Re:Brave Search passes 2.5B queries, allows users to choose ...
by arthuredelstein on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:38PM
(#31909953)
Hi -- I'm the maintainer of privacytests.org. To be clear, most of these tests were built before I applied to work for Brave. And I am committed to keeping the tests impartial.
I do hope to include telemetry tests in the future.
It should be disclosed that this site is ran by a Brave employee and many choices are influenced by how Brave handles certain things. Regardless of that fact, I have a lot of problems with how are privacy-respecting features presented on this site, clearly amplifying one way of looking at things.
For example the site completely omits the most important test of a privacy respecting browser - is it zero telemetry by default or not. This is where browser privacy begins.
Or a 'privacy' test filtering __s query param (which Brave incidently filters). I would totally use a param like __s in my early dev days.
We need an independent, 3rd party, privacy tests alternative.