News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by thundergolfer on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:46PM (#32102742)
Remember that Stripe changed its RSU grant structure a year or so ago, so this won’t negatively affect newer employees. Stripe gives out a fixed amount of $$ value of stock each year now. The typical recent senior hire will get around $200k a year in stock. Now that the valuation is lower, they’ll be granted more stock units than before, which is good. Getting granted fewer stock units at a ‘fake’ higher valuation would have been frustrating.

1. https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/equity-for-software-engin... (Ctrl-F Stripe)

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by bcx on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:24AM (#32105212)
Personally, I don't see what the hubbub is about. A 409a is a standard instrument used to price options, a standard approach to a 409A valuation is the base the value of a company on its comparables, including public comparables.

If I were conducting this valuation, I haven't done this myself, but I most definitely read our 409A valuations closely. I'd imagine that the outside firm hired to conduct the analysis on Fintech would use data like:

BLOCK (down 49% in last 6 months)

PAYPAL (down 60% in last 6 months)

COINBASE (down 75% in last 6 months)

INTUIT (down 30% in last 6 months)

VISA (down 5% in last 6 months)

SHOPIFY (down 70% in last 6 months)

Everyone at these fintechs, has seen the valuation of their company drop significantly (with the exceptions of VISA in the last 6 months. It's possible that stripe's performance is closer to VISA than to SHOPIFY, but only dropping 30% is likely pretty generous given the broader market.

Anyone with options at any of these public companies is dealing with the same challenges.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by arcticbull on Sunday July 17, 2022 @03:47AM (#32125163)
There was a big shift over the last decade towards late stage startups and public companies issuing RSUs instead of options. Blonk stopped issuing options in like 2014. Coinbase is all RSU. Shopify is all RSU. The others I don't have personal knowledge of. It's possible someone is still vesting options from years ago but if so they're most certainly not underwater.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ruraljuror on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:55PM (#32103290)
This is why many Stripes on blind are not angry. They will get more shares next year.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by radicaldreamer on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:06PM (#32103815)
They should still be angry because this company should’ve gone public and made them liquid a year ago.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by OgAstorga on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:34PM (#32104004)
Shouldn't going public on an unrealistic market cap would cause more issues than benefits? Sure, a healthy exit is ok but later pressure to recover the market cap in the short term can cause heavy structural damages inside any org.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by repsilat on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:03PM (#32104172)
I think that's a more complicated explanation than necessary. If their private valuation is higher than their public valuation it means they can raise money more cheaply while private.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by echelon on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:00AM (#32105061)
To the benefit of the company and the people that control Stripe, not necessarily the hard working ICs that would enjoy liquidity.

The opportunity cost of this restriction on their lives is huge.

Had they gone public two years ago, employees would have benefitted from a market of a lifetime, with equity in one of the best tickets in town.

A lot of life changing early retirements and "Fat FIRE".

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by id on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:53AM (#32106174)
>The opportunity cost of this restriction on their lives is huge.

What restriction, exactly?

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by peanuty1 on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:13AM (#32107280)
The restriction of not being able to liquidate their shares on the public market because of Stripe staying private for an unusually long time (Block (formerly Square), the other double-digit billion-dollar Silicon Valley payments company founded in 2009, went public in 2015). I imagine most Stripe employees that joined in 2019 and earlier expected Stripe to have gone public by now.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ethbr0 on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:10AM (#32107262)
That they continue working at Stripe, instead of pursuing other life goals.

Or to phrase parent's point differently: by not IPO'ing, Stripe forfeited the premium public markets would have been willing to pay Stripe employees for their stock.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by id on Friday July 15, 2022 @11:00AM (#32108871)
Isn't that their choice, though?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ethbr0 on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:15PM (#32109667)
Not after Stripe decided not to IPO.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by throw125412423 on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:02AM (#32105855)
I'd rather have cash in my bank account and work for a company that will suffer structural damage than see my hypothetical net worth go down 60%.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by arcticbull on Sunday July 17, 2022 @03:49AM (#32125175)
You're gonna love a job at Netflix :)
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by 40acres on Friday July 15, 2022 @10:37AM (#32108634)
I'm not too sure about this. Stripe has double trigger RSUs with a 6 or 7mo lock up.

Let's say they went public in '21 instead of raising money in June of that year. The market would've already turned by the end of the lockup period. By delaying the IPO there is still some chance that the shares can be sold on the public market for more than the grant price -- I would note that this really benefits Stripe hired post-2020 but at this point that's like 75% of the company.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by rob74 on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:44AM (#32106400)
I doubt that last year was a good time to go public. At the stock market, the shares would likely have fallen by more than 28%. Plus, you can't sell RSUs right away, and watching them sit there and lose value is a pretty frustrating experience too...
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by peanuty1 on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:18AM (#32107309)
The market caps of other Silicon Valley payments companies like Block (formerly Square) and PayPal peaked in Q1-Q3 2021 before declining in Q4. So if Stripe went public before Q2 2021 (to account for 6 month lockup period), their stock-holding employees should have been able to enjoy the opportunity to profit very nicely on their RSUs.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by beebmam on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:39PM (#32103152)
Frankly, I'd be fucking pissed off about this if I had options.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by stingraycharles on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:06AM (#32105488)
The whole stock market is crashing, it really makes sense for Stripe to adjust their own private valuation accordingly. As far as I can see, this is just the rules of the game when you accept stock options as compensation, and it would be unwise for Stripe to pretend their company is different and their valuation can “only go up” forever.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Brystephor on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:54PM (#32103280)
I'm genuinely curious why you say this. Could you please elaborate? I've only worked at publicly traded companies.

I don't understand how this wouldn't be the exact situation you'd want to be in. my understanding is this:

1. If you're granted options at price X, and the new share price is lower than X, you're under no obligation to exercise your options. So no real financial loss or cost to you.

2. If you're granted options at price X, and the new share price is higher than X, you're still under no obligation to exercise your options. So it's up to you now.

3. You've exercised options at price X and now it's less than that. Well that sucks. No significant different from publicly traded shares being bought and suffering a price drop. Granted, it's easier to sell your public shares at a loss for reducing tax liability on other capital gains.

4. If you exercised options at price X and it went up then yay, you're winning.

5. If you are ensured to have been given $X worth of options, and your options have dropped to $Y, and now you'll be granted options to cover the difference of $X and $Y, these latest options will be granted at a lower price, $Z, and therefore will be better priced overall. Which would mean you could now exercise the options granted at the higher price or the ones granted at the lower price. Doesn't seem like it really matters or affects anything since the net gain is the same for the year.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by fossuser on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:15PM (#32103875)
It's designed to screw employees out of upside and they sell it pretending it's employee favorable.

If you reprice equity comp each year then you lose most of the upside.

Compare the two following equity plans:

Example Year 1:

---

PLAN 1

FMV: $1

Strike: $1

Total #: 40k ISOs

Vesting: 4yrs

---

PLAN 2

FMV: $1

Strike: $1

Total #: 10k ISOs

Vesting: 1yr

---

In the second plan you get granted new equity per year targeting some total comp. This means if the equity goes up in value a lot in the first year, when your new amount is recalculated it'll be way less than 10k.

Example Year 2:

---

PLAN 1

FMV: $2

Strike: $1

Total #: 40k ISOs (10k vesting in year 2)

Vesting: 1yr into 4yr period

---

PLAN 2

FMV: $2

Strike: $2 (new grant)

Total #: 5k ISOs (The 10k from the first year, and now half that # determined by new FMV for a cumulative total of 15k instead of 20k ISOs).

Vesting: 1yr on new grant

---

This lets the company keep the majority of the upside, taking it away from employees. It also hurts employees that stay longer or have a longer term interest in the company from capturing the value they helped create.

And the more the company goes up in value, the worse the trade off becomes.

Sure in the case of a crash you may get more stock (maybe assuming they don't reduce that given hard times, target comp is just a target after all - I don't think they commit to it). Typically companies regrant underwater equity in the case of a crash anyway (see peloton). Even in the best case, I'd guess it's unlikely the grants during a down year make up for being excluded from being able to get more at a lower price 5yrs out.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by anonymouse008 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:41PM (#32104373)
You’re thinking way too hard - they have talent they need to retain. Promise status quo for the foreseeable to common shares even in the “wild world.” When the exit comes, see how common vs debt/preferred are treated.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by zlast on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:38PM (#32104031)
In the case of a crash, "typical" companies do not re-grant equity. Look at your typical big tech company, did they regrant equity? All of tech is down -- few tech companies have granted additional equity.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by fossuser on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:48PM (#32104092)
Depends on the crash and if employees are underwater or not.

In this case Stripe cut their validation by 28% and may give more stock based on that price. Assuming they do, will employees come out ahead when compared to if they had been able to lock in 5yrs of equity up front at whatever the price was when they started?

You can always negotiate for more if your locked equity becomes worth a lot less, it's a stronger position to be in as an employee. The equity is a bet on capturing value of large upside imo, their structure limits that.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Brystephor on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:54PM (#32110185)
I think 1 down year has more of an affect than your crediting, although it does depend on timing.

If you're given a 4 year grant for $X and during the first year, stock/options/whatever equity form drops 25%, then you now need to wait for the company to grow 33% to get back to your original target comp.

If that same situation happens except the drop happens in year 4 of a grant and you're above your target equity, then you'll be ahead only if the company has grown more than 33% since your initial grant date.

Now let's say you're granted an amount annually. And it drops 25% your first year and you plan to stay 4 years. Your equity portion of pay goes down for 1 year and then it goes back up. Now on year 2 you're given 1.33x the number of shares you were year 1. So let's say the company goes back up by year 4 to the original price and it steadily climbed back. If you sell at time of vesting, year 1 you took a 25% loss, year 2 you made some sort of gain. Year 3 you also made some sort of gain.

Let's say you held all vested stock and decided to sell at the end of year 4. Well your 1st year is flat but it's a loss due to opportunity cost and inflation. Year 2 has gone up 33%. Year 3 has gone up some amount as well. Year 4 probably has as well (assuming equity is priced at the beginning of the year).

I'd have to run real numbers to understand this, but again, I think people under estimate the affect a drop has. 4 year grants up front are just more risky and more of a gamble since you've basically bought 4 years worth of stock at a single price (e.g. you're timing the market).

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by anonymouse008 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:11PM (#32103439)
Think preferences - there’s no way a vc is getting diluted on the back end
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Brystephor on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:27PM (#32103570)
I'm not familiar with this. Are you referring to common vs preferred shares?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by anonymouse008 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:50PM (#32103702)
Preferred shares, covenants, etc - there’s no way you can guarantee an employee static dollars without finessing the cap table. The things that keep the compensation static on paper are usually tested and stressed during an acquisition, and a public offering at a valuation lower than the highest priced round - additional terms begin at those points: clawbacks, earn outs, lockups, tips, first rights of refusal, and new things fresh mbas dream up…
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by jssssa on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:45PM (#32104070)
I don't know how stripe does it , but employees want to know what his stock is worth and the company needs to know how much stock to give. Since we are private we just say "our internal best guess for our evaluation is $XXmillion therefore we will give you X number of shares worth $200k at this valuation. There is no finessing of the cap table. We have pre allocated a certain percentage of stock for employees, we issue out of that allocation.

I don't see an answer here for why reducing the unofficial internal valuation is bad except for the fact that they are saying we might not sell for as much anymore which affects all current stock holders if it ends up being true.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by anonymouse008 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:29PM (#32104305)
If they’re able to keep all things equal, with your example in mind, then they cushioned the employee pool at an earlier round and are burning through the shares faster than when the round closed. It’s a bandaid, the real hope hope is that the injury in terms of valuation is truly a scratch that won’t leave a scar.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by dalyons on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:48PM (#32103690)
They’re not taking new funding though?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by JohnJamesRambo on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:01AM (#32104475)
Maybe it’s time they did.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by seanhunter on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:47AM (#32106139)
> 1. If you're granted options at price X, and the new share price is lower than X, you're under no obligation to exercise your options. So no real financial loss or cost to you.

> 2. If you're granted options at price X, and the new share price is higher than X, you're still under no obligation to exercise your options. So it's up to you now.

The payout on a call option is min(exercise - strike, 0). If you are granted options and X and the new share price is lower than X your options are now worth 0[1]. If the price is higher than X, you have lost some function of the volatility, time to expiry and Price_new - Price_old.

In both cases there is a real mark to market financial loss to you even if you haven't yet crystallized that loss by exercising (which of course you would never exercise if the value was zero).

[1] Actually very close to but not exactly zero because of the vol and the time to expiry. They could get above water again.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by peyton on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:13PM (#32103451)
One, why would you ever want more of a growth company that is shrinking 13 years in with no exit in sight. Two, you miss out on 3 years of upside relative to a 4-year grant. It’s a terrible deal, but I see why they’d want to give it.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Brystephor on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:27PM (#32103564)
> One, why would you ever want more of a growth company that is shrinking 13 years in with no exit in sight.

Because if your given a fixed dollar amount of shares, and the overall evaluation goes down, you get a higher percentage of ownership.

Why would you want this? In the event that there is an exit, I presume the payout is better.

Public companies are also declining currently if you're using valuation to determine growth. And some of these are 20+ year old companies.

> Two, you miss out on 3 years of upside relative to a 4-year grant. It’s a terrible deal, but I see why they’d want to give it.

This only true assuming things keep going up. Which as we can see, is not true. It's not a "terrible deal". It's a more risk averse deal. If you started a new job at a company in the last 6-12 months and were granted 4 years of stock at a higher price, then stripes offering probably looks pretty good right now.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by projectazorian on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:31PM (#32103988)
If the other posts are to be believed they don’t have options, they have RSU’s. Not the same thing. Still not great of course but it’s better in the long run if leadership levels with people.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by nostrebored on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:32AM (#32106045)
Stripe employees in the U.S. have RSUs. Not always true abroad.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by doktorhladnjak on Saturday July 16, 2022 @12:53AM (#32115322)
A previous place I worked had this situation of employees in countries like Australia getting options because of the tax laws there. Company IPO’d at a price below the last 409a. By the time lockup was over, options going back several years were underwater.

Those employees’ equity was worthless while those on RSUs in the US (and many other countries) still got something.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ushakov on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:42PM (#32103181)
i'd imagine all the already executed options are now worth 28% less on paper, correct?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by JumpCrisscross on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:14AM (#32105556)
> Stripe changed its RSU grant structure

RSUs are worth less than transferable stock. You can’t get liquidity for an RSU (or nontransferable stock) without using a forward, which may be illegal if you have less than a $10mm net worth. Options yield stock, however, which can be sold.

For Stripe’s VCs, on the other hand, employees accepting RSUs makes their stock special. That increases the value of their shares.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by hef19898 on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:26AM (#32105628)
RSUs are great at public companies, as soon as they vest they turn into regular shares. At a private company, well, it seems pretty hard to sell any shares in those isn't it?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by JumpCrisscross on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:28AM (#32105639)
> private company, well, it seems pretty hard to sell any shares in those isn't it?

It’s a multibillion dollar market that all the banks are active in.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by hef19898 on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:42AM (#32105730)
I honestly didn't know that... Well, no big surprise since I never had anything to do with shares in private companies my whole life...
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by seanhunter on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:43AM (#32106112)
It's still extremely expensive, slow and challenging to sell pre-IPO shares even in a major stock that has a lot of active liquidity.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by JumpCrisscross on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:21AM (#32106298)
> still extremely expensive, slow and challenging to sell pre-IPO shares even in a major stock that has a lot of active liquidity

Sure. But "expensive, slow and challenging" liquidity beats no liquidity at all. Which is why few investors would agree to the lock-up terms of an RSU. (These terms make sense at companies which aren't going concerns, because they're young or going bust. They also make sense for executives at all stages. They don't make any sense for a multibillion dollar enterprise.)

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ushakov on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:58PM (#32102843)
isn't that $200k/year in stock worthless anyways?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by rmk on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:22PM (#32103015)
Not exactly, but has huge valuation risk and is likely to end up being $50k all said and done. The trouble with equity is that it can fluctuate wildly in value and you only have yourself to blame (because the decision to sell is ultimately yours, and there can be a lot of anxiety and regret attached to it).
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ushakov on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:32PM (#32103103)
most of the startups that offered me stock options had completely exaggerated valuations, so...

my heart goes to engineers, who joined a startup on bold promises to make it, but never got to IPO, M&A or even worse - were forced to execute options to later sell them at loss

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by rmk on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:26AM (#32139457)
This happened to me as well. Ridiculous billions+ valuations for companies that have not much of a moat and questionable market sizes, plus competition. Consequently the stock grants were for laughably thin slices of the company for massively inflated "Fair" Market Values per share, not to mention below-average salary offers. Basically, many startups think employees are only too willing to assume inordinate amounts of risk to make founders and their cronies rich while putting their futures on the line, and expect employees to be grateful they are given such opportunities. F that.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by nowherebeen on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:17AM (#32104559)
So many startups never IPO, and their stock options are effectively $0. When they leave they have a small window to exercise them and pay capital gains tax (with inflate valuation, this could be $100k or more).

Anyone thinking of making money off stock options at pre-IPO startup are taking a get a) valuations are realistic b) startup will IPO. In this current environment, both are false.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by simonebrunozzi on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:15AM (#32106275)
IIRC, at Stripe, and other nice-minded startups, you have 7 years to exercise, instead of the usual 60 days.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by perlgeek on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:15AM (#32105560)
It really depends on how easily you can sell it.

For some shares, there is a private market, and typically the company has to approve of sales. If they do, and the market has willing buyers, no problem. If the company blocks every sale, it's worthless.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ztratar on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:05PM (#32102898)
Can you clarify? How is $200k worth of something ever "worthless"?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by ushakov on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:05PM (#32102901)
how is something worth $200k if you can't sell it?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by askafriend on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:06PM (#32103397)
I assure you, you will have no trouble selling Stripe stock at what its worth. There is a big appetite for Stripe shares in the secondary markets even if the company never goes public.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by magneticnorth on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:15PM (#32104235)
Stripe has "double trigger" RSUs, meaning you don't actually own them until after IPO + lockup period. There are tax advantages to doing it this way, but it means that a senior hire "getting" $200k/year can't sell on the secondary markets, and may be getting shares that they will never be able to sell for their supposed value.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by bogomipz on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:21AM (#32104580)
>"Stripe has "double trigger" RSUs, meaning you don't actually own them until after IPO + lockup period. There are tax advantages to doing it this way, ..."

Interesting. I've not heard of the term "double trigger RSUs" before. What are the tax advantage of this over regular options? Most companies have right of first refusal of secondary market sales of pre-IPO stock. If the goal was to prevent secondary market sales. What does "double trigger RSUs" provide that right of first refusal does not?

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by doktorhladnjak on Saturday July 16, 2022 @01:03AM (#32115367)
There are some benefits for employees. So long as the company goes public, RSUs are worth something unlike options which can be underwater. You don’t have to pay to exercise them. Tax is only due at IPO and treated as normal income. There are none of the rules around AMT. There’s not the risk as with options of paying out of pocket to exercise plus taxes then the stock drops or there’s no liquidity and you’re net negative.

From the company’s perspective, employees with RSUs are not actually shareholders until IPO. All those SEC and state rules about having to report like a public company once you have a certain number of employees are avoided. It essentially lets companies stay private much longer.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by magneticnorth on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:18AM (#32104855)
The (arguable) tax advantage is that the employee isn’t taxed until they are able to sell the RSUs for the same value they are taxed at (since company is public and lockup is past) so you avoid a tax burden on a non-liquid asset.

The “double” trigger is the ipo requirement plus the usual time-vesting for stock grants

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by frays on Friday July 15, 2022 @06:06AM (#32106519)
If a Stripe employee has $100,000 worth of RSUs and leaves Stripe now, what happens to their RSUs?

Stripe has double-trigger RSUs which won't vest until after IPO.

Do they get to keep these RSUs until after the IPO + lockup period, even though they're not employed at Stripe anymore? (Is there another name for RSUs owned by someone not employed by a company anymore? e.g. unvested shares?)

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by magneticnorth on Friday July 15, 2022 @10:32AM (#32108584)
Yes, the employee will still get the RSUs they earned once ipo + lockup happens, even if they’re no longer at stripe. Not sure what the term for that is, though.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by bogota on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:12AM (#32105127)
You also get a really fun tax bill when you have been at the company for 4 years and they IPO.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by JohnJamesRambo on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:14AM (#32104548)
Sounds like SchruteBucks a company hands out.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Spinosaurus on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:27PM (#32103965)
Many companies actually prohibit employees from selling shares to third party investors (including investors on marketplaces like EquityZen) without board approval.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by askafriend on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:15AM (#32104553)
This is a really fair and important point - I appreciate you bringing it up.

I've seen a couple of Stripe secondaries before so I assume that some set of employees are able to transact on the secondary market.

However, important disclaimer that not all companies have the same terms - and the terms can change depending on when you were hired. Startup equity isn't absurdly complicated, but it very much is situation-specific which is where the confusion usually comes from.

Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by spoonjim on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:16AM (#32105156)
They could be investor secondary sales which won't have the same restrictions.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by bogomipz on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:24AM (#32104590)
Sure but usually if they refuse they have to buy them from you at the same price i.e right of first refusal.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by wmf on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:09PM (#32102927)
You'll be able to sell it eventually.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by 0xEFF on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:21PM (#32103007)
Maybe, maybe not. If so, maybe for a profit, maybe for a loss.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by rzazueta on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:46PM (#32103215)
Not a loss, per se, but if you were told you were receiving $200k in compensation as RSUs, and they drop in value to $50k, you could argue that's a $150k loss. It's absolutely a loss when you factor that in as compensation for the effort and labor your produced for them rather than co-onwership of the company, which RSUs decidedly do not represent.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by lostlogin on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:31PM (#32103100)
How would you sell it for a loss?
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by Calavar on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:47PM (#32103226)
If you are accepting stock or stock options as compensation, that's generally coming in lieu of cash. Maybe you had an offer somewhere else with $30k more in salary, but you took this offer instead because the projected value of the stock made the total compensation higher. If you sell your stock after 4 years for $50k, you have taken a $70k loss relative to the other offer.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by peyton on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:07PM (#32103400)
I’d love to count profits and losses relative to the best possible outcome in hindsight rather than the difference between what was spent to obtain an asset vs. what I got for it, but generally that’s not how the IRS sees things. A loss is not relative like that.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by kodah on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:39AM (#32105303)
I'm not quite sure what you're saying, but RSUs are only taxable at vesting, and are taxed based on their market value at vesting. If the companies stock is worth less per unit, then you are taxed less.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by tdy_err on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:20PM (#32103500)
Might not be the case here but, generally speaking, it's unfortunately not uncommon for stock option agreements to _require_ the recipient to exercise them at a certain time- in particular, when they leave the company who is granting them.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by nazka on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:47PM (#32103223)
I think he means sold for less than what it was on paper at the beginning. Like you start to work there and it’s valued at 200k but then time passes and now it’s at 30k.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by srpm on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:46PM (#32103219)
The company can go public or be acquired at a lower price than it's currently (privately) valued.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by jiveturkey on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:05AM (#32105874)
As an example, imagine you have $200k of crypto, held in custody at an exchange that has frozen withdrawals.
Re:Stripe cuts internal valuation by 28% by patmorgan23 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:57PM (#32104451)
You can buy several acres of land in the middle of the desert for $200k.