News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by whalesalad on Friday September 09, 2022 @08:41AM (#32778403)
Why is there so much overlap between infosec and furries?
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by poszlem on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:17AM (#32778825)
Well, before it was a cool identity to have, geeks used to go into computing often in order to escape what they perceived as reality that was hostile to them. I guess if you think you are an animal (even if ironically) you would also be more keen to stay in the virtual world. And infosec is one of those fields where hiding behind an avatar or a nickname is still somewhat accepted.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Kye on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:05AM (#32778682)
Possibly the same reason there's an overlap of queer people and furries: motivation to learn, a need for well-paid work to get out of hostile families and geographies, a need for an accepting community while you're working toward getting out.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by some_furry on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:23AM (#32779629)
To anyone confused by Kye's comment: Most of the furry fandom is LGBTQ+.

https://furscience.com/research-findings/sex-relationships-p...

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by cochne on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:14AM (#32778787)
I think you might have wrote furries instead of infosec/software?
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Kye on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:20AM (#32778865)
The furry/infosec/queer Venn diagram isn't a perfect circle, but the overlap is significant and growing with greater acceptance showing in surveys.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by malfist on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:37AM (#32779063)
Maybe in your social circles it is. If you move outside of the social circle of furries you'll find that they're just a small fraction of the queer population, just as they are only a small fraction of the non-queer population.

We might be more accepting of furries than our non-queer counterparts, but that doesn't make us furries ourselves. Claiming furry and queer is anywhere close to a a perfect circle venn diagram is way off base.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Kye on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:42AM (#32779115)
I don't know what to do with a response that's completely unbound from anything I said in the thing it's replying to.

I didn't say:

* all queer people are furry. Most A are B is not all B are A.

* that the Venn diagram is anywhere near a perfect circle. In fact, I said that's not the case.

HN's guideline on reading things charitably could have saved both of us some annoyance here. Try again. It's absurd to think I could mean the things you thought I meant.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by burnished on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:16PM (#32782924)
They aren't objecting to 'all' they are objecting to 'most'. Your post reads as LGTBQ is mostly furries, I suspect you meant that furries are mostly LGTBQ?
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Kye on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:17PM (#32783650)
I'm a fan of this guideline:

>> "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

It would be absurd to suggest queer people are mostly furries, so that interpretation is implausible. Act as though the person you reply to is rational, and you can discard the absurd.

A strong, good faith reading could reasonably assume I don't know anything about Venn diagrams and didn't realize all the circles are equal when I posted that. I'm assuming good faith, and that's why I didn't just flag their post for trolling. Maybe they're not trolling and just don't practice this principle.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by burnished on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:30PM (#32785680)
Why aren't you applying that principle to yourself here? You could be far more charitable and seek to bridge some misunderstanding. It feels like you don't understand that this expectation is symmetrical.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Kye on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:08PM (#32786693)
Giving someone some small benefit of the doubt when they make a comment like that is about my limit. This isn't my first rodeo. It's on them to demonstrate their absurd, unreasonable, unfair, completely off the rails read of my comment wasn't meant to kick off a hell thread.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by egypturnash on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:48AM (#32779917)
There’s a path from “hanging out on a role playing server” to “running the server” to “hey I can fill this Unix admin job” that has only gotten easier as more furries take it, then look to their friends when their company has positions that need filling.

This furry-to-IT pipeline has been running since the beginning of the World Wide Web as a thing people put money into.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by ThrowawayTestr on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:50AM (#32779209)
I hope I don't get flagged for this but neurodiversity is wide in the furry community.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by kayodelycaon on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:00AM (#32779340)
You're correct and shouldn't be downvoted for it. Diversity in general is pretty wide in the fandom. We have a much higher percentage of LGBTQ+ people here, because we do accept those people.

Furries on the whole are accepting and welcoming. For people who have faced discrimination in one form or another, the fandom is a place where one can belong and simply be who they are.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by lynndotpy on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:59AM (#32780042)
I only heard this anecdotally, but I understand that "alternative" folks and lifestyles were intentionally curated in the early years.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by deepdriver on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:57AM (#32779309)
People who spend inordinate amounts of time indoors on the computer have more time in which to develop computer skills.
[dead]
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by _notathrowaway on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:13AM (#32778773)
That's a very prejudiced and uncharitable way of looking at a fellow hacker. Have you got evidence to back your views?
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by some_furry on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:22AM (#32779618)
Despite what the other commentators on this thread seem to want to believe without evidence, I'm not at all attracted to children, and I'm offended that someone would drop such a gross accusation in a HN thread.
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Pigalowda on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:08AM (#32780149)
Be offended and then clarify - why are so many furries in the infosec field? Do you have a speculative answer?

By the way a person using a dark market to get drugs and then meeting up with other consenting adults to “cosplay” as animals may very well be an illegal and potentially humiliating event for a person. Maybe just growing up with the subculture created an early need in a person to hide/obfuscate and therefore motivates entry into infosec. I don’t know - that’s why I’m speculating. Going straight to the child angle is too narrow/myopic.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by some_furry on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:15AM (#32780217)
> why are so many furries in the infosec field? Do you have a speculative answer?

Honestly, the answer has already been posted several times. It has nothing to do with the incorrect associations you have in your mind.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32778682

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32779209

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32779917

> By the way a person using a dark market to get drugs and then meeting up with other consenting adults to “cosplay” as animals may very well be an illegal and potentially humiliating event for a person.

I have no idea what this means, considering:

1. I don't use dark markets

2. I don't use drugs

3. Being a furry isn't "animal 'cosplay'" in the sense your comment implies

> Maybe just growing up with the subculture created an early need in a person to hide/obfuscate and therefore motivates entry into infosec.

Roughly 80% of furries are LGBTQ+.

https://furscience.com/research-findings/sex-relationships-p...

An early Internet tradition, started by Something Awful, was to use "anti-furry" as a dog-whistle for anti-LGBTQ+.

https://soatok.medium.com/if-you-hate-furries-youre-anti-lgb...

This also motivated a lot of LGBTQ+ and furry people to need to learn security just to exist online. What you're gesturing towards is actually self defense against shitty people.

> I don’t know - that’s why I’m speculating. Going straight to the child angle is too narrow/myopic.

It's probably better to ask questions than to speculate incorrectly, especially when it's a nontechnical matter.

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by Pigalowda on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:40AM (#32780568)
It might be better not to speculate online but come on - this isn’t an in person group where you can see there’s a person waiting in the wings to answer questions.

If my blunt speculation motivated you to give the answer you did then it kinda worked, did it not? Of course that point is moot if you would have taken the time to answer the OP’s question.

And I wasn’t that far off anyways, just wrong on the timing in a persons life. From your answer apparently the motivation for infosec comes from an early need to obfuscate online identity from parents/family because of non-traditional sexuality. Is that humiliating for a person or is it trying to avoid feelings of humiliation that discovery would bring up in a parent. Does it really matter?

Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by some_furry on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:51AM (#32780722)
> It might be better not to speculate online but come on - this isn’t an in person group where you can see there’s a person waiting in the wings to answer questions.

This observation might have any merit at all if you weren't commenting on an HN thread for an article posted on my furry blog wherein I answer questions about the furry fandom all the damn time.

> If my blunt speculation motivated you to give the answer you did then it kinda worked, did it not? Of course that point is moot if you would have taken the time to answer the OP’s question.

This is a silly justification for assuming incorrect things publicly. This is how misinformation and willful ignorance spreads.

[dead]
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by whalesalad on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#32778930)
Your above response was very judgmental and not kind. My goal with the question was not to shame the lifestyle, and I don’t think that type of discussion is relevant here.
[dead]
Re:Should you delete your Patreon account after they laid of... by TakeBlaster16 on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:44AM (#32779143)
I understand wanting to protect real-life children, but I'll never understand why we need to protect drawings of fictional bears