Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by me_me_me on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:37AM
(#33175050)
PC/laptop is a luxury goods for middle income families. Currently uncertain times are definitely not helping sales. And if they are forced to buy a new one a budget options are more likely (cheaper chip option - amd).
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by thehappypm on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:54PM
(#33184038)
Companies maybe not, but more likely, people just dont need PCs. My wife and I share one computer at home for like doing taxes. If we want another I’ll probably get a Chromebook for cheap. I do everything on my phone.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by PaulHoule on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:52AM
(#33178798)
I wonder how much profit Intel really makes on the data center. The tech press never questions it, but Intel does a lot of gaslighting and notoriously has many sock puppets in the industry press. We are told all the time that the data center is subsidizing the consumer but I wonder if the truth is the other way around... Certainly Intel wouldn't have gotten within 100 miles of the data center if it hadn't been for the volume of client parts being able to pay for technology that pulled ahead of SPARC, MIPS and all the legacy chips.
On one hand, the data center gets better utilization, maybe gets more value, and maybe turns over hardware faster. (e.g. why do I want to buy a new computer when the IGPU is just going to make it crash faster?)
On the other hand there is more competition for the data center, particularly cloud providers who could amortize rewriting simple but large scale applications like Amazon S3 for ARM or RISC-V over a large fleet of machines. If the data center is able to drive a hard bargain, it may well be that the client is still subsidizing the data center, but we just get told its the other way around so that we won't ask for me and complain about the e-waste Intel tries to pass off on us. (e.g. "try" because their sales are collapsing)
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by Entinel on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:34PM
(#33183714)
It's insane to me that Intel just can't figure what to do vs AMD. They continually position themselves as the premium choice and price their products accordingly even though that isn't true any more.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by lame-robot-hoax on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:58PM
(#33184106)
Is Intel meant to be a jobs program? Should they just hire and retain people they don’t need…just to keep them employed? Should they hire me to twiddle my thumbs for $100k a year just because they can afford to?
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by orangecat on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:53PM
(#33184819)
Assuming output is the same in both cases, this is wrong. If a company is making $10 million in profits, is it better for society if they spend $9 million hiring people to dig ditches and then fill them in? No, because those people could be doing something else that is actually useful.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by janef0421 on Thursday October 13, 2022 @08:53PM
(#33198440)
It's good locally, yes, but our current economic system does not have adequate systems to support people who are laid off into other work. Layoffs will result in significant hardship. Also, it's good for a company to have a degree of slack.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:14PM
(#33184342)
PCs?
Gamers (and non-Mac high-end desktop performance users) would seem to be a pretty small slice of the pie these days. I have a high-end current M1 laptop but I do a lot of my work on a couple of 7 year old Intel-based desktop/laptop machines which are perfectly fine although they're about to go out of OS support. (Though I'll probably use them for a few more years anyway.)
I remember when you wanted a new PC with every tick of the processor cycle. These days, for most people, who cares?
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by UncleOxidant on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:24PM
(#33184459)
Can't recall where I heard this recently, a podcast I think, there was a CS professor talking about undergrad introductory programming classes. He said that about 5 years back his students stopped coming in with experience using a PC because they'd only been using phones/tablets. So the prof said it was kind of like going back ~25 years when not a lot of incoming students had PC experience either.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:38PM
(#33184646)
Was talking to someone at work and their kid didn't want a laptop because they were fine with doing papers on their phone. Blows my mind (and that of others) but I guess that's where we are.
Interesting situation. I never touched a PC until after college. But, yeah, there was at least a period where basic "computer literacy" was expected. Maybe things have shifted again.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ar_lan on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:55PM
(#33186606)
I, and most of us on here, are likely power users of computers, and beyond my job, they are a big portion of my hobby as well.
I acknowledge I'm in a unique situation where I run a home lab and so I have a local cloud, but because of that, I can effectively do 100% of my job off an iPad Pro (I don't want to for quite a few reasons, but I could). If I didn't have my home lab, I could get close by deploying my OS on AWS/Digital Ocean/etc. and have the same effect (though latency would drive me nuts eventually + internet connectivity issues - though this would break my job anyway).
If I weren't coding, I'd probably entirely switch to the iPad. I do all my document editing on it. I do my code reviews on it, architecture planning, etc.
I could realistically see the average consumer never needing anything more powerful than something like an iPad Air. I complpetely believe we will head to the era where the only hardware the average consumer needs includes:
* Great resolution screen
* Great internet connection
* Great input controls
* Minimal CPU/RAM to run a robust, hardened portal to cloud services
iPads are basically beefier versions of even that.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:33PM
(#33186867)
>iPads are basically beefier versions of even that.
I'm happy using a good Chromebook for most things but I've never found an iPad--even with external keypad--to be an adequate substitute for anything involving text editing.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ar_lan on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:47PM
(#33186983)
Yeah - it's a specific implementation of the general idea. Chromebooks essentially fit the same bill. I just happen to have an iPad (and I do most arch design with a stylus so the Apple Pencil is fairly crucial to my workflow).
I'm fairly happy with the magic keyboard with it, but understand different preferences!
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Thursday October 13, 2022 @12:18AM
(#33187179)
Yeah, I don't really draw much and I'm used to a mouse/touchpad for editing so it's probably a matter of what I'm used to. Also, at events I often want a laptop on my, well, lap and tablets+keyboard don't work as well for that.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:31PM
(#33186851)
I never learned touch typing--I basically never used a typewriter until college and a word processor afterwards. (Nor any formal shorthand.) But I still am a pretty fast typist so long as I can look at the keyboard and get frustrated in a hurry even doing searches--much less editing--on a tablet. I know people who even write a lot who can handle doing it on a tablet with an external keyboard but I'll travel with a laptop rather than trying it.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by dont__panic on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:28PM
(#33184519)
It's worth noting that Intel has been stuck at a single tick in the processor cycle for... 7-8 years now?
Interestingly, Mac sales are up 40% recently. So I guess a lot of people actually do care -- they just want in on the best laptop processors out there, which are decidedly not offered by Intel.
With no good Windows support for ARM, I'm curious what trends we'll see over the next few years for PCs. Will they languor in their current state, using Intel's hot n' heavy processors? Will some manufacturers switch to ARM + Linux solutions to offer battery life and heat generation competitive with the Mac?
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ghaff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:36PM
(#33184620)
The Mac number is till relatively small though and it sort of makes the point that the people who really care about their laptops are disproportionately going with Macs (relatively speaking). While the basic corporate box is mostly don't care.
>Will some manufacturers switch to ARM + Linux solutions to offer battery life and heat generation competitive with the Mac?
I don't know. You already have Chromebooks but those aren't really mainstream outside of education even though they're all a lot of people need. And Google exited as basically one of the most high-end hardware makers there.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by dont__panic on Thursday October 13, 2022 @08:19AM
(#33189972)
I know that the Qualcomm's 8 Gen 1+ is within spitting distance of the A-series phone chips -- inferior for single core work, but superior for multicore loads.
Both Qualcomm and Samsung produce tablet chips that perform well enough.
I wonder why they haven't expanded into the laptop space? I imagine Apple's M-series would be hard to compete with, but many consumers would be fine with something competitive with the M1, which seems doable.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by matheusmoreira on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:24PM
(#33186794)
Can we develop software on tablets though? It seems like this is the one missing component. On a PC we can easily get access to the tools to program the machines. Phones and tablets require a real computer to program them. Corporations own the machines so you need to go through them to reach the users.
It's like we've all gone back to the time before free software and GCC. It's a bit worrying that the PC market is shrinking. The PC is the only freely programmable computer on the market today...
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by twobitshifter on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:28PM
(#33185150)
Intel just received money from the US government and they swiftly started laying off American workers. The money is supposed to be for the new Ohio plant and 3000 jobs, but now we’re losing thousands of jobs up front?
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by giantg2 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:50PM
(#33185344)
Same as always. I'm pretty sure Ford did something similar several years ago. They got money for jobs, then closed the plant like a year later or something.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by mullingitover on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:03PM
(#33185902)
That chip plant will be the factory of the future. However:
“The factory of the future will have only two employees, a man and a dog. The man will be there to feed the dog. The dog will be there to keep the man from touching the equipment” – Warren G. Bennis.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by tenpies on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:56PM
(#33185858)
Looking at the chart, would it not be a good time - especially with USD losing 8% of its value on a yearly basis? After all, you can only invest so much into capital projects and who knows what will be left of the US after Biden's tenure, so you want to be cautious.
Also Intel never had a hyper-inflated share price like most other semis. It's actually quite comical just how much the share price has dropped because its previously meagre dividend yield is now 10% due to denominator effects.
The buy back would similarly help ex-employees with stock or options, and I'm sure the package on the way out from Intel will be quite good.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by scarface74 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:23PM
(#33185613)
20% is in sales and marketing. How would you feel if taxpayer money was going yo marketing? Hopefully the money is going toward equipment and research. Maybe they don’t need the people.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by ksec on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:40PM
(#33185757)
It is not 20% of the Job Cuts are in Sales and Marketing, which is what your sentence could implied. But up to 20% of Sales and Marketing department being cut, which represent majority of the 1000s of job cuts.
I am pretty sure there are lots of bloats at Intel that requires trimming down.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by giantg2 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:48PM
(#33185327)
I have a desktop that had decent specs 10 years ago. I still use it today. I did add a graphics card, more ram, and more storage over the years. Guess what? It's still decent specs and able to play many new games. That's a long time compared to when I was growing up.
I also have a 14 year old laptop. That one's days are probably numbered. Maybe I'll get one in the next two years.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by alfor on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:29PM
(#33185668)
Hire Jim Keller back and build the next thing instead of milking the same customers.
The company developing a competent alternative to the M1/M2 or nvidia GPU is going to have a good business.
Seems to me that Intel is alway in this cycle of greatness and then crash while sitting on their laurels. It seem they need to have a fire under their buts to make the right decisions.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by phendrenad2 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:08PM
(#33185944)
I love comments like this. I don't think any other industry has this kind of sport-team mythos in the mind of the layman. If Ford or Toyota has a bad year, people think "Hmm they need to make better cars". If Intel or AMD has a bad year, people say "Clearly they need do hire that guy who was in charge when they made all those good chips". It's incredibly lazy thinking, and I love it.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by alfor on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:30PM
(#33186443)
If Ford or Toyota had a Steve Job or Elon musk they wouldn’t be in the same place.
Listen to interview with Jim Keller, yes, there is a whole team doing the work, but you need a technical/management person with the credibility and willingness to make the hard choices and take risks.
99% of people hired for CEO roles will be happy to coast, take their bonus on short time gains and move to the next opportunity. Who is willing to take risks for long term success that will not appear on the quarterly report?
You need someone who can get that job and at the same time doesn’t give a damn about what people think and about the money. Those people are rare. That’s why Apple doesn’t have ’another’ Steve Job, Apple will coast on the previous trajectory for a while, but won’t disrupt anything else major, they will play safe.
The same is true for Google, they got their own money printer going nonstop, who would be crazy enough to take risks with that?
The last disruption of Google was Gmail/GSuite and was started as a side project. How many top engineer do they have, where is all their output?
For Intel they need to disrupt their own products to move forward, that’s why it’s hard to do, you don’t want to kill the golden goose. But it’s either you now or the competition in a few years.
Man Intel was really sleeping on this one to be kicked that hard by Apple on the first release of their desktop chip.
So in a nutshell: talented engineers are everywhere in those companies, that’s not the diferenting factor, good leadership is and the incentives reward those who don’t take risks.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by adrr on Thursday October 13, 2022 @12:38AM
(#33187307)
Intel has had a bad 10 years. The market has more than doubled in size and yet they have grown 25%. 10 years ago Intel made more revenue than AMD, Nvidia, and Qualcomm combined. I bet Qualcomm passes Intel in revenue in two years. All those companies have more than doubled their revenue. AMD went from $6b to $22b. NVidia from $4b to $30b. Qualcomm $19B to $54B. Intel went from $53B to $68B with the last 2 years being flat and this year actually declining.
Intel can't execute. They are failing to shrink transistor size. Failed at a 5G modem. Failed to deliver a competitive mobile processor.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by phendrenad2 on Thursday October 13, 2022 @01:41AM
(#33187649)
This is irrelevant. If Ford or Toyota have 10 bad years, people will not suddenly start talking about all of the superstar, legendary car designers they should pull out of book signings back onto the field.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by Dalewyn on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:20PM
(#33186028)
It would be more accurate to say Intel CPUs will have performance cores alongside efficiency cores from 13th gen onwards.
That is to say, i9 13900K will have 8 performance cores and 16 efficiency cores if I recall correctly. Many of the mobile CPUs in 12th gen also have more efficiency than performance cores.
Re:Intel Plans Thousands of Job Cuts in Face of PC Slowdown
by pipeline_peak on Thursday October 13, 2022 @10:38AM
(#33191600)
Like they said, Intel hasn’t had the technical edge in years. With laptop oems transitioning to Arm, I don’t see where they have a future other than competing with AMD. AMD has more than just x86-64 CPUs.
I don’t think a company like Intel was ever designed around innovation past what made them dominant in Windows PCs. And like Microsoft, they’re going to need to diversify to survive.
Around 30%-40% of PC sales were going to cloud compute. This is slowing.
On one hand, the data center gets better utilization, maybe gets more value, and maybe turns over hardware faster. (e.g. why do I want to buy a new computer when the IGPU is just going to make it crash faster?)
On the other hand there is more competition for the data center, particularly cloud providers who could amortize rewriting simple but large scale applications like Amazon S3 for ARM or RISC-V over a large fleet of machines. If the data center is able to drive a hard bargain, it may well be that the client is still subsidizing the data center, but we just get told its the other way around so that we won't ask for me and complain about the e-waste Intel tries to pass off on us. (e.g. "try" because their sales are collapsing)
---
A good example of the gaslighting is this article
https://www.tomshardware.com/news/linux-kernel-update-kills-...
which should have the headline "Intel iGPU kills laptop displays".
Increasing productivity is a good thing actually.
a company that has low profit and many employees is a lot more beneficial for society than the opposite
Gamers (and non-Mac high-end desktop performance users) would seem to be a pretty small slice of the pie these days. I have a high-end current M1 laptop but I do a lot of my work on a couple of 7 year old Intel-based desktop/laptop machines which are perfectly fine although they're about to go out of OS support. (Though I'll probably use them for a few more years anyway.)
I remember when you wanted a new PC with every tick of the processor cycle. These days, for most people, who cares?
Interesting situation. I never touched a PC until after college. But, yeah, there was at least a period where basic "computer literacy" was expected. Maybe things have shifted again.
I acknowledge I'm in a unique situation where I run a home lab and so I have a local cloud, but because of that, I can effectively do 100% of my job off an iPad Pro (I don't want to for quite a few reasons, but I could). If I didn't have my home lab, I could get close by deploying my OS on AWS/Digital Ocean/etc. and have the same effect (though latency would drive me nuts eventually + internet connectivity issues - though this would break my job anyway).
If I weren't coding, I'd probably entirely switch to the iPad. I do all my document editing on it. I do my code reviews on it, architecture planning, etc.
I could realistically see the average consumer never needing anything more powerful than something like an iPad Air. I complpetely believe we will head to the era where the only hardware the average consumer needs includes:
* Great resolution screen * Great internet connection * Great input controls * Minimal CPU/RAM to run a robust, hardened portal to cloud services
iPads are basically beefier versions of even that.
I'm happy using a good Chromebook for most things but I've never found an iPad--even with external keypad--to be an adequate substitute for anything involving text editing.
I'm fairly happy with the magic keyboard with it, but understand different preferences!
Interestingly, Mac sales are up 40% recently. So I guess a lot of people actually do care -- they just want in on the best laptop processors out there, which are decidedly not offered by Intel.
With no good Windows support for ARM, I'm curious what trends we'll see over the next few years for PCs. Will they languor in their current state, using Intel's hot n' heavy processors? Will some manufacturers switch to ARM + Linux solutions to offer battery life and heat generation competitive with the Mac?
>Will some manufacturers switch to ARM + Linux solutions to offer battery life and heat generation competitive with the Mac?
I don't know. You already have Chromebooks but those aren't really mainstream outside of education even though they're all a lot of people need. And Google exited as basically one of the most high-end hardware makers there.
Both Qualcomm and Samsung produce tablet chips that perform well enough. I wonder why they haven't expanded into the laptop space? I imagine Apple's M-series would be hard to compete with, but many consumers would be fine with something competitive with the M1, which seems doable.
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Qualcomm-Snapdragon-8-Gen-1-Pr...
It's like we've all gone back to the time before free software and GCC. It's a bit worrying that the PC market is shrinking. The PC is the only freely programmable computer on the market today...
With all the things we book under the "National Security" banner a much needed next gen chip factory should be one of them.
“The factory of the future will have only two employees, a man and a dog. The man will be there to feed the dog. The dog will be there to keep the man from touching the equipment” – Warren G. Bennis.
Also Intel never had a hyper-inflated share price like most other semis. It's actually quite comical just how much the share price has dropped because its previously meagre dividend yield is now 10% due to denominator effects.
The buy back would similarly help ex-employees with stock or options, and I'm sure the package on the way out from Intel will be quite good.
See: https://www.tradingview.com/chart/?symbol=INTC 50% down YTD.
I am pretty sure there are lots of bloats at Intel that requires trimming down.
Just had a little flashback to 2008 me
I also have a 14 year old laptop. That one's days are probably numbered. Maybe I'll get one in the next two years.
The company developing a competent alternative to the M1/M2 or nvidia GPU is going to have a good business.
Seems to me that Intel is alway in this cycle of greatness and then crash while sitting on their laurels. It seem they need to have a fire under their buts to make the right decisions.
Listen to interview with Jim Keller, yes, there is a whole team doing the work, but you need a technical/management person with the credibility and willingness to make the hard choices and take risks.
99% of people hired for CEO roles will be happy to coast, take their bonus on short time gains and move to the next opportunity. Who is willing to take risks for long term success that will not appear on the quarterly report?
You need someone who can get that job and at the same time doesn’t give a damn about what people think and about the money. Those people are rare. That’s why Apple doesn’t have ’another’ Steve Job, Apple will coast on the previous trajectory for a while, but won’t disrupt anything else major, they will play safe.
The same is true for Google, they got their own money printer going nonstop, who would be crazy enough to take risks with that?
The last disruption of Google was Gmail/GSuite and was started as a side project. How many top engineer do they have, where is all their output?
For Intel they need to disrupt their own products to move forward, that’s why it’s hard to do, you don’t want to kill the golden goose. But it’s either you now or the competition in a few years.
Man Intel was really sleeping on this one to be kicked that hard by Apple on the first release of their desktop chip.
So in a nutshell: talented engineers are everywhere in those companies, that’s not the diferenting factor, good leadership is and the incentives reward those who don’t take risks.
Your original post had no argument, either, so I don't see the necessity.
Now that you've provided an argument, we can have a discussion, starting with:
> Intel was really sleeping on this one to be kicked that hard by Apple on the first release of their desktop chip
This isn't true. The M1 in a desktop isn't competitive against Intel chips.
Intel can't execute. They are failing to shrink transistor size. Failed at a 5G modem. Failed to deliver a competitive mobile processor.
That is to say, i9 13900K will have 8 performance cores and 16 efficiency cores if I recall correctly. Many of the mobile CPUs in 12th gen also have more efficiency than performance cores.
1. Is desktop computing still relevant?
2. Is server CPU market not making enough return?
3. I thought Intel needs talent to bootstrap their US-based fabs.
4. Does this mark the beginning of an end for PC?
I don’t think a company like Intel was ever designed around innovation past what made them dominant in Windows PCs. And like Microsoft, they’re going to need to diversify to survive.