Proof of stake and other “environmentally friendly” consensus algorithms allow a select few to control the network and benefit the most from it which I suspect is the real goal here. The “environmental impact” is just an excuse.
It’s true that a large percentage of Bitcoin is owned by a few people, but at least now the benefit to them is only financial gain. Once you start to allow rich people to validate the blockchain itself, then they can begin to censor and block transactions or wallets from any individuals they deem unworthy or a threat to the powers at be.
We’ve already seen this happen with pretty much every traditional payment provider over the last few years to some extent so it was only a matter of time before they decided to come for Bitcoin.
Their real goal is to cripple and control the Bitcoin network. If they really cared about the environment they would go after energy companies or defense contractors or the banking industry who all use orders of magnitude more energy than Bitcoin miners.
As a sidenote, the executive branch has become much too powerful. They were never supposed to legislate like this. Every president since George W Bush has used extreme executive power, and no one seems to care. We are supposed to have elected representatives to legislate, not a king.
I managed to get into a top forging position on a major DPoS blockchain in spite of both founders and the CEO of the project hating my guts. It's not fair to suggest that it's like institutions within the fiat monetary system. Imagine being promoted as a Google executive if CEO Sundar Pichai, Larry Page and Sergey Brin all hated you; that would never happen.
That said, I think it would be dangerous to have 1 PoS blockchain with no other alternatives. The presence of alternatives is what enables any meritocracy to exist.
These are the same. Well, at least Wall Street. Main Street banks may be positioned against (I have seen no evidence of this), but that’s just community banks at this point. The big boys are universal.
What you’re seeing is the environmental and anti-finance lobbies allying. The fact that crypto users see Wall Street as the enemy constrains its leaders, who can’t openly ally with traditional finance on policy without looking compromised.
On the other hand, at least some people in the crypto industry care more about the other proprieties: anonymous, unconfiscatable, censorship resistant, fixed issuance/supply, free of central bank/government control, etc.
If you are correct, what reason would Wall Street folks have to be against a ban on mining?
If anything all a ban would do is enhance their ability to take control of crypto and make more money since they will be able to simply buy up the network ownership with their virtually unlimited cash. At least with POW, it actually takes some effort to buy up mining hardware, find an energy source, run the software, keep up operations, keep hardware and software up to date, etc. Much simpler to just buy up a stake and do nothing.
With PoS consensus you put up a big pile of money and validate transactions.
With PoW consensus you put up a big pile of money, turn that money into ASICs, burn some electricity, and validate transactions.
PoW seems like PoS with extra steps to me....
The stake, however, is internal to the network. Even if you have a big pile of money, there is no guaranteed that the big stake holders are willing to sell you their coins.
I think the majority of the arguments about the advantages/ disadvantages of PoW and PoS stems from that difference
It's impossible to mine anonymously with any non-negligible hashrate due to power differences and required specialized hardware - all trivial to track.
Taking over PoS is much harder because there's no way for governments to print tokens. It's easy to stake anonymously. A closed stable state in which only non-censoring validators control the network is always possible to achieve.
With PoS, although governments can’t print tokens, it doesn’t really matter. The governments and central banks have unlimited money. They control the money supply. Even if some of the top stakers won’t want to sell, they would still be able to find enough sellers who are. We have already seen how a single tweet from someone like Elon Musk can cause thousands of people to buy or sell. Manipulating the market is easy and doesn’t require permission from the people with the largest stake.
All they would need to do is float a bill that they are planning on making Bitcoin illegal and then after it is on the front page of all the news sites, when everyone is rushing to exit, swoop in and buy up the supply. I think Wall Street has already done this to a large extent. Hence, this is why I believe they are likely the ones behind this push as opposed to the people who will be hurt as a result.
All of that said, I’m willing to keep an open mind and see what happens to Ethereum after its switch to PoS. If I had to guess, I suspect we will begin to see stories of blocked transactions and blocked wallets, etc.
so they pump eth price to infinity to get majority of stake? While in theory it could work, it would cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars. Compared to maybe $1B-$2B to take over PoW from nothing. Two orders of magnitude difference.
As nobody needs a blockchain with censorship everyone else would move to a fork without the governmental stake. A very foolish plan.
If a POW miner invested the resources to take over the network, breaking the network would certainly crash the price.
However, node operators get a bigger payout than delegating your stake or staking it yourself. Overtime, this percentage difference will allow the node operators to control the network 'without breaking it'.
Btc can be minimally exploited because it doesn't do anything. POS networks are by design highly adaptive networks, with smart contracts, oracles, virtual machines and any other wonder programmers can dream up. This allows a 'soft control' exploit rather than btc's 'hard control'.
In practice, us government would pass a regulation that forces miners to register and to censor sanctioned addresses. Once they realize that miners they control own majority of hashrate, they can add a requirement to ignore chains with sanctioned addresses (from others miners).
There's no defense against this, because unlike PoS, you can't really move anywhere else. China has its own ban. Energy prices in europe are insane. Russia is sanctioned and just getting chips in is almost certainly a crime.
Under PoS as long as there's any subset of non-censoring validators a fork away from censorship is possible. Unlike mining, staking is extremely mobile globally.
What is the equivalent mechanism in PoS?
What is the 'true' hamburger chain? What is the 'true' flavor of ice cream? If less people like bacon flavored ice cream or vanilla flavored hamburgers it doesn't make them not 'true' representation of the archetype, just unpopular ones.
How should someone determine the most "popular" chain in PoS based on the chain history alone? Is it the one with the most 'staked'?
The problem (which PoW doesn't have) is that alternative versions of valid PoS history can be generated at zero or close to zero cost.
Yes.
>The problem (which PoW doesn't have) is that alternative versions of valid PoS history can be generated at zero or close to zero cost.
This is simply a misunderstanding of how it works. In order for you to propose a version of the chain that has some other history you need network consensus. If you claim something that is not true you get slashed. Thats the whole point. You can go make an entirely disconnected chain if you'd like to do that but you'll be the only one on it unless you can convince someone else to join you in your personal universe where you are a trillionare.
This leaves a problem: how should new nodes joining the network know if the version of history they’ve been presented with is ‘honest’.
The answer for Ethereum PoS is ‘checkpoints‘, but it’s not an ‘objective‘ measure, unlike ‘chain with most work’ in PoW.
Even Vitalik admits this, it is why he invented the term ‘weak subjectivity’, he is totally explicit that this is a fundamental weakness of PoS: the valid chain is subjective.
The only question that remains is whether the economic incentives that have been designed are good enough to work around this weakness and guarantee whatever properties Ethereum network users have decided is important.
It seems more realistic that the manufacturers of the most efficient mining hardware would refuse to sell it and instead use it themselves or sell to allies since that has you know, happened.
Which is why it should be banned.
Functionally, this isn't possible. If the open method is banned, people will start using layers of indirection.
It's fundamentally a problem with democracy.
Yes, powerful people flout them (Sarkozy) or find ways to pass off contributions as gifts (Fillon's suits) or use the support of media oligarchs without a direct monetary contribution (Macron, Zemmour) but overall, the end result is that there's a lot less money in politics, and politicians aren't completely dependent on the funding of industry lobbies for their election.
Same thing with political advertising. I'm seeing scandal after scandal about Facebook censoring or not censoring this or that political ad, and I'm just thinking "I'm so glad this is the kind of bullshit we don't need to deal with".
But if nothing else, we can assume that there's less money in politics because campaigns are less expensive.
Macron's last campaign cost 16 millions euros. Biden's last campaign cost 1.06 billion dollars. That money has to come from somewhere.
In theory, Macron's campaign could have hidden costs not reported in accounting (which is what Sarkozy did) but in practice it's hard to hide that (hence Sarkozy getting caught). Big campaign meetings in expensive stadiums are, by design, hard to hide.
Also, since you can't spend money getting your candidate on TV ads, there's not a huge incentive to blow up your campaign budget. Regulators also ensure that TV outlets spend an equal amount of time on each candidate. (Though there are also ways to game that, eg CNews got fined for putting Zemmour on prime time and every other candidate in night slots).
So while power games still exist (the key to becoming French president is basically being friends with Xavier Niel), we can assume there's less money overall because parties have fewer things to spend money on.
I don't think this is self-evident even for money, if the money is simply being spent in ways that can't be tallied.
It's even less assured for all undue influence, including insider networks of non-financial favor-trading – as you note in your (fairly cynical!) observation that "the key to becoming French president is basically being friends with Xavier Niel".
Is that really tangibly better than overt, measurable money influence from many competing sources?
It's possible the low (above-board) spending totals are really a negative indicator: evidence that a de-facto cartel has enough levers to repel challenges without explicit cash outlays. When spending on wages seems suspiciously low, as with American college athletes or French IT workers, it's not a sure sign evil money has been kept out of a lily-pure process, but rather that insufficient competition has kept all the real money/power with secure incumbents.
I am not an expert on French politics, but from the outside it seems just as protetive of traditional elite/insider interests as politics elsewhere. Maybe more so!
> Is that really tangibly better than overt, measurable money influence from many competing sources?
You're implying that any overt influence from political donations is fungibly replaced by an equivalent amount of hidden undue influence. That's not at all obvious.
It's not like hidden influence doesn't exist in a system with political donations. Having the support of media corporations is important in France, but it's important in the US too.
And to bring it back to the original subject, if crypto regulations were proposed in France, we wouldn't be worried that the MPs had been pre-bribed by crypto exchanges before the vote even began.
Maybe. It'll make it less effective. But it'll also make it more difficult to detect.
Making something illegal rarely prevents it completely, but very often reduces it.
Why does anyone believe this?
> Why does anyone believe this?
Good laws are great. And there are plenty of them.
But passing bad laws just because "we need to do something" is worse than doing nothing.
Under a majoritarian system, even if >50% claim to want a law in polls or ballots, but far-more-than-50% of the same people (or even just: the relevant targets of the law) can flout it without consequences, that's typically a bad law.
Some people seem to think that people are like computers and “law” is the programming. No, people will continue to mine Bitcoin, or do drugs, or whatever other illegal thing up until the point where the FBI breaks down a door and some people get shot or (best case) thrown behind bars. My opinion is that laws are nothing other than a form of violence. If you support violence against people for running a computer program I don’t know what to say.
Noo it's spreading!!
He could just tweet how easy it is to lobby for electric vehicles and how he will spend a fraction of his money maybe a couple billions on lobbying. Maybe name a specific senate he may or may not donate to. He could specify donald trump or a certain republican senate for maximum impact.
There's no need to spend anything.
There will be a push to ban political donation immediately.
Banning PoW would benefit Bitcoin; it's the main thing preventing it from becoming more popular right now. Having the government force the Bitcoin community to do what they've been unable to do themselves would be the best of all worlds for them.
The US is the second largest polluter.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_greenhous...
But fact is, greenhouse gases have the potential to end humanity, and the US is not addressing them enough.
I mean, that would mean exponentially more expensive food…
https://news.un.org/en/story/2021/03/1086822
My take is we need to allow unlimited emissions of carbon dioxide and nitrogen (reduction in other stuff though actually toxic). It increases food growth (plants love carbon) and arable land and decreases poverty. Plus cheaper energy means improved quality of life and technological advancement.
We have centuries of known fuel sources and can move to nuclear any time we wish.
A carbon tax effectively increases human suffering for the hope of reduced temperatures. In reality, the cost is passed to consumers and there’s no indication it will reduce global temperatures.
All taxes collected are redistributed back to citizens.
Best of both words - progressive taxation and incentive to develop anti-carbon tevh.
This has been enacted in Canada. If you care about the environment this isn't the way to go.
Your take is so misinformed that we all have to wonder how you could have twisted yourself into such a position
CO2 is the primary driver of climate change and will do far more harm to these plants/crops that 'love' excess CO2 than you seem to understand.
Having worked on climate models and read many papers I have become skeptical we know the manner or degree humans have an effect.
Those with a statistics background should look at the data honestly. We have relatively poor data (very sparse, unknown error rate, high variance, measurements taken with different mechanisms, etc) that can’t be validated. With correlations abounding in every which way. We also have a precision problem when we look at global temperatures in the past, we simply don’t know when we are taking a 1-5% change in temp.
You cannot prove carbon does absolutely anything. We have a correlation not causation. It could be natural carbon increases with temperatures. It could be our measurement mechanism is just wrong. It could be plant growth will expand to meet a new homeostasis with the carbon (imo highly likely). From the same measurements we use to show the Earth is warming we can show carbon levels have been higher previously on Earth.
> CO2 is the primary driver of climate change and will do far more harm to these plants/crops that 'love' excess CO2 than you seem to understand.
North America was covered in a sheet of ice until a few thousand years ago. The largest desert in Africa was a full of life during the same time period. Both disappeared before the industrial revolution and we have been seeing carbon increase exponentially ever since; as visible in the linked website
https://skepticalscience.com/co2-lags-temperature.htm
Now once we cover that, the question is what too do? We know cheap energy directly correlates with quality of life. Easy thought exercise - is your life easier walking or driving a car? Is it easier with a wood burning stove or a gas oven?
The argument we should reduce something that we know improves life and remove it requires a high level of proof. The threshold hasn’t been met. Even if it had, is China going to cut emissions? Do you really think wealthy will? No. They won’t. China will expand and continue to produce more overtaking the US in every category - they’ll use the cheap energy we aren’t using. The US will be destitute due to us cutting all energy production. Now what? Is the world better off? Germany is doing that right now, let’s check back in a couple years and see how that goes…
My point is that (1) we don’t have solid enough evidence to reduce the quality of life in our civilization and (2) even if we had said evidence, we couldn’t meaningfully make an impact- tax or no tax. So you’ll have all the downside, with no gain.
This is probably where you get your information on CO2: https://twitter.com/CkDexter15/status/1569530162873516034
Since Bitcoin relies on PoW, banning PoW effectively bans mining Bitcoin. On the surface, why that would make Bitcoin more popular is nonsensical, but I see two interpretations, and I’m guessing you mean the second one:
1) Banning PoW mining in the US, like they did in China, severely limits industrial-scale Bitcoin mining in another big part of the world, lowering the total mining incentive, and moving mining out to places where people don’t object to it and where electricity is cheap and in excess: this somewhat lowers the total hash rate, conflicts less with our growing energy demand in populated areas, but more significantly makes the environmental cost more abstract to people and thus easier to swallow. It’s a lot more upsetting to see a power plant down the river mining Bitcoin than knowing they come from somewhere called “the cloud”.
2) Banning PoW mining in the US could somehow incentivise towards a PoS transition, like with Ethereum. I don’t see that happening for Bitcoin. Sorry.
It won't happen for bitcoin. PoW is such a fundamentally intrinsic part of what bitcoin is, that a transition to PoS will never happen, nor would it be desirable for most bitcoin holders who actively believe PoW to be the intrinsically interesting invention, and PoS to simply be a slight iteration of the old system. PoW was never a fundamental part of what ethereum was, because ethereum is fundamentally just whatever Vitalik and team and their early investors want it to be.
Ethereum, or any other PoS token, isn't a real alternative to bitcoin. It's something else that covers different use cases, and I'm still not sure what those use cases are.
In order for Bitcoin to remain secure, the $$$ amount spent on electricity to mine Bitcoin has to be commensurate with the value of Bitcoin purchased on the markets. Because there is only so much electricity in the world that can be allocated to mining, this places an upper bound on the price that Bitcoin can reach in the markets.
You have a lot to learn then because your analogy is weak. PoW vs PoS debate is one of decentralization, power, democratization and control.
As for bitcoin being dated: it’s ossification is intentional. It is, by design, a predictable and reliable monetary system.
Some dude though about some basic concept of decentralization and that's it.
This was not some mastermind who created the perfect money system.
There are massive amounts of issues with Bitcoin in particular.
Alone one reason why Ethereum was trying to be ASIC resistent was to make GPUs stronger and allowing for more / better decentralization.
Plenty of people who are no longer able to recover their wallets (I know two friends having lost 150k$\initial investment of 10k$).
Fraud issues like you see in El Salvador.
The huge changes in value (no Bitcoin is apparently not stable and independent from the economic market).
And it doesn't even solve the trust issue. As soon as you wanna spend Bitcoin you need other systems like smart contract (which also doesn't solve the problem) or trusting third party.
The only advantage of Bitcoin is that's unregulated and everyone is taking a bit of it who is fast enough, rich enough or smart enough from everyone else who is not.
Now that's funny!
In 2028, how many new US dollars will enter circulation? How many bitcoin?
It already happened. 10 years ago a pizza was worth how much? And how many bitcoins do you need now for one pizza?
I do suspect it will trend toward stability on a decades timeline.
Also Bitcoin will 100% not remove proof of work ever. The overwhelming majority of node operators would not agree to that, ever. It goes against the ethos of Bitcoin. Proof of work is part of the social contract, right up there with 21 million hard cap and users running their own nodes.
It would be interesting to see some real numbers on that claim. For me, much bigger would be volatile value, lack of places to spend it, weekly stories about people losing life savings because off coding errors and whatnot and just generally that it seems to be an interesting solution to a problem I don't have.
PoW is in there somewhere, but nowhere near the top.
But it's irrelevant, the community is already stuck in this place.
All hail the great Satoshi. Thou shalt not change but one #define.
Well, he seems to be shitposting or knowingly lying, then. It says he has a $30 billion fortune currently, yet still drives a Corolla and uses his parent's Netflix account, so he apparently wasn't super rich to begin with. So unless he thinks he's going to become the world's first multi-trillionaire, there is no $100 mil to $1 bil investment that can return what he got out of starting his current business, which wasn't a political donation.
Or he means something non-financial by "highest form," as in he might actually care about the Democratic agenda apart from whether it can make him even richer or not.
Numerous startups turned $1 mil into $1 bil. But nobody yet turned $1 bil into $1 trillion. Scale matters. When you deal in billions, your expected returns are much lower.
After all we all are loosing the climate change game thanks to Bitcoin and co.
We all pay the price. High electric bills due to more AC usage, more demand on electricity through Bitcoin mining and higher GPU prices.
What are the associated fees and process times with sending 100 dollars with bitcoin including the purchasing and selling in order to complete the transaction of currency?
What countries does this end up being useful for?
And no I don't want to argue about pro and cons of air travel because it doesn't change the current discussion it only deflects.
This doesn't mean I'm pro air travel btw. Another weird outcome. What would you have won if I said 'yes also let's ban airtravel'?
Gotta win this climate fight.
Thanks in part to Bitcoin and co. There's a mess of other really major contributors as well, and most all of 'em are filthy rich and/or giant corporate entities.
He's donated to climate-change charities & declared FTX to be carbon-neutral.
He might even see an angle for profit in helping suppress proof-of-work!
My understanding of crypto culture is hazy, like most, but from what I've picked up: to some degree, there's Bitcoin, and there's everything else (well, there's that mistake of lumping everyone together again, but at least its more specific). Bitcoin has a weird traditionalist culture surrounding it; I once heard it described as "Bitcoiners would rather spend millions harvesting energy from a volcano than just reduce their energy needs." There's less culture of open collaboration and integration; less interest in useful utility; Bitcoin maximalists still cling on to the Digital Gold metaphor, whereas ETH maximalists have more utilitarian aspirations toward the currency/network acting like the Visa or Mastercard of a global computer, stacks of applications built-on-top-of one another, and ETH rises with the tide.
I sometimes wonder if the difference in culture has anything to do with Bitcoin's lack of a BDFL. ETH has Vitalik; very public guy, well spoken, has that fantastically nerdy & idealistic aesthetic reminiscent of early Page, Brin, Gates, and Zuck. Bitcoin has no one; and maybe that's allowed its community's more baser human instincts to manifest. Distrust, fear, greed, etc. Whereas BTC maximalists will argue that there's no perfect decentralized trust POS system, and thus POW is fundamentally necessary, Vitalik has publicly said that POS isn't perfect, but good enough.
I suggest you learn some humility from history.
This is peanuts for a hated industry. Facebook squirrels away far more to no benefit.
One of them (Tone Vays) even participated in the Stop the Steal marches and Jan 6 riots.
I guess that is getting close to what Balaji Srivanisan calls the network state. Different virtual states with different ideologies.
Wow. Put all the cyberpunk stuff immediately into nonfiction.
Crypto firms are among the top Democrat donors. Crypto CEO SBF plans on donating $100mil - $1bil in the 2024 election, and calls political donation the highest form of return of investment that exists:
> He was also one of just a handful of donors who spent $10 million-plus backing President Joe Biden in 2020, and in the last year, he’s hired a network of political operatives and spent tens of millions more shaping Democratic House primaries. It was a shocking wave of spending that looked like it could remake the Democratic Party bench in Washington, candidate by candidate. Looking ahead to the 2024 election, he has said he could spend anywhere from $100 million to $1 billion.
https://www.politico.com/news/2022/08/04/democratic-megadono...