News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by SleepilyLimping on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:37PM (#32903597)
I like how there's a degree of "too old to cancel" and R. Crumb is in there. I don't think people who bring up how messed up a dude he is can get much social currency from cancelling him, so he just kinda persists.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by michaelwww on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:05PM (#32903944)
To be cancelled you have to first be part of acceptable society and want to remain there, which Crumb never was and never wanted to be. He's a creep who likes to make interesting cartoons, even if they are filled with misogyny and bitterness. He comes from a creepy family, which the film "Crumb" makes clear with Crumb's blessing. He's doing alright considering.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Lammy on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:44PM (#32906183)
> even if they are filled with misogyny

"This is not a fantasy. They dwell among us!" https://i.imgur.com/9tituT7.png

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by noduerme on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:39PM (#32906611)
But it's funny. And how is it misogynistic? Misogyny means "hatred of women". As far as I can tell, he loves them, in his own strange way. Objectifying someone's physical attributes can go two ways. It can come from a place of hate, but it can also come from a place of obsessive love.

I think people see their own worst selves when they look at Crumb. His only crime is being honest enough to draw the dirty jokes that go through his mind. But this isn't a commentary on women, let alone a statement of hate. He's observing himself, from a distance, and unafraid to write and draw what he sees, regardless of how people think it reflects on him. He's always displayed a total rejection of ego... and it's just ego and hypocrisy which drives his critics.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by function_seven on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:10PM (#32907217)
Agreed. That diagram was downright wholesome. Appreciation for a woman’s body that doesn’t conform to typical beauty norms is, like, the opposite of misogyny.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by hnbad on Thursday September 22, 2022 @03:47AM (#32935908)
I think this is the crux many people fail to understand: obsessive love is bad, too, if it is non-consensual. I think it's not entirely fair to describe Crumb's work as misogynist as it's intentionally so broadly obscene that singling out his portrayal of women feels incomplete and reductive.

Crumb is misogynist in that he clearly sees women as an "other" and objectifies them by obsessing about features he finds arousing and grotesquely stylizing those he dislikes. But unless you're specifically trying to write an academic paper on his portrayal of women, I don't think pointing out that his view on women is problematic is very insightful or helpful.

It's like pointing out the shoddy insulation of a house that's already completely engulfed in flames. Yes, the insulation is bad and maybe you can reclaim some of the rent from your landlord or sue the builders, but the entire house is burning down so who cares.

Crumb's work is a trash fire. The only question is what merit it has once you can get past the noxious fumes.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by noduerme on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:35AM (#32980451)
Obsessive love is bad if it leads to bad outcomes, but Crumb himself has been happily married for decades. It seems very judgmental to pile on criticism of the style of someone's obsession - when most of his own work is devoted to disentangling those obsessions. It's also unkind to pronounce his work a "trash fire". Surrounded by hypocrites who don't have the self-reflection, intellectual honesty, or skill to reveal their inner dichotomies and turmoil, who are we to criticize someone for trying to download their inner mess to the rest of us? Sure, he's an easy target, but it's obnoxiously priggish to deride the one guy who puts it in print while you and your neighbors have the same or worse obsessions that cannot be spoken or named.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by hnbad on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:02AM (#32982044)
I don't see a difference between me calling it a trash fire and you calling it his "inner mess". His work is intentionally jarring and offensive.

I think the more important aspect of my metaphor is that while these "noxious fumes" clearly create a barrier for his work, that doesn't mean there's nothing valuable within. It just means that it's harder to find out.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by badpun on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @04:31AM (#32909122)
> But it's funny. And how is it misogynistic? Misogyny means "hatred of women". As far as I can tell, he loves them, in his own strange way.

I think that was the point of the OP. Crumb is clearly fascinated and taken by women.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by jibe on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:42PM (#32906159)
Phoebe Gloeckner, the author of the graphic novel “The Diary of a Teenage Girl” (2002) and an associate professor at the University of Michigan, was accused of “curriculum-based trauma” by students in a comics course, in part because she showed them Crumb’s work

As a society, we need to come together and move past things like curriculum-based trauma. Not good for anyone.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Crumbbum on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @11:48AM (#32913382)
Broadly, I agree. I don't think removing a seminal artist like Crumb from a curriculum because some students are offended is at all good or appropriate.

However, when you read into the Gloeckner case it seems like the students weren't the only ones acting insufferable. The thing is if you're going to be teaching Crumb in an academic environment you have to be able to speak to the more challenging aspects of his work on an intellectual level. If even half of the allegations were true, Gloeckner wasn't justifying her curriculum academically, and she also wasn't behaving appropriately in and out of class for her position.

https://www.michigandaily.com/news/daily-investigation-finds...

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by rwnspace on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @07:38AM (#32910372)
Let's pray they didn't read Maus on that same course!
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by goto11 on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:52PM (#32903802)
I'm not sure how you could "cancel" someone like Crumb. He is self-employed making independent comic books.

But with his oeuvre it is unlikely Disney will hire him any time soon.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by footpath on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:16PM (#32905464)
Interestingly, Disney's new Chip 'n Dale movie actually features a cameo of Crumb's Mr. Natural character.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Crumbbum on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @11:49AM (#32913401)
I did an episode on that for my R. Crumb YouTube show, Canonically Crumb. https://youtu.be/6MI9L870sXU
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:46PM (#32905197)
Yeah, I am thinking I don't even know what "cancelling" means.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Gigachad on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:42PM (#32906170)
Usually means trying to disrupt someones employment or have them removed from being able to publish on the internet. These days it's powerful enough if a popular streamer is after you, they can have your domain name provider, email host, phone number provider, and infrastructure hosts shut you down which at that point you are gone.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:44PM (#32906635)
I still don't get it. Would Serge Gainsborough have disappeared if Twitter were around in his time or would he have just told Twitter to foutre le camp and kept releasing albums?
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by lovich on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:42PM (#32907415)
As the other posters are implying, if you would continue doing what you were doing regardless of the rest of society's acceptance of your behavior, you are relatively immune to being cancelled. It only really works on people who require everyone else around them to help facilitate their actions
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @08:05AM (#32910563)
That makes more sense. I guess if people are always true to who they are then they have nothing to worry about.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by goto11 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:24AM (#32908360)
Cancelling only works if you depend on gatekeepers to reach an audience. E.g. Kevin Spacey is only cancelled insofar as he will not be hired for any major studio production - but he can still make his own independent movies for his own money.

Gatekeepers will only cancel an artist if they are more dependent on public opinion (i.e. advertising money and partnership) than on the income generated by the artist.

It is difficult to cancel an independent comic book artist because he is not depending on gatekeepers who are sensitive to public opinion.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by SleepilyLimping on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @04:57PM (#32931415)
It depends; the gatekeepers aren't just cultural. If someone gets you thrown off platforms and payment processors that you need in order to establish your independence and run a business, you get cancelled that way.

Only the already-big can become immune to this. If you're no one, small, or medium, you suddenly lose all ability to escape a network of other "problematics", so it becomes your only audience and limits your growth.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by harry8 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @12:33AM (#32907687)
The question is a little different in my mind.

The question is would Serge's record company continue to release albums when placed under pressure. Would French TV continue to allow him to perform there? Would French radio continue to play his albums? Would he appear in French magazines and newspapers.

In those days when Serge was the enfant terrible the answer was clearly yes, they all would and they did. Today, I still strongly suspect they all would, at least in France. But what do I know of it?

How about the "next Serge" if such a phrase can have meaning. The person trying to get noticed with their work using youtube, soundcloud, myspace, their own domain etc. How would it play out if they released something as unsettling as "Lemon Incest" in duet with their under-aged daughter? [1].

Accusation is also a hell of a powerful thing. The prevailing zeitgeist of "believe the accuser" is understandable given historical context but seems to be equally capable of damage to the innocent. It seems someone would accuse something to supercharge the outrage machine and that accusation could even be true. And it sticks impacting that persons' access to something as basic as the financial system even when it seems pretty unlikely that it is true, eg Julian Assange. I guess some people still believe he's a rapist but the accusation has massively impacted his life and work even if it came from someone who literally wrote about the need to take revenge on former lovers. [2] Among a series of other pieces of information that seemed to strongly undermine her accusations. Being "likable" like Matt Lauer and Katie Couric seems to be more important in such things - which whatever one thinks of their relative merits as humans or even as "the accused" it just doesn't quite seem like justice according to law. [3]

So, I think we can only speculate about what would happen in France. As we can if the "next Serge" were born and raised in the USA.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon_Incest

[2] https://www.crikey.com.au/2010/12/13/rundle-assange-accuser-...

[3] https://nypost.com/2021/10/01/katie-couric-reveals-herself-a...

Full disclosure: I think I'd cross the road to avoid all of Gainsbourg, Assange, Lauer and Couric. I can't imagine liking any of them at all. The cancelling business bothers me. Law reform seems to me to be the correct place to address shortcomings in the rule of law. The endrun around it will be abused by the powerful against the less so. The importance of the rule of law is that the strongest might not always get their way. As corruption rages, the agents of the strongest aren't your friends the way they claim to be by standing against those who are the objects of the current edition of "the hate" be it 2 minutes or more.

Assange the person can make my skin crawl while I still acknowledge the ideas - he really was more right about the Afghanistan war than what I was reading in the NYT, WJS, WaPo, ToL, Guardian etc. And it really did greatly annoy a lot of people with power and/or money fueled vested interest in a quite different view of that war than the one he was publicizing - and we now know how it all turned out.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @08:18AM (#32910658)
I am a Gainsbourg fan. When he pushed the boundaries he was both clever and artistic about it. The rest of the people you mention have no artistic integrity? I don't care anything about them, really.

I don't know, I am on the fence about Woody Allen so I'm probably hypocritical. I grew up liking his stuff and so find it hard to despise him now. "Manhattan" might (now) be his most cringey film but it has one of the best closing lines of any film ("You gotta have a little faith in people.").

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by brudgers on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:46PM (#32905701)
My working definition:

Canceling is when a person with power experiences social consequences from their actions similar to the consequences a person without power is likely to experience from a similar action.

YMMV.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by noduerme on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:45PM (#32906642)
Canceling happens more often to people with no power, for all sorts of unjustified reasons, and often based on unfounded accusation leveled by people with more power than they have. You just don't read about it, so don't perceive it that way until someone makes up a totally false story about you or someone you know, and tries to get people to stop working with you. The problem with cancelling people had nothing to do with whether or not it's justified; it has to do with setting a pattern where anyone can ruin someone else's life by making up anything, and encouraging people to believe it without checking for themselves.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by SleepilyLimping on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @04:54PM (#32931387)
I think it's totally possible today, because if you take away peoples' access to payment processors (Paypal, Venmo, Stripe, Mastercard, Visa) and platforms to grow (Instagram, Patreon, Kickstarter, etc) you keep them from getting to a point of gaining legacy, tenure, etc. Crumb can survive as self-employed because he has a name and value that supercedes canceling attempts.

An artist or creator that doesn't have that already is just as vulnerable because they have no weight to throw around. Independence or being underground doesn't matter when you need the same infrastructure as everyone else to survive.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by dicknuckle on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:50PM (#32905740)
There's little value in cancelling Crumb, because he's not influencing modern media or the impressionable youth, and he's not influencing neo facists. The whole point of cancel culture seems to be hitting the biggest problematic targets and avoiding the whole "don't meet your heroes" dilemma before fans naturally come to that crossroads. It's also a practicing example of "sunlight sanitizes" low ideologies.

Or that's my opinion of it. Good or bad it's here to stay for at least a few more years.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by narrator on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:03PM (#32903922)
If you've ever read Crumb's comic books, he was fully cancelable in the 1970s. He has always existed outside the mainstream and thus has never relied on mainstream distribution or publicity. If anything, he's a little more acceptable to the mainstream now because hardcore pornography is more widespread and grudgingly accepted these days.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by prvc on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:24AM (#32908356)
The NYT, masthead of the mainstream, appears to already be in the process of co-opting him for it.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:54PM (#32905275)
> If anything, he's a little more acceptable to the mainstream now because hardcore pornography is more widespread and grudgingly accepted these days.

That seems like quite a stretch — and I would say built on a questionable premise.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by tomcam on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:42PM (#32906172)
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:40PM (#32906616)
To be sure, I am not questioning the "pornographic" aspect of some of Crumb's work.

Hard-core pornography is "accepted" by society today? Is that true?

Because hard-core pornography is accepted by society today, we now appreciate Robert Crumb more?

I'm not seeing it.

Robert Crumb was accepted (by some) back in the 60's, 70's, etc. long before the internet and PornHub.

Robert Crumb is rejected (by some) even today.

If he is more popular today than he was 5 decades ago it's because he is an elder statesman of sorts with a rich (storied) and wide body of work. He is an icon of an era and a movement both culturally and artistically. He is an amazing artist with an identifiable and unique style.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by exolymph on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:55PM (#32904608)
It's not about age. It's about whether you piss off the people paying your bills and/or gatekeepers who can restrict your ability to reach the people who pay your bills. I'll hazard a guess that Crumb fans aren't overly invested in ideological purity.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by majormajor on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:43PM (#32903696)
"Too old"? He's younger than Bill Cosby...

Maybe "cancelling" is a cheap word for a more complex set of phenomenon than you're treating it as.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by standyro on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:18PM (#32904880)
R. Crumb was authentic.

That said, I think “canceling” has more meaning behind it than you might think.

Bill Cosby was an inauthentic and visible symbol of the black middle class and “canceled” among media types because his messy real life persona clashed with his clean cut image. Age didn’t factor in. I think many also had an ax to grind.

These days, to be “canceled”, I think you have to be profoundly inauthentic and ultimately accept the blame when the Twitter mob comes. Plenty of media figures have woven their careers to even embrace the image of fighting the Twitter moral police.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by lancesells on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:22PM (#32906485)
And let's not forget Bill Cosby raped people. R. Crumb drew pictures.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by JKCalhoun on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:51PM (#32905250)
I like that.

Yeah, hard to imagine people like R. Crumb (or Ed "Big Daddy" Roth, others) worrying what the hell Twitter thought. Some artists (lets add Frank Zappa?) would probably have relished the publicity.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by sbf501 on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:26PM (#32904970)
> fighting the Twitter moral police.

There are no twitter moral police, there are just opinions you don't like.

Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by lmm on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:42PM (#32905670)
The regular police are also ultimately just people who might have different views from you.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by sbf501 on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:38PM (#32907029)
What is your point? Twitter isn't the government and doesn't carry a gun and doesn't get qualified immunity when they shoot people. But you knew that, right? Or are you one of those lovely people who thinks Twitter removing Qanon/Russian propaganda violates the first amendment?
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by lmm on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:57PM (#32907147)
The twitterati may not carry guns but they can certainly have a huge impact on people's lives and livelihoods, and while they don't explicitly have qualified immunity they often benefit from selective enforcement.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by chasd00 on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:07PM (#32904766)
"canceling" means getting kicked off of social media platforms and fired. if you're not on social media platforms and self-employed then you can't really be "cancelled" at all.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by bhk on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:21PM (#32905993)
It apparently can also include losing your email hosting, website hosting, domain name registration, payment processor, or book deal, and having your independent business spammed with negative reviews. But, yeah, if you don't use the internet and do not have income (and don't associate with anyone who does... because they might be targeted as well) you really can't be canceled at all.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Gigachad on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:45PM (#32906192)
There are several cases of people having their email and phone number through google and having them both shut down at the same time. Effectively locking them out of everything including personal banking and government services.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by klyrs on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:56PM (#32904625)
Turns out that "cancel culture" is just a marketing slogan.
Re:R. Crumb Means Some Offense by Test0129 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:48AM (#32908509)
It's not at all a marketing slogan. The woke people have a problem though. To cancel someone properly they have to possess a desire to stay in the social strata they are in. For example, a developer makes a Python joke and loses their job over it. Those developers had a desire to stay in their industry and thus canceling worked on them. "Cancel culture" is the term for the phenomenon of people actively looking for opportunities to cancel someone. I've seen it at two companies now where people seem to be deliberately offended at something no matter how mundane. This is the "culture" part of "cancel culture".

Crumb doesn't care what social strata he is in. There are plenty of people like him who don't care. These types of people are impossible to cancel because no matter what social mechanism you use to bully them it will not work. It is far easier to cancel someone who needs some social status to eat than it is to cancel someone who couldn't care how he eats.