> But this is not a given, of course; there can potentially be different ways to describe physical reality which are comparably successful, but which grow from entirely different foundations, are internally consistent, and otherwise work like our mathematics, but are not connected to it (yet).
Are you or anybody else aware of any other way to describe physical reality? Maybe some culture took a different path. That would be very interesting. It seems almost impossible to imagine one for me though.
Ted Chiang's short novel "Story of Your Life" [0], later turned into the movie "Arrival", describes an alien culture which uses variational calculus [1] as the normal way to describe physics, that is, their equations are mostly about finding functions with extrema of certain kind, not just derivatives (as are the normal PDUs we use in physics). The idea is that "our" equations mostly deal with the arrow of time and thus use terms like dx/dt extensively, while "their" equations are about the entire configuration of something in spacetime, not singling out the time dimension.
Thank for for the references that is really fascinating.
Re:Alien Truth
by theonemind on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:07PM
(#33253976)
> Math is a formal game
> Even more funny is that Gödel's incompleteness theorem guarantees that "our" (currently developed) mathematics contain true statements which cannot be proven either true or false within the set of axioms which produce our mathematics
These two statements together suggest that math isn't actually a formal game, but that formal methods offer an useful method for dealing with it.
But the physical reality makes some structures more important in practice. Hence natural numbers, or real numbers, or complex numbers stand out among the sea of possible group structures.
Chances are very high that aliens live in the universe with the same laws of physics, which make the same, or isomorphic, structures important for them, and thus informing the development of their mathematics.
But this is not a given, of course; there can potentially be different ways to describe physical reality which are comparably successful, but which grow from entirely different foundations, are internally consistent, and otherwise work like our mathematics, but are not connected to it (yet).
Even more funny is that Gödel's incompleteness theorem guarantees that "our" (currently developed) mathematics contain true statements which cannot be proven either true or false within the set of axioms which produce our mathematics. One can imagine that these true statements can be used to successfully describe important aspects of physical reality and were discovered by aliens for this purpose, while remaining incomprehensible for us. (But this is softer sci-fi stuff, of course.)