An open, permissionless, and GLOBAL monetary network for final settlement and small payments (and micropayments) which no single competing nation state has unilateral control over would be a game changer for fintech innovation. The function of everything from Visa/Mastercard, Fedwire, SWIFT, Paypal, Western Union, etc, all rebase onto one global network with countless businesses competing on top of it to provide the most appealing user experience.
BTC and Crypto at large don't seem like a viable alternative solution, or even a solution to any real problem at all.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bOo3zLFhEk
For small payments, lightning is instant and extremely low fee. For larger payments that you want certainty of settlement, even a few hours confirmation time is drastically superior to traditional settlement networks that take days if not weeks internationally. FYI, your credit card payments are instant, but not finally settled. That happens in periodic bulk batches between banks.
https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/
Even the Fed is on top of trying to understand this, https://www.clevelandfed.org/~/media/content/newsroom%20and%...
Money arrives instantly, and as far as a retail customer is concerned, it settles instantly. Under the hood their regular batch settlement between banks, but that doesn’t matter to a retail customer, because the money is instantly withdraw-able, and covered by government deposit protection the moment the faster payment appears on your bank statement (which is milliseconds after the payment is initiated by the sender).
Why would I want to mess around with Bitcoins, when I already have access to fast, secure, cheap, money transfers to any UK bank account?
Or else what? They'll deposit some money into your account? The biggest reason bank accounts are semi-secret in the US is free-for-all ACH pulls; a minimal threat in other countries due to the fundamental differences on who is liable for unauthorized withdrawals (not the depositor!)
What’s wrong with share bank details? You can’t do anything with them, except send me money.
Most countries have similarly capable local payment systems. The US is the only developed nation I’m aware of that’s missing such basic financial infrastructure.
With the exception of stores that are cash only, 100% of my money movements in the past 10 years have been digital, from my perspective. The actual money movement technology doesn't really matter to me, as long as I can do it online. Excluding settlement times (which I don't notice, unless I'm doing a wire transfer), as a consumer there's no difference.
> without fees
With bitcoin, you're paying fees per-transaction for bitcoin itself, and both parties are paying fees to move money to/from fiat. Wire transfers for large transfers may be slower, but they're absolutely cheaper than bitcoin. Bitcoin is considerably more expensive for small payments.
> with a fair exchange rate
With the fluctuations in price in bitcoin, the exchange rate is rarely fair and almost always worse than fiat. Note that there's lots of cards that don't charge foreign transaction fees, and have quite competitive exchange rates.
To point it out again, using bitcoin requires two fiat exchanges, each of which charge fees and each of which has an exchange rate that the exchange is profiting from. If you're transferring fiat of the same currency, there's no fees and no exchange rate. Even if your transaction is between two fiat currencies, bitcoin is worse, because there's one extra layer of fees and exchange.
> With no limits on transaction sizes
I can't think of a time in which I've hit a transaction size limit. Who is this feature for? Transaction size limits exist primarily to protect people. If my card is compromised, it won't result in 100% of my money immediately (and irreversibly) being transferred away.
> with complete finality
This is an anti-selling point. If my money is stolen, I want to be able to get it back. If I typo an account number when I send a payment, I want to be able to reverse that payment.
but the point remains that just because the legacy system exists doesn’t mean no alternative should ever exist.
The second link follows the Wadsworth Constant in fabulous fashion.
https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/... is almost exactly 30% of the way down the page.
> 1 hour 31 minutes read
In rhetoric we call this 'assigning homework' and it's considered deflecting, aka, trying to get out of jail free, aka, poor form, aka, you lost the argument.
I'm sure we can do better than either of these for educational material. If that's the best that exists, which I hope is far from the case, then this is essentially a "git gud scrub" situation and you have yourselves to blame for the unwashed masses still not understanding things.
If bitcoin needs a similarly hierarchical trust-based settlement systems as banks, how is that different from traditional banking?
At this point, and given HN's POV on BTC, I can't take these statements serious unless you are willing to post the tx hash?
Most of these criticisms seem to be unfounded and only speculative, or you deliberately put a low priority mining fee and feel the need to blame the protocol for that.
The truth is a 30 cent mining fee was clearing all day in the next block, so I struggle to see how this is the fault of Bitcoin mainchain. With that said, as someone already mentioned, LN txs are instant and near free.
The solution was in the message you replied to.
You'll continue using a service that obfuscates their use of bitcoin and lightning, like you do now with services that obfuscate their use of Fedwire and SWIFT. They'll provide you with consumer protection services, either for a fee or in exchange for harvesting and selling your data, like they do now.
I'm not suggesting that everyone is going to use raw bitcoin and have to manage their own keys. I'm suggesting that nation states and corporations (and many individuals) will all rebase their money operations on an open network, digital protocol. Bitcoin.
This is not ever going to happen.
Witness today the Ethereum tumbler getting sanctioned. When a payment method gets significant enough it will either be regulated or squashed by the state.
It is also quite easy for a state to exclude themselves from cryptocurrency networks, to the extent that the only transactions taking places are enabled by black market in person exchanges for cash, and no legal business entity could use that currency so you're left with the only thing bitcoin was really ever good for, evading legal controls to do trivial things or illegal things. Nothing more.
That bitcoin's biggest proponents still haven't embraced lightning is a pretty clear admission of defeat by bitcoin apologists that bitcoin doesn't actually solve anything, and isn't actually very useful for anything, even with the fix that was supposed to finally bring bitcoin into the promised land.
Crypto being filled with scams is a feature, not a bug.
Do you even know what you're talking about? The energy concerns are real, but please avoid exaggeration to win arguments.
>By far the most power-hungry crypto in our study, we found that a single Bitcoin transaction uses an average of 1,173 Kilowatt Hours (kWh). If we consider that the average monthly electricity usage for a UK household is 350 kWh, that’s enough to power the typical UK home for more than three months at a cost of roughly £125 ($173), based on a fixed cost of £0.11 ($0.148) per kWh
>In the U.S, it would equate to roughly 6 weeks of electricity based on an average household electricity usage of 877 kWh per month (U.S Energy Information Administration).
Not quite an entire year, but definitely a number of months.
Also according to digiconomist's latest figures, it's currently at around 1500kWh per transaction. So even worse.
Even if they do rebase on top of one global network, what incentive do these companies have to change their product offerings or their fees? Consumers will not care what Visa/Mastercard or Western Union use on the backend, could be carrier pigeons as far as most people are concerned.
What would cause fintech to become more competitive? I'd love to see every transaction fee, loan rate, etc. go to zero. But would "one global network" lead to that?
Actually, one of those two isn't necessary – the payment network.
It's possible to build a payment platform _just_ on top of banks. We're doing exactly this at Sway.
In Europe this is driven by Open Banking initiatives. In the US, this will land next year with the FedNow service.
In other parts of the world, like China, Brazil, and India, instant (and free) payment networks have existed for a long while.
https://standards.openbanking.org.uk/customer-experience-gui...
https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/about....
It’s a fundamentally hard market for anyone else to enter because Mastercard and Visa basically have natural monopolies.
The value that both Mastercard and Visa bring to the table is:
1) if you’re a bank, most merchants accept their cards
2) if you’re a merchant, most banks provide a card from one of them.
So any new network has the classic chicken and egg problem. How do you convince merchants to accept your card (and potentially additional payment processing terminals) when none of the merchants customers have the card. And in the inverse, how you get a bank to invest in integrating with your network, when no merchants accept your card?
The EU tried to force a fox on this issue by creating EuroPay. Which ultimately failed and was bought by… Mastercard. But on the upside, part of the purchase deal require that Mastercard provide “at-cost” access to its network for a new card network to piggy back off, to help solve the above chicken and egg problem. But atlas’s, even that doesn’t reduce the barrier to entry enough, especially when coupled with the EU rules capping maximum interchange fees.
Well, at least at the national scale, it can and is done. You start with terminal providers or select the niche that doesn't use them at all (online payments). Then you need top 5 banks to support your new method in their mobile apps/transaction systems. All is left is massive advertising campaign, and if it is successful, other banks will join. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_payment contains a huge list of attempts that worked out (or not).
It is going international where things get very tricky. Even Paypal and Stripe had to be based on Visa/MC, there are no other worldwide options than credit cards. It is a bit better if you want to only cover EU(thanks to PSD2 banks had to provide APIs), but that is all. Google's and Apple's payment systems could become independent from Visa/MC but people just don't want to top up some weird accounts when they can just "connect" a card instead.
In Russia banks and merchants were convinced to use the national payment system basically overnight.
Because markets are never anti-competitive on their own, oligopolies are only ever due to big bad regulators, right? Uh-huh. Some alternate ideas about why the CC payment processors are an oligopoly:
1. They have a card in every wallet and a reader in every aisle.
2. They can force merchants to hide the fees they charge.
3. They don't just process payments, they arbitrate disputes.
(1) could be addressed by standardization (see: Europe). (2) could be outlawed. (3) could be replaced with better consumer protections or smoother small-claims process.
Most markets have a substantial undergrowth of perverse incentives and anti-competitive strategies. Killing the gardener doesn't make the weeds disappear.
Doing that doesn't actually depend on eliminating Visa/MC, so the fact that it hasn't been done suggests that there are other barriers.
If you want to argue that eliminating Visa/MC will also eliminate those barriers, some details would be nice.
Fintech is much bigger than credit card networks. Bitcoin may be the most obvious fintech example that requires neither, but there are many others.
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_technology: "[Fintech] is the technology and innovation that aims to compete with traditional financial methods in the delivery of financial services. Artificial intelligence, Blockchain, Cloud computing, and big data are regarded as the 'ABCD' (four key areas) of FinTech."
In contrast, the credit card networks which have been with us for decades are considered to be "traditional financial methods". Even Visa thinks about itself as a company that partners with "fintechs" and "fintech enablers" rather than being a "fintech" itself, e.g. "Our worldwide network helped fintechs like Chime, Rappi and Airwallex deliver on their vision". (https://usa.visa.com/partner-with-us/info-for-partners/info-...)
They got rid of all the fees and BS the banks had been abusing me with for decades. There have been a few times traditional banking was better so I used a credit union I kept open. All my other traditional bank accounts have been closed for years.
I'd expect more out of UniPay at this point -- I do actually see that quite often.
All fintech relies on two things: A bank and a payment network (Mastercard/Visa). This makes fintech an inferior product and most fintech I have tried have an abysmal customer service. Also, because fintech does its verification thing over the Internet, it seems that they rely more on their AI to block/ban people than a phone call. Fintech also seems to be more down to lick regulation, banks and mastercard feet at the expense of their customers.
This explosion of credit cards/offers/rewards is hardly innovation. It has already happened with banks (every big store has its own credit card) and it's usually a bad deal for customer as it requires "loyalty" to that brand.
That's it folks. The market has been cornered by a couple guys and it seems the regulatory barriers have been lifted high enough that nobody can enter again. Remember when MasterCard/Visa used to send these cards for free without any KYC whatsoever?