News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by dkbrk on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:35PM (#32990018)
I'm reminded a bit of NASA's work with 3D printing high temperature superalloys [0].

One difference is, NASA's work uses Hot isostatic pressing [1], a post-processing step that homogenizes the part. Whereas it sounds like this work is trying to dial in the composition such that they can get acceptable performance without any post-processing.

Tesla went through a similar thing with their Gigacastings. The only reason making such large die-cast parts is practical for them is, they put a lot of work into the material science to come up with a composition they gave the desired properties without any post-processing such as heat treatment.

The really cool thing NASA is doing, though, is coating the metal powder with nanoscale ceramic particles, which get dispersed throughout the part. That's something that can't be done with traditional manufacturing at all (the ceramic particles would separate out of molten metal rather than staying dispersed). With 3D printing, each little melt pool is too small for the ceramic particles to migrate too far, and after HIP they end up at the grain boundaries. Using that approach, they developed an alloy with higher ultimate tensile strength and vastly higher (x1000) resistance to creep at high temperatures (1100 C) compared to the best available superalloys.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TapNnQZ9Ek

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_isostatic_pressing

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by xyzzyz on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:26PM (#32991265)
> Using that approach, they developed an alloy with higher ultimate tensile strength and vastly higher (x1000) resistance to creep at high temperatures (1100 C) compared to the best available superalloys

That sounds really cool. Do you think this will allow us to build jet engines with higher operating temperatures, improving efficiency of electricity generation and plane travel?

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ezekg on Monday September 26, 2022 @05:58PM (#32989110)
If this is interesting to anybody, CGS recently created 3D printed suppressors using direct metal laser sintering (DMLS), but with Titanium instead of SS [0]. It allows for new geometries to suppress the expanding gasses that just weren't possible with CNC'd parts welded together. SIG also started producing suppressors with DMLS [1].

I don't have one (yet), but the results on sound signature look to be pretty impressive [2].

[0]: https://cgsgroup.com/product/hyperion/

[1]: https://www.sigsauer.com/suppressors.html

[2]: https://pewscience.com/sound-signature-reviews-free/sss-6-71...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by wyager on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:36PM (#32990420)
I have a Helios QD Ti suppressor (same company, also 3D printed out of titanium) - just got ATF approval after about 6-7 months. It was pretty pricey (around $1300 IIRC), but it's very cool. Super lightweight, suppresses very effectively. Almost feels like dense plastic because it's so light. Sheds heat very quickly - safe to touch much faster than my Omega 300. They claim it's good up to 300 Norma Magnum, which is extremely impressive for the weight.

The American suppressor market is super interesting, because the $200 flat tax, extreme physical stresses, and low weight limits conspire to incentivize some of the most advanced high-temperature high-stress metallurgy outside of jet engines. In most other countries, where suppressors are unrestricted or even required (!), it seems like there's not nearly as much incentive to go straight to the ultra-high-end like most American suppressor mfrs have done.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by pvarangot on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:53PM (#32989675)
I'm in California so I can't suppress my firearms because that would put the rest of the population in grave danger. That being said, the most impressive thing of the sintered suppressors rather than the sound signature for me was the reduction in blowback. I heard them on pistols and semi-auto rifles though, I suppose to truly hear it I should have seen it on a bolt action.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ezekg on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:01PM (#32989738)
SIG’s new DMLS suppressor line supposedly has less blowback than unsuppressed, which is incredible. Gas to the face sucks.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by sbierwagen on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:42PM (#32990065)
>I'm in California so I can't suppress my firearms because that would put the rest of the population in grave danger.

?

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by collegeburner on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:33PM (#32991299)
California, a state known for regulations that ostensibly promote safety, has banned safety devices despite their already being extremely heavily regulated at the federal level.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by xyzzyz on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:28PM (#32991276)
He is making fun of California laws prohibiting suppressors being idiotic.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by GordonS on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:41AM (#32992911)
As a non-American, this seems... fine?

Are there legitimate uses of a suppressor I'm unaware of, or are they truly only useful for clandestine violence?

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by xyzzyz on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @10:40AM (#32995845)
They are in fact basically never used for clandestine violence in places where they are legal (which is most of the US). On the other hand, there is a clear legitimate use of them: protection of hearing when you are shooting your own guns for fun, which is a legitimate activity that millions of Americans engage in every day.

Banning suppressors is kinda like as if European countries today banned possession of English longbows. These very much can be effectively used for violence, as Agincourt has shown. However, nowadays, they emphatically are not used for that, and if modern European government loudly declared a war on longbows, and went after the owners, one would think that they went crazy: shooting longbows is a pastime of medieval reenacters, not criminals.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by collegeburner on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:59AM (#32995329)
They make guns quieter and reduce recoil. All around more pleasant to shoot and reduce hearing damage. Guns are loud enough that exposure to even a few rounds in close quarters can cause hearing damage so suppressors should be in regular use as safety devices. They don't make guns safe without earpro, they don't make them silent, they don't even make them that quiet. You will still know if one goes off nearby. This is one of the things about hollywood that pisses off everyone who knows squat about guns, and why we try to refer to them as suppressors rather than "silencers".
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by wyager on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @11:53AM (#32997017)
Suppressors are legally required in many european areas, and completely unrestricted in many countries even with restrictive gun laws. They are primarily a nuisance reduction and hearing safety device. The US's strict regulations mostly stem from people watching spy movies and failing to understand that they are not realistic.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by lesuorac on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:07PM (#32998927)
John Wick isn't a documentary.

Firearms with suppressors are still very loud (>130 decibels or about as loud as an ambulance siren) [1].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silencer_(firearms)#Effectiven...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by voakbasda on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @08:43AM (#32994587)
Guns are stupidly loud. A suppressor can literally save you from permanent hearing damage if you are forced to fire one inside a confined space.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by zoltar on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:49PM (#32990121)
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by giantrobot on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:52PM (#32990143)
Suppressors are just flat illegal in California. So much as possession of a suppressor is illegal.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ncmncm on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:56PM (#32990527)
Some places, cops will visit if they think you are buying too many oil filters because you might be making and, presumably, selling suppressors.
[dead]
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by pvarangot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:53AM (#32991924)
It's not a fetichism to want to add a safety device to an already dangerous hobby or work tool. To own a suppressor _in the United States of America_ you need to pass a BATFE background check that lasts a year or more. It's a registered item and has a 200 dollar tax stamp. And that's a federal law. What gains in "the safety of the public" are made by making it outright illegal when you already have to do that to have one is at least debatable.

Also if they are so dangerous maybe they shouldn't be putting them in the AR-15s of SFPD SWAT like you can see here: https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/At-Outside-Lands...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by littlestymaar on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:01AM (#32992279)
> Also if they are so dangerous maybe they shouldn't be putting them in the AR-15s of SFPD SWAT like you can see here: https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/At-Outside-Lands...

What is that argument? Do you also want to be allowed to drive an M1 Abrams because the Army use them? Legalize depleted Uranium APFSDS, it will be OK, there is a background check.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by louky on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:58AM (#32991952)
Suppressors are more widely legally available and even required in many European countries.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by adolph on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:06PM (#32989198)
I wonder if the methods could be used for acoustic suppression of other things, like fans.

For example the foam used in the below one wouldn't be useful for a kitchen hood fan.

https://www.amazon.com/VIVOSUN-Noise-Reducer-Silencer-Inline...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by _carbyau_ on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:49PM (#32991091)
Just give me an actually quiet vacuum cleaner...
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by tguvot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:20AM (#32991779)
central vacuum.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by oktwtf on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:12AM (#32992014)
Quiet for me, but not for thee.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by tguvot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:43AM (#32992177)
in crawlspace/garage where it's typically installed there is no thee
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by _carbyau_ on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @08:33PM (#33014956)
Yeah. I live in an apartment because house prices are crazy. So not for me...
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by tguvot on Friday September 30, 2022 @01:32AM (#33031351)
miele c3. quietest vacuum i ever had
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by mhb on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:05PM (#32989766)
Dan Gelbart on metal 3D printing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nyYcomX7Lus
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by c_o_n_v_e_x on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:24AM (#32992066)
For those who don't know, Gelbart's videos are amazing on manufacturing methods, making prototypes, etc. A god of hardware IMO.

https://makezine.com/article/digital-fabrication/machining/1...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by sbf501 on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:46PM (#32990104)
I'm really amazed they can retain the phase of the material this way. When I learned about annealing different forms of steel in college materials class, I thought the entire object had to participate in the phase change. The fact they can preserve the structure not only at each 2D layer, but also at the junction of those layers in the 3rd-D really blows my mind. It's like the whole game of different steel phases is up for re-analysis when produced this way.

This is the future. We aren't even remotely close to scaling up and optimizing this kind of manufacturing.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by adrian_b on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:44PM (#32987403)
Non-pay-walled version of the research paper:

https://tsapps.nist.gov/publication/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=93265...

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by bozhark on Monday September 26, 2022 @04:13PM (#32987733)
2nd page of the paper has a decent description with data and a visual diagram of the process, it's worth checking out.

"Characterization of phase transformation dynamics of commercial additively manufactured 17–4 stainless steel (C_17–4) during laser melting. (a) Schematic illustration of in-situ laser-melting X-ray diffraction experiment. A vertical laser beam scans the sample to create a localized melt pool. The micro-focused high-energy X-ray beam is used to probe the phase transformation dynamics with a frame rate of 250 Hz. (b) Room temperature XRD pattern of as-solidified C_17–4 after laser melting. (c) XRD intensity map (XRD peak intensity evolution as a function of time) during laser melting of C_17–4 from 0 s to 20 s. The liquid gap near 0.15 s without any diffraction peaks denotes the period when all the material in the X-ray path was fully melted. The time axis is enlarged in the 0–1 s range to highlight the phase transformation details during the initial solidification stage. (d) EBSD of as-printed C_17–4 microstructure displayed in inversed pole figure (IPF) coloring. (e) EBSD of as-printed C_17–4 microstructure displayed in image quality (IQ) map. Martensite (α’) phase and a mixture of austenite (γ) and δ-ferrite (δ) phases were pointed out in the microstructure. (f) EBSD phase map of as-printed C_17–4. (g) XRD intensity evolution from (c) during solidification. The time axis is enlarged in the 0–1 s range. The uncertainty for BCC intensity measurement is 1 %. The uncertainty for FCC intensity measurement is 2 %."

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by TOMDM on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:29PM (#32987210)
Are there any pictures of a finished part?

I'm assuming there would be features that need to be cleaned up after a print, but this looks incredible.

I wonder what the cost savings are like vs a 6dof CNC mill for parts that can be made that way.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by monkpit on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:31PM (#32987235)
Not only that, but if you can print finished parts you can engineer parts that cannot be physically machined.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by TOMDM on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:32PM (#32987250)
Yeah, the ability to rapid prototype parts with occluded cavities that can't be machined by a CNC makes this a compelling capability all on its own.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by dekhn on Monday September 26, 2022 @04:24PM (#32987873)
Example: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1068443 if not impossible, would be very difficult to machine, but is straightforward for a printer.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by etrautmann on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:59PM (#32989721)
Great point, though I think this isn’t a great example - it should be straightforward to machine that part with a 5 axis cnc since all of the suns rays pass straight through and an end mill could approach from each of those angles as well.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ezekg on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:03PM (#32990226)
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by jjk166 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:42PM (#32997771)
Balls in a cage are actually common CNC machined art pieces.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by dekhn on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @02:22PM (#33011365)
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by amelius on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:54PM (#32989684)
I wonder if you can make screw threads and how fine using this technique.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by Intermernet on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:26AM (#32993174)
You can, but they usually require re-tapping / re-dieing. This is usually easier and less wasteful (from a material point of view) than tapping / dieing a drilled or lathed part, but involves careful calibration in order to end up with a good finish. If you don't really care about "machinist fit" threads you can usually get away with 3d printed threads, but they'll bind, or have lots of backlash, or both.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by rsfern on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:50PM (#32990488)
I don’t think there are full part builds related to this study. this group does these cool single track experiments where you can follow along with synchrotron x-rays and get really good structural data through the whole solidification process. So it’s more basic materials science than applied at this point.

Someone else posted a link to the paper

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by SV_BubbleTime on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:44PM (#32987400)
>6dof CNC mill

6-axis, dof is the wrong term here.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by defterGoose on Monday September 26, 2022 @04:02PM (#32987603)
5-axis. No one uses Stanford arms for milling strong materials. The sixth axis would be redundant with the spindle rotation anyway.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by SV_BubbleTime on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:30PM (#32991006)
I was correcting one thing at a time. We use a 6-axis laser at my work, I’m only hobbiest machinist level at best.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by TOMDM on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:11AM (#32991487)
Either way I appreciate the corrections from both of you!
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by triggercut on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:32AM (#32993214)
On-demand high performance steel parts are a really exciting prospect and these results look impressive.

One of the difficulties in adoption I see is finding ways to assure the process and the materials that industry will trust and adopt.

Conventional procurement of exotic or high-performance/high-spec materials can typically include destructive and non-destructive testing to confirm properties at different stages in the supply chain. This is relatively straight forward if you are getting bar or plate stock. You take some bits off and test those separately knowing everything from the same mother-plate will perform the same.

In an additive process, I don't know what that looks like, or what would satisfy those who need it (usually insurance companies). Do you print an extra tab onto the part, or a seperate piece in the same print run? Or is it the consumables (i.e. the metal powder) that you QA, similar to how welding consumables are QAed. Maybe a combination? Either way, it could be a while before industry adopts a standard approach to this.

In a similar but different vein, Modumetal use nanolamination to get the structures they need. I've always wondered why they don't try to match to current steel specs, maybe they can't, maybe it's not a business model that would work for them. https://www.modumetal.com/

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by SV_BubbleTime on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:43PM (#32987394)
An annoyance, but if they're heat treating in the printing step... that's 17-4 steel, but it will never be 17-4 PH, as there is no perception hardening step.

Also, "one of" should be emphasized there. 17-4 is very good common steel. But there are tons like inconel (a tradename for a 600 series), or maraging steels that beat in strength applications. It's good, but it's common good. Not common great. And certainly not exotic good.

As a machinist, you had better have a good plan before get into inconel. For 17-4, you can pretty much just have at it.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by jseutter on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:11PM (#32990272)
I think you meant precipitation hardening. The article mentions that they can 3d print material that has a similar structure to 17-4 PH steel, with similar strength properties. They aren't specifically heat treating while printing, they're effectively printing heat treated material.

So I think you're right that it won't be 17-4 PH. It sounds like it could be just as strong without the need for heat treating. That's pretty cool.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by kansface on Monday September 26, 2022 @05:13PM (#32988511)
This isn't my area of expertise. The article mentioned that they could skip some sort of tempering/annealing step. Is that distinct from the PH step here?
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by SV_BubbleTime on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:39AM (#32991600)
Right.

There is no PH step here. That typically involves heating the metal and spraying it with a solution that contains different metals. Some steel is hard to heat treat in the typical way (heating/quenching), but precipitation hardening may work differently. It gets real science real fast.

I don’t know all the ins and outs, but I suspect the article was taking liberties in “just as good” being “the same”. That was my point, they might have made something great, but without sprinkling it was copper or chromium or whatever solution, it’s not PH.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by saboot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:18AM (#32992366)
This is great, but we should be aware there are real and dangerous consequences as this technology advances.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by Intermernet on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:17AM (#32993122)
Is this a meme? This exact comment can be made about every single technological advance.

Humans create a better vaccine? "This is great, but we should be aware there are real and dangerous consequences as this technology advances."

Humans create more efficient solar cells? "This is great, but we should be aware there are real and dangerous consequences as this technology advances."

I never know when I'm replying to something that may be tongue in cheek or sarcastic. I'd suggest that we need better NLP tools to extract semantic meaning from web comments, but "we should be aware there are real and dangerous consequences as this technology advances."

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by saboot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:18AM (#32994865)
For 3D printing of high strength materials specifically, it easily allows a way to bypass all existing export control laws
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by jjk166 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:45PM (#32997806)
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by saboot on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:34PM (#33001410)
As I previously mentioned in the other reply, the specific reason with this technology is the complete circumvention of all export control laws
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by abdullahkhalids on Monday September 26, 2022 @04:30PM (#32987952)
Anyone have a rough idea of how much such a printer would cost?
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ezekg on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:00PM (#32989123)
A direct metal laser sintering (DMLS) machine costs >$100k.

Maybe someday it'll be as affordable as FDM is now.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by abdullahkhalids on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:50PM (#32989649)
That doesn't sound too expensive, given the temperatures and safety features involved.

But the raw parts are probably an order of magnitude cheaper, so price should come down to those levels if production scales up.

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by ezekg on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:08PM (#32989806)
Oh absolutely. If you’re using it in production manufacturing, $100-250k is a small startup cost. I was thinking more of personal ownership like with an FDM 3D printer. Maybe one day!
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by monkpit on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:30PM (#32987225)
> As a bonus, some compositions resulted in the formation of strength-inducing nanoparticles that, with the traditional method, require the steel to be cooled and then reheated.

Is this just a fancy way of saying it doesn’t require heat treatment?

Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by zactato on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:19AM (#32991774)
Probably a dumb question (it’s a decade since my last materials class): why can’t you laser scinter during the printing and then heat treat in an oven to regain material properties?
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by Intermernet on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:30AM (#32993200)
Not a dumb question at all (despite the apparent down-votes). NASA have developed advanced techniques for doing this, and annealing sintered parts is actually a fairly common procedure as far as I can tell.
Re:How to 3D-print one of the strongest stainless steels by convolvatron on Monday September 26, 2022 @04:25PM (#32987884)
thats insane. its animated crystallography.