But why? Seems silly you use the mechanism of education as a filter and make a course obnoxiously and unnecessarily difficult for that purpose. Why not... filter pre-med students by simply limiting admission into the program? The earlier you make people seriously consider things the less time they waste and headache they endure. How many practicing medicine today actually use organic chemistry regularly? Most don't at least from the pool I've worked with (surgeons, internal medicine, pharmacists, nurses, etc.). Pharmacy is the closest but most rely on database systems outside of hospital pharmacists or active researchers in drugs.
It is sort of like learning C but programming solely in Python: you can get your job done, but when one of your abstractions breaks it is worthwhile to be able to at least identify the root cause and talk to the right people.
My organic chemistry course was excellent until the half-semester, whereupon the professor's well-organized and insightful presentation ceased. Instead we were confronted with a plethora of memorization with little organization. The change in teaching method and learning was obvious to everyone in the room. We questioned it and the professor said apologetically "That's the way it is! It's hard! I'm sorry!" Within a week a large part of the class dropped and many of the remainder became more reclusive and protective about their study.
So much must be memorized in medical school that the process alters the way students think. I watched an excellent scientist fall away from science (but become an excellent memorizer) in medical school. Once a brilliant researcher, now a doddering encyclopedia of (sometimes incorrect) facts. Sad.
The mental gymnastics that go in colleges are bonkers. I’m paying for my education, tell me exactly how hard, and what’s required, but don’t set up the ‘product’ to fail.
While this shouldn't be taken as support for the filter courses - they at least provide a bit more equal opportunity for the students. When you have students coming in from various backgrounds, different schools, different level of preparation, you want to give them a vaguely even starting point to a test like that. Doing the filtering post-admission helps.
My undergrad math program was the same - there was a difficult abstract linear algebra class that was the gate to being a pure math major.
That would be a much narrower window into what the students are capable of. Instead, you offer them a challenge, and let them succeed or fail on their own merit. You'll find some students who don't look great on paper have the grit and determination to make it through the class, and some students who look outstanding on paper wilt when put up to a challenge.
So we use university degrees which take 4 years and cost hundreds of thousands of dollars instead, because then we can say it's about putting in the work. And for some reason people are more accepting of someone else being more successful because they are perceived to have worked harder rather than just because they were born smarter.
But now we have another problem, the customers of the university who have spent all this money are being denied the status that they have purchased for such a high price. So they are pissed now and claim the system is unfair. And the universities respond by dumbing down their degrees to the point where everyone who gets in will pass.
And now we have yet another problem. A gatekeeper of status can't be widely available, or it doesn't confer status. So we will have to find a new gatekeeper, and then the cycle can repeat.
If one subscribes to the theory that culture moves in cycles (hedonistic Weimar Republic, WW2, conservative backlash in the 1950s, left backlash in the 1960s, conservative backlash in the 1980s/1990s, woke backlash in the late 2000s), then sometimes the complaints are valid.
Gen-Z has an unprecedented cancel power, anonymous reports, controlling speech of Gen-X. It has never been like this before.
Certainly Gen-X disliked their older generations, too, but they didn't have the tools or the self-righteousness to openly intrigue against them.
Gen-X is too soft to fight back, to the detriment of our society.
Boomers have massive economic entitlement. Gen Z have massive social entitlement. And Millennials are caught somewhere in the middle not feeling entitled to either, but struggling nonetheless.
To turn around and now call Gen Z the entitled one seems stupidly forgetful.
You should realize: your problem with boomers is that they exist and act like human beings. It might be time to let this one go.
Hope you don’t mind, but I am saving this lovely little nugget of wisdom.
;)
They both have the same sense of entitlement. They both have the same obsession with money. They both have the same persecution complex.
And they love to blame each other for everything rather than face up to the fact that life isn't fair.
There's that obsession with money I mentioned. Moreover, Who cares? Lots of generations had less money than Millennials do now and still did great things.
Are you under the impression that Millennials are entitled to a certain amount of money? There's that entitlement complex.
Who told you that life is fair?
All I said was that these facts have an impact on each group’s psyche and world outlook. Is that controversial to you?
… I know, I know, it’s not exactly the same, but the logic is analogous. Hurting people so that an outcome matches some prespecified distribution is just lazy.
Of course we should have hard classes, and of course some people that try a hard thing will fail, but they should fail on their own merit.
The counter-example is trivial: suppose you have ten "Einsteins" in your class, but due to your dumb-ass stack ranked curve, you "cut" 4 of them. Congratulations, you just set back human progress 300 years.
For the record, UCLA was equally-idiotic when it came to grading. Technically, getting an A+ (4.3) was possible, but they were virtually NEVER given out. Why? Who the fuck knows -- I asked multiple times what I could have done better. I only ever got a handful of A+'es (and basically had straight A's).
As an aside, I wish I could nuke the entire educational system. It's corrupted by lazy and complacent professors (that clearly suck at their job: see the reproducibility crisis, p-hacking, etc.), a veritable swamp of administrators (syphoning six-figure salaries across the board), and bloated sports budgets. All while issuing unforgivable loans to record-high numbers of students.
Knowing from experience that 33% will fail is not the same thing as explicitly planning for 33% to fail. We don't have enough information to call this "stack ranking", IMO.
One of the calculus professors at my undergrad institution was reportedly asked on the first day of Calc I class whether there would be a grading curve.
He asked how many of the students were planning to be engineers. Roughly 3/4 of the hands went up. Then he said "I drive on bridges and fly in airplanes all the time. There will be no curve."
Generational reductionism aside, one has only to browse a few online forums dedicated to pre-med studies to note that organic chemistry continues to maintain its reputation as a “weed-out course” in practice and in reputation.
It doesn’t strike me, based on their own words, that the current generation of students have any misapprehensions about the difficulty of the subject matter.
The link between feelings of entitlement to basic social decency (which isn’t particular to any generation) and entitlement to academic success also wasn’t substantiated beyond the nominal misapplication of the words “explosion effect,” which isn’t a rigorous term appropriately derived from any science or art with which I’m familiar.
Care to explain? I followed the benefit of the doubt through a few biological, psychological, sociological, and historical searches and found nothing that would apply to your conversation; unless you meant to reference quite literal chemical and physical explosions, which doesn’t follow in that context either.
I see your prestigious ye olde education really heightened your critical thinking skills.
A significant minority dropped out after the first term, unable to cope with the need to push themselves instead of simply doing as they were told as they had done at school.
Yikes? Everyone should be treated well, that's the default. I'm not saying the class should be simplified, but identity and background should not be a factor (educational background maybe, but that's assessed before people can attend uni).
A rather confusing way to state it.
It's one thing for art or philosophy students to want an easier class. This is doctors. I don't want someone doing surgery on me who couldn't handle the workload and took the easy way out.
Everything described in the article sounded just like my experience at two different colleges, and I wasn't in for something as important as medicine.
If you can't handle the work, then maybe it's time to look at yourself and think that maybe you shouldn't be a doctor. There are plenty of other professions out there.
But I don't want my doctor to only understand the core basics of medicine. I want her to understand how to diagnose any crazy thing I might show up in her office afflicted with.
Everything is a trade off. If organic chemistry keeps your family doctor from diagnosing you with confidence, they can pass you to a specialist whose practice needs organic chemistry more regularly.
So this is a problematic one. Currently the workload in a few areas of medicine is not sustainable. Those who pass also can't handle it. There's a threshold where instead of people toughing it out, we'll need to adjust the system so it's not necessary that much.
For people who disagree with this, I ask them the following:
“Think of the average person in generation / group <insert>. Would you want them defending you on trial for murder? How about fixing your break lines?”
Young 20 somethings can do that today, but far fewer than a generation ago.
Regardless, I actually think it’s far simpler.
If I pay $60k/year, I can’t fail out. If the uni does fail me, they lose future revenue from donations and potentially my enrollment for future years.
That's some serious entitlement right here. Why can't you fail? What's the point of education then when all one needs to do is to pay some money and do their time?
If one student fails, it’s that student’s failure. But at some point, once (x)% of the class fails, it is a systemic failure of the institution itself.
Isn’t that what education is? Paying someone money and putting in the work?
The people who fail usually should fail. When I was doing CompSci most people would fail discrete maths 2-3 times until they managed to get it. It's a good thing that they failed the first few times. I don't see how that's bad, they didn't understand it at first.
Yes. That's what it is. But it isn't "paying someone money and feeling entitled to finish because I paid the money".
Well orgo is hard... no not really, its a first - second year class? The students are setup to fail. Do I think the professor is the root issue, no just look at replies in the this thread, 'its been that way for 30 years, blah blah'.
I am paying you to teach me orgo, not to fail me at orgo. Teach it in a passable way and then test the students outside of the class, like the MCAT or LSAT where you are not commingling the selection criteria on the whims of a professor.
Is this really that hard to see?
Can't fail? Not even on exams? So a mere sum of 180k USD guarantees a degree? I hope not.
But now the market has figured that out, so there is a massive value premium on STEM degrees, and shifting to a history major is no longer a viable option, which is why there is now pressure to dumb down STEM degrees.
Not “I’m guaranteed a degree”
Im saying once you fail out, $180k in debt, most peoples lives are effectively over.
You have to go get a job making $40k-60k a year and pay $10-12k per year for the next 10-20 years.
After taxes, food, housing.. you’ll basically have to live with your parents, will have trouble starting a family, etc
Wife: "This is bonkers, the entire point of orgo is to cull the pre-med students. When I took orgo they showed the planned curve and explicitly said: one-third of you will fail."
Me: "Yeah, we had classes like that in electrical engineering as well, it was understood that that was the point of the class. It is hard to avoid the implication that Gen Z is really spectacularly entitled."
Wife: "It's the explosion effect. They have learned they should feel entitled to good things, like being treated well no matter their identity or background or whatever. But they also are entitled for other areas where entitlement is not justified."
I thought that was a pretty insightful thought!