News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by mostlysimilar on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:18PM (#32515029)
It would be nice if we could evacuate walled-garden social media platforms and return to individual websites/blogs + RSS. RSS clients that empower the user to follow, sort, filter, and control their "news feed" of content from individual websites/blogs.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by foresto on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:40PM (#32516106)
I would love this, or something like it, but I don't think it can happen until hosting is effectively free and managing it is dead easy.

Not everyone has access to a $100 server, reliable power, and unmetered internet, let alone the knowledge and time to be their own sysadmin.

What if organizations in a position to do so, from mobile phone operators to ISPs to public libraries, provided some basic level of content hosting with standardized content management APIs? People with the means and motivation could host their own, but most people wouldn't have to. Perhaps that could pave the way for universal front-end tools and independence from the social media giants?

Related: It looks like someone is trying to address the issue by layering a social media experience atop an existing distributed messaging system (Matrix): https://www.kombuchaprivacy.com/circles/

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by Schroedingersat on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:24PM (#32517066)
Federated protocols serve this purpose, and fediverse has clients with many of the features people use in social media.

Then for actual social networks, things like briar or manyverse are perfectly functional and only lack network effect.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by ggariepy on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:50PM (#32517177)
The problem is the network effect IS the game. Without it, you can have a perfectly functional but essentially useless social media application. MeWe comes to mind for me. I thought it would be a perfect Facebook replacement. I thought wrong. With a user community in the mere hundreds of thousands (last I checked) virtually nobody you know is on MeWe, even though technically they have all the bells and whistles Facebook does, and they pledge not to sell your information.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by Schroedingersat on Friday August 19, 2022 @08:56PM (#32527939)
Another private company is just going to do the same things, pledge or no.

For actually community owned protocols (an example is matrix or fediverse), someone has to go first. May as well be you.

Make an account, ask a community group to be contactable without signing over your private info, get a couple of friends to do the same.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by nonrandomstring on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:58PM (#32515378)
I like your use of the word "evacuate".

Recently I came upon the the phrase "cloud repatriation", which seemed a fresh angle on a word that's fallen on hard times.

Evacuate! Yes we need a Dunkirk for those helpless souls left on the beaches of Facebook. The idea that they're going to swim, one by one, back the safety of personal web pages is silly.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by function_seven on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:59PM (#32515388)
Bring back MySpace exactly as it was in 2005. Yeah, even with the XSS and other craziness. That was part of the adventure!

(Okay, okay, maybe a bit more work on security, but don't go so far as to make it bland.)

Maybe I my lenses are rose tinted, but that era of social media was fun.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by 800xl on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:33PM (#32516796)
Part of the fun of MySpace was customizing your page with backgrounds, music, moving your top 10 friends around, etc. I sometimes think there is a niche market for this kind of social media again, adapted for mobile devices.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by xwdv on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:34PM (#32516472)
We did. It was called spacehey.com and for a while it was a novelty then people got bored and left.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by chestervonwinch on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:04PM (#32515881)
I'm upset they lost all their photo and music data. Going back to old pages feels like visiting an abandoned mall.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by leephillips on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:25PM (#32515100)
Is anything preventing you from just doing it? There are plenty of RSS/Atom readers.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lancesells on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:34PM (#32515172)
I don't use any social media and I've found that many businesses at least neglect their website and quite understandably resort to posting on social media. The few local news sites that I use usually will have an article about a business or a news story and then link to instagram or twitter rather than their website.

I don't feel like I'm missing out on anything but the usefulness of the web lessens year over year. Now that the platforms have locked down even viewing an instagram or twitter fee without an account I almost wish I could just get rid of all links pointing to them.

The easiest thing would be to give in an make an account but I'm too stubborn ha.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by johannes1234321 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:10PM (#32515482)
During the pandemic lockdowns I found that reactivating my Facebook account was the best way to figure out if a shop did still exist and how they changed their opening hours ... websites unmaintained all in the walled garden. And looking at my "news feed" reminded me that I don't really miss anything from there.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by JohnFen on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:58PM (#32515832)
I figure that any business that effectively only communicates using social media is a business that actively doesn't want me as a customer.

Good riddance.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lancesells on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:20PM (#32516374)
I don't agree with that and think you should reconsider. There are only so many hours a day for most small businesses and they get the most out of social media compared to their website plus theirs a strong chance they themselves or their employees can use instagram compared to something like squarespace.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by JohnFen on Friday August 19, 2022 @11:59AM (#32522652)
I have no moral obligation to support social media companies (who I have serious ethical issues with) simply because there are businesses who choose to use them as their sole communications platforms.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by giobox on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:29PM (#32515136)
In my experience, RSS isn't close to the level of widespread high quality support it had in the early "web2.0" days on the server side - picking an RSS client even with the demise of Google Reader hasn't been my issue with RSS in recent years anyway, its just the content isn't there anymore like it once was.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by rakoo on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:35PM (#32515185)
People I want to follow don't have the technical chops to self-host. One can say it's sad, but I think it's worse that one needs technical chops to self-host.

Come up with a way for anyone to publish content from their phone, with no subscription, and no need for an always-on server, and you'll have the basis for something less centralized.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by kixiQu on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:06PM (#32515450)
Tumblr's owned by Automattic now, and they're throwing in some Indieweb features ([this] doesn't look official, but it actually is!). It also has proper RSS. Using a platform like that rather than a totally closed one like FB seems to me like a step up.

[this]: https://github.com/indieweb/tumblr

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by bluefirebrand on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:50PM (#32515319)
How do you discover people in this system, though?

And at the end of the day, there has to be some kind of server somewhere. Even if it's using SMS or DNS or something to accomplish this.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by ghaff on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:28PM (#32515124)
At least one complaint is that a lot of content has moved on. And maybe you can just ignore that content. Which I'm not sure would be wrong.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by atestu on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:30PM (#32515138)
That's fair. There are a lot of big news sites that don't have RSS anymore, like axios.com
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by IncRnd on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:46PM (#32515283)
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by giobox on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:43PM (#32515710)
Your mileage may vary, but I only ever wanted RSS feeds that provide the actual article content. Just spitting out a feed of links back to the site with headlines is not how I or many others used RSS and RSS readers wayback when. Full article feeds have all but died out now anyway, another nail in the RSS coffin for me.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by IncRnd on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:13PM (#32516688)
That's my issue as well with the RSS feeds I use. None of them are full article feeds anymore. These sorts of RSS feeds are a way I can still centralize my feed data, even though they isn't true offline copies. I think this has to do with monetization and wanting to change the text of pages ad-hoc.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by giobox on Friday August 19, 2022 @11:32AM (#32522259)
It's of course monetization. Everyone jumped on giving away their content via RSS/public APIs in the early rush to web2.0 style standards, then of course retreated from that position when it became clear directing eyeballs to the actual site and keeping those eyeballs there for as long as possible was required to maximize ad revenues, especially for sites giving away written content. The only full content feeds that really survive are the occasional blog or site that offers it as a bonus to paying subscribers.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by atestu on Friday August 19, 2022 @10:48AM (#32521682)
I don't know how you found this but I stand corrected!
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by IncRnd on Friday August 19, 2022 @11:25PM (#32528751)
No worries. I did this search on Google: https://www.google.com/search?q=axios+rss I've found this helps to find these sorts of feeds that don't easily show on the site's themselves.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by ghaff on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:43PM (#32515250)
And a lot of people who blogged more now do twitter threads. Or they just don't get started doing blogs.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by Barrin92 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:45PM (#32515271)
that nobody else is doing it. There's a reason it's called a social network. The value is in the connections, hence the dominance of platforms.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by n3storm on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:54PM (#32515339)
How do you call it when the platform replaces the social network? 80% of the content is created to acquire relevance in/to the platform not to create or consolidate meaningful relationships.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by _carbyau_ on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:08PM (#32517253)
My thoughts are to get rid of the "network" effect.

IE have a DNS where anyone can register whatever they like. That way you can send a message direct to your friend's phone with no middleman.

My invariably naïve thoughts on the SuperSimpleSecretsServer:

- Alice generates 2 publicPrivate key pairs. 1 for the SSSS and 2 for their own use.

- Alice contacts SSSS with PublicKey1.

- SSSS responds with randomstring.

- Alice privatekey1 encrypts the random string and privateKey2 encrypts her IPv6 address and sends both to SSSS.

- SSSS authenticates and stores the encrypted-IPv6-blob against that publickey.

Bob does same.

Alice and Bob exchange (PublicKey1 and PublicKey2) however they do. Alice and Bob can now query SSSS for IPv6 of the respective key(aka person they want to talk to) whenever they want.

But I honestly don't know much about crypto, security, scaling, routing, replication, who'd run it etc etc etc. I just plain don't know much....

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by f1refly on Friday August 19, 2022 @12:51AM (#32517649)
Such a thing already exists: https://www.gnunet.org/en/gns.html
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by _carbyau_ on Friday August 19, 2022 @01:53AM (#32517881)
Well for this GNS...

1. the focus is still on human readable names and converting that to an IP.

2. the IP address seems plain text to anyone who requests it. Not a key encrypted blob.

So. Not really like what I was describing at all. Maybe it could be tweaked to behave like I wish and it could solve the other aspects of such a service already.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by f1refly on Friday August 19, 2022 @07:32AM (#32519741)
There are some Video presentations to GNUNet and the newest one on the GNS subcomponent mentions "Record confidentiality" - Values in the Table are signed and encrypted by the zone owner. To query a zone you'd first have to get the key of the zone owner, accomplishing what you requested, right?

https://www.gnunet.org/en/video.html

The Videos are kind of hard to watch, so maybe the slides are enough to understand how it's supposed to work:

https://git.gnunet.org/presentations.git/plain/icann66/20191...

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by _carbyau_ on Sunday August 21, 2022 @10:21PM (#32546602)
:-) Thank you so much for that extra effort of providing information links to clearly explain concepts.

I am picturing the use case of such a service as different to how we use DNS today, but I think this would support it.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:16PM (#32515524)
I think this cannot be done with IP/TCP because of the reliance on each individual to pay for both active web servers and some kind of DNS config. It's possible to imagine other protocols that could force at least text messaging to flow over other networks. Simple text, over a simpler network protocol, might be possible. The governments could potentially force all cable companies to support it, as a requirement of being licensed. That would allow something like the text exchange that universities enjoyed in the 1980s, when the Internet was confined to universities and subsidized by the Nation Science Foundation. Or, for that matter, the government could directly subsidize something similar. But I think the protocol would have to be simpler. Just plain text, I think.

Merely keeping the current system, but wishing consumers would use it differently, is a utopian dream that is unlikely to come true. You need to look at why consumers behave the way in the current system, and then you have to imagine a different system, and that different system cannot look anything like IP/TCP/UDP.

We currently have like 8,000 RFCs. We've designed the world's most flexible system. It is very complex. I think you'd need a system simple enough that you could specify the whole thing in a 50 page document. That kind of simplicity. The simplicity should allow it to be cheap, and therefore easy to subsidize, either by the government or out of the profits of cable or phone or network companies.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by wwweston on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:54PM (#32515801)
> I think this cannot be done with IP/TCP because of the reliance on each individual to pay for both active web servers and some kind of DNS config.

You can pay someone for that, somewhere around the order of $5 a month, probably less, or free but ad-supported.

And that's more or less what Facebook is, except we pay with our data and attention on the back end rather than our dollars up front. The product might be rather different if we did pay in dollars, and for that reason I suspect digital protocols aren't the fundamental problem.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:34PM (#32516068)
Every time this conversation comes up, someone on Hacker News says "You can pay someone for that, it only costs about $5 a month." Every time. And then someone points out "$5 a month is a lot, even for some people in the developed world, and very much so in South America, Africa, and much of Asia."

$5 a month is far too expensive for most of the world, which is why so much of humanity is now in the walled-gardens like Facebook. So if we want to find a way to destroy the walled-gardens, we're going to have to find an approach that is orders of magnitude cheaper than $5 a month.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by wwweston on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:39PM (#32516504)
$5 isn't THE number. It's a number that's meant to illustrate a monthly outlay on the order of a meal -- something big enough that it might not fall below the level of consideration for some people (I can certainly remember when it was something I had to think about), but small enough that people with an income level that makes them food-secure can probably swing it. As for other places where 5 USD is a lot of money for reasons of currency and local economic conditions, they'd probably have their own markets and pricing on the order of a meal for a month of service.

Any amount will always be a sacrifice compared to free, but given that "free" actually has a cost in terms of privacy, attention, and even baseline function of the tool, there's really no free lunch here, just the currency you want to pay in. Making it actual currency lines up certain incentives better. Even if it doesn't solve the problem among, say, food insecure.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:37PM (#32517387)
"given that free actually has a cost in terms of privacy, attention"

Why? You're assuming your conclusion. A different protocol can have different starting assumptions.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by Schroedingersat on Friday August 19, 2022 @01:57AM (#32517897)
A $3/mo vps can serve tens or even hundreds of blogs. Static hosting is even cheaper. This should really be a function of libraries.

Then there's fediverse or even briar or manyverse that work without internet.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by switchbak on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:18PM (#32515977)
Huh? How does: "because of the reliance on each individual to pay for both active web servers and some kind of DNS config"

translate into (roughly): "network protocols are too complex, I want simple text only"?

I just don't see how those are related, why we'd have to restrict ourselves to text, why IP is somehow not "enough", etc.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:31PM (#32516053)
I think you read my comment backwards. You wrote:

why IP is somehow not "enough"

How did you get that from my comment? I said we have almost 8,000 RFCs, IP is very robust, but in its complexity there is a certain minimum, unavoidable expense. If we're looking for a protocol that is cheaper, and therefore easier to subsidize, I'd guess that we need a spec so simple that you could write it out in a 50 page document.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by switchbak on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:10PM (#32516673)
Ok, I get the last part, bad choice of words on "enough".

But the idea that we can't have a grassroots socially networked connection of computers on the internet because of the protocols? I just don't see how you've made a case for that. I certainly don't see why it'd have to be text only.

The complexity of the internet has grown organically based on responding to limitations (mostly). No doubt there's some unnecessary complexity in there, but what you're talking about is essentially throwing everything away. I just don't see how you've made a compelling case for such an expensive proposition.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:36PM (#32517374)
"for such an expensive proposition"

We need something cheaper than what we have now. People gravitate to walled gardens like Facebook because setting up their own systems is too expensive.

"No doubt there's some unnecessary complexity in there"

At no point did I mention the unnecessary complexity of IP/TCP/UDP, I'm not sure where you got that. I'm only talking about the necessary complexity. It's a great protocol that enables the modern Web. But it is complex enough that there is some expense to setting everything up, and that is why humanity ends up in walled gardens like Facebook. If you want to destroy the walled gardens, then you will need a simpler, cheaper protocol.

Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by immibis on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:51PM (#32515770)
IPv4 doesn't help. If every PC had an IP address, you could have a blog on your own PC, leaving it on overnight - even a laptop.
Re:To Hell with Facebook (2021) by lkrubner on Friday August 19, 2022 @03:43AM (#32518446)
Absolutely. That used to be much more possible back around 1993. The limitations of IPv4 are certainly a contributing factor.