News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by Alex3917 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:44AM (#32789766)
> The Bitcoin lobby is already to strong in the US.

Banning PoW would benefit Bitcoin; it's the main thing preventing it from becoming more popular right now. Having the government force the Bitcoin community to do what they've been unable to do themselves would be the best of all worlds for them.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by danuker on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:49AM (#32789792)
Even better would be to tax all industries fairly, according to their greenhouse gas emissions. Or even energy production directly.

The US is the second largest polluter.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_greenhous...

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by kitten_mittens_ on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:09AM (#32789923)
The third per capita by your link.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by mkl on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:10AM (#32790285)
Only in the graph, which shows a subset of countries. In the main list it's 11th by the 2018 column.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by danuker on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:49AM (#32791125)
If you look at area (pollution per capita x population), it's the second.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by hx833001 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:32AM (#32790047)
Carbon dioxide is not pollution.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by blooalien on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:44AM (#32790572)
It is, and isn't. Climate is a complex system, and CO² interacts with that system in a myriad of interesting ways. One of those ways is contributing to the whole "climate change" issue that so many climate scientists are concerned about, and that's a big honkin' part of what's causing the increased extreme weather issues, droughts, floods, etc, and directly contributing to wildfire dangers, among other fun stuff it's a big part of… On the other hand, if not for the drought issue affecting plant life in really negative ways, CO² is a thing plants happen to like, so there can be some benefits (to plants … in places not prone to drought). Still, in this particular case, the benefits do not appear to outweigh the dangers of continuing with "business as usual" as humans are so fond of doing.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by hx833001 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:42AM (#32850931)
Carbon dioxide is the source of all life on Earth.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by eric_cc on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:14AM (#32790316)
Yes! Give more money to the government! Letting the government steal more money to spend on their agenda is always a fantastic idea!
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by blooalien on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:26AM (#32790402)
My problem with exactly that is that governments in general seem to be keen to spend money quite freely on making, participating in, and/or funding various wars and other military spending, yet are loathe to spend more than they absolutely must on things like education, infrastructure, and other things which most directly benefit their own people. It's the people's money they're spending, so logically they should be spending it most freely "at home" to it's own citizens' direct benefit instead of abroad. Not to say that we shouldn't support our allies in times of need, but … priorities?
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ahtihn on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:26AM (#32790953)
The federal government's budget is completely unrelated to tax income. If the government wants to spend more money, it doesn't need to raise taxes it can just increase the deficit. More taxes just means less deficit.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by sdenton4 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:06AM (#32791288)
Or just print more money...
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by danuker on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:52AM (#32791152)
You could cut other taxes. Or you could remove the received funds from existence (such as by paying down government debt).

But fact is, greenhouse gases have the potential to end humanity, and the US is not addressing them enough.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by eli on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:28AM (#32790020)
What if you tax them based on the ratio of greenhouse gas to utility of the product? So still ban bitcoin in other words, but let people hear their homes.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by lettergram on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:15AM (#32789957)
> Even better would be to tax all industries fairly, according to their greenhouse gas emissions.

I mean, that would mean exponentially more expensive food…

https://news.un.org/en/story/2021/03/1086822

My take is we need to allow unlimited emissions of carbon dioxide and nitrogen (reduction in other stuff though actually toxic). It increases food growth (plants love carbon) and arable land and decreases poverty. Plus cheaper energy means improved quality of life and technological advancement.

We have centuries of known fuel sources and can move to nuclear any time we wish.

A carbon tax effectively increases human suffering for the hope of reduced temperatures. In reality, the cost is passed to consumers and there’s no indication it will reduce global temperatures.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by blooalien on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:35AM (#32790481)
There will be no "reduced temperatures" for rather a long while, even if we stop all excess human-induced carbon emissions this very instant. We've made quite a mess of things on that front, and despite the planet's resiliency, it's gonna take it a bit to re-adjust itself back to what we've been used to up to this point.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by tomp on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:51AM (#32790153)
Not if the tax is revenue neutral.

All taxes collected are redistributed back to citizens.

Best of both words - progressive taxation and incentive to develop anti-carbon tevh.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ipaddr on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:35AM (#32790488)
Money goes into pot. Large player lobby to not be included. Government programs take from pot for programs. Pot get's redistributed based on political groups offering votes remaining goes back to the tax payers. Average citizen pays a dollar more per/gallon and is worse off. Environment no effect.

This has been enacted in Canada. If you care about the environment this isn't the way to go.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by freshpots on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:49AM (#32790145)
"My take is we need to allow unlimited emissions of carbon dioxide and nitrogen (reduction in other stuff though actually toxic). It increases food growth (plants love carbon) and arable land and decreases poverty."

Your take is so misinformed that we all have to wonder how you could have twisted yourself into such a position

CO2 is the primary driver of climate change and will do far more harm to these plants/crops that 'love' excess CO2 than you seem to understand.

https://skepticalscience.com/co2-plant-food.htm

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by lettergram on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:09AM (#32791319)
> Your take is so misinformed that we all have to wonder how you could have twisted yourself into such a position

Having worked on climate models and read many papers I have become skeptical we know the manner or degree humans have an effect.

Those with a statistics background should look at the data honestly. We have relatively poor data (very sparse, unknown error rate, high variance, measurements taken with different mechanisms, etc) that can’t be validated. With correlations abounding in every which way. We also have a precision problem when we look at global temperatures in the past, we simply don’t know when we are taking a 1-5% change in temp.

You cannot prove carbon does absolutely anything. We have a correlation not causation. It could be natural carbon increases with temperatures. It could be our measurement mechanism is just wrong. It could be plant growth will expand to meet a new homeostasis with the carbon (imo highly likely). From the same measurements we use to show the Earth is warming we can show carbon levels have been higher previously on Earth.

> CO2 is the primary driver of climate change and will do far more harm to these plants/crops that 'love' excess CO2 than you seem to understand.

North America was covered in a sheet of ice until a few thousand years ago. The largest desert in Africa was a full of life during the same time period. Both disappeared before the industrial revolution and we have been seeing carbon increase exponentially ever since; as visible in the linked website

https://skepticalscience.com/co2-lags-temperature.htm

Now once we cover that, the question is what too do? We know cheap energy directly correlates with quality of life. Easy thought exercise - is your life easier walking or driving a car? Is it easier with a wood burning stove or a gas oven?

The argument we should reduce something that we know improves life and remove it requires a high level of proof. The threshold hasn’t been met. Even if it had, is China going to cut emissions? Do you really think wealthy will? No. They won’t. China will expand and continue to produce more overtaking the US in every category - they’ll use the cheap energy we aren’t using. The US will be destitute due to us cutting all energy production. Now what? Is the world better off? Germany is doing that right now, let’s check back in a couple years and see how that goes…

My point is that (1) we don’t have solid enough evidence to reduce the quality of life in our civilization and (2) even if we had said evidence, we couldn’t meaningfully make an impact- tax or no tax. So you’ll have all the downside, with no gain.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by freshpots on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:33PM (#32827549)
You should have a Nobel prize or at least be on the IPCC because you seem to know more than everyone else involved in the field. There's no point in arguing with someone who is as arrogant as you.

This is probably where you get your information on CO2: https://twitter.com/CkDexter15/status/1569530162873516034

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by peyton on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:20AM (#32791411)
The upside is captured by dishonest actors consolidating power using lies that make people feel good. Obviously policies pursued locally won’t change outcomes.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by cwalv on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:11PM (#32795316)
I'm looking forward to reading thoughtful and direct answers to some of your points. This deserves more than just downvotes, calls to just shut up and "accept consensus", or pitchforks.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by sshine on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:15AM (#32789954)
> Banning PoW would benefit Bitcoin

Since Bitcoin relies on PoW, banning PoW effectively bans mining Bitcoin. On the surface, why that would make Bitcoin more popular is nonsensical, but I see two interpretations, and I’m guessing you mean the second one:

1) Banning PoW mining in the US, like they did in China, severely limits industrial-scale Bitcoin mining in another big part of the world, lowering the total mining incentive, and moving mining out to places where people don’t object to it and where electricity is cheap and in excess: this somewhat lowers the total hash rate, conflicts less with our growing energy demand in populated areas, but more significantly makes the environmental cost more abstract to people and thus easier to swallow. It’s a lot more upsetting to see a power plant down the river mining Bitcoin than knowing they come from somewhere called “the cloud”.

2) Banning PoW mining in the US could somehow incentivise towards a PoS transition, like with Ethereum. I don’t see that happening for Bitcoin. Sorry.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by anonporridge on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:47AM (#32791677)
> Banning PoW mining in the US could somehow incentivise towards a PoS transition, like with Ethereum. I don’t see that happening for Bitcoin. Sorry.

It won't happen for bitcoin. PoW is such a fundamentally intrinsic part of what bitcoin is, that a transition to PoS will never happen, nor would it be desirable for most bitcoin holders who actively believe PoW to be the intrinsically interesting invention, and PoS to simply be a slight iteration of the old system. PoW was never a fundamental part of what ethereum was, because ethereum is fundamentally just whatever Vitalik and team and their early investors want it to be.

Ethereum, or any other PoS token, isn't a real alternative to bitcoin. It's something else that covers different use cases, and I'm still not sure what those use cases are.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by Alex3917 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:26AM (#32790405)
> I see two interpretations, and I’m guessing you mean the second one

In order for Bitcoin to remain secure, the $$$ amount spent on electricity to mine Bitcoin has to be commensurate with the value of Bitcoin purchased on the markets. Because there is only so much electricity in the world that can be allocated to mining, this places an upper bound on the price that Bitcoin can reach in the markets.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ricardobayes on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:53AM (#32790164)
IMO Moving from Bitcoin to e.g. Ethereum is akin to banning ICE engines and moving to EVs
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by eric_cc on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:10AM (#32790283)
> IMO Moving from Bitcoin to e.g. Ethereum is akin to banning ICE engines and moving to EVs

You have a lot to learn then because your analogy is weak. PoW vs PoS debate is one of decentralization, power, democratization and control.

As for bitcoin being dated: it’s ossification is intentional. It is, by design, a predictable and reliable monetary system.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by MeltingAaah on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:17PM (#32791951)
It's just not.

Some dude though about some basic concept of decentralization and that's it.

This was not some mastermind who created the perfect money system.

There are massive amounts of issues with Bitcoin in particular.

Alone one reason why Ethereum was trying to be ASIC resistent was to make GPUs stronger and allowing for more / better decentralization.

Plenty of people who are no longer able to recover their wallets (I know two friends having lost 150k$\initial investment of 10k$).

Fraud issues like you see in El Salvador.

The huge changes in value (no Bitcoin is apparently not stable and independent from the economic market).

And it doesn't even solve the trust issue. As soon as you wanna spend Bitcoin you need other systems like smart contract (which also doesn't solve the problem) or trusting third party.

The only advantage of Bitcoin is that's unregulated and everyone is taking a bit of it who is fast enough, rich enough or smart enough from everyone else who is not.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by couchand on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:18AM (#32790342)
> a predictable and reliable monetary system.

Now that's funny!

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by eric_cc on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:29AM (#32790985)
What is unpredictable or unreliable about the monetary policy of bitcoin?

In 2028, how many new US dollars will enter circulation? How many bitcoin?

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by MeltingAaah on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:19PM (#32791970)
It doesn't matter as Bitcoin will just create more 'value' through existing bitcoins getting more valuable and therefore the domination will change.

It already happened. 10 years ago a pizza was worth how much? And how many bitcoins do you need now for one pizza?

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by eric_cc on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:05PM (#32792994)
Cost of pizza is an example of buying power of bitcoin which is not the same as its monetary policy. I can not argue that the buying power has been volatile thus far.

I do suspect it will trend toward stability on a decades timeline.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by rufusroflpunch on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:29AM (#32790023)
No. The average person (or even crypto user) doesn’t know anything about the difference between consensus algorithms and that is certainly not stopping growth.

Also Bitcoin will 100% not remove proof of work ever. The overwhelming majority of node operators would not agree to that, ever. It goes against the ethos of Bitcoin. Proof of work is part of the social contract, right up there with 21 million hard cap and users running their own nodes.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by wickoff on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:09AM (#32789928)
Currently the immutability of Bitcoin is its core value proposition. Once that's gone, it becomes just another another altcoin, so the community will fight against the move to PoS.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by cookie_monsta on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:15AM (#32789956)
> Banning PoW would benefit Bitcoin; it's the main thing preventing it from becoming more popular right now.

It would be interesting to see some real numbers on that claim. For me, much bigger would be volatile value, lack of places to spend it, weekly stories about people losing life savings because off coding errors and whatnot and just generally that it seems to be an interesting solution to a problem I don't have.

PoW is in there somewhere, but nowhere near the top.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by 323 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:56AM (#32789847)
I agree with you that PoW is the biggest threat to Bitcoin and that it will be the thing that takes it down, if not solved.

But it's irrelevant, the community is already stuck in this place.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by api on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:03AM (#32789882)
The other crypto stuff seems like it’s designed for money or utility (or scammy crap). Bitcoin on the other hand seems like a religion.

All hail the great Satoshi. Thou shalt not change but one #define.

Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by Bakary on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:07AM (#32789912)
It's definitely a cliché to point it out but... religions themselves are pretty scammy and money-oriented in their own right.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ipaddr on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:44AM (#32790571)
So are the biggest charities.
Re:White House Is Mulling a Ban on Bitcoin Mining by ben_w on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:52AM (#32789809)
Bitcoin is by design not capable of being a major payment mechanism. Stuff on top of bitcoin might, but at that point the natural question is “then why bother when bitcoin?”