I think you're almost there but not quite. It's not that we're spending money pushing people around. It's that we're spending people pushing money around. If medical spending were focused on medical equipment, facilities, and professionals, we would free up huge amounts of resources. But we have legions of hospital and insurance administrators whose entire job is to fight against each other over billing. Those people are resources who could be used to produce things, or provide care!
Even before that, litigation encourages the same.
Companies (hospitals and the like) in the US resell (or used to) perfectly good equipment abroad with a huge discount after it's been used so that it can be replaced with the newest model with the shiniest bells and most expensive cost to avoid a lawsuit.
ACA is directly responsible for the perverse incentive in not reducing medical costs.
ACA is bad, and they knew it when they passed it. IIRC, senator Lieberman stopped government supplied medical care for the other 50% of people who don't already get it that way
You accidentally forgot the $800 billion for the military-industrial complex every year (it's easy to miss, I know).
"This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children. The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities. It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population. It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals. It is some fifty miles of concrete pavement. We pay for a single fighter with a half-million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people. . . . This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron."
US President Dwight Eisenhower, 1953 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chance_for_Peace_speech
If you're talking about making machines that make everyone more productive... then you're back into IT and Finance allowing everyone to be more productive... just as much as robots and factory lines. And at the end of the day it's still just goods people buy or use.
You pay for an Uber, or you pay for a car and all of its associated costs, and pay with your time sitting in soul-crushing traffic either way, because your municipality responded to population growth by building incredible sprawl and dangerous roads with no alternatives instead of a development and transit infrastructure that scales. Or you pay premiums and copays and various fees as tribute to the insane byzantine healthcare system that the U.S. has because there is no simple public option or sane way for providers to communicate information to each other. Or you pay 4x the cost for 1/4 the speed for Internet because $TELCO_GIANT has a monopoly and lobbied the municipality not to compete.
We have incredible, jaw-dropping amounts of misallocated value, with expensive services willing to sell you back a fraction of that value at an outrageous price. I don't think I would call that economically productive.
> Our currency loses value because too much of the economy is constituted by unproductive jobs where people just attend to each other instead of creating any value.
Which is a broad enough context for my point. The incredible inefficiency of the U.S. economy means that it is not providing the quality of life to its people that our per-capita economic activity suggests that it should be. In the aggregate, there's a lot of people paying a lot of money and getting a crappy life in return. That manifests itself in, among others, physical/mental health problems, constant economic precarity, overconsumption of natural resources, degradation of public services, profligate time-wasting, frustration with each other and one's self, and unachieved potential. And those things put the U.S. on the path to long-term decline.
After you account for externalities, and the fact that much of American economic activity would not exist if it simply had a better-structured society to begin with, the amount of value it actually creates starts to look a lot lower.
> "In the USA we want "good" jobs that come with personal fulfillment, agency, mental stimulation... great"
That doesn't so much depend on the type of job, it depends on the management environment and coworkers. People can be happy with a sense of fulfillment and agency, or unhappy without those things in both skilled or menial, high or low paid jobs.
> "i.e. manufactured products, which can only be made by soul-crushing labor and toil."
In Henry Ford's autobiography, he wonders at the factory worker who is happy dipping metal components in liquid, with only the gentlest wave of the hands as their labour, over and over all day, and cannot be tempted by money to do anything more interesting or complex.[1]
Are the people making James Webb, or ASML's EUV-lithography machines or X-Ray machines doing soul-crushing labour? Are the people making hand-made wooden furniture doing soul-crushing labour with no agency and no mental stimulation? And, more importantly, do they need to be? Is that the only way we can imagine work and jobs? Does labour necessitate micromanagement, time tracking, awful bosses, skeleton staff, high stress, squeezing for maximum value extraction? Couldn't we change that instead, and keep the healthcare and welfare?
[1] in as many words; I forget the exact anecdote.
Can you show that labor is the bottleneck here because I don't think it is. Agriculture is more and more industrialized and the issue is more stuff like fertilizer and fuel prices, and also shipping issues. All due to war. Housing is made expensive because no one wants a poor (hence annoying - so people think) neighbor. Medical equipment and computers, actually I really don't know enough about how those are made to say.
Politicians have just kept digging us deeper into the hole because while it is not sustainable there is no turning back without major social upheaval and massive uncertainty.
I actually think services create more value than my code, so I’m unclear why I get paid so much.
Think the accountant that your clothes washer has to hire just to stay out of jail. (theoretically, of course)
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/how-big-tech-makes-their-bi...
We can thank Edward Bernays for single-handledly ruining the world.
In the USA we want "good" jobs that come with personal fulfillment, agency, mental stimulation... great. We also want free healthcare, free education, free everything. Fine. But at the end of the day our money has to buy things of actual value, even as we provide the aforementioned niceties, such as food, housing, medical equipment, computers, i.e. manufactured products, which can only be made by soul-crushing labor and toil.
There's a difference between productive labor (creating value) and service (moving value around). Our currency loses value because too much of the economy is constituted by unproductive jobs where people just attend to each other instead of creating any value. 1.2 trillion dollars on health care every year. 800 billion dollars on welfare. The wolves are at the doorstep.