitable business and funds itself. And SpaceX doesn’t hold any Tesla stock as far as I’m aware.

My point is that he would divest ownership of Tesla before allowing himself to be blackmailed over SpaceX. I’m not saying that he wouldn’t care if the factory in China shut, though I am saying he might prefer that over SpaceX being neutered.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by vineyardmike on Sunday October 23, 2022 @03:09PM (#33309352)
> It is simply wrong on the evidence that Tesla’s stock rise funds SpaceX. It is a profitable business and funds itself. And SpaceX doesn’t hold any Tesla stock as far as I’m aware.

No but musk owns Tesla shares and as they rise he can invest new cash into it.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by rlt on Monday October 24, 2022 @01:01AM (#33313104)
He could, but so far he hasn't, AFAIK. You might be thinking of Jeff Bezos who pours something like a billion dollars a year into Blue Origin.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by simondotau on Monday October 24, 2022 @04:24AM (#33314157)
You said "Teslas growing stock price basically funds all of spaceX" and now you're completely changing your story to something else which is also speculation based on nothing. It would be appreciated if you actually admitted that to yourself and perhaps in an apology here.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by baq on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:33AM (#33289093)
There's nothing easy about what you propose. It requires launch capability similar to what SpaceX has, i.e. state of the art.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by shadowgovt on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:42AM (#33289222)
Given that they have a working space station, I'm certain China has enough launch capability to make the Starlink orbit hell with several well-placed rockets undergoing very dirty disassembly in orbit.

(In fact, among the things that makes that scenario less likely is the fact they have a space station and would like to keep visiting it without worrying about passing through a Kessler cloud).

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by panick21_ on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:20PM (#33289732)
A space station doesn't mean you have a lot of launch capability.

Its and its not clear how you standard rockets can easily be used as anti-sat weapons, and if that makes finical sense.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by soperj on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:09PM (#33291163)
US had a working space station for over a decade without the ability to put people onto that space station.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by shadowgovt on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:06PM (#33291863)
This is true, but seems irrelevant because China is self-crewing its station.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by ncallaway on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#33291262)
A Kessler cloud would not persist in orbit at the altitude of Starlink satellites for very long.

And building and maintaining a Kessler cloud at that altitude seems like it would be… not effective with just a handful of rockets due to the significant atmospheric drag.

Kessler syndrome is a real concern, but only at higher altitudes where atmospheric drag is negligible.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by mlindner on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:24PM (#33292638)
> Given that they have a working space station, I'm certain China has enough launch capability to make the Starlink orbit hell with several well-placed rockets undergoing very dirty disassembly in orbit.

Yes and their "working space station" is also below that orbit. So they'd need to blow up their own station as well. Also the international space station as well.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#33290951)
Kessler syndrome is not "easy" to create at 550km. The orbits decay way too fast. Whole satellites decay in 5 years or less; smaller debris decays faster due to higher surface area to mass ratio. And the orbit doesn't have to decay all the way to 0 for the debris to stop being a threat to Starlink; a few km is all it would take. I haven't seen a lot of calculations about this but my belief is that even intentionally creating Kessler syndrome at 550 km would be infeasible, and it certainly won't happen by accident.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by tomatotomato37 on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#33291258)
The point really isn't to completely shut down that orbit, just deny it for however long you strategically need. Throwing up a huge flak cloud using magnetized cheap metal tinsel on an old ICBM isn't only easy, but also has actually been done before, albeit for different reasons

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_West_Ford

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:26PM (#33291372)
You won't be able to cause Kessler syndrome promptly. It takes a while for the collision debris to build up, and it takes a while for individual satellites to get hit. Space is big and even huge debris clouds will take a long time to hit something. It's not going to help your ground invasion next month or anything like that. Very impractical as a weapon of war.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by simondotau on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:09PM (#33293917)
Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mind-bogglingly big it is. Any given orbital plane is larger than the entire surface of Earth, including the oceans. Combine that with the fact that explosions and collisions introduce randomness to the orbital plane of each piece of debris, and you’ve got a lot of hurdles to overcome in order to get to some short term low earth orbit Kessler.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by godelski on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:26PM (#33293644)
That just makes it more likely. If you think war is going to last awhile, or you have a severe disadvantage, you shut down access to space for a few years. The cost of such an attack is lower BECAUSE it resolves itself rather quickly.

Though the issue is that it is substantially harder to create the Kessler Syndrome than people claim.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:35PM (#33293709)
I disagree that it is more likely. It would take months worth of launches to fill an orbital shell with debris at the very least and nobody's going to do it before starting a war. You don't start a war with the intention of having it drag on for years. If you're losing a war you're not going to have the resources to do it nor the ability to do the launches without getting your launch pads destroyed. Furthermore it doesn't shut down all access to space, as you can launch through the cloud to a higher orbit.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by godelski on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:23PM (#33294010)
> I disagree that it is at all likely. It would take months if not years worth of launches to fill an orbital shell with debris

Aren't we in agreement?

>> Though the issue is that it is substantially harder to create the Kessler Syndrome than people claim.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by chickenpotpie on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:49PM (#33290177)
I would be more worried about the undersea fiber optic cable. There's 13 cables that provide the vast majority of internet into the country and they're deep underwater where they could easily be destroyed with no defense.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by njarboe on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:04PM (#33291108)
See Nord Stream 1 and 2 for an example.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by dylan604 on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:54PM (#33293844)
I'm guessing it's a bit easier to repair/splice a fiber break than repairing gas pipes
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by pencilguin on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:55PM (#33294197)
Harder if they roll up the cable, or just drag the cut end a mile away.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:42PM (#33290835)
Every part of the constellation passes over China. The Starlink satellite constellation is practically invulnerable to physical attack because it would be prohibitively expensive to hit thousands of individual satellites with interceptors. And SpaceX can keep launching them, 50 at a time (potentially hundreds at a time once Starship is working, along with an increase in constellation size to 30,000+).

Physical attacks on the ground stations are more feasible from a physics perspective, but now that the satellites have laser links you'd have to take out ground stations all over the world to completely cut service, not just locally.

The way to attack Starlink would be hacking, either of the command and control system or the user terminals. Failing that, then jamming, and/or anti-radiation missiles targeted at the user terminals. Russia is known to be trying hacking and jamming already. I haven't heard about them locating user terminals by their transmissions but I'd be shocked if they aren't trying that too.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by mike_d on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:08PM (#33291881)
China already has an extensive network of fixed location coordinated signal jammers deployed across the country. It is regularly used to overpower Radio Free Asia and Voice of Tibet broadcasts, and has conducted exercises blocking GPS.

But a much more likely response would be equipping local police with direction finding equipment for signals in the 10-12 GHz band and bashing in the skulls of anyone found with a terminal.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:30PM (#33292110)
The military threat of Starlink to China is as a way for the Taiwanese defense to communicate during an invasion. In peacetime they can prevent Starlink from operating in China simply by threatening Elon Musk with the loss of his Shanghai factory.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by wolpoli on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:35PM (#33292158)
Starlink seems to be protected by the fact that it could launch satalites cheaper than the adversary. That advantage will hold until the opponent gains the ability to launch small satalites at a low cost. Eg. Opponents launches and pre-positions mini suicide satalites 100 at a time in orbit, leading to a weaponization of space.

Or it might be easier to just pressure Musk's other business interests.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by uri4 on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:48PM (#33292294)
Not really. To destroy satellite you need suborbital rocket with much lower speed. Usually it is a missile launched from airplane. Even WW2 V2 missile could propably do it, if it had navigation.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:54PM (#33292923)
Even so, SpaceX can launch 50 satellites in one launch, and each suborbital interceptor can only hit one. And the "if it had navigation" part is doing a lot of work in that sentence; a satellite interceptor kill vehicle is not easy to build. Are 50 of them cheaper than one Falcon 9 launch with a 15x reused booster? I think "maybe" is the only possible answer, but probably the cost of killing all the satellites that way would be around the same order of magnitude as putting them up in the first place. You would need to build multiple whole factories just to make the thousands of interceptors you would need.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by Rebelgecko on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:59PM (#33292974)
I wonder how hard it is to take out multiple starlink satellites right after launch, when they're all on essentially the same orbit?
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:04PM (#33293016)
It's an interesting idea. They are deployed and start spreading out within minutes of launch. You might be able to take them all out in the first couple of orbits. I expect it would be much harder after that. SpaceX could possibly defend against this by varying the orbit so you don't know where to place your interceptors, and maybe by having the satellites boost apart from each other sooner.

But you'd also need to take out most of the on-orbit satellites before it would be useful to blow up the replacements.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by zeroimpl on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:00AM (#33307501)
Seems like it’d be easier/more effective to take out the launch vessel.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by modeless on Sunday October 23, 2022 @05:35PM (#33310505)
Sure, but you'd have to be relatively close to the launch pad. The advantage of doing it in orbit is you can do it from the other side of the world.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by sgc on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:49PM (#33293399)
Since 500 terminals a month are being destroyed in Ukraine, per Elon, it seems clear they are targeting them.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by Schroedingersat on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:39PM (#33294870)
I would have assumed most advanced militaries would have a maser or similar capable of cooking civilian solar panels at 500km by now.
Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by VincentEvans on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:08PM (#33291153)
Recent actions of Russia in Ukraine have shown how vacuous the term “valid military target” is, to the point that there’s very little sense in discussing it.

(One may argue that along with that it also exposed how empirically inadequate are a lot of other terms, institutions, conventions, and rules we’ve become accustomed to relying on for maintaining our peace, security, and ensuring that bad guys don’t go unpunished, but i guess that would be a digression for another time).

The meaning behind such terms exists only for those warring states that choose to respect them - the list that likely does not include any of the realistic opponents we consider today, such as Russia, or North Korea, or Iran, or unfortunately, China.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by rzimmerman on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:34PM (#33291472)
There are a few technical reasons I don’t see this as a real threat:

1. There isn’t a particular part of the constellation that passes over China. There are probably a few launch groups that never or rarely pass over China, but a majority do. An adversary would have to destroy or disable a few thousand satellites.

2. Anti-satellite weapons aren’t nearly plentiful enough and given the ground support required, I’d be surprised if launching more than a few per day is feasible. A counterattack would come too quickly.

3. Precise positions don’t help that much. Even knowing a satellite position to ~2m still requires some active tracking on the interceptor. It’s not much benefit over knowing the position to 1km.

4. The debris created would be catastrophic and likely to damage the ISS even at Starlink’s low altitude.

All of the first three apply to GPS as well even though it’s only ~32 satellites.

Re:Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS by mytailorisrich on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:25PM (#33293201)
Any communication systems are valid military targets in case of war. So much so that they are usually among the first targets.

But there are also other considerations. In your example I doubt China would want to provoke the US by shooting American-owned satellites out of the sky, and I doubt Starlink would be that important anyway.