News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by EnKopVand on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:18PM (#32714603)
I'm still not sure what the metaverse is supposed to be. I have an idea, sort of Second Life with VR, but if that's true, then I'm not sure why they think anyone but a few enthusiasts would want it. Before I got into working on climate change software, I did a long stint in the Danish public sector, and nothing in any of the stuff we did suggested that young people wanted to use VR. AR maybe, but not VR. In fact, the way young people consume entertainment media today, is basically exactly how we did it on a Gameboy, except now the Gameboy can do more than just play games. There are also so many social platforms that aren't Facebook, that a lot of youngsters aren't even on a Meta product anymore.

I guess time may prove me wrong, but I really don't see why the world would want a metaverse until you can actually plug into it, like the matrix. Then things may change.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by nathanaldensr on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:30PM (#32714749)
Think of it as an effort to replace your real, natural identity in physical reality with a virtual one. I believe the goal is to make your virtual identity your primary identity. That gives your would-be masters the technological control that is much harder in the real world. It allows for much easier atomization and propagandization.

Or it would, if the technology was actually real. Although, one might argue that Twitter, in a way, could be considered a metaverse already.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by TrapLord_Rhodo on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:35PM (#32716224)
Yeah - this thought scares me since meta has zero customer service.

I recently lost access to my email and phone 2fa to my instagram. Although my facebook is linked to it and i have changed the email on my facebook, instagram keeps asking me to verify using the 2FA i no longer have. There' no email address you can send requests through, only a wall of FAQ's and automated lines.

There are people i have met abroad i no longer can contact as i used instagram chat as my sole means of communication. I can't even request that my instagram be shut down. Now i have this public profile with thousands of followers and no way of controlling.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by mistrial9 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:48PM (#32714970)
agree that this lens is a useful one; secondly there is a massive capacity to build "digital twins" of the civilized world, with enough faux painting of pure nature to make it look good while riding past in your premium tourist seat. E-Tickets, anyone?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by rwmj on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:37PM (#32714832)
Isn't it just Zuck read Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash and because he's a billionaire he didn't just think "that's cool", but believed he could pivot his company to building it?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by hotpotamus on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:05PM (#32715187)
I assumed it was because they ran out of places to stick ads on and they need more. It's an ad company afterall.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by johannes1234321 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#32714913)
I think there is quite some ambiguity on purposes. They try out a few ideas and look for companies in the VR space to acquire. Once they got something which works they will retrofit the Metverse strategy to be describing that from the get go.

If they are precise an d that idea fails they have a lot more explaining to do, while now Zuckerberg is a visionary you simply don't understand, yet.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:39PM (#32714855)
Imagine a future where everybody in the world can have a house as big as they like, with literally no limits. You never need to do any maintenance. You can have whatever furniture you want, it's delivered instantly, and you never have to pay.

Space is infinite. Resources are infinite.

You just need an absolute bare minimum of subsistence to keep your physical body alive, keep your electricity on, and connect you up to the Internet.

We just need people to stop caring about the physical realm and only care about the virtual realm.

That is how we achieve practical post-scarcity. That is what the metaverse should be.

OK, right now it's not there, but it'll never get there if we never start.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by nicbou on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:45PM (#32714931)
Aren't the creators of this multiverse trying to embed artificial scarcity into it already?

In any case, what's a giant garden in which the sun isn't warm, the flowers don't smell, and the grass doesn't brush against your skin?

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:48PM (#32714968)
They might be; in that case they're not building my personal vision of the future.

With better VR, the sun is warm, the flowers do smell, and the grass does brush against your skin.

Your current experience of "reality" is not as real as you may think it is. Everything you've ever done or experienced has been communicated to your brain through sensory neurons. If we make a VR that can connect up your sensory neurons to the virtual world, your experiences can be just as "real" as "reality" is.

And if VR is where all your friends are, and where your work is, and where your leisure is, who cares about "reality" any more? It's just an alternative plane of existence where resources are finite, you get cold in bad weather, you need to clean when the place gets dirty, you need to wait for things to arrive, etc.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by felurx on Monday September 05, 2022 @06:08AM (#32722526)
That sounds good and all, but at the end of it somebody has to run it, and I don't think there's any person or (kind of) organization I'd like to entrust with managing _reality_. (And if I had to make a list, Meta is probably close to the bottom.) The good thing about our universe is that it doesn't care what we do with it, and it doesn't have any incentives.

But once there's a company in it that needs to maximize profit, things are going to get sticky. Democracy isn't perfect either and can turn bad.

And what about the potential for technical malfunctions? What about hacking? What about abuse? What about those who can't afford the hardware? What about those who don't want to join?

Building that utopia is going to require rebuilding half (or all) of society first, if we don't we have a near guarantee of getting a dystopia real fast, and even if we manage to avoid that there are too many intrinsic ways for this to turn horrible.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by bckr on Monday September 05, 2022 @12:51PM (#32726390)
> who cares about "reality" any more

People who realize that Reality is where you can lose Wi-Fi reception, stop receiving nutrient liquid, and otherwise be enslaved and/or killed.

Seriously, your future is a nightmare.

If you want a perfectly clean, warm, automated existence, work on robots and O'Neill colonies, not the Matrix.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by inquirerGeneral on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:35PM (#32716228)
... So the matrix, ok
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by woeirua on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:43PM (#32714898)
Sounds like a dystopian hellscape if you ask me.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:49PM (#32714983)
In what way is it dystopian? You can live whatever life you want.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by woeirua on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:51PM (#32715013)
The Amazon series Upgrade does a really great job mocking the idea that a virtual world would be better than the real world.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:09PM (#32715222)
People who lived in caves might have done a great job of mocking the idea that towns and cities would be better than caves, and yet here we are.

(But thanks for the recommendation, I will check it out).

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by patch_cable on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:44PM (#32715614)
How does raising children work in that world? Do you just strap them in when their infants?

(Also curious how sex and exercise work…)

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:54PM (#32715707)
You don't need exercise.

I'm not sure about children and reproduction. My best guess is that humans are replaced by AI quite quickly and they solve it for themselves.

Or maybe we just have a state-sponsored reproductive conscription scheme, where the best people are selected to donate sperm and eggs, the children are born from test tubes, and the state keeps the children alive until they're old enough to fend for themselves.

(I grant that this is getting dystopian now).

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by gremlinsinc on Monday September 05, 2022 @02:46AM (#32721272)
If we're all plugged in at birth, why does it matter our 'genetic makeup', why select the 'best of the best' if everyone in existence just gets booted up into the metaverse?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by rospaya on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#32714910)
Sounds more like the matrix than the metaverse. And almost nothing in it can replace the real thing, and the things that could be are already digital, like books or movies.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:47PM (#32714946)
With current technology it can't replace the real thing. But:

- people make better technology all the time; VR of today is at a quality and immersion level that was unimaginable 200 years ago

- a lot of people in the world live in pretty poor conditions (relative to the lifestyles of rich programmers on HN); at the margin there will be people willing to trade a loss of fidelity for an increase in quality of life, and the amount of people making that trade will only increase as the immersion level improves

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by pappa on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:53PM (#32715042)
You'd get bored after a few days... Putting effort into obtaining stuff is what makes obtaining stuff rewarding
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:08PM (#32715208)
You can still put effort into obtaining stuff. You just don't have to pay.

You can still do art. You can still create stuff. It's just that it's more like building software than building houses: the tools are free, the materials are free, you don't need any permits, etc.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by rewgs on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#32714916)
That sounds absolutely horrible.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:11PM (#32715236)
What part sounds horrible? You can have whatever life you want. Assuming sufficiently high-quality VR, it is obviously better than actual reality.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by LunaSea on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:19PM (#32716025)
You'll own a house you can't live in, with a pool you can't swim in, sipping cocktails that are not refreshing, with a girlfriend that is not a girl and not attracted by the real you either.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Monday September 05, 2022 @05:08AM (#32722079)
But you can do all of those things. If you can't do those things, it's not a sutiable replacement for reality.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by LunaSea on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:41AM (#32724833)
Well a simple response is that if you can feed yourself on virtual food you're creating something out of nothing.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by marssaxman on Monday September 05, 2022 @12:55AM (#32720679)
The life I might want would involve a whole lot of wild nature and absolutely no advertising, among other things which might be difficult to synthesize in VR.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Monday September 05, 2022 @05:08AM (#32722075)
You can have as much wild nature and as little advertising as you want. My vision isn't for a corporate-owned virtual prison. In my future the user is fully in control of their computer.

You could have a much richer experience of nature in VR than you could ever have today.

That you privilege "real" nature over the infinitely many possible "virtual" natures is a hangover of pre-metaverse thinking. It will only take a couple of generations for this kind of mindset to fade away.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by marssaxman on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:24AM (#32723482)
All right, well - have fun with your project, I guess!
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by kradeelav on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:45PM (#32714924)
do you realize how dystopian that is?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:10PM (#32715228)
No.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by flashgordon on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:43PM (#32714907)
So why should I stop caring about the physical realm especially given YOLO (who knows you might be reincarnated as a bug for those who believe in that)?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:48PM (#32714977)
Because you can have a better life in the virtual realm.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by locutous on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:04PM (#32715180)
Life is defined more by relationships than things. In this a virtual world will be no different.

The things you lose is the valuable lessons in the physical world like production and decay, health and sickness unless they are also brought over - then why be virtual?

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:12PM (#32715250)
Production and decay are only valuable to learn because you need to learn how to deal with them.

Learning about production and decay in the VR future is no more valuable than learning how to make fire from sticks is valuable today. OK, it's intellectually interesting, but it's just not a practical consideration in daily life any more.

Re health and sickness: muscles would obviously atrophy, but you don't care because you don't need them. I think diseases would spread less because physical human bodies won't be mixing as much.

I'm not sure what happens to human reproduction. Maybe human-inhabited VR is only a brief prelude to the true AI-owned future anyway.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by dale_glass on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:31PM (#32714763)
Why AR?

I'll admit upfront that I'm biased and develop a VR "metaverse" platform, but where exactly is the appeal of AR for the average person? AR augments reality, so what do you imagine your grandma doing with that?

In general there's just not that much information that is useful that we've not already put somewhere accessible. Streets have names, products have ingredient lists, devices have connectors with particular shapes and colors.

I see AR having a lot of potential, sure, but I'm not quite seeing where is its mainstream appeal exactly.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by urthor on Monday September 05, 2022 @02:46AM (#32721270)
AR seems extraordinarily attractive to me.

Look at the indstrial applications of Google Glass.

Seems like once there is hardware + SDK, there will be an absolute explosion in AR.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by dale_glass on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:38AM (#32723610)
I get industrial uses. A doctor or aircraft mechanic might benefit from a vision overlay.

But for virtually any normal use, you can just pull out your cell phone and have most of the same functionality. My Nokia N9, a decade ago, had a camera overlay app where you could point it at the street and it'd give you an "AR" overlay pointing out there was a coffee shop in that direction.

That was neat, but 99% of the time I don't really need such an overlay because shops label themselves just fine, and I don't care very much what lies beyond when going somewhere.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by urthor on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:24AM (#32735571)
Fair enough about the shopping.

I just can't criticize a technology if it's helping actual human beings do important jobs. After Blockchain it'll be an absolute relief.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by barkingcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:19PM (#32714624)
It doesn't matter what people want. Big companies can afford to push something and force it on you until you think you want it.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by EnKopVand on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:26PM (#32714719)
> It doesn't matter what people want. Big companies can afford to push something and force it on you until you think you want it.

Then why aren't Meta making sure all those youngsters join their platforms? I'm not going to pretend that advertisement doesn't work, but there is also a big difference between getting people to drink a Coke or a Pepsi and getting them to join a social media platform and actually spend time on it.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jamiek88 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:21PM (#32714656)
I don’t think this is true, or at least i can’t think of any examples of a big company forcing a products success, I can only remember lots of counter examples.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by yunohn on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:28PM (#32714732)
Why would people be forced to use Meta’s metaverse? Or any metaverse for that matter? This is nonsensical.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by zamalek on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:31PM (#32714768)
I agree with your conclusion, but not your reasoning. People are going to love it because very few people care about, or are even aware of, Zuck's voyeurism fetish. The loud reaction to this creepy behavior is actually unfathomly small compared to Facebook's active user base.

The initial users then drag their entire sphere into it, often convincing people to ignore their own better judgment.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by brtkdotse on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:21PM (#32714651)
Do you have an example of something that was pushed upon people, forcing them to like it?
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by Theodores on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:36PM (#32714813)
Hold that pitchfork: bottled water!

Hydration. Bottled water was only available in specialist stores for putting in things like your car radiator. The only bottled water for drinking on the marketplace was 'Perrier'. It was fizzy and came in distinctive bottles. People bought it as often as they bought spirits and it would stay in the drinks cabinet for months.

Then they started advertising it. After a few false starts the market for 'hydration' was established and paying money for something that came free from the tap was de rigeur.

France and other European countries were ahead of the UK with bottled water, possibly because the tap water was not deemed potable. These brands soon took over the UK market and TV showed the adverts to rake in the consumers.

The original word of 'thirsty' was swapped for the American 'hydration' and instead of asking if someone was thirsty you would ask them if they were properly hydrated.

Clearly there was no government decree or cartel pointing guns at people and insisting that they forget the thirsty idea and public water faucets. Through marketing and the 'hydration word' they got the job done.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jstanley on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#32714922)
> because the tap water was not deemed potable

So what were they doing in France before bottled water? Just going thirsty?

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by Theodores on Monday September 05, 2022 @02:58AM (#32721339)
Drinking wine.

In Ye Olden Days in the UK some fermented beer was 'drinking water'.

In Ye Olden Days yeast strains were not the ones we have today. The yeast got killed by alcohol at a lower concentration. Drinking wine or beer all the time was fine when it was as weak as shandy.

Waaait a minute!

People used to drink lightly alcoholised drinks made from natural ingredients, recycling their receptacles? And now we pay for bottled water laced with plastics that render mankind infertile?

I am going back to the old ways!

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jamiek88 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:23PM (#32714678)
Yeah I just posted a similar question, can’t think of any and can think of the converse quite easily.

Even Amazon couldn’t push the Amazon phone for example.

The nearest I can think of is Xbox but that came out of the gate strong with halo and had a fandom.

Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by mhb on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:22PM (#32714672)
Masks
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by jamiek88 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:23PM (#32714683)
Well that’s just silly.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by woeirua on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#32714915)
Yeah… FBs experience with Portal would prove otherwise.
Re:Meta’s metaverse hype leads to real-world backlash by peyton on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:41PM (#32714877)
A lot of people want to hang out like the influencers they follow.