If you watch the video, you'll see that she knows that she doesn't have a 3 - she checks her hand before she calls and also a player at the table asks her if she has a 3 and she says no. Then afterwards she did an interview in which she explains how she thought she had a 3 but that doesn't match what she said at the table.
> She was only 47% to win the hand after her call of the all-in bet and while the play was marginally +EV, it wasn’t much.
It's not marginally +EV to call given the pot odds and she doesn't need to know her exact equity to be cheating, she could be getting binary "you're good" / "you aren't good" signals (and that's much easier to transmit and read without being noticed).
The play on the turn is way too ridiculous. The other thing is why did she return the money after the hand if she won it fairly? Sure, maybe she was intimidated but to me it looked like she cheated, she realised that she's in over her head and tried to make the whole thing go away by returning the money and coming up with a story about the hand she thought she had.
I watched the hand. I've been in that spot. You think you have a good read on someone such that your not-great hand may actually be best, say, they're chasing an open-ender and your high card is good. (Which it would be, barring cards folded by other players.) You're nervous, you're facing an all-in decision, you know the safe move is to fold and move on, but damn all you just can't shake the feeling, and you have to gamble.
Poker player trusting a soul read is the Occam's Razor answer here.
You didn't say this, but I fear that if this were someone like Daniel Negraneau monologuing about what to do and stating his read aloud ("I'm pretty sure you're chasing. I'm probably beat but if you're holding 8 9 I'm beating you right now. I'm right aren't I? sigh I call. Show me I'm beat.") then this wouldn't be an issue at all.
> The other thing is why did she return the money after the hand if she won it fairly?
"He cornered me & threatened me. If he has the audacity to give me the death stare ON camera, picture what it’s like OFF camera. I was pulled out of the game & forced to speak to him in a dark hallway."[twt]
Shit, if I was in that position, and producers/officials pulled me out of the game and put me in a room with my opponent where I was accused of cheating and told to return the money, damn good chance I'd return it just to make a scary situation stop. Maybe you're different, but that doesn't mean intimidation doesn't work pretty damn well.
[twt]: https://twitter.com/RobbiJadeLew/status/1575758837465812992
Right but chasing what - she can't beat J8, QJ, KQ, any high flush draw. Let alone value hands (she's drawing dead against a 10). So she has to put him specifically on 78 (which he had), 68 or 67. That makes it more suspicious, not less.
The intimidation thing makes sense if you believe her story. I can only guess what happened between the two of them after the game. I know that I've seen her change her own story about the hand that she thought she had. If you're questioning someone's credibility, you can't really go with their own story about what happened as a reason to exonerate them.
Fair, there are definitely semi-bluffs that beat J4 here, and of course if Garret had a made hand she's toast.
There's also (and I think she says this at some point, "purely a bluff-catcher" IIRC) tons of pure air bluffs that J4 beats.
I simply do not understand the stance that if a poker player makes a call with a crap hand that turns out to be good, and then holds up, that she must be cheating. Not for nothing, but I have never heard such accusations leveled at a male player like this.
> If you're questioning someone's credibility, you can't really go with their own story about what happened as a reason to exonerate them.
I am not questioning her credibility.
Because there is no reason to.
The only reason anyone thinks she might be cheating is because her heads-up opponent angrily accused her of it. Not even after a bad beat! After his hand, which was never ever the best hand of the two, failed to make any of its draws over a river that was run twice.
I question the credibility of the accusation. Garret has every reason to accuse his opponent of cheating, especially given that he successfully intimidated Robbi into returning his chips, which to me is just insane.
Why the conversation isn't "poker player doesn't catch his outs, demands his money back" is beyond me.
I suppose Hanlon's razor is adequate here - "never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity".
My sense is that the different reaction would be because of the narration, not the identity of the player (though it would also make sense that a player with a decade(s) long reputation would be given more deference than a newer player).
I think the reality is she just made a shitty decision in the moment that happened to play out well. Anyone who's played poker long enough has done the same dozens of times.
Daniel Negreanu [0] has the opposite read from you:
"The fact that she gave him the money back isn’t an admission of guilt, but likely the contrary.
A money hungry scumbag cheat isn’t likely to give money back in that spot.
Felt like she didn’t want to deal with conflict and can afford it."
[0]https://twitter.com/RealKidPoker/status/1575726681117011968?...
Re: 3 vs 4. I think both the cheaters and the non-cheater followers of this story believe that she was rattled and made a bad move. Even if she was cheating and KNEW his hand, she had no way of knowing that her Jack-high would hold up, unless people believe the entire casino is on in it and she knows all the cards coming.
If we accept that she was rattled, and stressed, and made a rash move, and got away with it, then it's equally believable that in the moment she briefly got confused and remembered the wrong hand. Memory isn't foolproof, and in the emotional decision to decide to call she confused the last 2 hands or ipso-facto justified what she could tell was a terrible decision but needed to cover up with bravado because the game had to continue after this hand.
Once you understand all of the above, it's clear she didn't need to cheat to wind up in this position, and in fact it makes LESS sense.
I haven't played running it twice but it looked like there was still importance to secrecy before the second river was flipped given the way they were acting.
> The play on the turn is way too ridiculous
Assuming the cheater doesn't know the deck (which would be extremely hard to pull off). How is cheating in this case logical? She had the losing hand at the time she called by a few percentage points.
Sometimes you call bluffs with a face card figuring it will win. It isn't a good bet but it isn't a terrible one as this hand shows.
Also insinuating that no one would return money when threatened is weird.
It’s +EV because of the money already in the pot.
Not by a lot though, and she played badly in other spots previously.
And it would also match her banter of "you probably got me".
It was effectively a coin flip given how many outs he had and the fact that her hand was better at the turn.
Saying she needed to cheat to win a coin flip is just weird.
Also the fact that it is a coin flip is well known in the poker community. If you haven't heard people bitching about losing to JX you haven't played enough.
I think if she cheated (I don't have any strong opinions on whether she did), that her signal was binary. It makes the most sense given her actions, and inability to explain them.
Buzzer that buzzes when "you have the best hand right now" makes a lot of sense and is easy for a bad player to understand.
It's a coin flip, but she's 55% favorite unless she knows the discarded/dead cards. If she knows them, she has 47% equity which makes her call very profitable given the pot size of 40k.
This is basic "pot odds" or EV calculation, I encourage you to do it.
If she didn't know his exact hand, her play is unspeakably bad. She has virtually zero equity against Garrett's range here. He's holding one of the two or three hands she can beat given his line. Most of his bluffs are crushing her.
Also the whole counterpoint hinges on not believing she felt she was calling a bluff which she explicitly called her plays as being.
He was behind and needed an out. So many outs existed he was more likely to win but "high card beats almost flush/straight".
Edit: And again, not saying this is remotely a possibility here, or has been suggested by anyone. But all the cards were in fact known by the television program covering the table, and there have been cases of someone in the control booth feeding info back to a cheater at the table.
And if she only knew the hole cards, that only tells her she is 47% to win.
I mean, it's still +EV because of pot odds, and it's possible a cheat happened I guess, but it's hardly conclusive. To reasonably allege cheating requires more than a sample size of one hand.
No, there isn't.
In tournaments, players are forced to put hands face-up when no more betting can take place. This is in part so people can see there's no cheating/collusion going on, and in part because it's better for TV.
In cash games, there's no such requirement. Players often don't show their hand because they don't want to give away information to the other players. There's rules about who has to show first, but if she had lost the pot, she could have folded without showing.
> Assuming the cheater doesn't know the deck (which would be extremely hard to pull off)
The insinuation is exactly that, that she knew the deck. (Rather, that software knew the deck and alerted her to a favorable position)
If you're not up-to-date on how that can happen, I suggest you review the mike postle scandal, and other proofs of concept where people are, in fact, reading the state of the entire deck.
The presumption that people don't call with JX is a weird one, unless you have never played poker before.
This assertion belies your mistakes. Giving you the benefit of the doubt, I think you're talking about playing J4 preflop. It's pretty bad, but whatever, people do it all the time. And of course they can win with it.
They don't usually rely on calling a $109k bluff on the turn with jack high to win, though.
> unless you have never played poker before.
I was a professional player before they shut down the big 3 online sites.
Also you're calling out a whole lot of top professional players with that statement.
Unless you can claim you haven't seen a huge bet on Jack Shit then that isn't sufficient evidence of cheating.
This tells me you don't understand the basics of poker. Which is fine, but you might want to be clear about that before opining :P
While the expected percent change of her winning the hand was slightly worse than a coinflip, her pot odds made her call +EV. In other words by calling that allin, she stood to profit. Your comment was implicitly assuming that she can only win as much money as she puts in with the final bet.
So yeah, 53% of the time she's going to lose the hand, but her actual expected value of making the call is positive.
> I haven't played running it twice but it looked like there was still importance to secrecy before the second river was flipped given the way they were acting.
I'm a bit confused by this, could you explain this in another way? If you're saying that there was maybe a reason to maintain secrecy (as far as what hand she had) after the first run, that's not true because she already won a hand therefore she will have to show her hand regardless of how the second river goes.
"He cornered me & threatened me. If he has the audacity to give me the death stare ON camera, picture what it’s like OFF camera. I was pulled out of the game & forced to speak to him in a dark hallway."
Given bad bets leading to threats of violence is not unheard of presupposing the threat wasn't made is baseless.
Hm why would a woman when confronted with an enraged man threatening her seek to minimize conflict…
Giving the money back is also a bad look.
The other odd thing is she's a very new player suddenly playing some of the biggest stakes in the world, and she's now won $100k in back to back appearances, while presumably making amateur mistakes like calling $130k with Jack high.
I agree there's no convincing evidence but it's enough to raise my suspicions.
With TV cameras and thousands of people watching every tiny thing you do, for hundreds of thousands of dollars, I can buy it. I’ve been in televised card games before and it is so easy to make dumb mistakes just because of the pressure of the cameras and audience.
I wouldn’t read too much into this, it can be either.
I’ve given back money during disputes just to avoid drama and because I was certain one way or another the money would come back to me anyway.
That's not what it means to make a +EV call. Expected value is estimated based on the opponent's presumed range. In this case the EV of the call was extremely negative EVEN IF we assume that the all-in was a bluff 100% of the time. Problem is that jack high usually doesn't beat a bluff in this scenario. If you adjust that 100% to something realistic like 60% or 30% or whatnot, it becomes even more severely -EV.
My point was that if she was cheating and knew what his cards were, there is no range to care about. And even then, it’s not significantly +EV.
edit: closer to 20k, i didn't remember the exact pot size
She loses her share/EV (47% per the graphics) of the pot (41.7k per the graphics) if she folds.
So it's worth more like 20k to call, if she knows his exact hand.
Much more likely to be cheating, imo
What would be the logic that a calm, rational, 3rd party (that could even be using a computer to calculate odds) would use that would justify risking $100K+ on that hand?
Also, don't you think that if someone's cheating they would be careful to play relatively conservatively so as not to cause this kind of attention?
If this is the first poker cheating scandal that you have followed, then you are forgiven for not knowing how funny that question is.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stones_Gambling_Hall_cheating_...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cereus_Poker_Network#2007_chea...
Because her call was +EV. Not knowing Garrett's cards, it was an insanely stupid call that threw away money. But if one knew Garrett's cards, they'd know it was a healthily +EV call.
The fact that Garrett had outs is very irrelevant here. You seem to think that one would only cheat by knowing that the opponent is drawing completely dead. But that's nonsense. You just need to know if your call is +EV or not.
Edit: to clarify, I doubt she knew her opponents specific cards. But she definitely knew her high card Jack had a good shot of winning, which is an absurd thing to suspect without cheating.
That’s a lot of money to give back
If she beat him fair and square, any reasonable person would call him a sore loser and be happy to have taken his money.
A lot of comments in this post are applying the commenter’s context to her situation when judging her actions.
I have personally lost all respect for at least two communities. Supposedly intelligent people apparently are all too ready to turn into a mob too.
Bullying is an effective tactic. If it wasn't effective we wouldn't have so many bullies.
Apparently we're still living by playground rules where if you don't stand up for yourself you deserve it.
I guess they know the odds of different scenarios playing out than I would.
When there's money involved there will be people who cheat.
Even when there's no money involved, some people will cheat.
Per Robbi herself, " i ran it twice because i didnt think j high could be good".
https://youtu.be/9NNKjWscKWo?t=717 (says it at 12:00)
Come on
Monetarily, there's no difference whether you run it once or twice. It just lowers variance.
I'm not sure what you're disagreeing with. She literally says it, I'm not reading into anything. What are you taking away from the video? (I genuinely am not sure what your argument is)
Most likely all she knew was she had the better hand at the time of his all in via someone spying his hole cards and some kind discrete alert system, like a vibration. She just wanted to make a play for the cameras but didn't think through how it would look.
The intention was most likely for her to get it first, then even if he called it would just look like she tried a big bluff. Would have looked great for clips and streaming...
It was either a colossally dumb mistake on her part followed by implausible explanations or she bet a ton of money somehow knowing she had him beat with jack high.
Without any actual proof of cheating (especially in this terrible spot) my money is on a fuckup.
"you have the best hand" buzzing in her pocket
Calling with J4 doesn't make sense in any other scenario, so it's hard for us to say "well it doesn't make sense to call in the flip scenario."
It makes way less sense to call with J4. She did something that doesn't make sense.
She also announced that she did not have a pair of threes, out loud.
Also for anyone else who wants to watch it, it was livestreamed, so it doesn't matter if you watch it live or now.
Far more likely was she misread J4 as J3, especially as she literally said “threes are good, right?” during her deliberations.
Cheating in this spot just makes no sense and there has been zero evidence to indicate it was anything more than what she said - she misread a 4 as a 3.