News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by RhodesianHunter on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:25PM (#33172429)
Hiring Kotlin devs is easy because you can just hire open minded Java devs.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by TillE on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:33PM (#33172477)
Seriously, there are so few circumstances where a good developer absolutely requires deep experience in a specific language (or framework) on day one. Smart people can learn, and they can learn pretty quickly if it's not radically different.

I'm currently doing a ton of C# work and it's great - my relevant professional background is basically all C++, with some Java in the very distant past.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by RhodesianHunter on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:09AM (#33172726)
I think it really depends. If all you're doing is slinging JSON over an API then sure.

If you're dealing with concurrency and distributed systems at medium to high scale you really want your senior people to be familiar with the language.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jonathankoren on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:16AM (#33172777)
Yeah, but you don't need that many to start. That knowledge will spread rather rapidly to where it's needed.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by egeozcan on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:42AM (#33173318)
But that has also the danger of forming islands (mortgage code) which can be maintained by some (or, one) specific engineers.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jonathankoren on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:56AM (#33177893)
That can be mitigated by hiring senior engineers that understand engineering leadership, and having competent engineering management to specifically encourage knowledge transfer.

It’s not really that hard.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by FpUser on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:55AM (#33173022)
>"If you're dealing with concurrency and distributed systems at medium to high scale you really want your senior people to be familiar with the language."

I've written my first application level thread/concurrency library for DOS in the 80s. So you can count me as experienced. In my opinion as long as one is senior developer and knows the subject language does not mean fuck all as long as it adequate and language / libraries support needed primitives. I've written distributed middleware with multithreading / concurrency in many languages including ones I did not know before starting the project.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by daguava on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:27AM (#33173211)
Time doesn't mean experienced.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by FpUser on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:54AM (#33173383)
You can challenge anyone with this type of arguments. I was doing this kind of programming and delivering successful solutions since the 80s. If you chose to doubt my expertise it is your right. Does not mean your opinion has a shred of truth in it.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by necovek on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:09AM (#33175765)
While you are in general right, GP specificaly has relevant experience for a long time, when time does equal experience.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by baq on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @02:28AM (#33173572)
I’d argue the language matters even less as folks with true experience in distributed systems know that the real problems arise between thread/ process/host boundaries which are mostly language-agnostic.

IOW you really want senior people, full stop.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by necovek on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:40AM (#33175066)
On the contrary, I think that people familiar with generic concurrency and distributed primitives will easily transfer their knowledge between languages (I mean, a race is a race, and starvation is starvation...), whereas you can be very senior in a language yet never experience the edge cases of parallel programming.

Sure, each language has different tools to solve corresponding issues, but I prefer to understand the problem I am solving to intimately knowing the tools I need to use.

Ofc, having both is perfect!

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by pjmlp on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:31AM (#33175972)
Unless they have experience in the language runtime handles them, and how they might differ across implementations, they are in for a surprise when debugging parallel code.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by doctor_eval on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:07AM (#33173093)
Yeah, I mean I hired a great Java dev to do Go work and she picked it up in 3 months... but I knew she was awesome, so I wasn't worried about it at all. But hiring someone you don't know, which is typical ... retraining in a new language feels like it surely adds to the already substantial risk of hiring.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by egeozcan on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:41AM (#33173309)
I think the same as you, but let's admit that C# is one of the easiest languages to get into, especially with the magnificent tooling.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by weego on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:52AM (#33175155)
I think everyone in this chain should admit that hiring the kinds of developers you can 'throw x language book at' and a week later you have a competent x lang developer is an incredibly expensive and time consuming processthat most companies will never be able to afford.

Even if you can, you then have to solve the issue of keeping a department stocked full of senior devs happy when you have limited promotion/perk/raise options and so churn will likely be relatively high even in a healthy environment.

It's a nice fantasy view of the market as an ideal world simulation but does not reflect the reality of hiring software engineers.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jen20 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:49AM (#33176143)
Surely the other solution is to improve the work environment such that it’s possible to hire the people you aspire to hire…
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jackcviers3 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:52AM (#33176188)
You can't buy a book, keep it on a shelf, lend it to new hires, and afford to have an employee take a week out of being productive to learn something? Or you can't afford salaries for a company of people who have more than 5 years of development experience?

Both sound like major dysfunctional problems.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by RhodesianHunter on Thursday October 13, 2022 @04:23AM (#33188584)
No one learns a new language effectively in a week.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by ch4s3 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:49PM (#33172591)
You can hire any senior dev and give them the elixir book and a week to read it. You can also pick up someone junior who hasn’t learned anything wrong and coach them for a few months. I’ve successfully done both. The org I work in was one of the Elixir lang case studies and we still love using it, and have very little trouble hiring. It would be different if we had to hire 50 devs in less than 6 months, but we just don’t need to do that.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by Apocryphon on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:57PM (#33172655)
Elixir is a functional language, which is definitely a less common paradigm than OO languages like Java, which Kotlin is very similar to. Plus you can hire Android devs.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jrvarela56 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:25AM (#33172842)
Is this true anymore? I'm biased by HN content but feel like I've been hearing non-stop about FP for the past 10 years.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jedberg on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:38AM (#33172916)
You're hanging around crowds that talk about FP. :)

Right now I'm working with a team where we're trying to introduce FP and reactive programming, and most of them have never heard of either one, or if they have, have never really used it.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by jrvarela56 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:01AM (#33173062)
Indeed, it's so bad I've found myself in conversations where teammates go 'ew, look, a class' and I go 'a closure is a poor man's object...'.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by markeibes on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @03:02AM (#33173780)
What's bad about learning the truth from your teammates?
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by egeozcan on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:39AM (#33173299)
If you are getting your daily dose of HN comments for a long time like me, you may also think there would be not a single dev that chooses Electron to develop desktop applications.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by hardwaresofton on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:21AM (#33174955)
Of course not, because we're all using tauri[0] right?

[0]: https://tauri.app/

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by ch4s3 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:11AM (#33172744)
Yeah of course, but the FP stuff is not very complicated in Elixir land. The heady stuff from ML family languages just isn’t there. The process model takes some time to adjust to, but a lot of JVM folks have used akka which is inspired by the BEAM.

The tooling an docs all guide you in the right direction and usually code in the wild aims to be straightforward.

I’ve really never had trouble onboarding people to Elixir unless they had started learning it solo as a Ruby dev, then they typically have to unlearn some stuff.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by cultofmetatron on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:15AM (#33175813)
functional programming overall isn't that difficult. day to day elixir work doesn't require you to understand currying, abstract types or monads. If anything it really only makes you pickup immutable data, pass by value, immutable bindings (with implicit lets)

Functional programming gets really hard when you try doing stuff like state and IO monads. Elixir in contrast gives you genservers for state which is very simple by comparison as well as having dead simple IO. you don't have to make special functions marked as IO or use any type of exotic type theory.

TLDR: yes Elixir is functional but its the 80% that is easy to learn. you don't have to bother with that last 20% of functional programming rabbit hole crazy town.

source: me with 6 years of elixir experience and having built the entire backend for my startup in elixir over the last 3 years. Elixir is s a platform that fits a nice sweet spot where you need to knock something out fast and still have something reasonably maintainable (and refactorable) that also happens to be really fast(performance wise) for the level of day to day developer productivity you get.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by redanddead on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:51AM (#33176168)
what would you say that elixir does better than anyone else?
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by cultofmetatron on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:10AM (#33176399)
better is subjective so I'd rather not go into that too deeply haha.

Its all about the tradeoffs you're going after. If you absolutely need to cut down errors to a minimum and are willing to sacrifice developer speed/productivity, Haskell with IHP is certainly a compelling offer. (yes I know an experienced haskell dev will probably be jsut as productive as a experienced elixir dev but it will take much longer to train someone from another language to haskell than to elixir.)

conversely, if you want speed at all costs, rust is certainly nice.

now if we're talking Pareto efficient intersection of performance, developer productivity and maintainability, yea elixir hits that sweet spot well. I haven't encountered a language that does that better yet. Python comes close if you're willing to take a drastic hit on performance. The tooling is descent, the day to day ergonomics let me focus on solving our startup's problems rather than wrestling with the platform. It's not perfect (lord knows I wish there were more libraries).

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by RhodesianHunter on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:59PM (#33172668)
That's great, but pretty tangential to my point. The person I was responding to seemed baffled that hiring Kotlin devs would be perceived as easier than hiring elixir devs, which is itself pretty baffling given that Kotlin is one of the top 15 most popular/used programming languages and elixir rarely even makes the list.
Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by graderjs on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:05AM (#33173079)
Just a question when you are hiring and posting job descriptions do your job posts use language like "6 years experience in Elixir" ?

Reason I'm asking is because I love this attitude and I think it works so long as your team will provide the support for someone to ramp up, but I seldom see these kind of job posts saying we're fine if you learn the stack.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by ajmurmann on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:24AM (#33173196)
I share the parents attitude. My job postings though don't say explicitly that we are fine if you learn the stack, however they list the stack as nice to have rather than must have.

IMO, everyone needs to learn a from of stuff for every job. Thus understanding of high-level concepts and ability to learn are paramount. If you tell me though that your primary language is XYZ and you cannot answer basic challenges with it we encounter during the interview then that's a really bad sign even if I don't care much about that actual language.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by thexumaker on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @02:31AM (#33173590)
Man I joined an elixir team to start my engineering career and while I love the language, and it isn’t too hard to pickup and read until you have to start mocking stuff and all the &’s start popping up. But still the pipelines and functional approach was solid.

The problem was actually getting the stuff deployed or running into weird niche issues that require a couple days to fix. I was a bit out of comfort level at that point but the exaws sdk’s, confex, releases, supervisors. Made me really appreciate how much more support and just easier mode/python has been in my current job.

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by whoooooo123 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:02AM (#33174536)
Where do you work? Are you hiring?

(I am an Elixir dev)

Re:Brex – A Message from Pedro [Layoffs of 11%] by SergeAx on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:02PM (#33182277)
Even better: you can just hire Android devs who are fed up with client side programming.