Today, the tolerance for risk is much lower, the costs higher and the budget much more controlled. There are many politicians who want to greatly reduce NASA's budget in favour of private ventures. A failed launch is ammo for their cause. So whereas Apollo could proceed (with some delays) after people burnt to death in a capsule, if that happened today the whole program would be halted indefinitely and NASA heavily questioned as to why it needed to take such risks. 50 years on from Apollo, NASA has learnt that an abundance of caution is needed.
Let's not diminish the brilliant, flawless execution of the Apollo program, with the argument that they cared less for the lives of Astronauts.
The comment you replied to is correct. Every launch has a non-zero chance of death, and the Apollo program was simply willing to tolerate a higher probability of loss than we are today. I think if you want to call that "they cared less for the lives of Astronauts" that that's your own interpretation.
Acknowledging that their risk tolerances were higher than politics necessitates today doesn't "diminish" anything.
In a redesigned spacecraft (based on the Block II that was already in development) that replaced the pure oxygen environment at launch with a Nitrogen/Oxygen atmosphere that was slowly bled off to pure O2 at the desired partial pressure once it was in space.
Grissom was one of the three astronauts that died in the Apollo 1 fire.
"Houston, we have a problem"
NASA had a manned spaceflight program after Apollo that was specifically designed for safety and efficiency—the Space Shuttle—which turned out to be expensive and unsafe. After the Columbia disaster the Shuttle was cancelled, but the subcontractors for the Shuttle cried foul and Congress pretty much forced NASA to build a new rocket out of Shuttle parts—first Ares, then SLS.
If it were up to NASA, they would either build the rocket out of something other than old Shuttle parts or just outsource rocket development and focus on operations. The politicians are the ones making them build SLS.
We are pretty close to (if not already at) the point where we don't need Government funding for space exploration.
He's hellbent on building Starship I think, but Mars? I don't see it. He's invested a lot of time and money into building a booster that will excel at putting satellites into orbit for Starlink and DoD contracts. But how much has he invested in Mars colony habitat technology? Virtually nothing.
Starship is a satellite launcher, not a Mars rocket. The Mars talk is a recruiting tactic.
yet SpaceX can launch a lot more often and a lot more reliably, and cheaper too. Strange, huh?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_Spacecraft_Qualificatio...
SLS is one and done. It’s the old Apollo and Shuttle strategy, with the post-Columbia and Challenger risk management. It’s a bad strategy.
Getting your launches right is always a challenge for any new rocket family, and delaying your early test flights when (not if) you see unexpected telemetry data during the countdown should be seen as normal while you're learning how your rocket works in the real world.
Even with Starship, where cratering the first few test article hops was considered pretty likely, they had a bunch of holds and scrubs during the countdowns to those launch attempts. I expect the next test flight not to have zero delays either.
And SLS is being cautious. Delays should be expected, and not seen as some terrible bit of mismanagement. "Go fever" is real, and is a bad thing.
ULA has 148 launches with NO accidents. SpaceX has put up more, but had an accident in flight with the Falcon 9 in June 2015, and another on the pad in September 2016.
Mind you, ULA started with a known rocket design. While SpaceX has been iterating as it goes.
But still, we don't have significant statistical evidence about which is actually more reliable.
And ULA had a number of issues in that time. For example a failure in an Atlas first stage and the only just managed to deploy the sat because the upper stage had just enough margin.
And ULA had major delays, way longer then what SpaceX could afford for things like their Delta 4 Heavy launches.
ULA of course also got 1 billion $ in subsidies per year to ensure launch safety, a luxury SpaceX never had.
> But still, we don't have significant statistical evidence about which is actually more reliable.
Actually we do. It you look at the launch rates and how often Falcon 9 has launched already the statistical significant of the results gets bigger and bigger.
Unfortunately I can't find the list that shows this data and explains the methods used right now.
But Falcon 9 is very clearly on top of the list.
The ULA workhorse was the Atlas 5. Over its whole lifetime, both under Lockheed and ULA, it had 95 launches of which one was a partial failure (declared success). Wikipedia is good enough for that.
The SpaceX workhorse is the Falcon 9. https://www.spacex.com/launches/ puts it at 176 launches with 1 failure and 1 partial failure. This is not counting one that blew up on the pad with the satellite aboard.
The measured failure rate of the Atlas 5 is 0/95. Of Falcon 9 is 1/176. Note that 0/95 < 1/176.
The measured "not perfect success" rate of the Atlas 5 is 1/95. Of Falcon 9 is 2/176 = 1/88. Note that 1/95 < 1/88.
Also anyone with basic statistical knowledge will immediately see that the sample size is sufficiently low that we cannot draw any conclusion at 95% confidence.
Now what Falcon 9 does have the crown on is the longest string of uninterrupted successes of any rocket family. They are now at 148. (Not counting, of course, the one that blew up on the launch pad with the satellite on board.) But not enough to be statistically strong evidence that they are best. Also ULA has over 150 launches across their rocket platforms without any being declared a failure - which exceeds SpaceX's current winning streak.
That said, I agree with you about ULA's advantages, and I agree that SpaceX is the future. But I'm not going to lie about the math. And the math says that there isn't significant statistical evidence that SpaceX is better on safety.
In low sample size cases such measures are a better predictor of the future.
Insurance rates also reflect this same reality, as SpaceX has industry leading safety rating.
If I can find this document again I will send it, but somehow I can't find the damn thing.
Furthermore the Starlink constellation 'only' has 3,000 satellites so far, but SpaceX has sought approval for 30,000 more than the 12,000 already approved. To launch and maintain a constellation that huge with Falcon 9? It might be commercially viable, but I doubt it, they already have a very rapid launch cadence with Falcon 9 starlink launches and they evidently think they need much more.
The lander contract is a 'safe' contract for SpaceX to win, despite their absurd proposal, since the whole program is very unlikely to ever get to the stage where the lander is actually put to use and sent to the moon.
No actually they want to give NASA more money so NASA can buy what it needs from private ventures.
They seem to have produced better results on less money — so if NASA can’t follow the strategy that works, why should we throw more into the money pit?
It's the curse of waterfall budgeting. A democratic government with typical constraints wants to minimize spending and to have all spending fully accounted for in advance.
"I dunno, maybe it will blow up this time?" is not an acceptable line-item under either standard.
Therefore, budgets must plan for success and design failure out of the process. Minimizing risk maximizes process and cost, ironically sacrificing the very low-cost public policy goal at the feet of risk intolerance. Instead of fifty SLS launches, of which the first dozen or so might fail as learning experiences, we get five that all must go flawlessly.
True "risky" development is reserved for programs of true national urgency (e.g. the original defense focus of the space race) or for programs that can operate well outside the public's watchful eye.
I don't think you can assert that NASA hasn't or wouldn't fall to Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy. What makes NASA special to be immune to such dysfunction?
Also SpaceX plan to make 1000 Starships, and NASA plans to make about 5 of theirs
You don’t get to decide where the money goes at all. Senators do so they can boast about bringing jobs to their state in reelection campaigns.
Put a teen, on the moon. Or some other random person without having them go through extensive training, really. I'll be more impressed.
Having said that, I consider representation to be a valid selection criteria for publicly funded mission. Representation matters and that’s something that a lot of people will never understand as they’ve been widely represented throughout history, so it’s just normal life for them. Not so for many, many other people.
I'm astounded that this open prejudice exists, and that people don't feel ashamed to defend it. It ought to get struck down by the courts.
>Having said that, I consider representation to be a valid selection criteria for publicly funded mission.
It's tax money spent on open, shameless racism and sexism.
A big part of a modern astronauts job is speaking to people outside of the agency. School children, politicians, etc... It's in the agency's best interests to be relatable and inspiring to the widest swath of the population possible.
>It's in the agency's best interests to be relatable and inspiring to the widest swath of the population possible.
I mean that just says it all, doesn't it? The organization pursuing whatever will further the organization, rather than achieving the nominal mission.
Thank God we have SpaceX who are actually slashing launch costs and aiming to commoditize space travel. Astronauts shouldn't be inspiring celebrities, they should be like aircraft pilots. Competent, professional, and ubiquitous.
I agree with you - thank God for SpaceX (and FWIW, they also have diversity commitments). They are an amazing partner for NASA and are making their competitors (especially Boeing) look incompetent.
We’ve heard the same story for 50 years.
Cancel the project now. There should be a price for taking the wrong path.
>The original launch date was planned for early 1967, but was delayed to November 9 because of a myriad of problems with various elements of the spacecraft, and difficulties during pre-flight testing.... These issues delayed the flight through much of 1967.
NASA is out of practice (and it's not being run by Germans anymore).
...This was an enormously expensive and time-consuming process, grinding the stage's production schedule almost to a standstill and jeopardizing the Presidential timetable.
When this happened Webb told von Braun to desist, adding that "We've got to trust American industry." The issue came to a showdown at a meeting where the Marshall rocket team was asked to explain its extreme measures. While doing so, one of the engineers produced a rag and told Webb that "this is what we find in this stuff." The contractors, the Marshall engineers believed, required extensive oversight to ensure they produced the highest quality work. A compromise emerged that was called the 10 percent rule: 10 percent of all funding for NASA was to be spent to ensure in- house expertise and in the process check contractor reliability..."
Literally laghed out loud on this one and had to explain to coworkers what was so funny :)
We are way past the original timeline and budget. You fail!
After 2 decades, time to acknowledge it:
https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2004/04/08/the-wrong-stuff/
Perspective helps
Doesn't get much clearer than that chart. Oof!
The part about the NASA budget is at 2:00 though it's all a good watch.
I wouldn't rise to an unconditional defense of SLS as a whole, but this particular issue is picking nits.
Understandably, her face was all in turmoil. It is three first picture popping into my mind whenever Challenger comes up.
People don't seem to understand that we make good use of space and space flight, but humans in space just aren't that useful at the moment. At the beginning of the space age it seemed like they might be; there were ideas for a manned spy satellite, such as the Manned Orbiting Laboratory[1]. But as tech advanced, the people who actually using space flight to accomplish things realized that automated systems functioned better.
NASA spends 44.9% of its budget on human space flight, and just 3.5% on aeronautics[2], when it's likely the aeronautics research improves people's lives much more than the human space flight efforts.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manned_Orbiting_Laboratory [2] https://www.planetary.org/space-policy/nasa-budget
There's zero useful science being accomplished here that cannot be accomplished minus humans on the craft for less money, faster.
It's a national embarrassment that we have teachers being paid a pittance, doing unpaid labor, paying for basic supplies out of pocket, and children go hungry at school because we think they should have to pay for a meal - but we can spend billions on what amounts to a blank check to the aerospace defense industry in the name of "science."
People always talk about the benefits of space exploration for developments in science and technology that are necessitated (when really, most of the tech was developed for spy satellites and nuclear weapons delivery, and the doe-eyed "exploration" missions are post-facto justifications and emotional manipulation.)
What would be the benefits for science and technology if every kid in the US was fed at school, had enough (and current) textbooks, sufficient stationary supplies in their classrooms, and teachers who were fairly compensated for their labor (and their school staffed sufficiently such that teachers didn't have to put in nearly 100% more labor than they are paid for?)
Do you really think single-digit billions is going to pay for a meaningful increase to teachers' wages, plus feeding students?
NASA gets $22B per year - less than $12B of that goes to manned flights.
There's 3.1M public school teachers in the US. If you took ALL of that money and gave it all to teachers (which is ridiculous - they're paid by states, not federally) - that amounts to a ~10% raise - and if you count future pensions - it's not even a ~3% raise.
You have $0 left over to pay for hungry students. There's also another 3M employees at public schools beside teachers that get nothing...
It's almost as if NASA's budget has nothing to do with anything you mentioned.
Antarctic exploration is a good analogy. A little over a century ago, it was the new frontier. But as we advanced, the excitement gave way to cold reality. Though it was exciting at the time, I doubt most people could tell you who the first person to reach the South Pole was. And the doubtful that the journeys actually provided any benefit to modern researchers there. If we had simply waited a few decades and started exploring when the technology was there (the so-called "Mechanical age" of Antarctic exploration), fewer lives would have been lost and we would have been in the same place we are today.
edit for humility: I had to look up the Artemis details last night to see that SpaceX is part of the critical path to a moon landing, so I'm not faulting someone for ignorance. It happens.
So "no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second" is totally untrue.
But if we are going to include previous programs before Apollo 7, then we should include the predecessors programs of Artemis 1. Meaning, none...What speaks to the delays and lack of execution. Also caused of course, by Congress mandates.
Half of century is a a lot of advancement in safety. You have many orders more of magnitude of data, sensors and understanding of what to look for.
Is Artemis a good program? Hell no. But that’s not a way to compare it.
50 Years ago...With less experience, more challenging technical issues, doing something never done, the Kennedy Space Center to the Moon line, had no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second. Think about that...
https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/37482/reason-of-ap...
"...Only Apollo 17 had a long launch delay of 2 hours 40 minutes, Apollo 14 of 40 minutes. Most delays were less than a second..."