News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by PontifexMinimus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:13AM (#32789943)
> political donation the highest form of return of investment that exists

Which is why it should be banned.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by nordsieck on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:34AM (#32790062)
> Which is why it should be banned.

Functionally, this isn't possible. If the open method is banned, people will start using layers of indirection.

It's fundamentally a problem with democracy.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by PoignardAzur on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:22AM (#32790920)
Speaking as someone living in France, where campaign budget limitations are a pretty big deal (to the point a former president is facing jail time for breaking them), I don't see how this is impossible.

Yes, powerful people flout them (Sarkozy) or find ways to pass off contributions as gifts (Fillon's suits) or use the support of media oligarchs without a direct monetary contribution (Macron, Zemmour) but overall, the end result is that there's a lot less money in politics, and politicians aren't completely dependent on the funding of industry lobbies for their election.

Same thing with political advertising. I'm seeing scandal after scandal about Facebook censoring or not censoring this or that political ad, and I'm just thinking "I'm so glad this is the kind of bullshit we don't need to deal with".

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by gojomo on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:07AM (#32791291)
How do you know there's less money in politics if it's gone dark in harder-to-measure ways?
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by PoignardAzur on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:30PM (#32795422)
Well I don't know for sure. It's not like private interests have disappeared, and I'm not privy to how they manifest.

But if nothing else, we can assume that there's less money in politics because campaigns are less expensive.

Macron's last campaign cost 16 millions euros. Biden's last campaign cost 1.06 billion dollars. That money has to come from somewhere.

In theory, Macron's campaign could have hidden costs not reported in accounting (which is what Sarkozy did) but in practice it's hard to hide that (hence Sarkozy getting caught). Big campaign meetings in expensive stadiums are, by design, hard to hide.

Also, since you can't spend money getting your candidate on TV ads, there's not a huge incentive to blow up your campaign budget. Regulators also ensure that TV outlets spend an equal amount of time on each candidate. (Though there are also ways to game that, eg CNews got fined for putting Zemmour on prime time and every other candidate in night slots).

So while power games still exist (the key to becoming French president is basically being friends with Xavier Niel), we can assume there's less money overall because parties have fewer things to spend money on.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by gojomo on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:55PM (#32795893)
> But if nothing else, we can assume that there's less money in politics because campaigns are less expensive.

I don't think this is self-evident even for money, if the money is simply being spent in ways that can't be tallied.

It's even less assured for all undue influence, including insider networks of non-financial favor-trading – as you note in your (fairly cynical!) observation that "the key to becoming French president is basically being friends with Xavier Niel".

Is that really tangibly better than overt, measurable money influence from many competing sources?

It's possible the low (above-board) spending totals are really a negative indicator: evidence that a de-facto cartel has enough levers to repel challenges without explicit cash outlays. When spending on wages seems suspiciously low, as with American college athletes or French IT workers, it's not a sure sign evil money has been kept out of a lily-pure process, but rather that insufficient competition has kept all the real money/power with secure incumbents.

I am not an expert on French politics, but from the outside it seems just as protetive of traditional elite/insider interests as politics elsewhere. Maybe more so!

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by PoignardAzur on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:59AM (#32798893)
Well we can ask the reverse question. Would most French people expect politics to be healthier, less elitist and less insider-obsessed if politicans were allowed to spend infinite money on campaigns, if politicals ads were allowed, etc? I certainly wouldn't expect that.

> Is that really tangibly better than overt, measurable money influence from many competing sources?

You're implying that any overt influence from political donations is fungibly replaced by an equivalent amount of hidden undue influence. That's not at all obvious.

It's not like hidden influence doesn't exist in a system with political donations. Having the support of media corporations is important in France, but it's important in the US too.

And to bring it back to the original subject, if crypto regulations were proposed in France, we wouldn't be worried that the MPs had been pre-bribed by crypto exchanges before the vote even began.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by cesarb on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:55AM (#32790183)
As they say, "perfect is the enemy of good". Adding layers of indirection makes it less efficient, which lessens its impact.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by nordsieck on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:07AM (#32790259)
> Adding layers of indirection makes it less efficient, which lessens its impact.

Maybe. It'll make it less effective. But it'll also make it more difficult to detect.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by hagy on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:45AM (#32790119)
Yep, if direct political donations are banned or highly limited, then SBF (and Thiel) will just fund a bunch of media startups that promote their preferred policies and candidates. These firms can appear to be profit seeking ventures while staffed with ideologues who are incentivized to optimize reach and influence.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by TomSwirly on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:13AM (#32790310)
You: "Nothing we can ever do will ever change anything. Best to give up before we start."
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by hagy on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:32AM (#32790457)
There's plenty we can do to improve things and therefore fighting a losing war against money in politics is a distraction that simply wastes our limited time and effort.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by PontifexMinimus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:28PM (#32792673)
You might equally argue that murder should be legal, as banning it won't stop it happening.

Making something illegal rarely prevents it completely, but very often reduces it.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by cwalv on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:53PM (#32795209)
It very often reduces it, and also often has unintended consequences (e.g. prohibition era in the US). In the context of the parent's point, that when "the open method is banned, people will start using layers of indirection", it's not hard to think of some unintended consequences that could end up worse than the original problem.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by TomSwirly on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:13AM (#32790303)
"There's no point in passing laws, because people will get around them."

Why does anyone believe this?

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by nordsieck on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:18AM (#32790349)
> "There's no point in passing laws, because people will get around them."

> Why does anyone believe this?

Good laws are great. And there are plenty of them.

But passing bad laws just because "we need to do something" is worse than doing nothing.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by gojomo on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:16AM (#32791382)
When you pass laws that can't practically be enforced, or that everyone figures the insiders/incumbents have already tilted in their favor with de jure or de facto immunities – such that they're only ever used unevenly against disfavored upstarts/outsiders – it erodes confidence in laws & law-enforcement more generally.

Under a majoritarian system, even if >50% claim to want a law in polls or ballots, but far-more-than-50% of the same people (or even just: the relevant targets of the law) can flout it without consequences, that's typically a bad law.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by oceanplexian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:52AM (#32790639)
Because ultimately a “law” is nothing other than words on paper that only exist in reality because the government is willing to use force to make it so.

Some people seem to think that people are like computers and “law” is the programming. No, people will continue to mine Bitcoin, or do drugs, or whatever other illegal thing up until the point where the FBI breaks down a door and some people get shot or (best case) thrown behind bars. My opinion is that laws are nothing other than a form of violence. If you support violence against people for running a computer program I don’t know what to say.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by pixl97 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:55AM (#32791177)
Law is like computer code, adding more of it to your application doesn't necessarily make it better.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by derac on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:33AM (#32791541)
What if the computer program hurts people / violates their rights?
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by blooalien on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:19AM (#32790351)
Mostly despair from seeing it happen far more often than it really should due to rampant corrupting "in high places" I'd imagine…
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by intelVISA on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:16AM (#32790325)
> If the open method is banned, people will start using layers of indirection.

Noo it's spreading!!

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by trappist on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:23AM (#32791453)
Of all the possible reasons, the ROI is why it should be banned?
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ergocoder on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:24AM (#32791465)
Elon Musk can solve this.

He could just tweet how easy it is to lobby for electric vehicles and how he will spend a fraction of his money maybe a couple billions on lobbying. Maybe name a specific senate he may or may not donate to. He could specify donald trump or a certain republican senate for maximum impact.

There's no need to spend anything.

There will be a push to ban political donation immediately.