News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by yongjik on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:35PM (#32220006)
Meh, the so-called "fake Kim Il Sung theory" isn't a new info found in 2011, it was a raging conspiracy theory all the way back from 1940s. If you speak Korean, search for "김일성 가짜설", you'll find wiki pages the size of a book chapter.

From what I've heard, the theory is largely discredited now. (Of course that doesn't mean North Korea's breathless account of Kim's heroic adventures is anywhere near believable, but that's a separate issue.)

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by halJordan on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:05PM (#32220128)
This document was declassified in 2011; it was published in 1949.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by wobbleblob on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:55AM (#32223135)
I've seen similar documents about Tito. In the end it doesn't change anything, you deal with the de-facto ruler of a country, not with his ancestors.

https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/news-features/decla...

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by hackerlight on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:06PM (#32220135)
> From what I've heard, the theory is largely discredited now.

Are there any reliable modern historians that have written about this? Especially the bit that says he was a serial killer in his early years.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pattusk on Monday July 25, 2022 @12:06AM (#32220386)
The reference biography of Kim Il Sung is "Kim Il Sung: The North Korean Leader" by Dae Sook Suh. A relatively fair treatment of the man given that the author is notable for his anticommunist bias: https://www.amazon.com.au/Kim-Sung-North-Korean-Leader/dp/02...

I can also recommend Kim Il Sung's own autobiography, With The Century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/With_the_Century (wiki page has many links to the full book). Because it was written by Kim himself, it's a lot less hagiographic than what you might expect (he didn't have to worry about censorship). Plenty of embellishments sure, but also shows a very human picture of the man.

To give a bit more historical background on the conspiracy theory: Kim's anti-Japanese actions in the 1930s-40s had received some coverage in the Korean press - despite Japanese censorship. He went into hiding in the USSR in the early 40s and was sent back to Pyongyang by the Soviets a couple months after the August 1945 liberation of the peninsula. Dissatisfied with their first choice for a North Korean leader (a man named Cho Man-Sik), the Soviets intended to replace him with Kim (a convinced Stalinist) after some PR efforts to bolster his public image.

At Kim Il Sung's first public appearance at a rally in Pyongyang in late 1945, people were shocked by his young age (there are several testimonies from people present at the event attesting to this). This was exploited by the anti-communist South to discredit him, claiming that someone that young could never have done the resistance deeds that people had heard about during the colonial period. As Suh's book shows, however, there is a good amount of evidence to support the fact that he was indeed a leader in the resistance against Japanese colonization (albeit not the only one) with several feat of arms (albeit not nearly as many as later claimed).

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by cgb223 on Monday July 25, 2022 @12:25AM (#32220489)
> wiki page has many links to the full book

The netsec person in me says we probably shouldn’t be downloading PDFs/epubs from the servers of literal North Korean Government sites…

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by hnarn on Monday July 25, 2022 @06:03AM (#32222452)
The post you're commenting on is a PDF file hosted on cia.gov, how is that any better? Or are you assuming that all readers of HN 1) are American citizens, and 2) that American citizens shouldn't care about possible threats from the CIA?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by jokowueu on Monday July 25, 2022 @06:32AM (#32222632)
just to be clear are you implying that the CIA is hosting malware on their clearnet servers so every one can get infected ?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by hnarn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:54PM (#32240798)
Are you implying that injecting malware into specific targets is not the CIA’s job?

Nobody said they infect “everyone”, it’s most likely not even in their interest to do so.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by trasz on Monday July 25, 2022 @11:19AM (#32225595)
Yeah, hosting malware is NSA's job.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by realo on Monday July 25, 2022 @06:51AM (#32222754)
Maybe just a few specific MAC adresses?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by permo-w on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:25PM (#32232301)
hacking provides a significant portion of the North Korean economy. the same cannot be said for the USA.

besides, the CIA has a lot more to lose. if you get a virus downloading a PDF from North Korean servers, that's The Scorpion and the Frog. you're not gonna get much sympathy. if you get a virus downloading a PDF from CIA servers, that's near enough an international incident

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by hnarn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:57PM (#32240833)
Doing things that may cause international incidents is, while avoided as a matter of priority, literally the CIA’s job.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by permo-w on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @03:02PM (#32242467)
something directly provable like a trojan pdf on their website would be doing that job extremely poorly
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by funstuff007 on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:51AM (#32223109)
Are you creating a false equivalency between North Korea and American? If so, Noam Chomksy in the house!
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by JadeNB on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:28AM (#32223936)
I think analogies can be taken too far, but "both North Korea and the US are probably interested in compromising the computers of their adversaries, and may intentionally or unintentionally infect others in the process" doesn't seem too far-fetched to me. It's not the same as saying "North Korea and the US are functionally and ideologically the same."
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by nickelpro on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:10AM (#32221396)
Respectfully, what do you imagine the attack vector would be?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by muricula on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:19AM (#32221444)
A zero day bug in the pdf parser or javascript engine of your browser. Such bugs are common enough that the North Korean military is believed to use them to gather intelligence and for theft, but also are rare enough that they're going to use them on just anyone.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by jhugo on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:15AM (#32222159)
Did you miss a "not" in the last part of that?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by muricula on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:30PM (#32244909)
yup :P
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by rjzzleep on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:41AM (#32221941)
I thought North Koreans don't know how to use computers? Remember the Kim Jong Un memes around that?

I'm frankly getting tired of all the hysteria. If that is indeed the attack vector just use a sandbox and a pdf viewer with low featureset. Is all we do nowadays mindless hysteria?

EDIT: comical. the response to the advice to use a PDF viewer with low featureset is to list Acrobat exploits. Seems like in the hysteria about how terrible "our enemies" are, all sarcasm and absurdity is lost

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by blu_ on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:58AM (#32222046)
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by MichaelCollins on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:55AM (#32223131)
Saying the inverse of what you actually believe but with a tone that suggests insincerity isn't comedic. It's just obnoxious.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by rjzzleep on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:04AM (#32223703)
I can see why calling out the hypocrisies of the hysteria of people like you would seem obnoxious to you.

EDIT: Comical indeed that MichaelCollins feels the need to come to muruculas rescue. The thread didn't start with murucula, it started with people saying they should not open NK PDF's because they're dangerous. The mindless hysteria could only have been trumped by people accusing one of China and Russia stoogedom in the comments below.

I was merely referring to the memes that were so popular in HN circles just a few years ago about how Kim Jong Un was too stupid to use a computer[1].

I have no skin in the game, but if the HN crowd is not able to read a PDF with basic Opsec to protect itself from malicious Acrobat exploits, we don't really deserve to be called hackers.

[1] http://www.slate.fr/sites/default/files/styles/1200x680/publ...

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by MichaelCollins on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:34AM (#32224031)
Pay attention to usernames, rjzzleep.

Anyway, muricula didn't say North Koreans don't know how to use computers, so there was no hypocrisy in his suggestion that North Koreans might have competent computer hackers. You're raging at numerous strawmen at once.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by alexnewman on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:18AM (#32224641)
So many strawmans, so little time. Viewing the history of rjzzleep is fascinating. He loves china and russia but can't say a nice thing about a western country. He constantly points to a collapsing west.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by qikInNdOutReply on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:57AM (#32221330)
Im not convinced. The Chinese communist party celebrates itself for its resistance against the japanese all the time, when one reads the history though, it gets obvious that the brute of the fighting was done by the nationalists and the communists then only performed a cleanup operation, engaging in no major battles.

These rewritten heroic-historys are largely worthless.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by elzbardico on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:01AM (#32224436)
Depending on the "history" you read, you'd think that the US, and not the USSR, was pivotal in defeating hitler in Europe.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by Claude_Shannon on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:22PM (#32229624)
USSR was so pivotal in defeating Germany - forgetting that the Second World War broke up because Soviets signed Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, essentially giving Germans free reign.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pattusk on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:16AM (#32221764)
Korea hardly had any nationalist armed resistance by the 1930s. The nationalists camp had either turned to peaceful resistance a la Ghandi (Cho Man-sik), exile (Syngam Rhee) or collaboration (Lee Kwang-su, Ch'oe Nam-Seon and so many others).

Kim Il Sung participated in two attacks on the Japanese in the Korean Peninsula confirmed by modern historians (at Hyesan and Pochonbo, the latter of which may have been led by someone else) and other attacks in collaboration with the Chinese communists (see book above for details).

For those wondering why Korean nationalists would have become collaborators: they thought colonozation by an Asian race was less likely to erase Korean culture than colonization from a white race (as the nationalists believed a Japanese defeat in the pacific war would lead to Western colonization of East Asia)

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by permo-w on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:30PM (#32232343)
>the nationalists believed a Japanese defeat in the pacific war would lead to Western colonization of East Asia

culturally, in many ways it did

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by sofixa on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:01AM (#32221700)
The Communists didn't fight major battles against the Japanese, they didn't have the resources for that after the Nationalist purges and civil war. But neither did the French resistance against Nazi Germany, does that mean they didn't resist at all?

The Communists used guerilla tactics, to much success in some cases. Who did more to stifle the Japanese war effort is an impossible question to answer, but both sides of the Chinese Civil war contributed in the fight, each to their own strengths.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by jinwoo68 on Monday July 25, 2022 @12:41AM (#32220538)
Yup. My understanding is that it was a propaganda spread by the right wing in order to discredit Kim Il Sung at that time. It's largely accepted as a conspiracy by the contemporary history communities IIUC.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by Diesel555 on Monday July 25, 2022 @01:11AM (#32220719)
I must preface my question by stating I understand it is not logical to request someone to produce evidence to refute an article which in of itself makes claims with no evidence. You could simply state the original article has no evidence, so why believe them? But, I'm just curious.

Do you happen to have any historical evidence or perspective which supports the theory that right wing people pushed this the false history - or that the right wing conspiracy is widely accepted by the contemporary historical communities? I'd like to read.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by jinwoo68 on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:20AM (#32221117)
I don't have any first hand documents but wikipedia seems to explain a bit[1].

Also note that the original article explicitly says "THIS IS UNEVALUATED INFORMATION".

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Il-sung

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by yomkippur on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:39AM (#32221575)
Namuwiki seems to discredit the claim that it was a right wing conspiracy theory (based on my limited korean abilities). It's a trope to constantly blame right wing groups in Korea for everything that the left doesn't like. I've seen it during my stay here and just realized man, this left-right rivalry seems like a major trend all over the world
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by VictorPath on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:51PM (#32220063)
Also as historical records show, and as some in the western braintrust noted at the time, the idea that Stalin was foisting revolution onto Korean communists, it was somewhat backwards - local Korean communists fighting the Japanese and then Americans, like the Chinese, were much more enthused about revolution in their countries than Stalin was.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by hackerlight on Monday July 25, 2022 @12:14AM (#32220427)
It was Mao foisting it onto Korea. Stalin was a careful opportunist and thought Korea would be too risky and reckless, so he was hesitant but was eventually persuaded by Mao that it was a good idea.

> local Korean communists ... were much more enthused about revolution in their countries than Stalin was.

Even if we substitute "Stalin" for "Mao", this statement has low epistemic legibility and low relevance. It could have been 100, 10k, or 1 million Korean communists who were genuinely more "enthused" than Mao was, given that there's likely to be N > 0 people who are more enthused about any kind of political project inside of a large population when their enthusiasm is contrasted to that of a single person. That's a given. It doesn't detract from the fact that an ideology and system was forced onto a sizeable unwilling population with Mao's direct backing.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pattusk on Monday July 25, 2022 @01:00AM (#32220637)
this is untrue, the Korean peninsula had a strong socialist (including non-Marxist forms of socialism) and later communist (as in affiliated with the COMINTERN) movement from the early 20th century and its main influence was the Japanese Communist Party - not Mao. (Incidentally, a large part of the membership of the Japanese Communist Party was Korean - up until the cadres.)

North Korean troops (and earlier the so-called "Yanan Koreans") were also instrumental in securing the Chinese communist victory during the Civil War through their actions in Northeast China. So in a sense they forced communism on China just as much as the Chinese forced communism onto Korea.

> It was Mao foisting it onto Korea. Stalin was a careful opportunist and thought Korea would be too risky and reckless, so he was hesitant but was eventually persuaded by Mao that it was a good idea.

Your statement refers to the Korean War. As archive records now show, both Stalin and Mao were reluctant and Kim Il Sung only managed to convince Stalin by pretending that Mao was on board for an invasion of the South (and likewise lying to Mao about Stalin being on board).

In any case, North Korea was already socialist before the Korean War. And the South also had a very strong communist movement - the first governments that sprouted in Korea after 1945 were "people's committees".

But the US backed dictator Syngman Rhee (selected for his staunch anti-communism, the man was so reactionary his conservatism shocked even US intelligence) managed to politicide the Southern communists in large numbers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bodo_League_massacre

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeju_uprising

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeosu%E2%80%93Suncheon_rebelli...

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by Synaesthesia on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:05AM (#32221024)
Most of the leaders selected for the South Korean govt where collaborators with the Japanese occupation.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by qikInNdOutReply on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:56AM (#32221675)
Because the "socialist" revolutions, were first and foremost national independence movements. The red decoration was nothing more then the "fashion" at the time. Had socialism existed when america declared independence and russia supported the us, the american indepence day would be significantly more hammer & sickled. This is why the vietnam war was so wrong, it was fought by a ex-colony for a colonial power, halucinating a enemy were there actually was just its own history repeating.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by int_19h on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:44AM (#32221954)
It's not "fashion", it's the practicalities of getting military and diplomatic assistance as an underdog. Enemy of your enemy and all that.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by UberFly on Monday July 25, 2022 @04:19AM (#32221784)
The Soviet Red Army "liberated" northern Korea in August 1945, just as it "liberated" half of Germany at the end of WW2. Calling the influence of the Soviet Union in vulnerable parts of the world "fashion" is mindbogglingly dumb.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pessimizer on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:39AM (#32224952)
It wasn't so bad for Germany, we still let ex-Nazis run the US half.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pyuser583 on Monday July 25, 2022 @08:33PM (#32232830)
In 1946, the infant mortality rate in Berlin was greater than 90%.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by TeeMassive on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:05PM (#32220126)
> it was a raging conspiracy theory

Sure, but is it false?

> From what I've heard, the theory is largely discredited now.

If you say so.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by kazinator on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:16PM (#32220182)
Using what evidence can you distinguish the content of the classified document from something someone just made up?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by TeeMassive on Monday July 25, 2022 @12:36AM (#32220518)
Probably not an internet stranger telling using himself and hearsay as a source.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pphysch on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:34AM (#32221188)
The linked document has a number of red flags.

The source was a South Korean periodical.

The document has a "THIS IS UNEVALUATED INFORMATION" stamp on it.

The document was published during a political crisis in South Korea.

For anyone experienced with the art of deception, this puts it squarely in the "probably bullshit" bin. Misinformation like this gets published every single day in reputable outlets, and most people don't question it, because it is written to confirm their prior beliefs ("North Korea bad").

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by MichaelCollins on Monday July 25, 2022 @08:04AM (#32223203)
> The source was a South Korean periodical.

This means basically nothing. If it were fake, would a South Korean periodical publish it? Yes, almost certainly. But if it were real, would a South Korean periodical publish it? Yes, almost certainly.

That sort of 'evidence' washes out. All we're left with is unverifiable claims.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by smcl on Monday July 25, 2022 @08:52AM (#32223599)
I think you're supposed to take two of them in concert with each other - it originated in South Korea and was published during a particularly politically convenient time in South Korea. I don't know personally how important or suspicious that is, but the fact that it's clearly been marked and acknowledged as "unevaluated" is maybe a stronger reason to take it with a pinch of salt.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by GekkePrutser on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:00AM (#32222071)
While I agree the document would be questionable, I don't think "North Korea bad" is so much a belief as it's a fact. It doesn't get much badder than that. Probably the worst dictatorship for their people we have on this planet right now.

I'm very lucky to have been born here and not there.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by smcl on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:36AM (#32223018)
I think the point is that "North Korea bad" is both regrettably true and an overly simplistic way to look at the current situation without really thinking about the history of the Korean peninsula, the causes of the split, the war and what roles our own governments had in causing the entire situation. This doesn't change the indisputable fact that the Kim regimes have been brutal and that the DPRK is truly a nightmarishly awful place to live, but it lets a lot of other people off the hook.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by tristor on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:52AM (#32224273)
Please explain how “our own governments” are in any way responsible for the actions and choices of one of the most brutal communist regimes in history. I’m presuming you’re Western. “Our own governments” have much to answer for, but North Korea isn’t one of those things.

The only alternative historical path would have completely erased South Korea, now a prosperous country that acts as a positive influence on the region and world. If any outside influence is responsible for North Korea, it is China, any other take beggar’s belief.

Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by trasz on Monday July 25, 2022 @11:37AM (#32225876)
What's communist about North Korea, apart from "something often said"? It's more of a feudal monarchy.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by vkou on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:59PM (#32231495)
We can split hairs about what is true communism, but between the cult of personality, the economic system, its art and media, and the more ephemeral peculiarities of its public culture, it looks an awful lot like stepping into a time machine that takes you back to Stalinist-era USSR. There's really no place on Earth quite like it.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by trasz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:27AM (#32248114)
So it’s a “cultural communism”?
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pphysch on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:40AM (#32223047)
Calling an ideological opinion a "fact" drains that word of all meaning.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by tristor on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:53AM (#32224297)
What is a “fact” other than a piece of information demonstrated through repeated direct observation? Acting as if “North Korea is bad” is “just like your opinion man” is one of the most bad faith statements I’ve ever seen on the Internet. It’s utterly ridiculous and you know that too.
Re:The Identity of Kim Il Sung (1949) [pdf] by pphysch on Friday July 29, 2022 @08:15AM (#32275943)
This is called "browbeating", and does not make your ideological opinion any more based in fact.