Re:Launch Attempt Scrubbed
by sashahrzg on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:52AM
(#32638244)
This. This right here. I absolutely hate seeing the two compared. They're doing two very different things with two very different goals.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Their goals are similar, NASA is just hamstrung by Congress and the general public. If NASA had the freedom to choose its direction they too would be working on a Starship style rocket by now, not attempting to pass off a dinosaur as modern.
Re:Launch Attempt Scrubbed
by MichaelCollins on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:33PM
(#32641002)
> NASA is just hamstrung by Congress and the general public
I don't think you can assert that NASA hasn't or wouldn't fall to Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy. What makes NASA special to be immune to such dysfunction?
Or they might have ran their original design of STS instead of one hamstrung and made hilariously expensive due to contract with DoD
What do you think is different about their goals?
SpaceX is a profit motivated company with large degrees of flexibility. They move fast and break ships.
NASA is a research institution focused on scientific advancement and space research. They also are very rigid due to the way they receive funding. NASA cannot afford to move to a starship style system because the SLS contract was locked in.
Re:Launch Attempt Scrubbed
by bottlepalm on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:21PM
(#32640030)
All that scientific advancement to end up 50 years later with a Moon vehicle not much more different than Apollo.