News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by SunlightEdge on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @04:39AM (#31985839)
"The best heroic journey is not the story of an incredible person doing incredible things. It is the story of a flawed, ordinary person who—when called upon—rises to an incredible challenge and finds within themselves something truly extraordinary."

This is the main reason I don't like superhero films. There is no sense of danger or vulnerability. It's just people in fancy jumpsuits doing acrobats around explosions till they win the day. I prefer main characters dying / at severe risk of dying. Give me tragedy. Show me vulnerable people who grow and become stronger.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by setr on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:35AM (#31986184)
I don’t think we need tragedy, or really most personal drama arcs. They’re usually so basic as to just be filler. I want more Jackie Chan — always on the back foot, always struggling against unfair odds (and usually a bit confused), usually the reluctant/accidental hero — and somehow succeeding anyways, usually through a combination of grit, talent and ingenuity.

And that struggle and growth is often best encapsulated in the fight sequences themselves.

Honestly I’m beginning to despise character drama. Superhero movies have tons of drama — the whole storyline typically lives solely to create character growth and personal shifts, and otherwise is largely irrelevant (if the characters don’t learn some lesson, they’ll never succeed). I want it to favor the other way; the story/fights exist, and the characters happen to grow through that experience.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by WastingMyTime89 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @06:05AM (#31986350)
> I want more Jackie Chan

I too want more Jackie Chan: long take highlighting the actions, extremely skilled performer, large budgets spent on retakes until the shot is perfect. But that’s Hong Kong Jackie Chan. Apart from a brief stint in the 70s, Hollywood has never been keen on making interesting movies. They are first and foremost a money making machine. With Disney having consolidated so much of the production market, I fully expect formulaic movies to be released ad nauseam and to be honest as much as it pains me that’s what the general public wants.

Thankfully things get better as soon as you leave the American market.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by gigaflop on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:24AM (#31988531)
My favorite sources of drama and tension come form horror and thriller movies. Something that gets me to pay attention, and get that feeling of *what happens next?

When I was watching the final episode of Stranger Things, there was a minutes-long sequence flashing between almost all of the characters, showing their struggles. I didn't feel engaged, because I didn't feel like the characters were actually at risk.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jeltz on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:29AM (#31986903)
As someone who loves character drama I have to agree with you about the drama in super hero movies. My issue is that I feel like there are no stakes or consequences. The drama is just manufactured filler on an inevitable road. The characters do not actually grow, they will be reset to the same state once they have cleared the obstacle the growth was necessary for.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:32AM (#31986165)
This resonates strongly! The predictability and cookie cutter stories of today's superhero movies made them into an unengaging, boring waste of time.

I assume they work for younger viewers but I really can't understand how any adult who respects their own time can enjoy these. There is never anything on stake, there's no danger, there's never a chance for the bad guys to ever win. You know even if some superheroes die, they will either come back or another way to win the day will emerge. So what's the point?

Martin Scorsese expressed a very similar thought(1) for which he had to answer later on. He then explained exactly this: nothing is at risk.

I think that's why shows like The Boys do so well, because besides the bloody visuals they offer the chance that some characters might just not make it, anyone can meet their end at any point.

You can't kill US superheroes because then how will you continue monetizing them? In that regard you can really appreciate the approach they have in the UK where they just end a franchise when they feel they told its story even if it became very popular.

I am just sitting here for an entire decade waiting for great, engaging movies to make a comeback.

1: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/opinion/martin-scorsese-m...

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by gilleain on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:28AM (#31986898)
Most hilariously (to me) is the vast difference in 'powers' between superheroes. There are the 'Gods' - some literal, like Thor, or godlike otherwise - and the 'normals'. Gods can fly, shoot lasers from their eyes, or call down lightning. Normals can, well, shoot bows or kick really well.

So in the ensemble movies (like Avengers) you get teams where some of the members are in no danger at all - the Gods - while the others are very much in danger! Except of course, the viewer knows that none of the good guys are really at risk of serious injury.

I'm sure directors try to avoid or work around this, but fundamentally if the big bad guy can knock out the strongest god (eg Thanos vs Hulk) then if they so much as strike one of the normals, they should really be dead.

Finally, it's very funny to me that Scorsese got criticised for expressing an opinion on movies. I mean, I've watched a lot of these crappy superheor movies, and they are enjoyable enough at times, but it's not great cinema ...

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:43AM (#31987529)
Scorsese eh? What does he know about cinema, right? Okay, enough sarcasm. I think a lot of people share his opinion but they won't publicly criticize the enormous money printing studios that eventually give them jobs. Disney is a beast of many tentacles and if you speak out against one aspect you might find yourself turned down in other departments which might actually matter to you.

I think though that it's a huge compromise and sometimes as far as giving up your artistic integrity when you make a superhero blockbuster. You're making entertainment for kids, you're being pinned by focus groups, ad men and franchising demands, not to mention the strict age requirements, and as of late, olbigatory cultural stances. How can you even make a movie like that?

Don't even get me started on the ensemble movies. Those are atrocious. Good luck jamming 40 lead heroes in your movie and having anything substantial happen to their characters. Not that having them together makes any sense. Even if you own both Iron Man and Guardians of the Galaxy, thay don't mix! They have a completely different vibe!

It would be a fun experiment to create a Marvel Movie Script Generator and see if you can get something resembling (or even better?) than their usual shtick.

Of course, money is to blame. When your movie is a corporate product designed to earn for shareholders, you get pictures like MCU and the Transformers movies. These movies are doing their job. Too bad for us for being interested in an engaging, original experience. Thank goodness off beat studios exist that produce some actually interesting movies.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by vintermann on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @04:50PM (#31993523)
Apropos role-playing games: superhero universes are a great example of how you don't want to end up in your storytelling. Mashing everything together (I believe the term is "jamming") just so everyone can have what they want, with no regard to consistency. Here's a Norse god with a mallet, here's a guy who got bitten by a radioactive spider.

Official RPG campaign did it a lot, because of course they wanted to sell the X supplements to the Y players too.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by gilleain on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:53PM (#31995557)
Yes, indeed. I understand that some editions of D&D are considered class-unbalanced because high level mages are so powerful.

When one member of the party can stop time, call down meteors or kill with a word then just being able to swing a sword really well seems less impressive.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by Fricken on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:19PM (#31991806)
This sketch from "Peep Show" is relevant to your argument:

https://youtu.be/zFuMpYTyRjw

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by synu on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:15PM (#31992481)
Very small detail, it’s from Mitchell & Webb Look, but Peep Show is great too.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by kcartlidge on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:38PM (#31992041)
Geniuses.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by oneoff786 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:33AM (#31987438)
I haven’t seen the boys. I tend not to enjoy the edgy deconstruction genres. I think they’re over shoot their pessimism. But I would ask, do characters really have a sense of danger associated with them? Game of Thrones was a series that supposedly did this, but I think that was very much a lie. Ned’s death and the red wedding were unexpected events. But they were largely setup for the story. After that many characters wore their shiniest plot armor. There was 0 chance Arya was going to die having left to some random murder cult and never actually impacting the story. Similarly for bran, and Jon, and most characters. Even most of the lesser characters had a fair chunk of plot armor. It’s largely unavoidable as plot threads spread out. I’d guess it’s fairly similar for the boys.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:00AM (#31987682)
The Boys shows a realistic version of superhero reality where powers actually create huge problems in the physical sense. It is combined with very juicy gore to increase the effect. A lot of it happens ny mistake.

That alone is an interesting take, but it gets better when dealing with the actual heroes. It's a great parody of Marvel and plenty of cultural queues. They explore a reality where the superheroes are marketable products and everything they do is for the optics. In reality, they are horrible, horrible people with a God complex that often do horrifying things.

It's the best superhero story I enjoyed in a long, long time.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by oneoff786 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:07AM (#31987754)
Eh. I don’t buy it. So many people think it’s smarter to be cynical. I don’t. Anime does this all the time ever since evangelion. So many mangakas crawling over each other to show how much more depraved humanity really is than the last.

I haven’t seen the boys so I can’t comment on it specifically but I would ask, is it really “realistic” or is it just cynical?

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by erybodyknows on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:51AM (#31988897)
It explores both. Some characters are cynical. Others, like (one of) the main characters Huey, is a hopeless romantic who believes in the basic goodness of people and doing the right thing. He also listens to a lot of Billy Joel.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by erybodyknows on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:55AM (#31988942)
If fact, I would argue that the juxtaposition of the main characters being essentially polar opposite’s is what gives the show most of its effective (dark) comedic moments.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by lelanthran on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:51AM (#31988177)
> I haven’t seen the boys so I can’t comment on it specifically but I would ask, is it really “realistic” or is it just cynical?

It's a different take. In a world where some people have absolute power, would they get absolutely corrupted?

The answer (from The Boys) is not so clear cut.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by oneoff786 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:34AM (#31988661)
See that’s where I have a problem.

Spider-Man isn’t a series that says what would happen if a dude got spider powers and fought crime. It’s a story about a specific person, built around specific themes. Stories aren’t simulations.

Some people think that if a deconstruction work has characters die, because normally some people would die if they fight all the time, that it must be a realistic portrayal of what would happen. That’s false! It’s still a story and glossing over the boys it certainly doesn’t seem very different. It’s not a story about what would happen if superheroes were real and had too much power. It’s a story about some specific assholes mostly who have superpowers.

The real answer is that if people gained super powers, they would not start being superheroes to begin with.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:27AM (#31989345)
We can discuss that, but first let me recommend the movie Chronicle (2012) which really is as realistic as I imagine it would get.

Conerecing The Boys, it's not about humanity as much as it's about American stuff. It's being very very specific with its criticism. Homelander is not just a psychopath, he's a product, literally, of American culture (represented by conglomerate Vaught).

Also, while The Boys has criticism and some characters might not survive, it's also very tongue in cheek and tries to entertain rather than lecture. Personally I have fun watching it. If nothing else, it manages to surprise me, which is not something I could say about superhero movies in the last ten years.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by lelanthran on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @04:39PM (#31993405)
> It’s not a story about what would happen if superheroes were real and had too much power. It’s a story about some specific assholes mostly who have superpowers.

No, the absolute power/absolute corruption in The Boys is not in the superheros.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by imchillyb on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:55PM (#31990684)
The Boys is the closest a studio can come to producing realistic reactions, effects, and backstory for superheroes.

The cynicism is portrayed, and expounded upon, by several of the show's characters.

It's not cynicism for cynicism's sake, or just to be edgy. The dystopian feel that the series imparts isn't corny or overdone. I imagine this is how a world with superheroes would act/react.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by spookybones on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:14PM (#31991727)
What other anime do you have in mind? You're ignoring a lot of series to get that impression. Most anime are based on manga out of Shonen Jump, which follow Jump's guidelines of friendship, adventure, and overcoming obstacles through teamwork.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by coryrc on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:55PM (#31991502)
> After that many characters wore their shiniest plot armor.

Season 4 was when things started going downhill with the "writing" team, and that plot armor is one of the major reasons. But it most definitely wasn't a lie before that or in the books.

Some of the zombie shows have killed off nearly all of their starting cast (some... haven't).

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by saalweachter on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:10AM (#31988380)
I mean, we'll see. In comic books, no one has managed to stay dead for long. In the MCU, they're still playing around with it.

Iron Man? Dead. Black Widow? Dead, returned for a prequel. Captain America? Dead, Captain Britain showed up for a cameo. Vision? Dead, returned in a magic dream for a span, still probably dead? Hawkeye? Retired, body battered beyond further use. Scarlet witch? Probably dead.

Only Loki is really playing into to the trope of "Dead, but not really, over and over again."

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by crooked-v on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:23PM (#31991852)
The big difference from the comics, of course, is that actors actually get older.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by saalweachter on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:16PM (#31992495)
There's still the possibility of a reboot of the MCU (I've made peace with the idea of "the story of Spiderman" being retold periodically the way we keep remaking Romeo and Juliet, but rebooting the entire MCU seems different) or "I'm Tony B Stark from another reality, I'm technically not a reboot and look slightly different but I'm basically the same character."

There's also the question of where imitators fall; is Kate Bishop just a reboot of Hawkeye?

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by librish on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:38AM (#31987481)
If you judge any movie where the protagonist will most likely win to be bad you will probably dislike most movies.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:05AM (#31987728)
If you abstract any long comment into a vaguely related single sentence, you can make anyone sound silly. Lucky for me you're trying to associate something completely different to my comment which is clearly not what I meant to say.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by librish on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:28PM (#31992610)
But what did you say beyond other than what I commented on? The main thrust of your comment is that super hero movies are boring because you know they won't die and will probably win. Does that make detective book bad because the protagonist usually solves the case? Does it make rom-coms bad because the main couple usually end up together?
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by BugsJustFindMe on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:52AM (#31989760)
> The predictability and cookie cutter stories of today's superhero movies made them into an unengaging, boring waste of time. I assume they work for younger viewers but I really can't understand how any adult who respects their own time can enjoy these.

Humans have enjoyed staring into dancing firelight for millenia. No plot even, and you know exactly what will happen to the flames in the end. What if not being able to just hang out and marvel pleasantly at visual spectacle is bad and the films are actually fine?

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by CleverLikeAnOx on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:15AM (#31989216)
Superhero movies are certainly not high cinema, but I challenge the "no risk" assertion. In the first 22 MCU films, the heroes take major losses in 5 films (e.g., a city is destroyed with impact affecting the rest of the series). The heroes suffer more personal losses in many other movies beyond those 5 (e.g., losing a loved one).

So you usually know what you will get, but the villain winning or partially winning is a credible threat.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by magic_hamster on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:43AM (#31989601)
I haven't watched all the movies (or even the majority?) but cities getting trashed while fighting has definitely become a meme. It never feels like there are any ramifications, you never see people actually get hurt even when huge skyscrapers collapse in the middle of the street. If there was an impact for the rest of the series, I haven't noticed, but the destruction scenes just feel like none of it has any weight or meaning besides the cool CGI. Passing mentions about an attack on NYC is not showing the actual consequences of these events.

The "major losses" always felt like they are manifactured in a shallow and meaningless way. You know your heroes aren't going to lose, or die, or get too badly injured. They will always bounce back and the damage will be reversed.

And this is all fine given you accept that superhero movies are primarily entertainment for kids. Which by the way explains why we get the same reboots and origin stories every 10-15 years for a fresh batch of kids.

Of course it's a matter of taste but I just don't see any substance in these movies. Honestly even when I was a kid myself I never really saw the appeal in something like "Batman vs Superman" or "Godzilla vs King Kong". It always seemed pointless to me. As an adult I am just puzzled trying to understand how these movies can hold anyone's attention. But to each their own I guess.

I have no choice but to wholly agree with Scorsese. Unengaging, predictable, day care in a theater.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by corrral on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:02PM (#31989912)
One frustrating thing about Marvel properties is they frequently almost have a point or address their own messes or even something important in the real world—but then pull back before actually saying anything. A couple of the Spider Man movies have done this, Falcon and Winter Soldier had a bad case of this, a few of the other films (Black Panther comes to mind—a riskier version of that film with a somewhat shifted perspective and a bit more bite could have been amazing). Most just don't even try to take a stance on anything whatsoever, but sometimes they start to and it's like "oh man is this going to be actually good instead of just good-for-a-Marvel-movie good?" but... no, never.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by fractallyte on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:47PM (#31991387)
On the other hand, the TV series are spectacularly good. Jessica Jones, Daredevil, Luke Cage...
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by corrral on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:55AM (#31989808)
> I am just sitting here for an entire decade waiting for great, engaging movies to make a comeback.

Tons exist, lots and lots of movies are made every year.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by chasd00 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:31PM (#31992648)
My 12 year old calls the invincibility of superheros “plot armor”.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by BrandoElFollito on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:09AM (#31986027)
This is exactly the reason why I like superhero movies. I go to the cinema to relax, switch off the rationale part of my brain and have fun.

I liked very much the Marvel movies that were fun (Guardians of the Galaxy for instance) and did not rewatch the sad and heavy ones.

It is of course a matter of personal taste. My wife terrorized me a few times into going with her to movies where I either had to take notes to follow the narrative, wonder about the mental sanity of the script writer and the director, wonder whether the movie froze when people were looking at each other for 5 minutes without saying anything, or simply trying to find a comfortable position to sleep.

Some of these movies left a trace, though, but maybe not a very good one (usually Almodóvar movies)

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by anonymous_sorry on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:12AM (#31986774)
I have enjoyed Marvel movies in the way you describe. I've also been bored by Marvel movies that felt formulaic (partly as I've become more familiar with the formula).

My gripe is that Marvel's dominance seems to have massively reduced the variety of movies in the cinema. I'm not talking arthouse, I mean blockbusters.

About half of all big-budget movies seem to be about a guy (usually) with special powers. I know derivative sequels were a thing before Marvel, but it would be nice to have a little more variety.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by andrepd on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:35AM (#31986185)
Definitely different strokes for different folks, but I cannot for the life of me understand how anyone can watch and rewatch 30+ movies which are completely interchangeable. Generic villain wants to do generic bad thing and generic hero saves the day in generic action sequences while making generic quips. Yawn. They are bad even as "low-effort movies" to relax.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by librish on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:40AM (#31987501)
Couldn't you describe a lot of movies as "antagonist does bad thing and protagonist stops them". What makes it generic? Why are they extra interchangeable in the super hero genre?
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by macintux on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:10AM (#31986770)
I cannot for the life of me understand why people feel compelled to jump on the Internet to denigrate others’ taste in movies.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by andrepd on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:42AM (#31987516)
I am not denigrating, that's why I explicitly started with "different strokes for different folks".
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by gilleain on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:21AM (#31986847)
But they are not? They are expressing their opinion on a type of movie. Why is that 'denigration'?
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by macintux on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:39AM (#31986988)
“You can watch what you want, but they’re obviously pablum and my taste is superior to yours.”
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by gilleain on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:51AM (#31987082)
Yes, that would be obnoxious ... if that's what they said :)

To be clear, I don't like it either if others consider their taste to be 'superior', but simply stating what you prefer is not - I think - implying anything.

I feel like there's a trap people fall into where they tie some of their self-worth to their entertainment choices. If you don't like the music (say) that I do, then that seems like no big deal to me.

More generally, there is the opposite situation to being a 'superfan' where people delight in putting stuff down. Ultimately if you don't like (say) Marvel movies, then just don't watch them, of course. However it's reasonable to be critical of any entertainment or art form if you can articulate why and how they could be better.

Just my two cents.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by BrandoElFollito on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:27PM (#32003263)
I think one should try and watch some of the movies they are by default against. I did this with movies that end sadly and despite the overall greatness of the movie, I regret having watched them. But I did and now I know that this i snot for me. Same for horrors, thrillers and whatnot.

When looking for some new styles, I found it interesting to see some of them on youtube "recap" channels. This opened me to some new styles (to a point at least).

Same for music. I listen to more or less everything except a few styles which I do not like. Take rap for instance - most of the current rap music is unbearable to me and I can qualify why I feel that way (either from a music perspective, the lyrics or the overall message). This said, I like very much some of them, usually a bit older ones, or from people who has a message to send. It just takes an awful amount of time to track them down.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by random42_ on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @04:22PM (#31993216)
Aren’t most stories written over the same template? I mean, look at The Hero’s Journey, Save the Cat, etc.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by oneoff786 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:25AM (#31987365)
Many superhero films, especially marvel films, are not heroic journeys. They’re entirely different concepts entirely. To pick the most recent one, Dr strange and the multiverse of madness, his (imo awkwardly executed) character arc is trying to figure out if he’s happy with his life and what superhero’ing has gained and lost him. The latest Spider-Man certainly had a great deal of personal loss if that’s what you must have.

Risk of personal death is tough to pull off convincingly. Risk of death to those they’re trying to protect is much better. And happens pretty frequently.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by buscoquadnary on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:47PM (#31990579)
Great book by Orson Scott Card, called "Characters and Viewpoints" its a book all about writing, and he points out that it seems to be a regular cycle where stories are created and become popular that are about normal people doing amazing things, and then the power level gets amped up, and moves to super powers and super threats, and things keep growing until everyone starts to suffer from fatigue at seeing super powered people do super things, and then normal stories about normal people came back into vogue and then things repeat.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by GuB-42 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:12AM (#31988407)
I think there is a cycle. We are now in the "happy" cycle. Entertaining movies, small problems, jokes, flashy effects just because it is cool, and the good guys win. I don't think it make inferior movies. Making a good joke is hard, and so is making the right jumpsuit, the right acrobatics and the right explosions at the right time.

Then, there is the "drama" cycle. No more jokes, this is serious business. People die, heroes are not so heroic, expect Pyrrhic victories if they win, actors get Oscars.

Personally, I like both, though I have my phases too.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by Poppys on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:26AM (#31986138)
I had a discussion about epic stories and a friend said that there are only two good stories:

* A ordinary person has to cope with an extraordinary situation, or

* An extraordinary person has to cope with an ordinary situation.

While we didn't feel it was a great fit for some stories, it definitely applied to a few of the greats.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by tpoacher on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:19PM (#31991804)
The reverse strategy also works, and is particularly common in anime. Namely an insanely overpowered character who otherwise leads an ordinary, mundane life (to them, at least), until the right circumstances arise to accidentally and effortlessly showcase their abilities to others.

A good example is one punch man. While everybody around him obsesses about the secret to his power, the main character is mostly concerned about not missing the 50% off mushrooms sale at the supermarket.

There's something about this plot that appeals to people. Perhaps the whole "how i feel inside but keep quiet" introvert personality pitted against "loud incompetents". Dunno. But it works great.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by lelanthran on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:48AM (#31988147)
> This is the main reason I don't like superhero films. There is no sense of danger or vulnerability. It's just people in fancy jumpsuits doing acrobats around explosions till they win the day. I prefer main characters dying / at severe risk of dying. Give me tragedy. Show me vulnerable people who grow and become stronger.

It's hard to pull off: you kill off the main character in a series, and the show can go on. You kill off the protagonist in a movie and it's the end of the movie, and the entire franchise.

Watchmen followed the graphic novel very closely, so maybe you might enjoy those super heroes.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by michaelcampbell on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:25AM (#31987363)
This is a ... theory in why some of the earlier MMORPG's (OSRS, Everquest, ...) have nostalgia, yes, but something more than that. Newer versions play the "You're the chosen one, seek your destiny..." game. Guild Wars 2 is exactly this, but the older ones were way more, "You're a character, like every other character in the world. Prove yourself."
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by hutzlibu on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:41AM (#31988088)
I thought this was funny to read, because lately there was here a post by someone complaining about, why superheros are not fun and easy anymore. Too much tragedy. Too many doubts and dark moments. Simple black and white setting missing, now all is grey.

So you maybe could give it a try again, as they try to reach more depth.

(but those I have seen, were mostly still pathetic)

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by corrral on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:52AM (#31989754)
> This is the main reason I don't like superhero films. There is no sense of danger or vulnerability. It's just people in fancy jumpsuits doing acrobats around explosions till they win the day. I prefer main characters dying / at severe risk of dying. Give me tragedy. Show me vulnerable people who grow and become stronger.

I watched a YouTube video recently (forget which one, or I'd link it) that claimed this is the reason all the Marvel superheroes are so quippy—it's a cheap way to get us to like them when the usual tool of making them relatable through vulnerability isn't available.

That's also easier (so, cheaper). It's easier to write that kind of thing than to write real characters. Less chance of a dud, quicker writing process, lower risk.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jpmoral on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:31AM (#31986158)
This is why I'm moving to different systems. Rules-as-written D&D is essentially a power fantasy.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by dsr_ on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:25AM (#31987946)
All RPGs, to a first approximation, are fantasies of agency. That is: your character can make a difference.

(If your character can't make a difference, it really isn't much fun.)

The strangest thing I see in today's young roleplayers is how they stick to a single system -- D&D 5e -- obsessively. Different systems are good at different aspects of storytelling, and the occasional attempts at universally-applicable rules (GURPS, I'm looking at you) tend to be mediocre at everything. A really good GM can overcome this, but you shouldn't need to depend on having a really good GM in order to have a successful game.

On the other hand, every lesson learned from this article is applicable across games and genres and media types.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jpmoral on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:25AM (#32012156)
For sure! System definitely matters, running tactical combat in PbtA won't work, just like trying to shoehorn relationships and inner turmoil into 5e.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by ticviking on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @06:35AM (#31986528)
The rules of the game have evolved to push things that direction. If you buy the reprints of 1st edition and play them you’ll find that for the first several levels characters are basically normal people, or a bit stronger fighting against overwhelming odds to seek glory and treasure.

The power fantasy comes as a reward for those early phases of the game where characters build their careers up in those editions.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jpmoral on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:20AM (#31987318)
Sure, that's fine if you want to tell a (nearly)zero-to-(overpowered)hero story. Which I did for some time (played a bit of 1e, 2e, and DMed a lot of 5e). But, genre aside, for any other kind of story you're better off finding something else.

e.g. trying to do https://bullypulpitgames.com/games/grey-ranks/ in any edition of D&D won't work well.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by thisjustintime on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:00AM (#31987690)
Which system are you moving to? I've been enjoying Savage Worlds and Call of Cthulhu.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jpmoral on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:22AM (#32012136)
I've GMed one-shots of Spire: The City Must Fall, Night's Black Agents, and Lady Blackbird, and Honey Heist (Lasers and Feelings hack). Running one-shots of Trophy Dark and Night Witches soon.

Haven't decided on a system for the next campaign, maybe Spire, Night's Black Agents (or other Gumshoe system), or one of the many excellent PbtA games.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by Multicomp on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:52AM (#31988908)
Not OP but Genesys helps me emphasize narrative play over just battles fwiw
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by buscoquadnary on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:32PM (#31992661)
I'm struggling with 5e being that way right now any suggestion for alternative systems that aren't as heavy as GRUPs, that still don't break once the characters get to level 10?
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by jpmoral on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:23AM (#32012139)
I've heard good things about Savage Worlds but have no experience with it.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by moritonal on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @04:42AM (#31985857)
Trying to think of examples: A Quiet Place, Day after Tomorrow, Lord of the Rings.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by ascar on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @05:33AM (#31986175)
Even Harry Potter matches his description. Harry's vulnerability, courage and personal growth even though the odds are stacked against him is a big part of what made it so good.

It's actually a very common pattern. Might even be Shonen manga 101.

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by oneoff786 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:38AM (#31987482)
Though it’s odd that one of the first things to happen is to establish that he was rich, famous, and popular. Not that this mattered too much along the way.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by krapp on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:15AM (#31987834)
The "chosen one" archetype in a nutshell. Luke Skywalker learns he's part of a royal bloodline, a child of prophecy and a super-powerful space wizard. One of the (few) things I respect the sequel trilogy for was trying to deconstruct this, showing how disillusioned Luke then became with his legendary in-universe celebrity status.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by krapp on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @09:10AM (#31987785)
And as far as Marvel movies go: Iron Man, Spider Man, Doctor Strange. Even Guardians of the Galaxy 2 and Thor:Ragnarok.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by rcurry on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:48PM (#31991401)
There’s a really fun movie out there called Special. It’s about an everyday Joe who participates in a clinical drug trial and starts to think he has super powers. He crafts a super hero outfit but he puts the drug company’s logo on his back and so the big drug company sends hitmen out to assassinate the poor guy because he’s bringing them all sorts of bad publicity. I guess I’d characterize it as Limitless meets Kickass. I love movies like that where the whole genre is turned completely upside down.
Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by kbenson on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:00PM (#31989882)
For many superhero characters, a flawed ordinary person rising to the challenge is exactly their origin story. It's compelling, so of course it's used.

Whether they pull it off convincingly or if it's just given lip service is another thing, but ostensibly just because it's a super hero movie doesn't mean it doesn't apply (at least for the first movie for a character).

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by langsoul-com on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:10AM (#31987225)
I think modern hero movies don't follow the Hero's journey any more.

Most times heroes in the heroes journey always loses something, a part of them dies off. Or when going back, it's never the same any more. See Lord of the Rings for the best example. Not sure if there's another modern one?

Re:Lessons from Dungeons and Dragons about storytelling (2013) by poulpy123 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:53PM (#31990658)
I have 3 problems with comics books super heroes: - their flashy costumes - their boringness - the inconsistency in their powers that one day is godlike and the next morning is mundane