News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by upupandup on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:59PM (#31838634)
Does anybody find the constant promotion of Brave on HN annoying? Everytime I look at comments its the same handles who are also pro-crypto

I can't take a browser serious when there are conflict of interset especially monetary ones in promoting it in public.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by assemblylang on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:04PM (#31839588)
>Does anybody find the constant promotion of Brave on HN annoying?

Yes, its extremely annoying, and I do not trust anyone saying positive things about Brave or its other product offerings. Brave is a shady company that:

>puts profits over privacy

>impersonates well known influencers to sell their products without their knowledge

>constantly pushes their cryptocurrency, functionality completely unrelated to web browsing and of negative value to anyone caring about their privacy

>their search results appear to be based off of google, despite claiming an independent index. all of your queries may just be going to google anyways

>the browser frequently sends telemetry to their servers

>they have consistently added more spyware to the browser unless users en masse call them out, which only happens some of the time

I don't think for a second you are being downvoted by real hacker news users. Brave has created some sort of native marketing arm or something that drowns out any criticisms with vague positive comments like "I've been using brave search, more privacy and better search results than google!". Something is truly fishy about Brave, and I refuse to go anywhere near their products.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by ALittleLight on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:23PM (#31839845)
I use Brave. It's basically chrome with a built-in ad blocker. I have no experience of Brave "pushing" their cryptocurrency, which I don't use and not using it hasn't negatively impacted me in any way. I think I see an option for it on the "new tab" screen, but that's it.

As for valuing profits over privacy - I was just reading an old Scott Alexander post on inconsistent rigor. Do you apply this standard to everything? You don't work with any company that values profits over privacy? Or, perhaps, when you dislike a company do you bring out strong criticism that would equally impeach almost every other company you do business with?

Brave is a good browser and a decent search engine. I use the search about 60/40 with Google and I hope that grows over time.

Since we're indulging in conspiracy theories here, I'll just throw out that mine is that you have ideological motives to dislike Brave and those motivate your criticism. Which is fine, I have ideological reasons to dislike Google, I just don't pretend that Google services are bad.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by assemblylang on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:43PM (#31840088)
>Since we're indulging in conspiracy theories here

Are you Brave's native marketing arm at work? When I open up wireshark and I see telemetry sent back to Brave after I open the browser, must be a conspiracy right?

I find it funny that you did not even try to refute the points about them impersonating people to sell their products or the telemetry in their browser. You instead deflected into a combination of "whatabout-ism" and then say the same vague positive statements "Brave is a good browser and a decent search engine."

I think Brave is shady, explain to me why they are not using technical merit. I will fully admit that I may not know all the facts, and I'm willing to hear you out, so explain why they impersonate people to sell their product.

>Do you apply this standard to everything?

Yes, if a company markets one thing, I expect them to deliver on that marketing promise. Brave markets privacy, and they do not deliver.

>I'll just throw out that mine is that you have ideological motives to dislike Brave and those motivate your criticism.

Explain further. What is my motivation here? That I'm tired of the Brave spam? That I want a browser that is actually private, like Librewolf or Ungoogled Chromium?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by ALittleLight on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:21PM (#31840601)
When I was young I was stung by a scorpion that had been hiding in my dirty clothes. My father told me "This is why you should clean your room. The scorpions won't have so many places to hide." I told him that I would rather be stung by a scorpion once a year (or so) than do the ceaseless work of keeping my room clean. I feel the same about the kind of privacy concerns you are raising here.

Maybe Brave telemetry is reporting stuff I don't care about - time spent in the browser, number of tabs open, crashes, etc. Maybe Brave telemetry is secretly smuggling data I do care about and they are using that for nefarious purposes. I would rather deal with occasionally being stung by the latter than spend my time worrying about it and restricting myself to open source, carefully audited, minimal risk tools.

As far as impersonating people to sell their products, I don't really know what you mean. I'm guessing it's something about them creating profiles to receive BAT tokens on their behalf until such time as those people joined the Brave ecosystem (if they do). I see this as a "growth hack" and maybe distasteful but not a deal breaker.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by potemkin_buster on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:44PM (#31840922)
TBH most the concern is overblown - anonymous-ish (there's always something someone can do) be default and easy to toggle off and the source is aviaible

all of the developers i've interacted with at brave have also been pretty chill

there's not as much news about other browsers here because they aren't doing much newsworthy, like this article growing a search engine

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by bdlowery on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:39PM (#31840849)
The only thing missing from your post is

“- sent from Google Chrome”

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by jacooper on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31840199)
> puts profits over privacy

And its still the most private consumer grade browser out there

https://privacytests.org

>impersonates well known influencers to sell their products without their knowledge

That's has been fixed, it affected the minority as crypto is disabled by default on brave.

>their search results appear to be based off of google, despite claiming an independent index. all of your queries may just be going to google anyways

If you have spent maybe 5 minutes using Brave search, you would see the difference, while Google is filled with stupid SEO spam, Brave has a forums section front and center.

And matching Google's index is a very very good thing, brave search is already better than DDG and probably also bing.

People want google results with better privacy.

>the browser frequently sends telemetry to their servers

Compared to what ?

Have you compared their telemetry to any other browser ?

Their telemetry is less than Firefox for sure.

>they have consistently added more spyware to the browser unless users en masse call them out, which only happens some of the time

Like what?, what is your definition of spyware?

> I don't think for a second you are being downvoted by real hacker news users. Brave has created some sort of native marketing arm or something that drowns out any criticisms with vague positive comments like "I've been using brave search, more privacy and better search results than google!".

This is just ridiculous, Because people like a browser which has actual privacy protections by default, an independent search engine, and an alternative ad network(that is disabled by default), they are bots or paid shells!

There is no one doing effective things to protect privacy in a friendly way like brave into the browser space, call me when Mozilla dares to block Ads or create a search engine, what they do is just increase the CEO salary while firing engineers, and then go on a political rant about fake news.

All other browsers require tweaks and changes, while with brave from your first click you are more private, I can give it to my grandma and she would be more private by just using it.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by cbm-vic-20 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:19PM (#31840585)
>>impersonates well known influencers to sell their products without their knowledge > That's has been fixed, it affected the minority as crypto is disabled by default on brave.

"We got caught doing something shady and fixed it" has been used a number of times by Brave. That's not a good look for a team that's presenting themselves as the white knights of the internet. Why would they be doing that shady stuff in the first place?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by jacooper on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:50PM (#31840989)
I agree, it isn't perfect, but nothing really is. Firefox has a unique key for every installer that can link people together, and runs Ads on the home page which is new (on brave its enable by default since brave ADs started)
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by manmal on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:07PM (#31841216)
Companies are prone to Groupthink: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groupthink
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by freediver on Friday June 24, 2022 @09:58AM (#31861889)
> And its still the most private consumer grade browser out there https://privacytests.org

It should be disclosed that this site is ran by a Brave employee and many choices are influenced by how Brave handles certain things. Regardless of that fact, I have a lot of problems with how are privacy-respecting features presented on this site, clearly amplifying one way of looking at things.

For example the site completely omits the most important test of a privacy respecting browser - is it zero telemetry by default or not. This is where browser privacy begins.

Or a 'privacy' test filtering __s query param (which Brave incidently filters). I would totally use a param like __s in my early dev days.

We need an independent, 3rd party, privacy tests alternative.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by arthuredelstein on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:38PM (#31909953)
Hi -- I'm the maintainer of privacytests.org. To be clear, most of these tests were built before I applied to work for Brave. And I am committed to keeping the tests impartial.

I do hope to include telemetry tests in the future.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by assemblylang on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:01PM (#31840365)
>And its still the most private consumer grade browser out there

>All other browsers require tweaks and changes, while with brave from your first click you are more private, I can give it to my grandma and she would be more private by just using it.

100% false. Ungoogled Chromium and Librewolf have zero telemetry. Brave has telemetry built in. Librewolf also comes with adblock built in, no tweaks required at all. Why should I use Brave over Ungoogled Chromium or Librewolf? Why are you defending a browser that is _not private by default_ when community-driven, conflict of interest free browsers exist?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by jacooper on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:48PM (#31840964)
I said consumer grade because I knew comments like this are coming.

Ungoogled chromium doesn't have ad block by default, and its default options are extreme.

Librwolf is even worse than UG, they disable WebGL, IPv6, WebRTC, Sync, and many other options that will break many websites, and you can't even change these options without a manual override file!

It really unusable for any normal consumer, even as an advanced user i don't use them, hardened Firefox is extremely slow, and UG doesn't have sync or advanced privacy protections from Brave like De-amp and Emphermal storage.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by stjohnswarts on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:44PM (#31840912)
All those accusations and no sources? eh....
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by gnicholas on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:04PM (#31838704)
I love Brave and have commented positively about my experience with it in the past. But I’ve never owned crypto, and I don’t comment on it much (or positively) on HN or elsewhere. Just an N = 1, but I imagine I’m not alone.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by kbelder on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:30PM (#31839911)
No, I'm in that boat with you. Crypto is pretty much a minor leftover relic of Brave's startup strategy, you don't need to touch it or deal with it.

If I had to fuss with it, that would be a negative for Brave; but it's basically irrelevant.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by dubswithus on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:49PM (#31840165)
> Crypto is pretty much a minor leftover relic of Brave's startup strategy

How do you think Brave makes money?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by soundnote on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:13PM (#31841286)
By selling ads and services for normal money. The crypto is for the users to tip content creators with. Brave buys the crypto used to tip users with normal money ad revenue from the open market, as far as I know. That means the creators users gave tips inevitably have someone to sell their BAT to.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by dahfizz on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:01PM (#31841123)
Ads, same as every other internet company.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by wickedsickeune on Thursday June 23, 2022 @04:40AM (#31846502)
I strongly dislike cryptocurrencies, but I love Brave. I don't follow news on it much though, so maybe it's because of ignorance?
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by capableweb on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:18PM (#31838944)
> Does anybody find the constant promotion of Brave on HN annoying? Everytime I look at comments its the same handles who are also pro-crypto

No, because I don't judge individual comments based on what handle is attached to it. If you make a shitty comment, it's a shitty comment no matter if you're pro/against cryptocurrencies. And if it's good, it's good, no matter previous stances.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by citizenkeen on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:56PM (#31839492)
But handles have value. It's why Hacker News has handles. So we can attach comments to them.

If four people say "I love Brave! It's awesome", and those four people are:

1. A new user just registered today

2. A long-time user who mostly talks about the Linux kernel and SQL optimizations

3. A long-time user who mostly talks about privacy and the search engine market

4. A long-time user who mostly talks about crypto

then that's four very different comments.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by dubswithus on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:39PM (#31840014)
A lot of users post comments about Brave that are inaccurate. They haven't done their research because "crypto is a ponzi" and learning about crypto would make them complicit or something. Unfortunately, this sort of attitude makes you lazy and stupid.

Obviously we can talk about the merits of Brave here and ignore the standard one liners.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by indymike on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:12PM (#31841276)
> Does anybody find the constant promotion of Brave on HN annoying?

Sometimes it is, but in this case it's actually an hacker newsworthy innovation.

> Everytime I look at comments its the same handles who are also pro-crypto

I'm 100% not into crypto. I don't like it's environmental impact and I'm not sure it will hold value long term. That said, it is an area where a lot of really smart people are trying to solve big problems... and maybe something of great utility will emerge.

> I can't take a browser serious when there are conflict of interset especially monetary ones in promoting it in public

I'm not sure what you mean here. Brave makes money by doing something other than either asking for donations (Mozilla), advertising (Mozilla, Chrome) or selling your data to whoever (lots of smaller browser companies)? Brave's interest in Crypto is a little strange, but the have made a great product, they are actively innovating, and their browser is really a better chrome than the original.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by soundnote on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:57PM (#31842382)
> Brave makes money by doing something other than either asking for donations (Mozilla), advertising (Mozilla, Chrome) or selling your data to whoever (lots of smaller browser companies)?

That's not correct. Brave is explicitly an advertising company. Their whole schtick is that they nuke nasty ads that track you, and fund their projects with revenue from ads they serve via separate channels that don't track you.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by soundnote on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:18PM (#31841362)
I mostly see people raging against Brave, not shilling for crypto. One of the main reasons I post in these threads is a bunch of unhinged stuff people spout nonstop that hasn't matched my experience using the browser at all. I pretty much just use it as a Chromium with better defaults and like that they're building their own search index. The tipping system seems interesting but I haven't bothered with it thus far. It's just a good browser, IME, from a team that understands their job is to make a good tool.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by mrweasel on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:50PM (#31840182)
Honestly no. As I wrote in another comment I don't trust Brave, but I do like to follow along with their progress. Also it's nice to see that there a products out there that are trying new things and that they have people who are passionate about them.

You could ask the same question in respect to something like VSCode, Github or Kubernetes. It's fine, just skip the news and comments about stuff you don't care about.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by GoblinSlayer on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:16PM (#31838897)
>I can't take a browser serious when there are conflict of interset especially monetary ones in promoting it in public.

What browsers do you think suffer from that?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by ziddoap on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:11PM (#31839691)
Just a wild guess based on their comment being negative about Brave, and that this is a topic about Brave Search... They might be referring to Brave.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by hunterb123 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:28PM (#31839891)
He was hinting that GP should apply that same standard to other browsers and see how many are left.

Brave is up front about how it's monetized. Browsers like FireFox that get their revenue from Google Search referrals, not so much.

Only one browser recently has been serious about implementing protocols and features that are beneficial to the user, not companies.

So while Chrome mulls blocking adblockers, Brave has one built in.

How many other browsers have Tor, Webtorrent, ENS, IPFS support?

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by ziddoap on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31840214)
>Only one browser recently has been serious about implementing protocols and features that are beneficial to the user, not companies.

Uhhh, do you just mean things that you specifically care about? Because I consider DNS-over-HTTPS, site isolation, multi-account containers, scipt-blocking, etc. all to be features that were beneficial to users.

>How many other browsers have Tor, Webtorrent, ENS, IPFS support?

I personally don't want Tor, Webtorrent, ENS, or IPFS to be in my browser, nor other cryptocurrency stuff to be near my browser. This is not as much of a selling point as you make it out to be, at least for some users.

I'm not really for or against Brave, but you're presenting your argument as if it is fact; everything you said is entirely opinion.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by hunterb123 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:10PM (#31840481)
> Uhhh, do you just mean things that you specifically care about? Because I consider DNS-over-HTTPS, site isolation, multi-account containers, scipt-blocking, etc. all to be features that were beneficial to users.

I mean implementing ALL useful technologies, the ones you mentioned, the ones I mentioned, not just the ones that don't threaten the moat.

There seems to be a pattern in the mainstream browsers to ignore the P2P tech for reasons ;)

> I personally don't want Tor, Webtorrent, ENS, or IPFS to be in my browser, nor other cryptocurrency stuff to be near my browser. This is not as much of a selling point as you make it out to be, at least for some users.

That's fine! But there are very valid use-cases for streaming torrents, for accessing onion sites, for ENS domain lookups, and accessing IPFS content.

Just because you personally don't want or need them doesn't mean others don't. I'm glad Brave gives the option and ability to easily access these technologies.

> I'm not really for or against Brave, but you're presenting your argument as if it is fact; everything you said is entirely opinion.

I mainly annotated browser monetization & adblocking policies and listed tech in Brave not in other browsers. Please be specific on your criticism and I will address it.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by jacooper on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:25PM (#31839875)
I use brave, and I have never cared about their crypto stuff.

Its probably most of brave's users, as crypto is disabled by default.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by dzdt on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:06PM (#31840434)
I think there is a high interest factor on HN for competitors to google search. Brave isn't the only one that comes up. Some combination of google being frustrating for power users, increasingly evil in moral alignment, and obnoxiosly dominant in its role makes competition an interesting topic here.
Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by zuminator on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:49PM (#31839378)
Not really. I count about 19 stories about Brave in the past 30 days. Compare that with at minimum 33 stories related to just Google searches. That's not including non-search related threads about Chrome, Analytics, Maps, Alphabet etc. Otherwise it's hundreds of stories.

I'm not a fan or user of Brave yet I don't consider a story every other day or so to be excessive.

Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ... by stjohnswarts on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:43PM (#31840900)
I don't. I see just as much about other popular pieces of software (chrome, firefox, gcc, etc)