News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @03:39PM (#33039717)
She hasnt even started as a pm yet the eu issued warnings. Apparently Ursula “has tools”. You can’t make this shit up.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by mark_l_watson on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:50PM (#33040608)
+1 I was also shocked to hear in a news conference the EU president Ursula von der Leyen threaten the Italian voters right before the election. Seriously, I was shocked. So much for believing in democracy.

I am very liberal politically, but I 100% support people on the right wing who run into trouble with the Neoliberal overlords.

We need to have respect for all people's opinions (that are non-violent, etc.) and support all people's rights to vote as they wish. I think the Neoliberals must envy China's authoritarian control of their population, because that is what I think the Neoliberals want also.

BTW, I joined the World Economic Forum for a while just to read directly what they were up to.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @05:29PM (#33041042)
Likewise, left leaning and i find it shocking. And as much as i want to not criticise the eu and its politics i simply can’t. Always sanctions and threats what happened to cooperation and mutual understanding?
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by systemvoltage on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:16PM (#33042402)
Another problem is the term Fascism that's been thrown around willy-nilly. I think next time one uses the term, it is probably worth looking up what Fascism really looks like.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by thiht on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:56AM (#33045110)
To be fair Meloni belonged to a neo fascist group when she was young, and has publicly expressed admiration for Mussolini.

The term fascism is often misused, but I’d say not this time.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by MrMan on Saturday October 01, 2022 @08:14AM (#33046034)
yeah she is an actual Fascist.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by arinlen on Friday September 30, 2022 @05:58PM (#33041344)
> +1 I was also shocked to hear in a news conference the EU president Ursula von der Leyen threaten the Italian voters right before the election.

This is the very first time I've heard such a thing. Do you have a source showcasing what you claim to be threats?

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by tarakat on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:06PM (#33041427)
During a conference on Thursday at Princeton University, an attendant pointed out to von der Leyen that “figures close to Putin” were among candidates for the upcoming legislative election on Sunday. “We’ll see,” she replied. “If things go in a difficult direction — and I’ve spoken about Hungary and Poland — we have the tools.” - https://www.politico.eu/article/italy-election-candidate-war...
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by arinlen on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:12PM (#33041460)
> “If things go in a difficult direction — and I’ve spoken about Hungary and Poland — we have the tools.”

Please explain what led you to interpret this as a threat of any form. The Orban reference was pretty clear.

From the article:

> "This is a clear reference to the ability of the European Commission to cut funds allocated to member countries when they are deemed to be violating the rule of law."

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:03PM (#33041845)
But who oversees the rule of law within the eu commission? Ursula is infamously corrupt, incompetent and rejected by germans, who sanctions the eu commission when it itself violates the “rule of law”? Dont get me wrong, i agree with the principle, but the eu needs reform. Each time anyone dares raise such desire they are either immediately pushed back or threatened with sanctions.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:07PM (#33041875)
> But who oversees the rule of law within the eu commission

EU courts are the judical oversight, and the EU parliament can remove the commission at any time (legislative oversight).

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:30PM (#33042049)
I know the theory but my question was more philosophical.

Corruption isnt just taking bribes. Urusula’s comments are akin to coercing voters into voting against their preference and are a clear violation of treaties whereby the eu has no right to intervene in the sovereign voting process of member states. Its not like italians were bribed or forced into voting a certain way. That means ursula is abusing a position of power in favour of certain political parties with the threat of cutting funding if their new leader isnt docile enough. That is corruption and the perfectly fine eu courts will never sanction her for it.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:38PM (#33042126)
I think that's interpreting too much into the comment, especially with the reference to Poland and Hungary: It's saying that if the governments cause problems with EU law, the commission has tools to handle that. The commission does not have the power to just cut funding without a reason, and if it ever attempts to do so the EU courts will put a stop to it. The treaty violation processes are slow, intentionally. (And the majority of member states is quite happy with that, since most of them run into that occasionally, and also has all the reasons to not stand for that)

"We'll pay close attention if you stick to the laws" is pretty much the worst the commission can really threaten a government, which isn't really all that much if there is nothing serious to punish.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:26PM (#33042471)
You could be right, lets see how things develop. But cornering the leader of a country from the get go can have the effect of rallying people around said leader and galvanising their position. You know, national pride and all. Instead ursula should have shown a bit more diplomacy and tact. The british have been rallied around brexiteers precisely because of a lack of diplomacy and tact on eu’s part. They basically said nein to any attempt of negotiation, voters put up their two fingers because of sovereign pride and all and here we are.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by miguelazo on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:54PM (#33041783)
Cutting funds allocated to member countries for not voting the way you want seems like a pretty clear threat to me!
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:56PM (#33041800)
They can't cut funding for "not voting the way they want". Funding can be held back if governments violate treaty obligations, after a lengthy process. (I.e. the other referenced examples have clear reasons why the process is running, and it's not because who the voters voted for ...)
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by tarakat on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:38PM (#33042125)
And maybe von der Leyen will lobby for a stricter reading of those treaties if the wrong party gets elected, which is the subtext of her words, obvious to all but the most willfully obtuse.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:48PM (#33042196)
So some lawyers will spend some extra years fighting over some edge cases, with very unclear results if its not something serious but a fishing operation as you suggest. Or some actual legal issues will have to be resolved. Scary.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by miguelazo on Saturday October 01, 2022 @08:55AM (#33046253)
Love that you finally admit they were threats, and now are just trying to minimize them. Go ask the Germans how empty Biden’s threats to end the gas pipelines they depended on were.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:37PM (#33049883)
No, I merely argue that if you read them to be threats in that sense, they are pretty pointless threats. And it thus makes little sense to read them as such, because they would be such unimpressive threats.

Your US/Germany comparison doesn't work, since that's an entirely different situation. For starters, a state like the US can actually apply pressure or use force, because there isn't an established strong framework saying it can't nor anything directly enforcing what little there is. US enforced sanctions over the pipeline construction because it didn't like the pipeline, nothing Germany can do directly. (And if you want to assume the recent sabotage was the US, pretty much the same applies)

The commission is just not an independent state-level actor in that way. It's actually constrained by a state-like legal framework around it, granting it limited powers for specific purposes. Outside of those, it can and will be reigned in very quickly.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by PatentlyDC123 on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:15PM (#33041484)
I found this article to cover the quote in her recent speech about "tools." [0]

[0] https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eus-von-der-leyen-deliv...

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by arinlen on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:36PM (#33041648)
Here's the quote from the article.

> My approach is that whatever democratic government is willing to work with us, we're working together," von der Leyen said at Princeton University in the United States on Thursday, responding to a question on whether there were any concerns with regard to the upcoming elections in Italy.

> "If things go in a difficult direction, I've spoken about Hungary and Poland, we have tools," she added.

So a liberal democratic organization is prepared to protect itself from sabotage from fascist organizations that are actively manipulated by external actors to undermine them. That's your threat.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:51PM (#33041753)
A corrupt liberal democratic organisation that has no right to intervene in the democratic processes of sovereign member states that have formed an alliance to create the said organisation. I dont agree with polands or hungarys politics but that is not my business. The us is not sanctioning texas or florida for its politics and looney governors. Why is the eu which is not even a federal government daring make such interventions? Who gave them the right? Who voted ursula in in this so called “democracy”?
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by arinlen on Saturday October 01, 2022 @05:54AM (#33045355)
> A corrupt liberal democratic organisation (...)

The European Union is a federation of liberal democracies. It's not a Bond-like villain organization.

The bulk of EU's member states value human rights, including women's rights and individual rights and freedom.

You're putting up absurd strawmen to try to rationalize nonsense.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Saturday October 01, 2022 @08:24AM (#33046090)
As much as i’d like the eu to be a federation it’s not quite there yet. At the moment it’s just a mechanism for europeans to dominate each other without starting wars.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by miguelazo on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:49PM (#33041734)
I assumed that you were using "liberal democratic organization" in jest, but now I am not sure. Would you like to elaborate on your "actively maniuplated by external actors" statement? Is this something like the Russiagate hoax? Are you suggesting Italian voters aren't capable of voting in their own interests?
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by mhoad on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:03AM (#33044039)
It’s probably more related to the fact that 70% of the country didn’t actually vote for them, it’s hardly the will of the people.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by miguelazo on Saturday October 01, 2022 @08:57AM (#33046265)
Which actually is worse for Draghi and the rest of the EU puppets— meaning the voters are so disaffected they couldn’t be bothered to even come out and vote for them.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by amadeuspagel on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:48AM (#33045085)
More then half of the country voted for her coalition.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by mhoad on Sunday October 02, 2022 @07:46AM (#33055081)
That’s not actually true either but good try.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by wellthatsawrap1 on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:10PM (#33042365)
> manipulated by external actors

The irony of this comment!

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:55PM (#33042672)
Well op does have a point. A certain country is very active in supporting nationalist movements in europe and isolationist policies in the us. The age old divide and conquer. It is a real threat and not a right vs left issue. This is a matter of collective security as the motives behind division have been repeatedly stated: expansion and domination. But i do agree with your sentiment assumed from previous comments, neither right or left leaders have an effective solution to the bigger issue.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by amadeuspagel on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:46AM (#33045076)
Von der Leyen did not refer to "sabotage", "fascist organizations", "external actors". There's a reason that she talks in vague terms about "things going in a difficult direction" and that is that there's nothing more concrete.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by arinlen on Saturday October 01, 2022 @06:00AM (#33045378)
> There's a reason that she talks in vague terms (...)

She did not. You're trying to pass off a conspiracy theory by omitting context and taking quotes out of context, including erasing parts of the quote.

If you're still confused just go learn about Victor Orban and Hungary's recent regression into an totalitarian dictatorship that's profoundly illiberal and outright a sock puppet of external actors such as Putin's Russian federation. Go learn about it's destruction of Hungary's independent judiciary and attacks on fundamental human rights, which go against fundamental principles of the European Union, and learn about how the EU has been reacting to this sort of illiberal drift.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by stjohnswarts on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:11PM (#33041901)
She's bad for italy but shouldn't be banned on twitter as she hasn't actually done anything yet. That will likely be forthcoming in the coming months. You really should take a look at her party's history. She's a lot like trump. A bit moderate-rightish but she prefers strongmen type leaders like Putin and Berlesconi, which I think speaks for her future plans as to how government "should be run"
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:05PM (#33042317)
My point is that we should respect the people of italy and their choice. We should do the same for hungary and poland. Sanctions and threats polarise voters or may even help their cause.

Maybe there is a third option, other than appeasement or threats. Maybe we can try and understand why people of now a third eu member state chose such a political leader.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by 312c on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:21PM (#33042438)
74% of voters in Italy did not want Meloni.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:28PM (#33042486)
Cool, we need to figure out why people dont go out and vote while we do respect those that did. Not saying we should blindly agree with their choice, but it feels like there is so much going on beneath the surface that threats will only make things worse.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by systemvoltage on Saturday October 01, 2022 @12:32AM (#33043893)
This is probably the most level headed political comment I've read on HN in a long time. Kudos.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by inkywatcher on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:40AM (#33045050)
Ask a gay person in Orban's Hungary what respecting the will of the voters is like.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by thehappypm on Saturday October 01, 2022 @12:48AM (#33043974)
“Bad for Italy” meaning what exactly? She won fair and square.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by wesapien on Saturday October 01, 2022 @07:31AM (#33045782)
I was talking to some the other day about why a certain city which has so many minorities vote conservative. Its funny how these celebrate diversity but the moment they vote conservative they lose the ingroup status of minority. The only concern is surface level diversity. True diversity is having some progressive and some conservative thought.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by wellthatsawrap1 on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:07PM (#33042335)
Because Biden's and his handlers approach is so much better. Things are great, everything is progressing so well, the morons currently in power have us on the brink of WW3. I'm begining to think that HN has the same bot count as twitter.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:17PM (#33042413)
Coincidentally trump did threaten states with cutting funding for not voting members of his own party. A bit like our leftie ursula, indicating that political ideology is not the cause of the issue. Anyway i dont know much about us internal politics but i do know that however gets elected in the us affects us here in europe. And biden is doing a hell of a job in not appeasing putin. Not sure if his approach is good or bad but he definitely seems to put america firmly on our side. If it was up to our european allies, such as germany, ukraine would have entirely been part of russia today.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by wellthatsawrap1 on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:20PM (#33048214)
Putin annexed Crimea under Obama's watch. He's just annex half of eastern Ukraine under Biden's watch. How much territory did Putin get under Trump's watch?? 0. Trump is way more on your side then the neocons like Nuland. You think Biden can actually form coherent thoughts? Do you think that Harris has any grasp of Geopolitics? The West has been horribly weakend by liberal democracies propped up by the WEF. Do you think any EU country has the stomach for war? Are you willing to send your sons to die on foreign soil for someone else's fight, because it sure as hell won't be US troops that get deployed.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by detaro on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:22PM (#33042445)
christ-democrats/EVP are not leftie.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:41PM (#33042574)
Oh but they are compared to republicans. I dont think the right in europe aligns with the right in the us. I think most centre right parties in europe would be seen as left in the us. But you are right the CDU is not left in strictly european terms. Thanks for pointing this out.
Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by landemva on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:23PM (#33042855)
> gets elected in the us affects us here in europe.

If you don't like it, kick USA out of NATO. Soon, please.

Crimea was part of Russia. Since 1783.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by yrgulation on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:32PM (#33042911)
> If you don't like it, kick USA out of NATO. Soon, please.

Oh but i love it. If anything nato should expand. Which it does.

> Crimea was part of Russia. Since 1783.

And before that it was ottoman. And before that mongol. And before that greek.

We froze borders, expect by force where people were genocidal, or by diplomacy everywhere else, after world war two.

Crimea is Ukrainian. Since 1954 love.

Out of curiosity, how did you creep in here?

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by foverzar on Saturday October 01, 2022 @05:11AM (#33045177)
> We froze borders, expect by force where people were genocidal, or by diplomacy everywhere else, after world war two.

Who are "we"? How did you "froze" border, what does that even mean?

After the WWII the borders in Europe had shifted multiple times, from the union of eastern and western Germanies and dissolution of the Soviet Union, to the teardown of Yugoslavia, the Kosovo case being the most controversial one.

And that's just Europe, not even talking about the rest of the world.

> Crimea is Ukrainian. Since 1954 love.

In 1954 Crimea had been a part of the Soviet Union, legally an autonomous republic (Crimean Autonomous Socialist Soviet Republic). I am not sure which part of it suddenly makes it Ukrainian.

When the SU had dissolved, being an autonomous republic, Crimea was supposed to become a whole independent state on its own. And it had been for 3 or so years https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Crimea_(1992–199...

It became de facto Ukraine only after Ukraine brought it forcibly under control in 1995, abolishing the status of republic.

Educate yourself, love.

Re:Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Fema... by cplusplusfellow on Friday September 30, 2022 @10:35PM (#33043254)
Can you elaborate on how “strongmen type leaders” differs from the behavior patterns of so many of our worlds leaders during and after the pandemic?