News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alien Truth by kmod on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:53AM (#33248161)
As much as I like PG's writing in general, this is him dipping his toes in waters that are already well studied and coming off as ignorant and/or presumptuous.

His very first premise "The truths of mathematics would be the same, because they're true by definition" shows an ignorance of an entire field of discourse called the philosophy of mathematics. Whether aliens would have the same math as us is one of the fundamental questions, and to presume the answer shows a disdain of the existing body of thought on this topic.

In particular, we humans still hotly debate which math is the "right" math. Is the axiom of choice "true"? Does it make sense to say that it has a truth value? Is such a truth value amenable to human discovery? Does PG know the answers to all of these questions?

PG is either unaware of the human-choice nature of the fundaments of math or he thinks he has special knowledge of it. Either way makes this essay one of my least favorites.

Re:Alien Truth by danielvaughn on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:13AM (#33248503)
No shade to you personally, but I really dislike this frame of thought.

There are mountains and mountains of literature about a great deal of things, no one human can be expected to be aware of them all.

Since that is obviously true, the lack of awareness about a single topic isn’t “ignorance” - it’s not like PG studiously ignored all of that literature. More likely he just never came across it, so the more apt word is “unaware” rather than “ignorant”.

To criticize someone merely for pondering about a subject they aren’t well-versed in is hostile gatekeeping. I think those who are educated in the relevant subject would do well to be more welcoming and informative to newcomers.

Re:Alien Truth by apeace on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:22AM (#33248691)
That's true, but this essay is written with an authoritative voice, not a pondering one. PG tends to write as if he is teaching his audience something profound. So I think it's fair to call out when he is wrong or misguided.
Re:Alien Truth by danielvaughn on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:34AM (#33248938)
This might just be a subjective thing then. My impression was that he was simply following a casual train of thought.

I agree with the other comment that my words “hostile gatekeeping” were too strong. I just get irritated with philosophers specifically, because philosophy itself is a normal human experience. Everyone finds themselves thinking about things that veer into philosophical subjects. To even criticize people for doing so without reading the professional literature is just so annoying to me.

Re:Alien Truth by missingrib on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:53PM (#33252152)
I think philosophers get a bit annoyed about this because they've spent literal years and years thinking about something that might be quite esoteric/tricky, and then someone comes along and just assumes the answer as if there hasn't been decades of discourse about this exact thing.

The subtext in your comment is that everyone does philosophy all the time, and there's no difference between professional and amateur philosophers.

Re:Alien Truth by jdthedisciple on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:35PM (#33254335)
> then someone comes along and just assumes the answer as if there hasn't been decades of discourse about this exact thing.

I'd think that would present itself as a rather pleasant opportunity for any bypassing philosopher to stop and teach them about the "decades of discourse" on it rather than being annoyed?

Re:Alien Truth by danielvaughn on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:01PM (#33276703)
Yeah that’s what I’ve seen before from chemists, biologists, geologists, physicists, etc. They’re excited, not irritated, to share their knowledge with the public.
Re:Alien Truth by missingrib on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:37AM (#33326303)
Nobody does this stuff to those kinds of scientists.
Re:Alien Truth by deltasevennine on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:23AM (#33248728)
True. But PG's authoritative status is weakened due to his lack of awareness no matter how you change the wording. This entire essay is weaker because of it as my opinion about his knowledge.

>To criticize someone merely for pondering about a subject they aren’t well-versed in is hostile gatekeeping.

The words "hostile gatekeeping" makes me classify your statement as accusatory and an actual attack. The Op's statements are just criticism. Harsh but valid, it certainly isn't hostile gatekeeping. In fact, PG is the gatekeeper here. He owns the site.

Re:Alien Truth by danielvaughn on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:46AM (#33249173)
Yeah my words were too strong, I’ll own that. I didn’t mean to come across so aggressive.

Another way to phrase it: if someone were to follow a thought experiment in a another subject like biology or geology, the response from the educated community would be different. I’ve seen it on here before. The response is something akin to “hey yep that’s an interesting thought. It’s been done before, here are some links if you’re interested in reading further”.

I just tend to see a very different (much more critical) response from people in philosophy, often with overtones of condescension and smugness. Not saying OP was guilty of that, just that I mistakenly responded as if they did.

Re:Alien Truth by ASalazarMX on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:24PM (#33249858)
> the lack of awareness about a single topic isn’t “ignorance”

Since everybody is nitpicking here, I'll add that this is indeed ignorance. We're know what we know, and are ignorant of what we don't. Being ignorant by itself shouldn't be viewed as a flaw, but an inevitable state of our limited capacity to learn. The real flaw is being proud of staying willfully ignorant.

Re:Alien Truth by danielvaughn on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:36PM (#33251057)
I agree with what you're saying, but practically speaking, using the word "ignorant" is universally interpreted as a negative term.
Re:Alien Truth by mechanical_bear on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:04PM (#33252319)
It is not universally interpreted as negative. I have often said in conversation; “Please explain [x] to me, as I’m ignorant as to how that fits in/works/etc.” I certainly don’t say it to demean myself.
Re:Alien Truth by mechanical_bear on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:59PM (#33252241)
Ignorant is unaware. I’m sure there are loads of things that you have ignorance of, such as the meaning of Ignorance:

lacking knowledge, information, or awareness about a particular thing: "they were ignorant of astronomy"

Re:Alien Truth by dooglius on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:33AM (#33248909)
This seems like an uncharitable take, the set of axioms and definitions used doesn't really fall under "mathematical truths", it's about agreement on what is implied by a given set of axioms. Even on Earth many people work in alternatives to ZFC and generally don't really disagree about what is "true".
Re:Alien Truth by TuringTest on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:53AM (#33249312)
Yet "what is implied by a given set of axioms" is the most common definition of "what's true" in mathematics. Therefore, an alien culture using completely different axioms and rules could arrive to an extremely alien math.

There might be some parts of it that are translatable to our own systems, but there's no guarantee that both systems will be ultimately compatible.

Re:Alien Truth by nine_k on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:23AM (#33248707)
Math is a formal game. You can define vastly varied algebraic structures, and, as long as they are internally consistent, we could consider them "mathematical".

But the physical reality makes some structures more important in practice. Hence natural numbers, or real numbers, or complex numbers stand out among the sea of possible group structures.

Chances are very high that aliens live in the universe with the same laws of physics, which make the same, or isomorphic, structures important for them, and thus informing the development of their mathematics.

But this is not a given, of course; there can potentially be different ways to describe physical reality which are comparably successful, but which grow from entirely different foundations, are internally consistent, and otherwise work like our mathematics, but are not connected to it (yet).

Even more funny is that Gödel's incompleteness theorem guarantees that "our" (currently developed) mathematics contain true statements which cannot be proven either true or false within the set of axioms which produce our mathematics. One can imagine that these true statements can be used to successfully describe important aspects of physical reality and were discovered by aliens for this purpose, while remaining incomprehensible for us. (But this is softer sci-fi stuff, of course.)

Re:Alien Truth by pluijzer on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:40AM (#33249055)
> But this is not a given, of course; there can potentially be different ways to describe physical reality which are comparably successful, but which grow from entirely different foundations, are internally consistent, and otherwise work like our mathematics, but are not connected to it (yet).

Are you or anybody else aware of any other way to describe physical reality? Maybe some culture took a different path. That would be very interesting. It seems almost impossible to imagine one for me though.

Re:Alien Truth by nine_k on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:17PM (#33249739)
Ted Chiang's short novel "Story of Your Life" [0], later turned into the movie "Arrival", describes an alien culture which uses variational calculus [1] as the normal way to describe physics, that is, their equations are mostly about finding functions with extrema of certain kind, not just derivatives (as are the normal PDUs we use in physics). The idea is that "our" equations mostly deal with the arrow of time and thus use terms like dx/dt extensively, while "their" equations are about the entire configuration of something in spacetime, not singling out the time dimension.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Story_of_Your_Life

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculus_of_variations

Re:Alien Truth by pluijzer on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:28PM (#33253418)
Thank for for the references that is really fascinating.
Re:Alien Truth by theonemind on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:07PM (#33253976)
> Math is a formal game

> Even more funny is that Gödel's incompleteness theorem guarantees that "our" (currently developed) mathematics contain true statements which cannot be proven either true or false within the set of axioms which produce our mathematics

These two statements together suggest that math isn't actually a formal game, but that formal methods offer an useful method for dealing with it.

Re:Alien Truth by poulpy123 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:32AM (#33248884)
I don't know for the axiom of choice but I would be surprised if 1+1=2 is not universal, whatever way is used to express it
Re:Alien Truth by colordrops on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:36AM (#33248976)
Is that "math" though, or just a particular construct in the system of math? I could imagine an alien mind that does not break things down across integer boundaries, when you consider that any labelings and groupings are arbitrary. That 1 "hat" you are wearing plus that 1 "hat" your buddy is wearing are actually not 1 and 1 but a conglomeration of fields/particles in an arbitrary configuration that can be torn or shredded or turned into plasma.
Re:Alien Truth by lupire on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#33249912)
You could construct such a mind in a simulation but I doubt one would arise naturally in the physical constraints of our universe. Approximate discretization is everywhere.
Re:Alien Truth by zdragnar on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:14PM (#33252443)
At the end of the day, you've still identified that particular configuration as a "hat"- a configuration forming a discrete unit. Without it, you have no concept of object permanence and no basis for comprehending any form of logic at all. After all, even within plasma, there are discrete units which are configurations of other discrete units.
Re:Alien Truth by colordrops on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:59PM (#33253861)
But these discrete units in the plasma are also model constructs of ours rather than fundamental properties of nature. The point is that any discrete lines we draw are ours, and not necessarily nature's. Of course we have no concept of object permanence without these, because concepts and objects are discrete models we create ourselves. It's tautological.
Re:Alien Truth by malux85 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:14AM (#33248526)
I agree with what you’re saying, at the thresholds of math (and even quite a bit before) it gets very murky very quickly,

But I think in this context he may have been better to say “arithmetic” or maybe root logical operations, because he was trying to convey small axiomatic units of universal truth rather than pull an entire field “into purity”

I could say the same about his comment about Carbon, the exact mass of carbon we use is influenced by isotopes and is not exactly standardised in all human chemistry - so it’s likely the aliens idea of “the mass of carbon” would also be slightly different. A better example would be “the atomic number of carbon” which is always the same because it’s definitional and integer, but the same point is there - he’s conveying the existence of the tiny axioms (alien truths), not trying to define them

Re:Alien Truth by TuringTest on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:57AM (#33249402)
> But I think in this context he may have been better to say “arithmetic” or maybe root logical operations, because he was trying to convey small axiomatic units of universal truth rather than pull an entire field “into purity”

What makes you think that arithmetic and logic are universal? A culture with a completely different way of thinking may not arrive to a system similar to our mathematics based on logical reasoning and search of consistency. Heck, we can see it in a lot of human beings who are not capable of consistent logical reasoning, and they're not even alien.

Re:Alien Truth by spookthesunset on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:11PM (#33249634)
> Heck, we can see it in a lot of human beings who are not capable of consistent logical reasoning, and they're not even alien.

All humans share this flaw (if it is a flaw). Not just some. We all do. It’s part of what makes us human—we have emotions that for better or worse transcend logic and reasoning.

In fact I could maybe argue that emotion is an important part of logic and reasoning. Emotion leads to skepticism and thinking outside the box. Both traits are needed to advance our understanding of the world.

Re:Alien Truth by malux85 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:52PM (#33250368)
I was thinking of simple arithmetic like addition and simple logical operations like “and” and “or”

I was illustrating the existence of these things - like PG was doing in the article - not attempting to define them

Re:Alien Truth by TuringTest on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:32PM (#33252665)
Yes, but these things exist because our brains reason this way, not because they are constants of nature. Other intelligent beings could have different non-symbolic ways of gathering and processing information about nature, such as evolving cellular automata adequate to represent and solve problems.
[dead]
Re:Alien Truth by spookthesunset on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:15PM (#33249692)
There is also bats who basically navigate the world by pinging sound off things.

Don’t forget microscopic creatures like Tardigrades. Their world is so small that the air around us acts like water.

Re:Alien Truth by jsbg on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:43AM (#33249121)
"The truths of mathematics would be the same, because they're true by definition" means that "(x => y) AND x" means y is true based on the definition of => and AND. There's no "philosophy" behind this.
Re:Alien Truth by lupire on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:24PM (#33249870)
Why would aliens have the same definitions? Your AND maybe wouldn't exist to them. They could have a more statistical/global non-binary/discrete mathematics.
Re:Alien Truth by vecter on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:30PM (#33249990)
I assume that PG was talking about "intelligent" aliens, which, for the sake of argument, let's say are those capable of interstellar communication (building radio telescopes and whatnot).

I cannot fathom such a civilization not having discovered Boolean logic.

Re:Alien Truth by wizofaus on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:44PM (#33252834)
I don't see why it's so absurd to think another alien species could develop interstellar communication without even being sentient in the way we understand it at all, or at least have anything like the level of abstract self-awareness that humans do. They may just experience something more equivalent to "emotional" reactions when attempting to manipulate the natural world to create technology in such a way that it guides them towards a successful outcome. Indeed comprehending Boolean logic seems no more necessary for that than it is for a dog in order to understand that when something in front of them is person 1 OR person 2, AND that certain sounds are coming from that person, they should sit.
Re:Alien Truth by vecter on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:12PM (#33253203)
You're right about dogs, but dogs cannot build radio telescopes so I don't understand the point. To be capable of interstellar communication, you have to be able to build machines, and doing so requires a systematic engineering culture and understanding of at least basic principles.

To put it differently, do you think such an advanced civilization would not be able to do something as simple as calculus, which would be far more advanced than manipulating a basic truth table? They almost certainly won't do it in any language that we understand on Earth, but they'll be manipulating and reasoning about the same concepts.

Re:Alien Truth by wizofaus on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:26PM (#33253394)
I honestly don't know, but I do think it's dangerous to assume an alien mind capable of interstellar communication would "think" sufficiently like human brains do for abstract concepts like calculus to be necessary or even make sense.
Re:Alien Truth by vecter on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:49PM (#33256442)
They would have to have developed calculus in order to build radio telescopes. We're not talking about how they think, we're talking about their understanding of concepts. These concepts are all hard prerequisites to being a species that can communicate across the stars.
Re:Alien Truth by wizofaus on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:46AM (#33258548)
But what does "understanding of a concept" mean if you have no idea how they think? And I disagree, I reckon even as humans we could come up with ways we might be able to build a device able to send radio signals interstellar distances without even having any real understanding of how it works. After all, beings as complex as ourselves came into existence via mechanisms that didn't involve, as far as we know, any sort of sentient understanding of the concepts of natural selection or basic laws of physics/chemistry/biology that you might think would be "hard prerequisites" for an ecosystem that can generate such an outcome. If there were a high selective pressure for the ability to transmit long-distance radio signals, do you really think natural selection could never have led to species natively capable of doing so?
Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:45AM (#33249141)
I think, like many commentators here, you're taking a very narrow technical view of what PG is talking about in what is actually a very broad a high level discussion.

Whether or not it's possible to prove a specific postulate in set theory is formally true (the axiom of choice, which was only formulated in 1904) isn't going to stop aliens counting objects and calculating the area of squares. They may not agree with us about formalism vs intuitionism, but it seems likely they would agree with us about a huge array of practical mathematical operations and results. PG is just asking what are the areas we would be extremely likely to agree on. Pointing out that there might be specific, advanced, highly obscure controversies we might disagree on isn't even in contention. Of course there are.

Re:Alien Truth by kmod on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#33249599)
It's turtles all the way down -- we don't know what "truth" is, or how one can come to "know" truth (as opposed to just believe it). I'm less informed on these topics so I avoided them, but I've heard that our notion of truth is intimately tied to our experience of physical reality, and it seems easy to imagine aliens that have different experiences of reality.

For example, what if aliens are so large that the non-euclidian nature of space becomes obvious to them? Perhaps they would never come up with euclidian geometry. Maybe they would never create the notion of pi. Yes it shows up in other areas but you can certainly imagine an alien civilization that has a different circumference-to-radius ratio or disavows the entire idea of having a constant circumference-to-radius ratio.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:34PM (#33250080)
We don't need to evaluate truth, we only need to evaluate what is practically useful. At the end of the day that's all science does - it's a methodology for generating guidelines for what actually works in the real world. We call those guidelines scientific 'laws', but truth in the absolute sense is less critical than is often made out by both proponents and critics of science.

Newton's laws of motion strictly speaking are not true, Einstein proved this, but they are incredibly useful as is the mathematics we use to formalise them.

PG is simply pointing out that since aliens, if they exist, live in the same real world we do they will discover a lot of the same practical results we do, and then goes further to suggest they might agree with us about a lot of the less strictly provable ones as well. Going "Oh well but this obscure question here would still be in contention" is, well, somewhat sailing past the point by a little smidgenette. It's criticising a claim PG isn't even remotely close to making.

Re:Alien Truth by kmod on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:41PM (#33250185)
Agree to disagree, I suppose. Another comment in this thread suggested using the value of pi to demonstrate intelligence, but you can imagine alien civilizations without the same reverence of pi as we do (if they are large enough). I mentioned in another comment that you can also imagine small enough aliens not inventing a real number line because they do not have the experience that everything is infinitely divisible.

I believe our difference is that you are presupposing that aliens will have essentially the same experience with reality that we do. I agree that if somehow a separate human civilization evolved in another galaxy, their math would likely look similar to ours. But you can imagine aliens that have very different experiences of "what actually works in the real world" (due to experiencing a different set of physics, such as at a different physical scale) and thus come up with different math.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#33250467)
We already have very robust descriptions of how the world works at every scale, from the planck length all the way up to the limits of the observable universe, and in extremes of environment from the surface of neutron stars, to the roiling virtual particles of empty space. We can calculate behaviours in these environments very precisely right now. Sure, there are things about these environments we still need to learn, but they're not utterly intractable or inconceivable to us.

There's a character Rimmer in a comedy series Red Dwarf that's always going on about how aliens would be unimaginable to use because they're alien and everything they do would be... well.. 'alien'. It's poking fun at SF that presents aliens as inherently utterly unintelligible to us simply by virtue of being alien, but frankly that's absurd. Physics doesn't care who or where you are, the same rules apply.

Re:Alien Truth by TuringTest on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:38PM (#33252756)
Yes, but the point I think is that the rules of symbolic reasoning are not like the rules of physics; formal systems have an arbitrary shape, so exploring the universe from a different starting point could yield a completely different method of representing it and processing information about it. And such methods needs not be compatible with our understanding of math.
Re:Alien Truth by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:57PM (#33252982)
You've already presupposed that experimenting across all those scales is somehow an integral (necessary?) part of being the kind of life that we might encounter.

That could be possible, but I don't think that we can assume that.

Re:Alien Truth by JackFr on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:21PM (#33254181)
Your brain is lying to you.

It's not your brain's fault, really. It doesn't know any better. Your brain has a way of interpreting the sensory perceptions communicated to it. It conflates this with 'reality' because it doesn't know anything thing else. And because it doesn't have anything else, it also declares itself the universal understander. Just like there are sounds you cannot hear, and chemicals you cannot taste, wavelengths you cannot see -- consider that there may be thoughts that you physically cannot think.

No magic and no spooky mysterious stuff. Just that it seems quite possible that our brains are limited in their ability to construct a representation of the universe, and insofar as the representation is true, we have kno way of knowing if it's the only true one.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:35PM (#33254332)
If you know what Turing complete means, and what a universal Turing machine is and can do, and that we are examples of such, then you must realise that’s not true. Provably. Unless you’re a dualist of some sort and believe thinking is some sort of spiritual woo, in which case I can’t help you. But I can imagine what that’s like (see what I did there?).
Re:Alien Truth by shkkmo on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:56PM (#33254582)
Our brains are technically only "turing complete" if you ignore their finite memory. (Edit: which is what is commonly meant by turing complete.)

It seems pretty obvious that there are thoughts that are too big to fit inside our heads.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:52PM (#33255147)
Again this is descending into nitpicking at the extremes. PG is not saying everything we understand will be in common with aliens, or that our cognitive match with them will be 1 to 1, just that there is likely to be overlap. That given the universality of human cognition, there is likely to be thoughts we can mutually appreciate. I am not claiming that human brains are capable of all thought possible to aliens, only that there will be common ground. That’s all. It’s a very minimal claim.

Pointing out possible edge cases is a non sequitur. Of course there will be things we don’t have in common. Yes, we know that. The fact we’re explicitly looking at common ground from first principles implicitly acknowledges there will be ground not in common. That’s given.

Re:Alien Truth by shkkmo on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:32PM (#33255517)
You said that JackFr was provably incorrect. I'm not pointing out an edge case but pointing out the massive hole in your argument.

As a limited computing system, our brain has been optimized to process the world in specific ways using various heuristics and compression techniques. Alien brains would presumably be optimized in different ways. Given our limited capabilities, it seems quite possible that translating any concepts between the two systems would be unfeasible for either our brain or the alien one.

I would like to think that there would common ground but that isn't something that can be known a priori, and is thus not presently "proveable".

Re:Alien Truth by msla on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:36PM (#33254342)
OK, then walk out the window of my old apartment.

I see it as being on the third floor, but that's only my brain lying to me, right?

Re:Alien Truth by karmakaze on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#33251143)
Pi is the human joke of the galaxy--they all use Tau.
Re:Alien Truth by gopher_space on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:55PM (#33252963)
> PG is simply pointing out that since aliens, if they exist, live in the same real world we do they will discover a lot of the same practical results we do

This isn't even accurate for the different peoples on our one planet.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:08PM (#33253999)
It really is, that’s why the basic mathematical principled discovered in India, Mesopotamia and Greece have spread and been further developed throughout the world. Because they work just as well everywhere. The Maya discovered the natural numbers and zero, did arithmetic and performed calendrical and astronomical calculations. China developed their numerical system independently, calculated Pi, performed division, root extraction and linear algebra and many original techniques. The forms of expression and some techniques were unique but maths is maths.
Re:Alien Truth by JackFr on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:23PM (#33254209)
All those cultures were running on the same hardware, so to speak. Let's see what the squids have to say.
Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:57PM (#33254593)
We’ll, there’s some evidence octopi and squid can count. If so then at least there’s some elementary maths in common. There’s no reason to suppose super intelligent cephalopod creatures would have particular difficulty with things like natural numbers, for all their different experience of the world. Two shrimp plus two shrimp is still the same amount of food as one shrimp plus three shrimp, no matter how many arms you have.
Re:Alien Truth by gopher_space on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:20PM (#33268080)
To a whale there would be either many shrimp or zero shrimp.
Re:Alien Truth by gopher_space on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:15PM (#33268037)
I'm saying that beings developing "basic math" isn't even a given on this planet.

All of your examples come from societies where not being able to count and record with perfect precision meant that you were going to be screwed by people who could at the market. They're also no strangers to conflict, and math wins battles. They share characteristics because they had similar pressures and desires.

Imagine a thriving group of people who only use the numbers "one", "two", and "many". What sort of environment and point of view would lead to such a situation, given equivalent intelligence? How do they navigate their universe so successfully?

Unfortunately most of the research I've read in this area has focused on what people like this can't do relative to our framework, and hasn't been especially curious about what we can't do relative to theirs.

Re:Alien Truth by mistermann on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:57PM (#33253826)
> We only need to evaluate what is practically useful.

As simple as this may seem, a few problematic points:

- who decides who gets included in "we"?

- who decides what "evaluate" is composed of?

- who decides what is practical, and useful?

- there is an implicit dimension of Time: for example, many things were initially categorized as useful, but then it can turn out to be a lot more complicated (Thalidomide, fossil fuels, arguably democracy & journalism (at least as they are practised, which seems to be fairly immutable))

Of course, these issues can be easily dismissed ("pedantic!"), but that doesn't make them go away.

> At the end of the day that's all science does - it's a methodology for generating guidelines for what actually works in the real world and for which accuracy, or truth, can be verified. We call those guidelines scientific 'laws', but truth in the absolute sense is less critical than is often made out by both proponents and critics of science.

Another problem we have is language (and various other things, semantics, semiotics, etc) - in this example, a reader could easily take away a few not necessarily correct beliefs from the way you've worded it:

- it could be (very poorly) interpreted to mean science does only this (and nothing else)

- it could be interpreted to mean science alone does this

- it could be interpreted to mean that the output of science (what actually works in the real world) is comprehensive, as in "all that works has been discovered by science - and if it isn't, science would (or will) find it"

- it could be interpreted to mean that science alone is able to produce accuracy, truth, and verification

- it could be interpreted to mean (or, a person may just not consider) that "what works" is not necessarily a constant over time (see: Thalidomide, fossil fuels)

To be clear, I'm not saying you're asserting these things, I'm just pointing out that language is extremely ambiguous and can be misleading.

Re:Alien Truth by lupire on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:23PM (#33249855)
> imagine an alien civilization that has a different circumference-to-radius ratio

Aliens still live in our Universe with our physics. Are these aliens bigger than the solar system?

Maybe a different universe with different parameters could look m athematically different in major ways.

Re:Alien Truth by kmod on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:34PM (#33250083)
Again, talking a bit outside my comfort zone, but I believe our universe's physics say that circles only have a fixed circumference-to-radius ratio at "small" (astronomically) scales. At large enough scales space is curved and the ratio begins to change.

In a similar way, a set of different physics would apply to small enough aliens that are principally governed by quantum mechanics. They might never come up with the real numbers because they do not believe that quantities are dense.

We could think of more examples -- aliens who typically move at speeds close to the speed of light would have very different conceptions of time, etc.

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:02PM (#33250544)
Our best estimate for the topology of the universe at the largest scale is that it is 'flat'. If it has curvature, it's below the margin of error we are able to measure it at. The only thing we know that can curve space significantly is gravity, but it would take truly stupendously strong gravity fields to significantly change basic results from classical geometry, such as those close to the event horizon of a black hole. Even then we can calculate it accurately nowadays so our results would still correspond to theirs even in those circumstances.
Re:Alien Truth by msla on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:39PM (#33254387)
If we aren't talking about the same things, we wouldn't be talking about the same things.

Part of establishing communication is ensuring we're talking about the same things.

Therefore, once we've established communication, we'd be talking about the same things, such as what a flat plane is.

If you think humans are the only species capable of comprehending Euclidean geometry, say so, and defend the assertion.

Re:Alien Truth by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:17PM (#33251668)
> It's turtles all the way down -- we don't know what "truth" is, or how one can come to "know" truth

> I've heard that our notion of truth is intimately tied to our experience of physical reality

It's been thousands of years since the first retorsion arguments were recorded, and yet I still see obviously self-refuting or self-undermining claims being made and quite often. Like these.

Re:Alien Truth by waffletower on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:00PM (#33254628)
Squares do not exist outside of abstract axioms. Solids projected from them share the same status. A mason making a tile forces reality to approximate the concept. Even crystalline structures which suggest them are too approximate. Why is a square implicit to an alien?
Re:Alien Truth by spookthesunset on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#33249598)
> In particular, we humans still hotly debate which math is the "right" math. Is the axiom of choice "true"? Does it make sense to say that it has a truth value?

I would love examples of this. Seems pretty cool to think about. I always assumed that “math” would be one of the constructs we could always reliably communicate with.

Re:Alien Truth by kmod on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:10PM (#33249622)
I really like the Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In this case: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/philosophy-mathematics/
Re:Alien Truth by witherk on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#33249752)
Math isn't choosing which axioms to use, is finding the consequences of a given set.
Re:Alien Truth by golemotron on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:19PM (#33249776)
To be fair, someone writes this type of comment every time he posts. It's not a unique take. It falls into the "well studied" category you mention.
Re:Alien Truth by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:49PM (#33250317)
Take some number of things. Lay them out more or less in a straight line. Somewhere in that line, put a little gap. Count them from left to right. Then count them from right to left. You get the same number.

That experiment is saying that addition commutes. If an alien ran that experiment, they would get the same answer.

Lay out some things in regular rows in a rectangle. Count the things row by row. Then count the things column by column. You'll get the same answer. So will an alien. That is, multiplication commutes both for us and for the aliens.

Now, as you go further into mathematics, things are true because they follow from the definitions, but the aliens may use different definitions. They may have a different definitions for, say, a commutative ring, and so abstract algebra may be different for them. But with the same definitions, we would arrive at the same conclusions.

Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:33PM (#33251030)
> If an alien ran that experiment, they would get the same answer.

This depends on the world they live in. If, for example, things were hard to control, tended to move, to disappear (and reappear in a different place), to look the same, etc., they would probably discover quantum field theory before arithmetic!

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:40PM (#33254404)
they would probably discover quantum field theory before arithmetic!

Sure, but much like we eventually discovered quantum field theory, they'll eventually discover arithmetic. And even if for some weird reason they hadn't, they're probably smart enough to understand it once we demonstrate it to them.

Re:Alien Truth by vecter on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:17AM (#33258392)
That's logically impossible for many reasons, the first of which is that arithmetic is a prerequisite for quantum field theory, and that secondly quantum effects like those don't occur at scales at which intelligent organisms live.
Re:Alien Truth by wizofaus on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:54PM (#33252947)
Good analogy but is it so crazy to think the concept of counting in a particular direction wouldn't make sense to an alien intelligence? That the way their brain processes inputs means that the knowledge of the total number occurs to them either subconsciously or as the result of parallel processing that is beyond what human brains can even imagine being aware of? Even if the input signals being counted are separated by time (e.g. pulses of light or sound), such that their brains must logically store the previous count and increment it as new signals are detected, the concept of ordered addition (i.e. where we can conceive of "x plus y" and "y plus x" as separate concepts, even if they yield the same result) might simply not be necessary or possible in an alien brain.

What even qualifies as "addition" at all is somewhat murky - e.g. "addition" of relativistic velocities is non-commutative (*), but is it meaningfully even addition in the same way adding integer counts is?

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity-addition_formula#Prop...

Re:Alien Truth by mcqueenjordan on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:02PM (#33250533)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity

Or, infinitely caveating all of your writing is tedious and makes it less interesting to read. It's more respectful to your readers to assume they understand this and will apply the principle of charity.

Re:Alien Truth by VyseofArcadia on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:54PM (#33251346)
> In particular, we humans still hotly debate which math is the "right" math. Is the axiom of choice "true"? Does it make sense to say that it has a truth value? Is such a truth value amenable to human discovery? Does PG know the answers to all of these questions?

If we did encounter intelligent (and peaceful!) beings out in the universe, there would be a set theory gold rush as people race to put out papers that such-and-such alien axiom implies choice, diamond principle, etc., or the other way around.

Every field of math would have such a gold rush really, on both sides, as we discover similarities and differences in techniques and formulations. And I bet famous unsolved problems on both sides would get solutions if not outright provided by the other species, then at least using novel tools from the other species.

I can't imagine a more exciting time for math as a whole than first contact.

Re:Alien Truth by benlivengood on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:06PM (#33251527)
I'd expect aliens to have discovered their equivalent of the Church-Turing thesis, Tarski's externality of truth, Godel's incompleteness theorems, etc. That would give them a strong ability to model our mathematics within their own and see its computational structure and begin finding correspondences to theirs. Similarly, we could begin modeling their conception of mathematics in a similar way and as soon as we both have arrived at a morphism between our representation and theirs of some particular theorem we could grow our knowledge and understanding of the other.

The key is that mathematics flows from logic and logic flows from computation and computation is universal.

Re:Alien Truth by solveit on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:03PM (#33252310)
> Is the axiom of choice "true"? Does it make sense to say that it has a truth value? Is such a truth value amenable to human discovery?

I imagine PG would say that these are not purely mathematical questions, but rather metamathematical questions. Theorems remain theorems regardless of whether the axiom of choice is "true", although one may contend that theorems assuming that the AOC is false (or true) are vacuous. Aliens would surely agree with us on statements of the form "working in first-order logic (or whatever) formalized in XXX way, assuming axioms YYY and ZZZ, we may prove that...".

Re:Alien Truth by WalterBright on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:11PM (#33252400)
Math has proven its predictive powers in the real world over and over. It's quite a stretch for it to be fundamentally wrong.
Re:Alien Truth by pazimzadeh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:35PM (#33253506)
Not that I agree with the argument, but this is relevant:

https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-evolutionary-argument-aga...

Re:Alien Truth by kubanczyk on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:06AM (#33259447)
A very interesting take. Your link is a worthy prize for enduring most of the other comments around this thread.