News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by akmarinov on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:01PM (#32526495)
And that's why we should open up stores by law if necessary.

Apple shouldn't be the one to tell me what kind of apps I can have on the device I've bought with my money.

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by fzfaa on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:05PM (#32526538)
You already knew what you were getting into when you bought it, and Apple is far from having a monopoly.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by BitwiseFool on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:25PM (#32526751)
I feel like this is a counter productive non-solution. The free market, in this case, isn't as free and full of competition as we would like. Smartphone OS's are basically a duopoly, and Android has serious challenges of its own.

That being said, a choice has to be made because two different entities have mutually exclusive rights: Do you side with an individuals' right to install whatever they want on a device they purchased? Or, a large company's right to restrict devices however they see fit?

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by Goosey on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:55PM (#32527053)
Personally I side with an individuals' right to install whatever they want on a device they purchased. Without that "right to repair" individuals are only renting their devices from a duopoly. Very unsatisfying!
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by trebbble on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:45PM (#32526952)
There's competition of regulatory regimes—mandatory and strict (could be stricter, IMO) vs. optional and looser.

Absent government outlawing a bunch of the bad behavior Apple tries to curb, I like being free to have that choice to opt into their regime. When corporate dragnet spying and other hostile bullshit is outlawed and the laws are effectively enforced, sure, I'd want Apple to tear down the walls on their garden.

(please don't just post "but you wouldn't have to use alt stores!" in response—it's been done to death on here, and everywhere else, differences opinion are apparently irreconcilable and we're not likely to gain any ground here today, and Android's still kickin', so the option for that kind of environment does exist for those who want it)

Amusingly, advocacy of optional regulatory regimes enforced by corporations is usually a right-Libertarian position. Not that that's necessarily a point in its favor (see again: I'd much prefer this crap simply be illegal) but those folks do love free markets.

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by stale2002 on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:10PM (#32527198)
> There's competition of regulatory regimes—mandatory and strict

Ok, well then there is similarly competition of regulator regimes in the literal sense.

> I like being free to have that choice to opt into their regime

Different governments, are competing with different set of laws. I like the fact that I can have these government laws.

And if Apple does not like these laws, then it can opt out of the EU market, when their laws come into effect.

They can opt into a different country, by not selling their product in a place that has laws that they don't like.

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by eastof on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:42PM (#32526921)
Except that it takes 5 mins even for a non-technical person to install CalyxOS and you get full control over your device and what apps you install using between FDroid and Aurora Store with 100% feature parity with mainline Android.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by Aeolun on Friday August 19, 2022 @08:12PM (#32527640)
Sure, it’s only half of a Duopoly. So if you don’t like Apple you have exactly one other option.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by CharlesW on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:38PM (#32526873)
> Apple shouldn't be the one to tell me what kind of apps I can have on the device I've bought with my money.

I'm confused. Did you buy an iPhone not knowing that it's not a general purpose computer?

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by ThatPlayer on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:49PM (#32527499)
Because the environment and therefore opinions change over time, and Apple App Store purchase lock-in is a high barrier of entry to switch to different ecosystem.

For example, when I purchased my device, Fortnite was still available on the device, and Apple wasn't actively blocking Xbox's Cloud Streaming (back then it was xCloud Beta)

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by detaro on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:40PM (#32526891)
How would that preclude the belief that Apple shouldn't do that?
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by CharlesW on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:53PM (#32527035)
Anyone can believe anything, but if one is buying products that don't do what they need or want, that seems like a poor use of funds.

Example: I can buy an Xbox and curse Microsoft that I can't play The Last of Us on it, but that's really on me.

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by detaro on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:00PM (#32527095)
In plenty product categories its basically impossible to find a product by a company that doesn't do something that it "shouldn't" do, and nevertheless picking one of them is still better than not picking any.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by stale2002 on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:05PM (#32527146)
Well there is an alternative solution. That alternative solution being to force Apple, under threat of legal action and massive fines, to do what we want them to do (using the legal and legislative process).
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by CharlesW on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:20PM (#32527280)
Giving nation-states control over how Apple runs their business in their countries based on what a tiny sliver of the most technically-adept users wants will somehow engender freedom. Is that the pitch?
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by stale2002 on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:43PM (#32527461)
> Giving nation-states control over how Apple runs their business ... based on

If you don't like the political process then you can vote for someone else, who will pass the right laws, or appoint the right people to make such laws.

If you don't like the legal process, then do that, leave the country, or do business elsewhere.

Countries have a right to have laws that regulate companies. The population does not belong to Apple.

That population has a right to run their country how they see fit, regardless of the objections of Apple.

And if Apple tries to get around the law, you can expect them to suffer billions and billions of dollars of fines, or further legal consequences. Countries do not belong to Apple, and they have no right to get around the legal process.

Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by yellowapple on Friday August 19, 2022 @09:20PM (#32528108)
Apple - like every corporation incorporated here in the United States - would literally not exist if it wasn't granted recognition as such by at least one nation-state. God forbid there be some conditions on that massive privilege.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by Bud on Friday August 19, 2022 @10:29PM (#32528446)
Conversely, though: what gives you the belief that you should get to dictate to companies built and run by other people the way in which they run their business? Why do you get to decide?
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by Apocryphon on Friday August 19, 2022 @10:36PM (#32528473)
Because they are a member of the public, and companies operate under the laws that the public deliberate upon.
Re:App Store doesn't accept “too simple” apps by Aeolun on Friday August 19, 2022 @08:14PM (#32527655)
> Did you buy an iPhone not knowing that it's not a general purpose computer?

Just because it’s the best of two bad options doesn’t mean you have to be happy with it.