I don't know what show you're listening to. I'm not a regular listener, by any means, but I hear Rogan routinely bring up things that he learns from other/prior guests. Often to challenge whatever he's hearing in the moment.
It really feels to me that people are just looking for reasons to attack him because he "platforms" voices they don't like. That was fine when he was just a comedian with a podcast, but now he has An Audience (tm), so it's Bad.
Rogan has certainly had some cranks on his show (IMO), but I'm comfortable enough with my intellect that I can listen to these (or not) without having my brain turned to mush.
One of the thing about Rogan's interview with Lazar is he fails to ask the obvious questions - such as "what are your credentials". 'Cause with Lazar, that question already takes you to dubious territory since Lazar's answer is "I have a PhD but MIT erased my records" (and his thesis advisor went along with this?).
And this kind of left a nasty taste in my mouth concerning Rogan. Sure, his questions might be just naive but it seems more likely he's using that naive pose to avoid the mine fields of the guests he likes.
I do feel for Rogan here...he's doing more-or-less the same thing he's been doing since the start, but now it's "wrong", because other people are expecting him to behave in a particular way. He builds an audience by being a good conversationalist with a huge variety of different, sometimes nutty, people, and suddenly uptight folks expect him to be Walter Cronkite.
Second, the thing with national level news isn't just that people are "uptight". It's that there are many professional and well-practiced liars out there eager for a softball venue (people less obvious than Lazar usually). These sorts of people make significant money from their deceptions and Rogan is an enabler of this stuff, making vast amounts of money himself.
Edit: and just on the question of Rogan's evolution. Just by Wikipedia's bio, I'd say he didn't start with small nuts and graduate to fronting professional conmen. Rather, he started MMA chat, built to national level and then moved laterally to interviewing people saying "hypothetically true" things about the world in generally.
I listened to that interview, with no background on Lazar or UFO-aficionados in general, and it seemed pretty clear he was full of it. I'm able to make my own decisions without the host telling me how I should think about the guest or needlessly arguing with someone they ostensibly brought on in good faith.
Hold up, think about what that statements means.
1. Let’s take the guy’s word at face value who is totally okay helping spread deception.
2. And the rich person says he’s not continuing to do “action that made him rich” because he wants even more money, but because he enjoys it.
Should that statement really be taken at face value given the context and the claim?
JR giving dubious theories a friendly platform is extremely harmful if his listeners are buying those arguments and repeating them.
Public figures who can heavily influence discourse and thought have an ethical obligation to not give unchallenged credence and a drastically increased audience to their nonsense. If Rogan thought that Goebbels was interesting and let him do his thing for hours to an audience of millions, he would be held to a higher standard. If Rogan thought that Ted Bundy was interesting and let him tell "his side of the story" without challenging it with the truth, he would be held to a higher standard.
This is a basic which we should expect of our society.
And your hypotheticals about Nazis and serial killers are totally irrelevant. You are arguing in bad faith and trying to inflame the discussion.
Normative ethics really don't just exist in one person's head.
This is not a question of whether or not people can think for themselves or whether they believe what they hear, and whether he's a comedian, politician, or astronaut has no bearing on what our ethical standards should be as a society.
We should expect better.
> You are arguing in bad faith and trying to inflame the discussion.
The fact that you have seemingly never really read philosophy or considered what we, as society, should expect from public figures does not mean the argument is in bad faith or inflammatory.
It is, very simply, a reductio ad absurdum. If your position is that the "rest of us" are capable of thinking for yourselves, who we allow to influence/control public discourse/thought should be up to individuals, then surely there's nothing wrong with having Nazis or mass murderers given airtime.
If you do have a problem with this, then you draw the line somewhere, and it's just a matter of determining where. If you have a problem with it, then you believe that some discourse is antithetical to the principles of a well-functioning society, and that we have a duty to shield people from it.
The question is where you draw that line, and why "he's just a comedian" (with 11-12 million listeners who see him as having "interesting conversations" with people who are not comedians) absolves him of a duty not to use his platform to spread dangerous misinformation. Not that he does it all the time, but it does happen sometimes, and the same normative ethics apply all the time.
Do you think you would get his 11-12 million listeners to agree with you on what society should expect? Who gets to decide that?
> then surely there's nothing wrong with having Nazis or mass murderers given airtime.
You invoked Godwin's law twice. What sort of argument are you going to win by invoking Nazis and worst case scenarios? Surely the slipper slope fallacy applies here?
I'm not sure why you presume that "we, as society, should expect better" means "this applies only to Joe Rogan listeners and we need to convince them." It's a general stance on how society ought to operate, and the use of "ought" is in the "how ought one live?" question raised by ethics.
We get to decide that as society. This isn't a new concept. Society would not have advanced to a point that we were capable of having this conversation at all if "we" had not already agreed on basic principles, such as "you should not steal", and "you should not murder", and "be generally honest in your dealings with others if you want to keep your reputation". These are all inherent rules of society which you implicitly follow in order to be part of it.
Holding public figures who have a louder voice to a standard of behavior which does not actively undermine society by giving credence to disinformation isn't some horrible leap or infringement upon your freedom. It's avoiding the Gracchi.
> You invoked Godwin's law twice.
Mentioning Nazis isn't Godwin's Law. Feel free to substitute some other bogeyman who you feel giving an unfiltered platform to would deteriorate society.
> What sort of argument are you going to win by invoking Nazis and worst case scenarios? Surely the slipper slope fallacy applies here?
No, it doesn't. Honestly, I'm getting the sense that you've never engaged in any kind of philosophical discourse before, which this is sort of veering into, and throwing out the names of fallacies doesn't mean they apply.
The point is, as I said in my last post, a reductio ad absurdum. It is constructing a contrapositive. It is saying "if we follow your reasoning to its logical conclusion, this is where it leads; verify whether that's true or false, less black and white."
And it was false/shades of grey. Clearly there is some level at which even ardent JRE listeners believe giving people a platform is harmful. So the question is "what are the guidelines for when something is too much?"
My position is, as repeatedly restated, that those with a greater platform have a duty to not do harm to society by allowing crackpots to talk without being challenged, whether that's denying climate change, believing lizard people run the government, believing we are secretly in contact with aliens, taking veterinary antiparasitics on the advice of one person rather than the guidance of literally every medical organization on Earth, etc.
It has no been made clear anywhere what the position of Joe Rogan defenders is other than "he's just a comedian; you shouldn't take him seriously; people can think for themselves; he doesn't have any obligation to question them". But again, it's apparent that having Nazis or murderers on with an unfiltered platform would cross some line. So where is that line? Where are Joe Rogan defenders drawing the line of what is "too much" to air? What is the basis for drawing it there and not somewhere else?
"You're not going to get COVID if you have these vaccinations."
-President Joe Biden, 2021
https://www.newsweek.com/joe-biden-2021-video-saying-vaccina...
Comedians don't qualify as "public figures" in that context. I'm not a Joe Rogan defender and don't particularly care about him one way or another, but you're obviously just making things up and trying to gaslight us. Let us know when you have a valid point to make instead of resorting to inflammatory comments about imaginary Nazis.
As for a "line", how about this. Comedians can say whatever asinine shit they like and the rest of us are free to laugh or ignore them as we please. There are no lines in comedy. Grow up.
Isn't this a "court jester" interpretation of comedy? The comedian debases themselves on all issues so thoroughly that it creates a convenient bi-directional fiction: I can ignore things that bother me, because they are just the ramblings of a clown. And so they can say whatever they want, with no requirement that it make sense (because there is no "low" they won't sink beneath).
The debasement of "journalism" to the point where it applies to Joe Rogan and/or "news networks" which have actively fought (and won) court battles on the basis that no reasonable person would believe the statements were actually true, or news radio which for decades gave equal airtime to "both sides" even if one of those sides believed in a Hollow Earth does not mean that "journalism" has lost high standards, merely that the term has been horrifyingly diluted in the United States.
> If you want to bring Nazis into this then how about all of the practically fawning interviews that US media had with Adolph Hitler right up until he invaded France?
Whataboutism is an intellectually bankrupt argument. Nobody is defending those journalists, but if you're going to try to make a whataboutist argument, apples-to-apples works a lot better than "with the benefit of hindsight, we know that Hitler was bad and that Ford would have actively led a fifth column if he could have, so they were bad". You could equally say "if you want to bring Dwayne Johnson into this, then how about all of the love for Cosby as America's Dad?"
The known facts are different.
If you want to assert that a comparison to Nazis (and I used Goebbels as an example because he was principally a radio propagandist rather than Goering, Himmler, Heydrich, etc; he's the sort of person who would have seemed like a harmless marketing geek) is bad in a whataboutist sense, you would do much better to say "if you want to bring Nazis into this, then how about Speer? He wasn't (actively) involved in the Holocaust and he could have had a lot of interesting things to say about architecture and designing an imperial capital?"
The fact that he didn't with Lazar but did with Bigelow indicates to me that he favours Lazar, and considers his story to be genuine, and that kind of bias is detrimental to the interview process.
It's an interesting turn of phrase, because there's a very real pipeline in which people with less-trained critical thinking skills listen to Rogan -> cannot distinguish openness from endorsement -> believe Rogan is endorsing anti-vaxx voices -> contribute to an aggregate increase in community transmissibility of communicable diseases with proven neurological impacts -> said diseases turn immunocompromised people's neurons to "mush" at an increased rate, through no fault or Rogan-listening of the victims' own.
Rogan has consistently made a decision to prioritize the "vibe" of his podcast over pushing his interview subjects in a way that would make it clear that his provision of a platform is not endorsement. Sure, he challenges things as you have mentioned, but when he challenges anti-vaxx voices no more or no less than he would a guest who, say, had an opinion about hunting he didn't like, that creates a responsibility that I think does scale with audience size.
https://www.npr.org/2022/01/21/1074442185/joe-rogan-doctor-c...
Strategic lying is employed for the "greater good" in the context of this way of thinking frequently, the most egregious example probably being Fauci telling the public not to wear masks because privately the government believed that there wouldn’t be enough protective equipment for health care workers -- they didn't want the dumbs to panic-buy and leave hospitals vulnerable.
Not looking to get into a covid debate, just pointing out that even governments will lie to keep the dumbs from doing something they don't like, and I think that's bad.
You don’t get to treat adults like children. They are adults who might know something you don’t.
It’s just toxic discourse.
True, but it could also be their priorities are somewhere other than yours. Which might be okay or might not depending on whatever.
What these "experts" and politicians did though... treat people like dumb children... completely inexcusable.
If this is your opinion, perhaps the problem is that society undervalues critical thinking skills. Not that an entertainer isn’t shilling in the correct directions.
If the intellect and judgment of mankind ought to be cultivated, a thing
which Protestants at least do not deny, on what can these faculties be
more appropriately exercised by any one, than on the things which
concern him so much that it is considered necessary for him to hold
opinions on them?
- John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859)
Perhaps the cause of this problem is refusing society the opportunity to exercise their critical thinking skills.No matter, we can just spoonfeed everyone the received and accepted wisdom. Then there will be no need for any faculties of discernment.
The Catholic Church has its own way of dealing with this
embarrassing problem. It makes a broad separation between those who can
be permitted to receive its doctrines on conviction, and those who must
accept them on trust.There are people who travel the country after school shootings, comforting parents who lost children, and one of the first things they have to tell them is to brace themselves for all of the harassment and abuse they will receive from people who believe that all school shootings are false flag operations.
I mean, I think before he got sued, Alex Jones would have actively disagreed with you. He would have taken pride of that in his audience. There’s some chance he may actually take offense to your comment.
Aside from that, why would it be a mistake if someone intentionally cultivated that? there’s been plenty of cult leaders who’ve cultivated terrible audiences. I’m not making a broad generalization about someone with general appeal like Joe Rogan, but there are some bad people out there, some self identified.
Does this principle apply only to information of a particular political leaning, or is it a property of information in general?
> veracity of those perspectives.
What is the process by which the veracity of any perspective is determined?
Could you go deeper into why you think political leaning would have anything to do with it? I wouldn't think so...
> What is the process by which the veracity of any perspective is determined?
> Scientific method
Undoubtedly: and such teaching
suffices on a subject like mathematics, where there is nothing at all to
be said on the wrong side of the question. The peculiarity of the
evidence of mathematical truths is, that all the argument is on one
side. There are no objections, and no answers to objections. But on
every subject on which difference of opinion is possible, the truth
depends on a balance to be struck between two sets of conflicting
reasons. Even in natural philosophy, there is always some other
explanation possible of the same facts; some geocentric theory instead
of heliocentric, some phlogiston instead of oxygen; [...]
- On Liberty (1859)> the truth depends on a balance to be struck between two sets of conflicting reasons.
This is terrible reasoning, for the opposite reason you seem to be arguing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma
But when we turn to subjects infinitely more
complicated, to morals, religion, politics, social relations, and the
business of life, three-fourths of the arguments for every disputed
opinion consist in dispelling the appearances which favour some opinion
different from it. The greatest orator, save one, of antiquity, has left
it on record that he always studied his adversary's case with as great,
if not with still greater, intensity than even his own.
https://xkcd.com/435/P.S. Can you demonstrate how the scientific method was applied when you reached the conclusion that this supposed "real pipeline" exists?
https://engineering.stanford.edu/magazine/article/how-fake-n...
This was a great podcast:
https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/12/02/504155809/epis...
The research on this stuff is fascinating.
Seems like talking about ideas for some is more a form of amusement/ entertainment/ mental stimulation (in the same way recreational or escapist drugs can be mentally stimulating), especially if there are no outward signs & indications that a person is committed to testing out, applying, integrating, and even replacing formerly held and inferior ideas – a process which involves a lot of trial end error, failures, humility, perseverance, and delayed gratification. It might seem open-minded and intellectual, but if across time, there's no change in belief via deeper understanding from considering new and different perspectives, that then results in outward action, then all the talk in the world about ideas and perspectives is just hot air.
Maybe that's not Joe Rogan and his loyal audience? I dunno!
Or, in other words, the ideas and values that people live their lives by usually work for them, to some degree. Often in ways that aren’t immediately obvious. Making changes to a working system that one relies on isn’t something to be done lightly. You can see this with a specific subset of psychedelics enthusiasts, who end up completely fracturing their ability to function in reality. Or in people who don’t have a working value and belief system in the first place and end up being preyed on by cults.
Human life is infinitely complex. None of us have it figured out, and none of us are going to figure it out even if we lived for a thousand years. What’s the biggest code change you think you can make to a working piece of software without introducing a bug? That entire piece of software is only a fraction as complicated as the human condition.
> It might seem open-minded and intellectual, but if across time, there's no change in belief via deeper understanding from considering new and different perspectives, that then results in outward action, then all the talk in the world about ideas and perspectives is just hot air.
Sure. Is that so bad? The cautionary tale on the other side of the ledger is every failed attempt to build a utopia based on theory. This sort of thing was one of the leading causes of unnatural death in the 20th century.
To be clear, I think it’s definitely possible to err on the other side as well. But erring on the other side looks like being unwilling to play with ideas at all. You need a sandboxed environment if you’re going to play with ideas, and even when an idea is promising enough that you might want to take it out of the sandbox, it’s hard to tell whether that’s because of the merits of the idea or just a vulnerability in your sandbox.
What I'm pointing at are people who think they're actually considering ideas as if they're trying to better themselves or understand a situation or concept so as to learn how to integrate it into their consciousness, but really they're just seeking mental stimulation with no intent to grow or take any real meaningful action. If you make no claims to be toying with concepts for the purposes of actually implementing them, I respect your choice to do so since I know what to expect. But I'm more pointing at the types who might like appearing as if they're seriously considering ideas and how to implement them, but in reality they're fairly complacent. The easy solve here would be to not present yourself as if you're actually going to do anything with the concepts you play around with in your head for amusement, and just own up to treating all this as a frivolous mental exercise. There's absolutely value in that, and there's no shame in owning it proudly.
The noun form of “solve” is “solution”, FYI.
This sounds very much like philosophy. In general, readers of philosophy enjoy looking at many frames without privileging any particular one.
I don't look to podcasts like these to make their guests conform to my beliefs, I look to them to see novel perspectives and to glean what I can from them for my benefit, and simply because looking at other perspectives in a format like this really does entertain me.
"Horrible randos" got where they were in some way, and it's certainly possible that they might have a unique perspective that might be helpful or that what they say might actually be information I need. I wonder if Edward Snowden, for example, would be classified as a "horrible rando" if he hadn't been the guy that worked for them and blew the lid off of what the government was surveilling but had only speculated about what they were doing as an outsider with his actual self as a contact in the NSA. He would be saying the same information, but his credibility would change. Which doesn't mean it couldn't be true, as it obviously was in this case. Dismissing him as someone who shouldn't be listened to would have been a mistake.
I keep a lot of thoughts flowing in my head to compare new information against and to make connections with and rate their truthiness as more information comes in. The more information the better. You don't find the truth by listening to people restate your set of beliefs every day.
But it's not really about hearing the same perspective multiple times that I'm after, it's hearing from multiple perspectives.
For instance, if you're talking to a Bitcoin developer and you ask them "what about the energy use", it's just a boring question that's been asked millions of times. You likely know the answer. I'd much rather they get in the weeds about some proposal or technical issue.
I would much rather listen to a musician interviewed by someone with experience with recording & songwriting & making albums, who can ask intelligent questions about the craft & process & equipment. (Warren Huart's interviews with music producers are a great example.) Not some random gossip journalist asking "So what are your inspirations on this album" and "what can we expect from your tour".
I think that's why broader podcasts are popular. You don't really know the specific topic you're getting, but it's often pretty interesting, and you can go deeper from there, finding the one or few expert podcasts that talk about that topic.
I have tried podcasts like that before (Farnam Street's "The Knowledge Project" comes to mind), but I found that often the guests weren't always interesting to me. If the hit-rate wasn't high enough I'd end up unsubscribing.
Derek Sivers tried doing the reverse, his podcast feed was every interview he'd done on other people's podcasts. So he was always the guest, but it introduced me to new podcasts & hosts I'd never heard of. That's actually how I found The Knowledge Project (and I did love the Knowledge Project interview with Annie Duke, who wrote Thinking In Bets).
Edit: Guess I should link those episodes for anyone who might be interested:
> If someone is an expert in their field or has a depth of experience, I'd prefer him to be challenged by someone with a similar level of expertise.
Preparing for an interview will give you some superficial understanding, which will probably fall apart during the interview, unless the interviewer is very intelligent/curious (Sean Carroll's Mindscape and Newtons Apple comes to mind).
Another alternative would be to have people on both sides present, but I've never seen that work out. The discussion you get with hostility is nowhere near the discussion you get with curiosity.
Ignoring an unsolved and critical issue simply because it’s been asked before is odd.
If someone is pushing something with an awful unmitigated issue, hell yes they should be challenged on it.
Cigarette company CEO: We understand that our product is dangerous and believe adults should make a judgement call as to the risks. We offer a lot of products to help people quit...
Aren't you glad you wasted N minutes with that canned response? Or were you expecting a change of heart and him relinquishing the role of CEO and dissolving the company?
> If someone is pushing something with an awful unmitigated issue, hell yes they should be challenged on it.
I don't want my interviewer to be doing advocacy or "mitigating" issues. I want to listen to an interesting conversation. Not everything has to be advocacy.
The problem is that Joe has some really strong opinions and uses the "I don't know" schtick as a cudgel to avoid confronting contrary evidence. Look at how he responds when pushed on aliens, COVID, etc.
Thankfully he's not like that in the majority of interviews, but anything dovetailing a conspiracy is painful is listen to.
I'm surprised the show is still on. I'd have thought its niche had been filled several thousand times over by podcasts.
Not at all.
I have a distinct memory in which I’m driving alone, late at night, on a long road trip. I don’t have any unlistened podcasts downloaded, I’m not in the mood for music, but it’s late and I would like to hear another human voice. So I turn on the radio. The night sky is a magical sight that implies endless possibility, so I’m not in the mood for sports radio or Dave Ramsey. I don’t know if I ended up listening to Coast to Coast AM or one of its imitators, but I found something along those lines and it hit the spot.
These days my unlistened podcast collection is large enough that I rarely get to that point. And my unlistened podcast collection is that large in part because the radio dial is a little bare lately when I hit "scan" in most of the places I'm apt to do so.
I've listened to probably 100 episodes so far, and I don't recall being exposed to any horrible people. Do you have some guests in mind? It seems they're incredibly rare.
Not if that's the format of the show, and the show is wildly successful.
Also: what's an example of a really good interview show where the interviewer only brings on people they agree with, or else brings on people they disagree with in order to tell them they're wrong? That sounds like a debate show rather than an interview, and it doesn't sound like my cup of tea. Reminds me of those political interview shows on TV where the host cuts the guest off to yell at them.
The other thing that bugged me about him is he pretty much has a playlist of topics he hits on most episodes. Hunting, Jiu Jitsu, DMT, etc. It's pretty interesting the first few times but after a while it's gets a little old. I still have a generally favorable view of Rogan but I haven't listened to an episode in years. I think the controversy around him is probably a bit overblown though.
But even so, I wouldn't say he never challenges people, especially if it's something he actually does have a strong opinion on, like MMA and fitness stuff. There's a (in?)famous episode where he interviewed Adam Ruins Everything and they had a pretty big debate over some of Adam's assertions, like the idea that alpha males don't exist, or that men only seem to be better at sports because the sport was designed for them to be better at it.
Compared to a clam, maybe. I am definitely smarter than a clam. Probably.
I admire your defensive use of 'probably', as clams can contain pearls of wisdom.
Can it EVER happen, since he is a talk show host that must be dumb and constantly say 'Lets hear what some folks think' and bring even more people to his show?
In my experience, the overwhelming majority of people who think they are smart and challenge "dumb" ideas with "facts" are the truly dumb people (see anyone in corporate media or government for examples of this).
But at some point it occurred, "Shouldn't at some point, if we're listening to all this that, we stop being a dumb guy who doesn't know anything and actually have opinion / challenge some of these things with some facts / solid ideas?"
But I never saw that happen, and as time went on the "I don't know" excuses just felt ... more and more insufficient, dumb by choice, or just excuses.
At some point just being "dumb" and listening to every rando person makes you susceptible to / a target of a bunch of horrible randos with bad ideas ... An open approach is admirable, but not learning along the way is not.