Re:NYU Chemistry Professor Fired After Students Said His Cla...
by zen_1 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @07:57AM
(#33094235)
I'm not a chemist, but I'd imagine the ten Einsteins would all be able to pass undergrad orgo without too much pain (assuming they were interested in chemistry).
Re:NYU Chemistry Professor Fired After Students Said His Cla...
by dagw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:05AM
(#33094319)
If the bottom 3rd always fail, then they literally cannot all pass, even if they all score 97+% on the test. Someone will always be the 'worst' performer.
Re:NYU Chemistry Professor Fired After Students Said His Cla...
by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:59AM
(#33094957)
> The counter-example is trivial: suppose you have ten "Einsteins" in your class, but due to your dumb-ass stack ranked curve, you "cut" 4 of them.
Knowing from experience that 33% will fail is not the same thing as explicitly planning for 33% to fail. We don't have enough information to call this "stack ranking", IMO.
One of the calculus professors at my undergrad institution was reportedly asked on the first day of Calc I class whether there would be a grading curve.
He asked how many of the students were planning to be engineers. Roughly 3/4 of the hands went up. Then he said "I drive on bridges and fly in airplanes all the time. There will be no curve."
The counter-example is trivial: suppose you have ten "Einsteins" in your class, but due to your dumb-ass stack ranked curve, you "cut" 4 of them. Congratulations, you just set back human progress 300 years.
For the record, UCLA was equally-idiotic when it came to grading. Technically, getting an A+ (4.3) was possible, but they were virtually NEVER given out. Why? Who the fuck knows -- I asked multiple times what I could have done better. I only ever got a handful of A+'es (and basically had straight A's).
As an aside, I wish I could nuke the entire educational system. It's corrupted by lazy and complacent professors (that clearly suck at their job: see the reproducibility crisis, p-hacking, etc.), a veritable swamp of administrators (syphoning six-figure salaries across the board), and bloated sports budgets. All while issuing unforgivable loans to record-high numbers of students.