Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:13AM
(#31884732)
> “The current inflation episode is just the kind of event that the fiscal theory of the price level can easily describe. It’s simple. The US government printed up about $3 trillion of money and sent people checks. It borrowed an additional $2 trillion of money and sent people more checks.” — John H. Cochrane, Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution, Stanford University
What is this? It's not like inflation was in the market for an explanation. It's already pretty well understood. We literally have a giant gaping deficit in supply for three very obvious reasons, 1. the pandemic ramp down-up, 2. the war which took out a very large part of energy, grain and other essential commodities, 3. tight labor market ("Great Resignation" anyone?). If anything, this situation vindicates MMT and other theories because over decade of free money and varying debt had no impact yet inflation started as soon as we got a perfect storm of pandemic, war and tight labor market. It sure took a lot to cause a crisis if QE and the pandemic alone weren't enough, we had to add a war and a labor market so tight that it allowed for a renaissance in unions and the Great Resignation.
> That’s actually a little more troublesome because there was a big deficit. And that one did not send inflation up. Everything’s hard to read in real time, but we can at least point to a couple of things. First, that was an economy with depressed demand. Whether extra aggregate demand spills into inflation depends on how the economy is doing. So, in 2008, there was arguably room to stoke aggregate demand to increase output.
Hmm gee, it's almost like it's an independent variable and your hypothesis was falsified over a very long period of time. Also they ignored every other country? There's a huge variety in debt-to-GDB ratios globally[1], yet somehow everyone is experiencing the exact same rates of inflation... almost as if it was for some common material reasons.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Mikeb85 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:20PM
(#31885823)
First, point 2 isn't valid, inflation was happening long before the war.
> yet somehow everyone is experiencing the exact same rates of inflation... almost as if it was for some common material reasons.
Western nations mostly took the same monetary action, likely with some level of coordination so that exchange rates don't wildly change and also because they all had a common problem.
Countries like Japan, Switzerland, China and Taiwan all have much lower inflation than the US, UK, Canada and the Eurozone for example.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:54PM
(#31886175)
> First, point 2 isn't valid, inflation was happening long before the war.
It's the reason that it's at the rate that it is rather than the rate that it was before the war, which is covered by the other two points.
I could be wrong but is China not getting discounted Russian, Iranian and Venezuelan energy right now or do they participate fully in the sanctions? That's a question.
Japan is an odd duck of an economy, I wouldn't use it in such an argument. Switzerland refutes your/their point as a counterexample since they mirrored EU/US policy. I don't know anything about Taiwan's economy. The further up the supply chain and those that can't sustain themselves are going to be the biggest hit though.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Mikeb85 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:08PM
(#31886313)
> but is China not getting discounted Russian, Iranian and Venezuelan energy right now or do they participate fully in the sanctions? That's a question.
They are but they also had much tighter monetary policy throughout the whole pandemic. Higher interest rates, money supply increase has been constant over the last decade.
Switzerland's money supply increased at a near constant rate the last few decades, there wasn't a massive change during COVID. No they didn't mirror US or EU policy, dunno why you think that. And they've had zero or negative interest rates for the better part of a decade, no change during COVID. Japan same deal.
Check these same indicators for the higher inflation countries and there's clear policy differences...
Late edit - also oil prices are high but not at all-time highs. Last time oil prices were this high the inflation rate wasn't this high. There's other obvious differences.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:06AM
(#31894766)
I think we're at an impasse. There's nothing more to argue without actually quantifying it which is going to be extremely difficult at this point. This [1] cites some beginnings on that front but we'll see what comes of it. The experiment is being done with or without that information though; the central bankers are acting on your story, not mine, so the blood will tell. My bet is that it can't possibly be enough (because the problem is material) and the consequences of the failure to recognize that are going to be very serious.
> Right now, the Fed has no control over the main drivers of rising prices but the Fed can slow demand by getting a lot of people fired and making families poorer.
This is the tip of the iceberg, I say. The global effects will be catastrophic.
Edit: Yep, it's already hitting [2]. And there's your reason for lower inflation in Asia, subsidies and other state spending, so basically the opposite of what you were saying.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by imtringued on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:29PM
(#31886542)
One thing that is actually obvious in hindsight is that austerity and balanced budgets result in both lower inflation and lower interest rates, that even applies if the interest rate is already at or below zero percent. The inability to conduct austerity and a balanced budget is tied to the inability to cut interest below zero.
We can't have the "nice" things because our money system doesn't support it, we are running an outdated version. So instead we expand the money supply in the hope that inflation results in real negative interest rates.
In my opinion raising interest rates isn't the best answer. If inflation has to be unrolled then according to MMT the government should run a budget surplus and as unintuitive that may sound, it actually requires an interest rate cut while simultaneously reducing the quantity of central bank reserves available to commercial banks i.e. quantitative tightening.
It is almost as if Friedman was right with his monetarism, but he never even once considered that negative interest rates are necessary to maintain a constant velocity of money.
Always remember that quantitative easing is an attempt to emulate negative interest rates with inflation. If you can cut the interest rate you don't need QE.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by credit_guy on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:43PM
(#31885481)
Here's how much money (M2) was in the economy in the last 4 decades [1].
In the decade from 2010 to 2020 the money supply increased by 7 trillion (from 8 to 15). It increased by another 7 trillion since (standing now at 22).
Nothing on the supply side comes close to a sudden injection of 7 trillion dollars in the economy.
As for everyone else experiencing inflation, guess what, they blame it on us. Money printed in the US has an inflationary effect in the whole world, not only in the US. Smaller countries cannot simply ring-fence their economy and live in a vacuum. And the EU was not shy about printing money either.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:15PM
(#31885779)
> Nothing on the supply side comes close to a sudden injection of 7 trillion dollars in the economy.
I think you should look into commodity prices. I'm surprised at how many people aren't paying attention to the global game on this. We're literally going to starve out other countries by outbidding them. That's what's going on here.
> As for everyone else experiencing inflation, guess what, they blame it on us.
No we don't because we know it's a material problem. That's "common knowledge" in Europe. The story here, and as far as I can see, everywhere is "producer costs."
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by alangibson on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:28PM
(#31885924)
This. I shut down a side business late last year because steel prices were already up 50% in Europe. Most don't pay attention to commodity prices because they aren't exposed to them.
There's also much willful ignorance and motivated reasoning. I've seen people in the US blame it on Build Back Better spending, seemingly unaware that BBB didn't pass.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:37PM
(#31886012)
Yep, that's it right there and most people don't know how much electricity goes into aluminum either, for example. Or that long term fixed prices contracts rose 30% last week while already on the order of 5 times higher than usual. This speaks to the risk being priced in about the fact that things probably aren't going to get better soon and could get worse.
> I've seen people in the US blame it on Build Back Better spending, seemingly unaware that BBB didn't pass.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by credit_guy on Sunday June 26, 2022 @06:09PM
(#31888577)
> I think you should look into commodity prices. I'm surprised at how many people aren't paying attention to the global game on this.
Let's look then at that.
Russia produces about 4 billion barrels of oil per year. The various sanctions reduced that, but not by much. I've seen estimates of 10% to 20% decline, although I have also seen lower estimates. The war has been going on for about 4 months, so at a very conservative 20% output decline it follows that they produced 270 million barrels less than last year. At $100 a barrel, that's a shock of less than $30 billion on the supply side. It's much less than that though, since other producers have increased their output.
$30 billion shock on the supply side vs $7 trillion on the demand side...
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:49AM
(#31929046)
You missed every other commodity, including a giant one, natural gas where electricity prices have double even in the most self-sufficient European countries and we're at the point of needing to bring back coal in Germany. Then there's the grain, knock on effects on steel and aluminum, nickel, the blocked ports, and on and on. It's a disaster.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by imtringued on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:19PM
(#31886427)
People like shouting and complaining but they haven't got a clue about how stable this system actually is. As long as your government keeps fiscal spending within the target inflation rate of the central bank there is nothing that can rock the boat.
We've got this inflation bomb and yet the market thinks we are going into a recession soon. One would have expected a renewable and EV boom with the high energy prices and what not but nope.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by vkou on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:17PM
(#31885259)
Asset price inflation was happening for over a decade, yet never made it's way into the cost of butter, until wages for butterchurners and milkmaids and the price of gas started growing.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by lumost on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:11PM
(#31885736)
Alternately, asset price inflation didn’t matter until it priced everyone out of housing, commercial real estate, retirement, and any other asset accumulation.
This inflation episode coincides with millennials nearing the end of the typical income growth phase of their careers without substantial asset buying power. Eventually people will simply drop out of the race, or demand vastly higher wages to compensate.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by alangibson on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:00PM
(#31886237)
> This inflation episode coincides with millennials nearing the end of the typical income growth phase of their careers without substantial asset buying power.
Interesting. Do you have any links that quantify this?
> Eventually people will simply drop out of the race, or demand vastly higher wages to compensate
Maybe in some places. But this doesn't line up with what we know about American nature. Their frustration will most likely be expressed via violent outburst, blaming other groups, believing in conspiracies, and who knows what other exciting new antisocial behaviors they'll cook up on the internet.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by lumost on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:03PM
(#31887421)
> Asset inflation doesn't matter in that, as long as the assets don't later deflate.
For most productive assets (including housing) there is a a limit to the degree of fractional ownership one can reasonably have. While I could buy into REITs, it only closes my short position on housing to own. It's in my interest to own an appreciating/inflating asset that I'm short on - particularly when I will go bust otherwise. If Rent captures all of my purchasing power, I may no longer be able to reasonably close this short position in a reasonable time frame.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by vkou on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:46PM
(#31887785)
Rents in most of the country didn't inflate like assets, though. (Because the asset growth was mostly funded through magical borrowed money, while rent is paid by real wages received by real people. No wage growth = limited rent growth. Except in places like SF, where it is paid by stock grants, which grow thanks to magical borrowed money.)
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by zozbot234 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:57PM
(#31885618)
MMT is basically a logically mangled variety of FTPL, anyway. Both of them see expectations about the government budget (i.e. future taxes and spending) as the main factor behind inflation.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by p33p on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:29AM
(#31884867)
The tone of your comment is intentionally antagonistic, but I agree with the underlying concept.
I think we can see inflation as a direct result of excess globalism, especially lean supply chains, and changes in underlying customer demand, i.e., the basket of products consumers are wanting was different than pre-pandemic. All of these are supply side problems, but it seems to reason that at least part of the pent up demand is a result of new consumer cash. I'd argue it's a political scapegoat though.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Izkata on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:25PM
(#31885893)
> It sure took a lot to cause a crisis if QE and the pandemic alone weren't enough, we had to add a war and a labor market so tight that it allowed for a renaissance in unions and the Great Resignation.
Um, what? It did start last year. Calling it the "Putin price hike" is pure propaganda.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ttul on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:29AM
(#31884866)
It seems obvious to me that giant fiscal stimulus was a factor in today’s inflation to the extent that it gave households extra cash to spend once the pandemic restrictions eased up. All that spending hit physical goods at first, and now services.
Because politicians are loath to take away the punch bowl just when things are getting good, central banks usually have to do so via interest rates and money supply.
And because politicians are unlikely to increase taxes or reduce spending to mop up the extra cash, it’s likely that sustained, harsh monetary policy will be required. This policy will put the economy into recession for a time, will reset asset values, and will lead to higher unemployment.
And central banks will inevitably overshoot, because it’s nigh impossible to predict the path of the macroeconomy with much accuracy.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ProjectArcturis on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:19PM
(#31885818)
This theory predicted inflation should have soared back in 2009 when QE began. The fact that it took 13 years and additional crises (pandemic, Ukr war) for inflation to surface is pretty good disproof of the theory.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by choeger on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:30PM
(#31885941)
But it did, for certain assets at least. I think part of the reason for the last decade of unorthodox inflation is that demand is not as flexible as theory would require it to be (people stop buying ever more consumer goods when they get x% more money). Some areas (housing, particular services) seem to have seen quite a rapid inflation, though.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by TuringNYC on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:51PM
(#31886147)
>> The fact that it took 13 years and additional crises (pandemic, Ukr war) for inflation to surface
Anyone trying to save up for a home in the US could probably tell you inflation has been around since interest rates plummeted and then more-so since QE. It isnt an uncommon scenario that families would save more money each year to buy a home with a decent down-payment...only to have homes go up in price more than they saved.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Klinky on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:04PM
(#31886281)
It's not inflation alone that is the problem with housing. It's housing being seen as an investment. People discourage new builds or high-density due to trying to preserve their existing asset value. Quick flip schemes juice the price up, for an often shoddy asset. Then hedge funds swoop in with cash, paying above market, to then flip, rent out, AirBnB or just let houses sit idle. There's a lot of bubble-like behavior still occurring in the housing market, and easy money has likely contributed, but I don't think that it all falls in line with classical inflation. It feels more like artificially constricted/restricted supply with high demand.
Housing as an investment is problematic, because it disincentivizes new builds, people want to keep seeing their asset value go up, never down, and constraining supply is an easy way to do that. Renting out can also be more lucrative than selling if you have the capital. Also the ability for markets to offer housing at commodity prices seems like it would require a drastic oversupply of a very resource intensive asset. How sustainable is that really in the long run?
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by TuringNYC on Sunday June 26, 2022 @10:00PM
(#31889852)
>> It's not inflation alone that is the problem with housing. It's housing being seen as an investment. People discourage new builds or high-density due to trying to preserve their existing asset value.
You're right that the issue is multi-factor, but i'd argue that the factor at play in the past two decades specifically was ZIRP+QE. That is the new factor at play.
Houses being seen as an investment has been an issue for a long time, I remember even in the 80s this was a big topic of discussion. Same for NIMBYism -- that has been an issue ever since forever (step into any home owner's shoes -- once you've put all your life savings into a house, most people dont want to dilute value.) I'll agree that the more leveraged you are to finally purchase a home, the more vehement the NIMBYism is...because now more housing is ruinous to existing owners' giant investment. The whole system is @#%!@#%
I think ZIRP/QE made things worse because houses started going up in value faster than incomes. This encouraged yet more leverage and lesser house. And now we're all left with a shell of the dreams our grandparents enjoyed with normal jobs.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by alangibson on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:22PM
(#31885853)
Inflation hawks are always eventually proven right because that just repeat 'inflation is right around the corner' until it finally shows up, no matter how long it takes.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by woleium on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:48AM
(#31885029)
Someone at a party once said to me that the witchdoctors, sooth sayers and mystics who used to consult with the courts and kings of yore have not gone away, they just rebranded as economists.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by imtringued on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:38PM
(#31886628)
When you consider that there are two sides of economics, i.e. abundance and scarcity, we have been playing on the scarcity side thinking that is the only way to play the game. When people haven't even played half the game it should be pretty obvious that we end up looking like idiots with our rube goldberg machines that have a hard time explaining reality.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Izkata on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:35PM
(#31885995)
Back in highschool, about midway through the semester, my economics teacher was like "Yeah, no one really knows what they're doing, and here's evidence", and showed us a recording he had of two economics experts on TV using the exact same evidence to argue for opposite outcomes.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by BenoitEssiambre on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:14PM
(#31885765)
The FTPL seems to put a lot of focus on the government debt aspect of monetary policy (not unlike MMT, which however draws different prescriptions). I think more mainstream Keynesian/Monetarist theories don't deny that government debt is an important part of monetary policy, they just add that there are other things that play important roles too such as private debt, banks, supply shocks, money velocity etc.
In the long arcs of monetary policy, government debt might play an outsize role along the lines of what the FTPL predicts but in the shorter term, because businesses and people often move faster than governments when it comes to borrowing and spending decisions, there remains important monetary policy work to be done to smooth out the potentially costly monetary transients.
In times when governments are acting somewhat responsibly and not spending too much beyond their means, FTPL might be much less relevant and there would still be monetary policy concerns stemming from fluctuations in the private movement of money or from other supply or demand shocks.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by alangibson on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:21PM
(#31885837)
This theory is ridiculous on its face.
> Inflation breaks out when there is more overall government debt than people think the government will repay by its future excess of taxes over spending.
No government with a sovereign currency need default. Anyone dealing in government debt knows that.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by drewcoo on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:38AM
(#31884940)
> The current inflation episode is just the kind of event that the fiscal theory of the price level can easily describe. It’s simple. The US government printed up about $3 trillion of money and sent people checks. It borrowed an additional $2 trillion of money and sent people more checks.
Great. What was the faceless government's motivation?
Because clearly it wasn't the government that profited. But the people who did profit seem to own them some government.
Let's blame the government instead! That's worked since Reagan, right?
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ramphastidae on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:45PM
(#31885501)
> Great. What was the faceless government's motivation?
To stabilize society during a time when millions of people were unable to work due to a pandemic, obviously? I don’t think this is the gotcha you think it is.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Izkata on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:43PM
(#31886058)
Stabilization would have just meant replacing paychecks. At least in the US, people on unemployment were getting an additional $600/week on top of normal unemployment pay. Something like 10-20% of the workforce in the lowest bands made more on unemployment due to this scheme than they did from working.
It's not a stretch to question if there were additional motivations.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by seibelj on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:13PM
(#31885763)
It appears that places without lockdowns (Florida, Sweden) did as good or far better than places with severe lockdowns (California, New York). So I still don’t see the evidence despite all the spittle from supposed scientists who know such things.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ajross on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:22PM
(#31886456)
> (Florida, Sweden) did as good or far better than places with severe lockdowns (California, New York)
That's just wildly wrong, FWIW. Per capita covid fatalities are 50% higher in Florida than California[1]. Sweden is even more of an outlier, fully three times more (per capita) Swedes are dead from covid than Norwegians.
[1] And only matches NY if you try to cook books by including the initial wave of fatalities from the initial outbreak that were contracted before lockdown.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:26PM
(#31887618)
> Sweden is even more of an outlier, fully three times more (per capita) Swedes are dead from covid than Norwegians.
I double checked your numbers and indeed I got that we had 3.09x deaths per capita compared to Norway. Also, we did have partial lockdown and many voluntary measures that were followed. Bars we closed down, restaurants were pretty restricted, there were measures on public transportation, many people used masks, very many people worked from home and there was mass testing and stay-at-home orders and such. So, I'm saying, it could have been even worse.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by guerrilla on Sunday June 26, 2022 @06:53PM
(#31888879)
No, that's not the impression I have, but I wasn't in the US at the time. It was definitely more liberal than anywhere in Europe for sure though. Don't you remember all the articles about how Sweden is "doing nothing"?
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ajross on Sunday June 26, 2022 @09:31PM
(#31889722)
"Age-adjusted death" has never been a term of art anywhere in the history on epidemiology. It's a term invented during the COVID-19 pandemic precisely to make the argument you are attempting here. It's wrong, and it's deliberately misleading.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by seibelj on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:50AM
(#31891364)
I don’t think any amount of evidence will convince the never-freedom mask-forever types. The mass deaths and horrors beyond comprehension prophesied for those who dared walk maskless simply never happened.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ajross on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:47AM
(#31893207)
Now you're moving goalposts and going weirdly ad-hominem. The subject was economics, whether saving 2-12M lives globally (extrapolation from the numbers under discussion) was worth a few quarters of heightened inflation. I don't recall anyone claiming you need "mass deaths and horrors beyond comprehension" to justify tolerating 8% inflation.
But given the actual measured impact? Yes, that seems undeniably tolerable to me. It's the right call.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by sega_sai on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:37AM
(#31884927)
It reads a bit like a text from people who were predicting rain everyday for last 10 years, and now when it finally rained they say "you see, we were right all this time".
Unless this people catalogue their specific predictions over time, and list their success rate, these articles will continue being adverts rather than demonstration what their doing is science as opposed to astrology.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ajross on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:40AM
(#31884962)
Amen. I mean, is it really so hard to view the existence of a global pandemic and related supply shock, historically large stimulus and relief packages enacted everywhere, and a subsequent petroleum supply crisis due to a (deeply weird) war entered by a major producer as...
...a big, whopping outlier in the data set?
I mean, really? Who anywhere genuinely believes that the economic events of 2020-22 could be reliably predicted from first principles?
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by Bostonian on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:16PM
(#31885785)
The price level depends on the money supply and the amount of goods available. It was predictable that giving people more spending power when production was lower would case inflation.
Re:The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level and Inflation Episodes
by ajross on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:45PM
(#31888337)
Then why did it take two years? Supplies were low and savings rates were high in 2020, too. Yet inflation didn't start growing until well after the omicron wave had subsided. Why? Nothing happened economically in January of 2022 that should have triggered anything notable economically. There was no new relief package. No change in supply chains (though the Shanghai shutdown was about to happen). Yet... inflation started to spike then.
It's not hard to guess at an answer: the covid recovery led to a loosening of purse strings that were kept tight during lockdowns out of general social anxiety. Makes enough sense to me. But it's still a special-case answer to a special case thing. First principles economics, in fact, would have done extremely badly.
What is this? It's not like inflation was in the market for an explanation. It's already pretty well understood. We literally have a giant gaping deficit in supply for three very obvious reasons, 1. the pandemic ramp down-up, 2. the war which took out a very large part of energy, grain and other essential commodities, 3. tight labor market ("Great Resignation" anyone?). If anything, this situation vindicates MMT and other theories because over decade of free money and varying debt had no impact yet inflation started as soon as we got a perfect storm of pandemic, war and tight labor market. It sure took a lot to cause a crisis if QE and the pandemic alone weren't enough, we had to add a war and a labor market so tight that it allowed for a renaissance in unions and the Great Resignation.
> That’s actually a little more troublesome because there was a big deficit. And that one did not send inflation up. Everything’s hard to read in real time, but we can at least point to a couple of things. First, that was an economy with depressed demand. Whether extra aggregate demand spills into inflation depends on how the economy is doing. So, in 2008, there was arguably room to stoke aggregate demand to increase output.
Hmm gee, it's almost like it's an independent variable and your hypothesis was falsified over a very long period of time. Also they ignored every other country? There's a huge variety in debt-to-GDB ratios globally[1], yet somehow everyone is experiencing the exact same rates of inflation... almost as if it was for some common material reasons.
1. https://worldeconomics.com/Debt/
> yet somehow everyone is experiencing the exact same rates of inflation... almost as if it was for some common material reasons.
Western nations mostly took the same monetary action, likely with some level of coordination so that exchange rates don't wildly change and also because they all had a common problem.
Countries like Japan, Switzerland, China and Taiwan all have much lower inflation than the US, UK, Canada and the Eurozone for example.
https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/inflation-rate-
It's the reason that it's at the rate that it is rather than the rate that it was before the war, which is covered by the other two points.
I could be wrong but is China not getting discounted Russian, Iranian and Venezuelan energy right now or do they participate fully in the sanctions? That's a question.
Japan is an odd duck of an economy, I wouldn't use it in such an argument. Switzerland refutes your/their point as a counterexample since they mirrored EU/US policy. I don't know anything about Taiwan's economy. The further up the supply chain and those that can't sustain themselves are going to be the biggest hit though.
They are but they also had much tighter monetary policy throughout the whole pandemic. Higher interest rates, money supply increase has been constant over the last decade.
Switzerland's money supply increased at a near constant rate the last few decades, there wasn't a massive change during COVID. No they didn't mirror US or EU policy, dunno why you think that. And they've had zero or negative interest rates for the better part of a decade, no change during COVID. Japan same deal.
Check these same indicators for the higher inflation countries and there's clear policy differences...
Late edit - also oil prices are high but not at all-time highs. Last time oil prices were this high the inflation rate wasn't this high. There's other obvious differences.
> Right now, the Fed has no control over the main drivers of rising prices but the Fed can slow demand by getting a lot of people fired and making families poorer.
This is the tip of the iceberg, I say. The global effects will be catastrophic.
Edit: Yep, it's already hitting [2]. And there's your reason for lower inflation in Asia, subsidies and other state spending, so basically the opposite of what you were saying.
1. https://stephaniekelton.substack.com/p/inflation
2. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-06-27/asia-s...
We can't have the "nice" things because our money system doesn't support it, we are running an outdated version. So instead we expand the money supply in the hope that inflation results in real negative interest rates.
In my opinion raising interest rates isn't the best answer. If inflation has to be unrolled then according to MMT the government should run a budget surplus and as unintuitive that may sound, it actually requires an interest rate cut while simultaneously reducing the quantity of central bank reserves available to commercial banks i.e. quantitative tightening.
It is almost as if Friedman was right with his monetarism, but he never even once considered that negative interest rates are necessary to maintain a constant velocity of money.
Always remember that quantitative easing is an attempt to emulate negative interest rates with inflation. If you can cut the interest rate you don't need QE.
In the decade from 2010 to 2020 the money supply increased by 7 trillion (from 8 to 15). It increased by another 7 trillion since (standing now at 22).
Nothing on the supply side comes close to a sudden injection of 7 trillion dollars in the economy.
As for everyone else experiencing inflation, guess what, they blame it on us. Money printed in the US has an inflationary effect in the whole world, not only in the US. Smaller countries cannot simply ring-fence their economy and live in a vacuum. And the EU was not shy about printing money either.
[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WM2NS
I think you should look into commodity prices. I'm surprised at how many people aren't paying attention to the global game on this. We're literally going to starve out other countries by outbidding them. That's what's going on here.
> As for everyone else experiencing inflation, guess what, they blame it on us.
No we don't because we know it's a material problem. That's "common knowledge" in Europe. The story here, and as far as I can see, everywhere is "producer costs."
There's also much willful ignorance and motivated reasoning. I've seen people in the US blame it on Build Back Better spending, seemingly unaware that BBB didn't pass.
> I've seen people in the US blame it on Build Back Better spending, seemingly unaware that BBB didn't pass.
Ouch.
Let's look then at that.
Russia produces about 4 billion barrels of oil per year. The various sanctions reduced that, but not by much. I've seen estimates of 10% to 20% decline, although I have also seen lower estimates. The war has been going on for about 4 months, so at a very conservative 20% output decline it follows that they produced 270 million barrels less than last year. At $100 a barrel, that's a shock of less than $30 billion on the supply side. It's much less than that though, since other producers have increased their output.
$30 billion shock on the supply side vs $7 trillion on the demand side...
We've got this inflation bomb and yet the market thinks we are going into a recession soon. One would have expected a renewable and EV boom with the high energy prices and what not but nope.
This inflation episode coincides with millennials nearing the end of the typical income growth phase of their careers without substantial asset buying power. Eventually people will simply drop out of the race, or demand vastly higher wages to compensate.
Interesting. Do you have any links that quantify this?
> Eventually people will simply drop out of the race, or demand vastly higher wages to compensate
Maybe in some places. But this doesn't line up with what we know about American nature. Their frustration will most likely be expressed via violent outburst, blaming other groups, believing in conspiracies, and who knows what other exciting new antisocial behaviors they'll cook up on the internet.
Asset inflation doesn't matter in that, as long as the assets don't later deflate.
> or demand vastly higher wages to compensate.
People can demand all they want, but won't get them until there's a labour shortage. Which is what actually caused wages to grow.
For most productive assets (including housing) there is a a limit to the degree of fractional ownership one can reasonably have. While I could buy into REITs, it only closes my short position on housing to own. It's in my interest to own an appreciating/inflating asset that I'm short on - particularly when I will go bust otherwise. If Rent captures all of my purchasing power, I may no longer be able to reasonably close this short position in a reasonable time frame.
I think we can see inflation as a direct result of excess globalism, especially lean supply chains, and changes in underlying customer demand, i.e., the basket of products consumers are wanting was different than pre-pandemic. All of these are supply side problems, but it seems to reason that at least part of the pent up demand is a result of new consumer cash. I'd argue it's a political scapegoat though.
Um, what? It did start last year. Calling it the "Putin price hike" is pure propaganda.
Saying this requires you to have followed absolutely no commodities news. Please, open Bloomberg or something.
You're right! It started in 2020, not 2021. It only accelerated in 2022 - months before the invasion of Ukraine.
Because politicians are loath to take away the punch bowl just when things are getting good, central banks usually have to do so via interest rates and money supply.
And because politicians are unlikely to increase taxes or reduce spending to mop up the extra cash, it’s likely that sustained, harsh monetary policy will be required. This policy will put the economy into recession for a time, will reset asset values, and will lead to higher unemployment.
And central banks will inevitably overshoot, because it’s nigh impossible to predict the path of the macroeconomy with much accuracy.
Anyone trying to save up for a home in the US could probably tell you inflation has been around since interest rates plummeted and then more-so since QE. It isnt an uncommon scenario that families would save more money each year to buy a home with a decent down-payment...only to have homes go up in price more than they saved.
Housing as an investment is problematic, because it disincentivizes new builds, people want to keep seeing their asset value go up, never down, and constraining supply is an easy way to do that. Renting out can also be more lucrative than selling if you have the capital. Also the ability for markets to offer housing at commodity prices seems like it would require a drastic oversupply of a very resource intensive asset. How sustainable is that really in the long run?
You're right that the issue is multi-factor, but i'd argue that the factor at play in the past two decades specifically was ZIRP+QE. That is the new factor at play.
Houses being seen as an investment has been an issue for a long time, I remember even in the 80s this was a big topic of discussion. Same for NIMBYism -- that has been an issue ever since forever (step into any home owner's shoes -- once you've put all your life savings into a house, most people dont want to dilute value.) I'll agree that the more leveraged you are to finally purchase a home, the more vehement the NIMBYism is...because now more housing is ruinous to existing owners' giant investment. The whole system is @#%!@#%
I think ZIRP/QE made things worse because houses started going up in value faster than incomes. This encouraged yet more leverage and lesser house. And now we're all left with a shell of the dreams our grandparents enjoyed with normal jobs.
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/10/home-prices-are-now-rising-m....
In the long arcs of monetary policy, government debt might play an outsize role along the lines of what the FTPL predicts but in the shorter term, because businesses and people often move faster than governments when it comes to borrowing and spending decisions, there remains important monetary policy work to be done to smooth out the potentially costly monetary transients.
In times when governments are acting somewhat responsibly and not spending too much beyond their means, FTPL might be much less relevant and there would still be monetary policy concerns stemming from fluctuations in the private movement of money or from other supply or demand shocks.
> Inflation breaks out when there is more overall government debt than people think the government will repay by its future excess of taxes over spending.
No government with a sovereign currency need default. Anyone dealing in government debt knows that.
Great. What was the faceless government's motivation?
Because clearly it wasn't the government that profited. But the people who did profit seem to own them some government.
Let's blame the government instead! That's worked since Reagan, right?
To stabilize society during a time when millions of people were unable to work due to a pandemic, obviously? I don’t think this is the gotcha you think it is.
It's not a stretch to question if there were additional motivations.
Keeping people from starving and employers from closing during a global pandemic where most of them couldn't work.
That's just wildly wrong, FWIW. Per capita covid fatalities are 50% higher in Florida than California[1]. Sweden is even more of an outlier, fully three times more (per capita) Swedes are dead from covid than Norwegians.
[1] And only matches NY if you try to cook books by including the initial wave of fatalities from the initial outbreak that were contracted before lockdown.
I double checked your numbers and indeed I got that we had 3.09x deaths per capita compared to Norway. Also, we did have partial lockdown and many voluntary measures that were followed. Bars we closed down, restaurants were pretty restricted, there were measures on public transportation, many people used masks, very many people worked from home and there was mass testing and stay-at-home orders and such. So, I'm saying, it could have been even worse.
Age adjusted deaths are basically equal for California and Florida, and vastly higher in NY.
Florida was essentially an open air party with no mask mandates way back in summer 2021. No one wants to look at reality.
But given the actual measured impact? Yes, that seems undeniably tolerable to me. It's the right call.
Unless this people catalogue their specific predictions over time, and list their success rate, these articles will continue being adverts rather than demonstration what their doing is science as opposed to astrology.
...a big, whopping outlier in the data set?
I mean, really? Who anywhere genuinely believes that the economic events of 2020-22 could be reliably predicted from first principles?
It's not hard to guess at an answer: the covid recovery led to a loosening of purse strings that were kept tight during lockdowns out of general social anxiety. Makes enough sense to me. But it's still a special-case answer to a special case thing. First principles economics, in fact, would have done extremely badly.