News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by SilverBirch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:35AM (#32564717)
I think it's a pretty open secret that Twitter is a fairly broken company. It's no surprise that their security practices are bad, because all their practices are bad. It's also very difficult to view this in isolation when you have the timeline of (1): Fired in January, nothing happens. (2) Musk makes offer for twitter then reneges. (3) Months before the lawsuit gets decided re-emerges with accusations.

What happened that caused him to suddenly start whistleblowing now, and not in January? Was it the same thing that caused Ken Paxton in Texas to start investigating Twitter?

This just looks like pretty plain mud-slinging from Musk's team to be honest. Especially since the Whistleblower seems to basically be blowing the whilst on himself.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jacooper on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:42AM (#32564795)
Apperantly he started the whistleblowing process before any Musk involvement with Twitter.

https://twitter.com/KimZetter/status/1562061556745089025

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by tablespoon on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:28AM (#32565425)
> Apperantly he started the whistleblowing process before any Musk involvement with twitter.

According to his lawyer as reported by someone on Twitter. IIRC, lawyers make statements that guilty clients are innocent all the time.

If he was working with Musk help him wiggle out of the Twitter deal, it would fatally undermine the goal for to come out publicly about the relationship. I'm skeptical unless they can provide verifiable 3rd party evidence (e.g. some document filed before the deal).

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by sp332 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:03AM (#32565910)
Linking to a Twitter thread is a little indirect, but Kim Zetter is a reporter on the infosec beat, and if you scroll up, you can see the link to the CNN article she's discussing. Also here's a video that includes the lawyer saying it out loud. https://mobile.twitter.com/donie/status/1562020176278716416 (@donie is the first person to talk in the video.)
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Larrikin on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:18AM (#32566168)
So instead of taking a statement from the lawyer you think it makes more sense to wildly speculate and make things up? The burden of proof falls on the other side now to prove the whistle blowing started after Musk.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Arainach on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:32AM (#32566399)
A statement from a lawyer saying "this is older" isn't evidence. Until the lawyer shows an example of any form of whistleblowing predating Musk, this is still on them.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by adamsmith143 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:30AM (#32565448)
I mean I want to give the guy the benefit of the doubt but is the only evidence that was the case this journalist saying "Mudge totally told me he did this before Musk got here I swear."
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by criddell on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:57AM (#32565845)
It doesn't really sound like you want to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by carvking on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:17AM (#32565267)
Mudge: "Jack Dorsey reached out and asked me to come and perform a critical task at Twitter. I signed on to do it and believe I'm still performing that mission," he said."

Seems like a legit answer. No need to accuse people of slinging mud.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by wpietri on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:20PM (#32567200)
Jack Dorsey's not there anymore, and the current executives clearly have a different view. So I think the question of "why now and why like this" is still open. Given how many savvy technologists use HN, I'd bet we could put together a list of thousands of companies with concerning-to-reckless security practices. But for better or worse, most of us don't end up getting our concerns on CNN.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by alvis on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:06AM (#32565114)
Looking at @paraga's response over the incidence, I don't see attacking Mudge Zatko's character does any help here. Does he know it can backfire?

https://twitter.com/donie/status/1562069281545900033

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by encryptluks2 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:03AM (#32565924)
Alleged whistleblower publicly attacks company's reputation... A okay, I hate big tech companies.

CEO of company defends organization and says previous employee has ulterior motives... Not okay, I hate big tech companies.

See a trend here?

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by _fat_santa on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:50AM (#32564907)
If you've worked for any major F500 Enterprise, this is all par for the course. Currently on a contract with a healthcare giant, while security is pretty tight because HIPPA, generally everything else is chaotic. I'm going to speculate that Twitter is probably worse than the mean, but at pretty much every large company that operates massive pieces of software, youre gonna get a ton of chaos by default.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by johndhi on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:21PM (#32567221)
this was my reaction, too. and I'd add: the legal requirement is basically to have 'industry standard' security; no more and no less. there is no legal requirement to have air tight security (which probably isn't even technically possible at a company of this scale anyway).
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jonstewart on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:00AM (#32565031)
An important detail: the whistleblower is mudge. I'm at a bit of a loss for words comparing him to Ken Paxton.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by factorialboy on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:46AM (#32564848)
> Especially since the Whistleblower seems to basically be blowing the whilst on himself.

Whistleblowers are by definition insiders.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by SilverBirch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:20AM (#32565311)
Sure, but it's not normally the guy in charge of security that gets to complain the security isn't good enough.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by zhengyi13 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:58AM (#32565863)
I seem to read fairly often about security folk (or even plain ol' sysadmins) bemoaning their companies' security, like their presence or oversight is a box checking exercise rather than a real commitment.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by bombcar on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:05AM (#32565947)
Being in charge of security usually means two things:

1. You find out all the problems. 2. You can't fix all of them (many reasons here, not all malicious) and are setup to take the fall.

Rinse and repeat.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by chihuahua on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:01AM (#32565040)
Yes, but that's not the point here.

A typical whistleblower would say "There were security problems, and the head of security ignored them."

Here, it's "I was the head of security, and security was shitty. I was doing a shitty job, and that's a terrible scandal!"

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by pb7 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:15AM (#32565245)
He tried to change things and was stopped by people actually in power (CEO, the board). Being head of security means nothing if you aren't allowed to do your job. He was also there for less than 2 years. If you read the article, you'll find that Twitter has had awful security practices since at least 2010.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by encryptluks2 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:07AM (#32565984)
How do you know that? The only way you'd find out is if there is a lawsuit that exposes said information. Everyone here is assuming because they want to believe Twitter is an evil behemoth. I'm not suggesting they are wrong, but this guy could have done the bare minimum for all we know thinking his status gave him basically a free income to do almost nothing. I would wait until more information comes out before making such generalized assumptions.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by prophesi on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:22AM (#32566234)
We're all speculating here.

But if I were a betting man, I do think both Twitter and Mudge's respective track records would place me in Mudge's camp.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by josefresco on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:27PM (#32567301)
I don't know Mudge and neither does 99.9% of the public. His timing here is suspect. If these problems existed for so long, why now?
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by prophesi on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:50PM (#32567639)
I'm not sure why any sizeable portion of the public would know _any_ reputable cyber security experts. Twitter's CEO said the firing was due to "the impact on top priority work", and whistleblowing 6 months later isn't a surprising timeline when you need to have long talks with an attorney and get your own work-life situated.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by josefresco on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:31PM (#32570168)
Mudge specifically referenced Musk in his complaint. This isn't just 6 months of due diligence it's targeted and timed for maximum damage.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by prophesi on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @07:15PM (#32572840)
That's probably the only thing that could lend Twitter any credence. Though, I'm not sure if they published the 200 page complaint, but none of the news outlets have said that he specifically references Musk, just that Twitter employees weren't aware of the amount of bots on the platform and were discouraged from doing so.

I did find one say that the complaint was already in progress before Musk's deal, and Musk rightly tried to subpoena Mudge for his recent exit. It does sound reasonable that the bot comment was added in light of the fiasco with Musk's deal.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by pb7 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:50PM (#32567638)
He just got fired in January. Preparing a 200-page legal document with references and accounts takes time. It had been submitted some time ago, it's only now that CNN got a hold of a copy.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by encryptluks2 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:56AM (#32576667)
A 200 page document may take some time, but we don't know how the document is even formatted. Have they even released a copy? It could be 200 pages but only 20 pages of basic accusations with no real details for all we know, just pandering to congress and a bunch of email threads trying to indicate something without any context. I still would advise everyone to withhold judgement at this time.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by pb7 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:43AM (#32566601)
I'm relaying information from the article based on the 200-page document sent to government agencies. Everything else is speculation based on nothing.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:30AM (#32565451)
As others have said, being head of security is meaningless if the people in charge of actually making changes refuse to make the changes you prescribe.

I've been in that situation at a previous job. The infrastructure for our service was set up so that EC2 instances would start up and pull their code from a central repo. But this repo was open to the world and did not require authentication. It was only a matter of time before some malicious user discovered this and our proprietary server code got leaked.

It took weeks of hounding and escalating until something changed, and at first all they did was change the security groups to limit where you could connect from, and even the first patch merely limited it to a few /8 and /16 CIDRs that covered massive swaths of AWS-owned IPs. They still didn't require authentication.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by msh on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:11AM (#32565192)
Its more like "I was head of security and the CEO blocked me and tried preventing me reporting the true state of affairs to the board."
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by SilverBirch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:26AM (#32565397)
I think the thing about reporting things to the board is extremely open to interpretation. The board doesn't need to know absolutely every skeleton in the closet - especially if you're aware and in the process of fixing something.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by PurpleRamen on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:31AM (#32565459)
It's not his responsibility if someone with more power is sabotaging his work. He tried to do his work, realized it was not possible, and escalated to a higher authority. A bit unusual, but technically a way to maybe solve the problem and still do the job at the end.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by raxxorraxor on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:34AM (#32566433)
To be honest, Twitter didn't manage expectations. If I register on such a platform, I expect my mail/pwd combination to stay reasonably safe. Reasonably, because there is never a guarantee.

The rest of these expectations are entirely on the users. If people take security as seriously as they proclaim, they should not have registered. To now demand meticulous access controls sounds a bit neglectful to me...

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by mcqueenjordan on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:52AM (#32564922)
It takes time to compile documents and write these things.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by happyopossum on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:15AM (#32566120)
You’re ascribing the worst possible motives to someone based on your hatred of Elon Musk. Someone who has no known relationship with Musk, who has claimed publicly they started this process before Musk was involved with twitter, and who is a long standing and well regarded figure in the infosec world.

I think you’re gonna need more than Musk Derangement Syndrome fueled conspiracy theories to make your accusations stick here.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by itsoktocry on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:34AM (#32566441)
>You’re ascribing the worst possible motives to someone based on your hatred of Elon Musk.

I'm not going to claim some big conspiracy here, but I do find this beyond coincidence.

I don't think that this is coming out now because Mudge is acting on behalf of Elon. I think Elon's Twitter bid (and ensuing drama and upcoming lawsuit) and this revelation are part of the same agenda. For better or worse, it looks like influential powers that be are going to take down/over Twitter.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by the_doctah on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:25PM (#32568142)
>it looks like influential powers that be are going to take down/over Twitter

Let them, Twitter can't get any worse.

At the very least, lets get to the bottom of the bot problem and expose these companies who rely on bot activity to drive their MAU numbers and as a result, their inflated valuations.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by toss1 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:54AM (#32564964)
>> thing that caused Ken Paxton in Texas to start investigating Twitter?

Immediately thought of this item that came up in my Twitter news feed last week [0]

>> "Elon Musk went to Kevin McCarthy’s Party last night in Wyoming—to celebrate Liz Cheney’s loss. While speaking at the MAGA party, Musk asked everyone to deny that he was there. Musk made sure that no press was allowed anywhere near the property — then people started posting selfies"

I'm sure Musk wasn't there to privately insult the Republican leaders by acting like they're the ugly person that they'll date in private but don't want anyone knowing about — he's almost surely seeking some kind of influence/benefit.

Maybe coincidence, but I certainly wonder about the purpose?

[0] https://twitter.com/FriendEden100/status/1559974086264209414

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jmeister on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:41AM (#32564790)
Did you read the article before slinging mud yourself? The whistleblower has been communicating with DC way before EM entered the picture.

Media only got its hands on the leaked material now.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jjulius on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:51AM (#32565751)
Not exactly. The CNN article doesn't say that, and The Verge's piece[1] on this puts it together pretty clearly.

>Zatko was fired by Twitter in January and claims that this was retaliation for his refusal to stay quiet about the company’s vulnerabilities. Last month, he filed a complaint with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that accuses Twitter of deceiving shareholders and violating an agreement it made with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to uphold certain security standards. His complaints, totaling more than 200 pages, were obtained by CNN and The Washington Post and published in redacted form this morning.

So, breaking it down more concisely:

1.) Fired in January

2.) Musk tries to buy Twitter in early April

3.) Complaint filed with SEC in July by Mudge ("way [after] EM entered the picture")

4.) WaPo published redacted, 200-page report today

[1]https://www.theverge.com/2022/8/23/23317857/twitter-whistleb...

Edit: This is not an endorsement of mud-slinging, just an attempt to make sure everyone knows what actually happened and when, at least as best we can discern at this point.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by semiquaver on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:23AM (#32574956)
From the complaint (pg 9):

  > Please note that Mudge began preparing these disclosures in
  > early March 2022, well before Mr. Musk expressed any 
  > interest in acquiring Twitter, and has not communicated 
  > these disclosures to anyone with a financial interest 
  > in Twitter.
Why debate what the timelines implied by various articles are when the primary source is available and makes a clear statement on this matter?
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jjulius on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @09:08AM (#32578966)
>Why debate what the timelines implied by various articles are when the primary source is available and makes a clear statement on this matter?

Probably because most of us in the chain you're replying to didn't have the time to read an 84-page source document in the middle of a work day (note the time of our comments and how late to this particular chain you are), hoping that a nugget of information like that would be dropped pretty early on in it. Hence my edit at the end, which I had hoped would have made it clear that I was open to being corrected.

But thank you so much for that snarky comment while you clarified things. You're so much better than us for finding that, how could we have ever been so daft? Forgive us?

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by semiquaver on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @08:20PM (#32587707)
I didn’t intend any snark, it was an honest question.

Apologies for having offended you.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jjulius on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @10:45PM (#32588809)
Nah, I think it's my fault. I have realized this week that I'm dealing with a lot of tough shit and haven't been handling it well. I think I've taken to looking for arguments on HN (and other places) as an outlet and, in hindsight, I am pretty sure that was one of those moments.

It's not fair to you, and I'm sorry. Hope ya have a great rest of the week. :)

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by semiquaver on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:41AM (#32607395)
Props for being vulnerable and introspective, which is not always easy.

Here’s hoping you overcome the things you are struggling with!

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jjulius on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:18PM (#32625446)
Cheers. :)
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jacquesm on Thursday August 25, 2022 @04:19AM (#32591038)
Thank you for this comment.

And much good luck with your situation.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by jjulius on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:36PM (#32596227)
:)
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by SilverBirch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:32AM (#32565478)
I read the article, and it doesn't say what you said.

>Zatko began the whistleblower process before there was any indication of Musk’s involvement

Define "Began the whistleblower process". Because that seems like an extremely fuzzy way of saying this. And even if you accept that he was genuinely a whistleblower in good faith trying to do this, which I'm perfectly willing to accept, the fact it's coming out in public now is still convenient timing.

It does say

>The disclosure, sent last month

Which means that the actual firm date we have coincides perfectly with Musk's legal wranglings.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by labcomputer on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:38AM (#32565557)
And they say the Tesla fans are a cult... I'm at a loss for words.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by gonzo41 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:45AM (#32564831)
In real life, if you're in the public square shouting your opinions at whomever will listen it's somewhat risky. Twitter are just providing the same digital risk for the modern public square. It's a feature, not a bug.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by agentultra on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:40AM (#32564777)
This was my first thought. TFA claims he started the whistleblower process before the Musk deal was signed. Seems kind of fishy though.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by pb7 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:16AM (#32565253)
Maybe, just maybe, Twitter is actually a poorly run company and it's not a conspiracy.
[dead]
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TeeMassive on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:46AM (#32565675)
I don't remember conservatives threatening Twitter to censor "dangerous" views or "misinformation" or telling who to ban.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by themitigating on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:43AM (#32566590)
They push for censorship of pornographic material, which is less dangerous than misinformation about vaccines.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TeeMassive on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:34PM (#32568276)
What's the problem with making public pages SFW?
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by themitigating on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:25AM (#32575563)
It's censorship
[dead]
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by kmeisthax on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:42PM (#32567523)
Bigger example: Donald Trump called Net Neutrality "Obamacare for the Internet", back when the bug-bear was Comcast rather than FAANG.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TeeMassive on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:39PM (#32568339)
Ending the enforcement of Net Neutrality was not about censoring content or subjects.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by kmeisthax on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:05PM (#32569700)
The specific worry about Net Neutrality was that ISPs would use their monopoly power to censor specific sources and/or self-preference their own businesses. It's something that should have been expanded to large online platforms rather than being disposed of entirely.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TeeMassive on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:38PM (#32572512)
As you said, it was a worry, but ending Net Neutrality about enforcing government censorship was never even an argument being made at all by any sides of the issue.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by kmeisthax on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @07:32PM (#32572999)
Justice Brett Kavanaugh[0] argued that Net Neutrality specifically violated the 1st Amendment because Comcast should decide what speech they do and don't retransmit.

[0] https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/01/judge-argues-net-neutralit...

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TeeMassive on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:36PM (#32568291)
You are making a false comparison. They refused to write a particular message, not to not serve the customer a cake.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Bud on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:37PM (#32573996)
False. Get your facts straight before misstating established facts in public. The baker in fact refused to make any cake whatsoever for a same-sex wedding. If you are fuzzy on this, watch the interview with the baker himself in this article:

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/04/us/politics/supreme-court...

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Banana699 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:07PM (#32567000)
Because a random bakery shop is totally like a pseudo-monopolistic social media giant that can censor millions arbitarily and at will.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by themitigating on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:47PM (#32567601)
it's not a monopoly because there are alternatives, and it only has a 10% market share in the US (https://gs.statcounter.com/social-media-stats/all/united-sta...).

The bakery also sets precedent as it did go to the supreme court, and it was used as a rallying cry by politicians on the right.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Banana699 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:21PM (#32568958)
So, in simpler words, they are indeed a pseudo-monopolistic (pseudo means apparent, something very close to but not quite there) social media giant that can indeed censor millions (10% of USA's population is 30 millions) arbitarily and at will ? Ok :)

And whether a bakery serves your gay wedding or not is perhaps the most petty and inconsequential thing to be upset about. There are thousands upon thousands of bakeries in a large city. You can learn how to bake a cake in a weekend and home-bake your wedding cake yourself, or any one of your wedding guests can do this as a wedding gift. You can go to a no-gays-allowed bakery but simply not tell them you're gay, and take a finished cake from them then write your own name and that of the guy you will marry on it yourself. You can not get cake at all and instead get any of the thousand other types of wedding sweets and food.

It's almost like the whole thing is a hilarious non-issue that some people just invented to cry and act like victims about.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by pb7 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:27PM (#32569052)
Monopoly on what?

There are not thousands of bakeries in any city. Many towns might have none, or one. In that regard, the bakery will have an actual monopoly on baked goods to people living there.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Jensson on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:53PM (#32569482)
The baker is a person with rights as well, you can't force him to make a special order cake for something he disagrees with. You can force him to sell standard cakes, and they offered to sell standard cakes in the case, but the customers wanted to force him to make a designed cake, that would be against the bakers individual rights.

Large corporations lacks those individual rights for obvious reasons, so large corporations should be forced to provide services to everyone even though individuals shouldn't always be.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Banana699 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:55PM (#32569514)
>Monopoly on what?

On users. Any network is worth a function of the number of nodes in it (typically a quadratic). Social Media are networks that link humans, and there is a finite number of humans (or, more accurately, internet-connected humans with time to spare) that grows very slowly and inevitably will stagnate. That means a social network is in direct zero-sum competition with all the other networks, and a giant like twitter hurts everybody else by concentrating a signficant proportion of users into a single (aweful) place, destroying competition by the lock-in effects of network dynamics.

>There are not thousands of bakeries in any city

There are in my city, actually. Dialing the number down to the hundreds or the high tens doesn't signficantly change the validity and implications of the argument either.

> In that regard, the bakery will have an actual monopoly on baked goods to people living there.

If you can actually prove that in a court, and if you furthermore prove that the complaining party will incur significant costs to themselves if they try to seek another bakery elsewhere (by a resonable legal definition of 'significant'), then you have my full blessing to force people to bake your cake.

Until then, comparing an easily-replacable food product with tons of suppliers and publicly-available recipes to a proprietary service supplied by a corporation with thousands of servers, thousands of employees and tens of millions of users is ideologically motivated bullshit.

Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Bud on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:39PM (#32574013)
Discrimination against gays may be "petty" for you, but actually, you're the petty one for saying that.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by themitigating on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:27AM (#32575578)
Again, it set a legal precedent and it's a restriction on freedom there shouldn't be a threshold to care
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by Banana699 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @09:07AM (#32578949)
It has to be an impressive kind of hypocrisy to panic about individuals refusing to associate with individuals out of their own free will and freak out hysterically about "restrictions on freedom"... then turn around and cheer on massive corporations censoring individuals with no oversight or recourse.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by TimCTRL on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:21AM (#32565326)
Musk's account was among those that were hacked in the 2020 high profile hack. He made the offer in 2022, he therefore can't claim to not have known that twitter's security isn't 100% and really can't use this in court, I guess
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by rtkwe on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:25AM (#32565386)
The contract Musk signed was very very one sided, from everything I've been reading there's very little Musk can claim that would let him scuttle the deal.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by phlhr on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:13PM (#32569827)
the contract does not allow twitter to commit fraud. Which they have.
Re:Ex-Twitter exec blows the whistle, alleging reckless cybe... by rtkwe on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:49PM (#32582152)
How vague and impossible to meaningfully argue. What specifically do you claim they've been fraudulent about?