According to his lawyer as reported by someone on Twitter. IIRC, lawyers make statements that guilty clients are innocent all the time.
If he was working with Musk help him wiggle out of the Twitter deal, it would fatally undermine the goal for to come out publicly about the relationship. I'm skeptical unless they can provide verifiable 3rd party evidence (e.g. some document filed before the deal).
Seems like a legit answer. No need to accuse people of slinging mud.
CEO of company defends organization and says previous employee has ulterior motives... Not okay, I hate big tech companies.
See a trend here?
Whistleblowers are by definition insiders.
1. You find out all the problems. 2. You can't fix all of them (many reasons here, not all malicious) and are setup to take the fall.
Rinse and repeat.
A typical whistleblower would say "There were security problems, and the head of security ignored them."
Here, it's "I was the head of security, and security was shitty. I was doing a shitty job, and that's a terrible scandal!"
But if I were a betting man, I do think both Twitter and Mudge's respective track records would place me in Mudge's camp.
I did find one say that the complaint was already in progress before Musk's deal, and Musk rightly tried to subpoena Mudge for his recent exit. It does sound reasonable that the bot comment was added in light of the fiasco with Musk's deal.
I've been in that situation at a previous job. The infrastructure for our service was set up so that EC2 instances would start up and pull their code from a central repo. But this repo was open to the world and did not require authentication. It was only a matter of time before some malicious user discovered this and our proprietary server code got leaked.
It took weeks of hounding and escalating until something changed, and at first all they did was change the security groups to limit where you could connect from, and even the first patch merely limited it to a few /8 and /16 CIDRs that covered massive swaths of AWS-owned IPs. They still didn't require authentication.
The rest of these expectations are entirely on the users. If people take security as seriously as they proclaim, they should not have registered. To now demand meticulous access controls sounds a bit neglectful to me...
I think you’re gonna need more than Musk Derangement Syndrome fueled conspiracy theories to make your accusations stick here.
I'm not going to claim some big conspiracy here, but I do find this beyond coincidence.
I don't think that this is coming out now because Mudge is acting on behalf of Elon. I think Elon's Twitter bid (and ensuing drama and upcoming lawsuit) and this revelation are part of the same agenda. For better or worse, it looks like influential powers that be are going to take down/over Twitter.
Let them, Twitter can't get any worse.
At the very least, lets get to the bottom of the bot problem and expose these companies who rely on bot activity to drive their MAU numbers and as a result, their inflated valuations.
Immediately thought of this item that came up in my Twitter news feed last week [0]
>> "Elon Musk went to Kevin McCarthy’s Party last night in Wyoming—to celebrate Liz Cheney’s loss. While speaking at the MAGA party, Musk asked everyone to deny that he was there. Musk made sure that no press was allowed anywhere near the property — then people started posting selfies"
I'm sure Musk wasn't there to privately insult the Republican leaders by acting like they're the ugly person that they'll date in private but don't want anyone knowing about — he's almost surely seeking some kind of influence/benefit.
Maybe coincidence, but I certainly wonder about the purpose?
[0] https://twitter.com/FriendEden100/status/1559974086264209414
Media only got its hands on the leaked material now.
>Zatko was fired by Twitter in January and claims that this was retaliation for his refusal to stay quiet about the company’s vulnerabilities. Last month, he filed a complaint with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that accuses Twitter of deceiving shareholders and violating an agreement it made with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to uphold certain security standards. His complaints, totaling more than 200 pages, were obtained by CNN and The Washington Post and published in redacted form this morning.
So, breaking it down more concisely:
1.) Fired in January
2.) Musk tries to buy Twitter in early April
3.) Complaint filed with SEC in July by Mudge ("way [after] EM entered the picture")
4.) WaPo published redacted, 200-page report today
[1]https://www.theverge.com/2022/8/23/23317857/twitter-whistleb...
Edit: This is not an endorsement of mud-slinging, just an attempt to make sure everyone knows what actually happened and when, at least as best we can discern at this point.
> Please note that Mudge began preparing these disclosures in
> early March 2022, well before Mr. Musk expressed any
> interest in acquiring Twitter, and has not communicated
> these disclosures to anyone with a financial interest
> in Twitter.
Why debate what the timelines implied by various articles are when the primary source is available and makes a clear statement on this matter?Probably because most of us in the chain you're replying to didn't have the time to read an 84-page source document in the middle of a work day (note the time of our comments and how late to this particular chain you are), hoping that a nugget of information like that would be dropped pretty early on in it. Hence my edit at the end, which I had hoped would have made it clear that I was open to being corrected.
But thank you so much for that snarky comment while you clarified things. You're so much better than us for finding that, how could we have ever been so daft? Forgive us?
Apologies for having offended you.
It's not fair to you, and I'm sorry. Hope ya have a great rest of the week. :)
Here’s hoping you overcome the things you are struggling with!
And much good luck with your situation.
>Zatko began the whistleblower process before there was any indication of Musk’s involvement
Define "Began the whistleblower process". Because that seems like an extremely fuzzy way of saying this. And even if you accept that he was genuinely a whistleblower in good faith trying to do this, which I'm perfectly willing to accept, the fact it's coming out in public now is still convenient timing.
It does say
>The disclosure, sent last month
Which means that the actual firm date we have coincides perfectly with Musk's legal wranglings.
[0] https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/01/judge-argues-net-neutralit...
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/04/us/politics/supreme-court...
The bakery also sets precedent as it did go to the supreme court, and it was used as a rallying cry by politicians on the right.
And whether a bakery serves your gay wedding or not is perhaps the most petty and inconsequential thing to be upset about. There are thousands upon thousands of bakeries in a large city. You can learn how to bake a cake in a weekend and home-bake your wedding cake yourself, or any one of your wedding guests can do this as a wedding gift. You can go to a no-gays-allowed bakery but simply not tell them you're gay, and take a finished cake from them then write your own name and that of the guy you will marry on it yourself. You can not get cake at all and instead get any of the thousand other types of wedding sweets and food.
It's almost like the whole thing is a hilarious non-issue that some people just invented to cry and act like victims about.
There are not thousands of bakeries in any city. Many towns might have none, or one. In that regard, the bakery will have an actual monopoly on baked goods to people living there.
Large corporations lacks those individual rights for obvious reasons, so large corporations should be forced to provide services to everyone even though individuals shouldn't always be.
On users. Any network is worth a function of the number of nodes in it (typically a quadratic). Social Media are networks that link humans, and there is a finite number of humans (or, more accurately, internet-connected humans with time to spare) that grows very slowly and inevitably will stagnate. That means a social network is in direct zero-sum competition with all the other networks, and a giant like twitter hurts everybody else by concentrating a signficant proportion of users into a single (aweful) place, destroying competition by the lock-in effects of network dynamics.
>There are not thousands of bakeries in any city
There are in my city, actually. Dialing the number down to the hundreds or the high tens doesn't signficantly change the validity and implications of the argument either.
> In that regard, the bakery will have an actual monopoly on baked goods to people living there.
If you can actually prove that in a court, and if you furthermore prove that the complaining party will incur significant costs to themselves if they try to seek another bakery elsewhere (by a resonable legal definition of 'significant'), then you have my full blessing to force people to bake your cake.
Until then, comparing an easily-replacable food product with tons of suppliers and publicly-available recipes to a proprietary service supplied by a corporation with thousands of servers, thousands of employees and tens of millions of users is ideologically motivated bullshit.
What happened that caused him to suddenly start whistleblowing now, and not in January? Was it the same thing that caused Ken Paxton in Texas to start investigating Twitter?
This just looks like pretty plain mud-slinging from Musk's team to be honest. Especially since the Whistleblower seems to basically be blowing the whilst on himself.