News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by sbf501 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:00PM (#31830883)
And an avalanche of "I told you so". Don't forget that part.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:07PM (#31830932)
I mean, we did tell 'em.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:12PM (#31830951)
Who did you tell?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:31PM (#31831061)
You're welcome to review my post history.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:41AM (#31832733)
Okay, I’ll bite. Your comment history doesn’t have you mentioning Terra, TerraUSD, or Luna before May 9, e.g.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

You just made generic anti-crypto recommendations, some of which look good in hindsight. That’s not the same as identifying the specific mechanism that proved to be Luna’s downfall; it’s more like being a permabear who predicted 8 of the last 3 stock market crashes. You can likewise claim to have “told you so” about Dai’s collapse, with equally good epistemic grounding.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:33AM (#31833727)
Why can't I rely on "avoid crypto, it's a scam"? I have to identify every new coin and it's mechanism of failure?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:13AM (#31835605)
For the reason I just gave: it would mean that others could say “I told you so” about Dai/Compound etc not crashing. If it’s still not clear, imagine I was always saying the stock market is a scam and would collapse. Do I get credit for predicting Netflix’s recent tumble? Even if it happened for completely unrelated reasons to the mechanisms of collapse I was warning about?

It’s fine to be risk-averse and avoid crypto as a rule; that’s not the same thing as knowing Luna couldn’t work long-term.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:27PM (#31838140)
> it would mean that others could say “I told you so” about Dai/Compound etc not crashing.

No, they really cant. Like, I have no idea what DAI/Compound are, and trivial googling didn't answer. A random counterexample doesn't disprove every famous and/or high market cap coin crashing.

To use your market example, if you kept saying tech stocks are overpriced we would judge it based on the performance of the NASDAQ. You wouldn't be able to say "well, Apple still convinces people to give them all their money and they're still doing well so you were wrong."

Besides, it's not enough for the greater fools to continue to exist. There needs to be a credible mechanism for wealth to actually be created.

> It’s fine to be risk-averse and avoid crypto as a rule

Being risk-averse and avoiding crypto are different things. I don't touch crypto because I think it's a scam

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:45PM (#31838417)
>No, they really cant. Like, I have no idea what DAI/Compound are, and trivial googling didn't answer.

Well ... yeah, that kinda highlights the problem. If you don't know what something is, and are unwilling to learn, and have a hard time with google[1], then no, you don't get to claim vindication as having wisely made an appropriate inference based on valid evidence. Hence my point.

To fill you in: articbull's comments were vague enough to apply equally well to lending out the stablecoin DAI no the Compound platform, which did not crash or have to suspend withdrawals at any point.

Also, you have no idea, but you knew to switch Dai to all caps? :-p I think you're switching modes.

>A random counterexample doesn't disprove every famous and/or high market cap coin crashing.

>To use your market example, if you kept saying tech stocks are overpriced we would judge it based on the performance of the NASDAQ. You wouldn't be able to say "well, Apple still convinces people to give them all their money and they're still doing well so you were wrong."

Okay, and if you had been saying to avoid tech stocks for the past ten years, then you wouldn't be able to claim credit for the few times it does fall back, esp if it was up o average (hence my point about predicting 8 of the last three crashes).

You definitely wouldn't be able to claim credit for "having warned" someone about a specific stock's fumble (like Netflix's unforced errors), if "tech bad" is all you were basing it on, which is what arcticbull was doing when claiming to have to have warned about Luna in his comments merely because of a general anti-crypto stance.

>I don't touch crypto because I think it's a scam

The point is that that's not the same as differential insight into which specific ones are scams and why. If some aren't scams, that makes you wrong about them, and inability to differentiate means you can't claim to have had deep insight even when some do turn out to be scams.

IOW, you can be right for the wrong reasons, and if so, you can't claim that as vindication.

[1] Also, really? "dai cryptocurrency" and "compound cryptocurrency" both take you directly to explanations of what they are. On google, the latter pops up a "what is compound..." question which, when expanded, explains that it's a protocol for lending and borrowing.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @06:20PM (#31842581)
> you have no idea, but you knew to switch Dai to all caps

I wasn't unable to find anything about DAI/Compound. Google turned up results. I couldn't find succinct enough information to see why it would be uniquely different.

> If you don't know what something is, and are unwilling to learn

I don't have to read 1,000 pages on crystal focusing power with amethyst to dismiss it. At some point the burden is on you to explain simply enough why everything else sucks but this is different for me to continue.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:25PM (#31843211)
All you needed from that reference was that it was another stablecoin and platform that was on solid grounding and didn’t collapse, which was implicit from the original context. It wasn’t a huge leap or research burden.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:28PM (#31844516)
It was claimed that it obviously didn't have the same structural issues as Terra/Luna. That is in no way

> All you needed from that reference was that it was another stablecoin and platform that was on solid grounding and didn’t collapse,

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:23PM (#31887592)
Don’t lose sight of the main point: arcticbull was claiming he “told you so”. He obviously didn’t. If you’re ready to accept that there’s a big difference between the two cryptocurrencies that needs research to understand, then you accept that he had no good faith basis to claim to “have told you so” in his comment history, because he didn’t do the research either.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:32PM (#31831068)
Do you also welcome retail investors that haven’t heard of HN?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:36PM (#31831098)
Welcome? Not sure what you mean. I maintain a similarly opinionated Twitter feed. It’s also to be clear not my responsibility. This whole “nobody could have known” is as asinine as it was predictable.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:52PM (#31831199)
There’s a lot of grumbling on HN and on Twitter but most won’t hear it.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by sumy23 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:14PM (#31830961)
People are so smug when they say “I told you so.” It really bothers me. On every negative story about crypto, so many people comment “hur dur financial regulation dur”. But that’s so easy to say after the fact. If these people really could foresee these events happening, then they could have made a lot of money by taking short positions. That would be a lot more impressive to me than taking cheap opportunities to feel inferior at others’ expense by saying “I told you so” after the fact. As far as I’m concerned, you don’t say anything unless you put your money where your mouth is. Anyone can give advice from the sidelines. Show some conviction.

Disclaimer: the only crypto I’ve ever owned was $50 of eth I mined on my GPU.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by jrmg on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:23PM (#31831005)
That assumes you are able to hold a short position for the indefinitely long irrational period in which the bubble can grow unpredictably large and your gains increasingly negative. It’s therefore also irrational to take a short position.

The sensible thing to do was to stay away - and I think it’s perfectly fine for people who did so to smugly say ‘I told you so,’ presuming they did indeed do that.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:28PM (#31831038)
Surely if you believe crypto is coming to an end in the next few years there is some way to profit.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by stephen_g on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:05PM (#31831279)
You never know how long they’re going to be able to prop up the scams. Additionally, many of the big exchanges, being unregulated, are alleged to (either directly, or through large players they’re associated with) manipulate the market and trade against customers. Front running, etc.

Put up a large short position, and soon enough there will be a pump and dump to liquidate it. And if you do make money, have you noticed that these exchanges often go down for “maintenance” when big price movements are happening? There’s no guarantee you’ll be able to close out a position when you need to.

The only way to win is not to play.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by joshjdr on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:34PM (#31831083)
Not buying and keeping your currency elsewhere may just be a totally reasonable alternative.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:46PM (#31831164)
People that are anti crypto are of strong conviction. I am sure they wish they could have their Michael Burry moment — if only it wasn’t for the damn volatility.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by anon2020dot00 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:52PM (#31831201)
Maybe people don't want to play a zero-sum Greater fool game. There are better ways to spend one's time.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:12PM (#31831332)
Like spending many hours commenting on such topics on Twitter and HN?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by plorkyeran on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:24PM (#31831403)
I have been consistently wrong about when various scams have exploded, both thinking that they would explode earlier than they did and that it would take longer. If I'd tried to short the crypto crashes so far I probably would have lost money overall even with just the ones where I was correct about them going to zero.

With a lot more research I perhaps could be net positive, but I don't actually want to spend a lot more time digging into something that I consider stupid bullshit.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by bandrami on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:46PM (#31831167)
I could take bets on the next mass shooting, too, but I prefer not to make money off of some things that I can nonetheless statistically foresee.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:14PM (#31831340)
I made 18k betting Trump would lose the presidency with Polymarket. I literally took money from the world’s biggest morons. Feel pretty good about that.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dehrmann on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:01AM (#31832553)
In 2020, a lot of swing states were close, and there was a big shift towards Trump in election results vs. polls. He might have won had he not gotten covid.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by fragmede on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:03AM (#31832856)
The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by unmole on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:36PM (#31831100)
> But that’s so easy to say after the fact.

HN was almost always negative about the crypto currency hype. Even when shitcoins were at ATH. So, no. The criticism is not after the fact.

> If these people really could foresee these events happening, then they could have made a lot of money by taking short positions.

Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent has been a cliche for almost a century. That is to say nothing of the absurd cost of taking a short position and the counterparty risk of dealing with unregulated exchanges.

> As far as I’m concerned, you don’t say anything unless you put your money where your mouth is.

The motivation for a lot of us was to prevent our less sophisticated friends and family from blowing up their savings. The idea that one shouldn't be critical of obvious scams unless one has a financial interest in them is not a particularly well thought out take.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:00PM (#31831548)
Y Combinator was an investor in Coinbase and other crypto startups.

Sam Altman personally invested in Worldcoin.

You are posting on a forum of an incubator that supports crypto. The irony.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by MBCook on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:19PM (#31831659)
If VCs think they can make money in the next pet rock, they’ll try.

It doesn’t make pet rocks an important or useful product. Just something people can make money on.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:25PM (#31831694)
Most products aren’t important or useful. The public uses them because, well, it’s complicated.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by alphabettsy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:00AM (#31832218)
> Y Combinator was an investor in Coinbase and other crypto startups.

This doesn’t necessarily indicate anything other than that they believed the business could make money.

They also invest in traditional banking startups. Even that isn’t necessarily a contradiction with crypto investments.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by unmole on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:36PM (#31831764)
It's almost as if YC and HN users have entriely different incentives and opinions. Shocking.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:39PM (#31831782)
Have you seen the comments when one of Paul Graham’s essays is posted?

Isn’t it kind of strange to be hanging on a VC funded forum that supports crypto?

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by ntoskrnl on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:20PM (#31830989)
There are ~18000 cryptos, and out of all those, maybe two worth owning. Do I need to go open short positions on 17998 assets before I can tell people "don't buy shitcoins"?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by sbf501 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:49PM (#31831182)
The type of crypto the world ends up with will absolutely not be BTC or ETH. It will be closer to Zcash with zero-knowledge proofs, and will like only be used for things like international exchanges, escrow, new types of trusts (contracts are quite brilliant), or transfers between banks. People will use it the same way the used to use Moneygram, or the way they pay a thousand dollars for an escrow agent. I also believe every bank and country and possibly corporations will have their own blockchains. I have a strong gut feeling I'll never be buying a sandwich with crypto in my lifetime.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by randomhodler84 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:02AM (#31832853)
Wait until the point of sale terminals support Lightning. It’s coming. International trade requires transparency in a zero trust environment.

I do like privacy tech and coins but no, I think we are far off acceptance. The risk of zk schemes is way too great for anything beyond science right now.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by npalli on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:19PM (#31830984)
"Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent" - Keynes. Why does only taking short position qualify one to speak on this issue. You could be right but get wiped out in the short term when the mania drives these shitcoins to 10-20 times their fair value.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by vba616 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:26PM (#31831024)
I was told a very long time ago to never sell something short because you have the risk of unlimited loss.

But another drawback, from what I read, is that selling something short is taking out a loan, and if something is obviously a very lucrative short, then the interest will usually cancel it out.

Free lunches exist, but if it seems really obvious, don't get your hopes up.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by sbf501 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:44PM (#31831156)
There is ample evidence before of people predicting pretty much everything that happened (with the exception of the bizarre transfer devices that evolved out of staking, tethering, contracts, etc.).

I think smugness is 100% warranted, especially given the intensity of the attacks from the other side.

Even your smugness with, "Well, if you're so smart why didn't you short and make a mint," is just sour grapes. Because shorting crypto required even more effed up investments into highly sketchy exchanges. There was really nothing to short in the traditional investment sense.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:54PM (#31831210)
Just short $MSTR. Easy.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by anon2020dot00 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:55PM (#31831220)
Maybe most people already have a job which they spend time and get money in return, so why would they spend even more of their free time in pursuit of a little bit more money? Life is more than money anyways
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:08PM (#31831298)
People are naturally greedy. Plenty of developers sacrifice their relationships, health, and appearance for high comp packages.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by anon2020dot00 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:11PM (#31831322)
Most people have the attitude towards crypto that it is an over-hyped technology that is just sucking-up people's time and attention and so the best thing to do is to ignore it and hope it goes away as soon as possible so as to free-up people's time and attention towards more worthwhile things.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:15PM (#31831344)
Facebook welcomes our return.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by hug on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:25PM (#31831017)
It is the opposite of impressive, to me: Crypto is deeply troubled and unethical, but betting against it by shorting the market and gleefully taking advantage of someone losing their shirt is worse.

Basically if I can lose your respect by not fucking people over, I don't want your respect. How's that for conviction?

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:31PM (#31831064)
Not really. It’s more likely experienced players in the market liquidate your position in times of great volatility.

Yes, there are good traders out there. But it doesn’t appear that the ones that short are anti-crypto.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by joshjdr on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:37PM (#31831103)
Arguably its helping them— you know… not lose more money than they otherwise could.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by tylerhou on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:34PM (#31831087)
Even if you know something will fall it's not necessarily rational to take a short position. You also have to correctly guess when it will fall. Otherwise you will lose money on premiums or get wiped out by margin calls.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by kareemsabri on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:36PM (#31831101)
I don't think that's true.

First, shorting is expensive. Second, people have jobs and bills and don't need their money tied up in some short position. Third, just cause you think something is gonna collapse doesn't mean you know when it will collapse.

I think certain assets are shit (crypto or otherwise). I'm not going to short them all, and I still reserve the right to say I think they are shit. I'm not a professional trader.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by denkmoon on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:22PM (#31830998)
I put my money where my mouth is by not investing in crypto???
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by coding123 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:25PM (#31831015)
This is still dismissing the con, not the people fooled. Blaming the victim, essentially.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by cowtools on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:41PM (#31831134)
They're a victim of their own voluntary financial decisions.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by jpgvm on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:17PM (#31831353)
People don't take short positions against highly volatile assets like crypto because sometimes the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent. The risk of a short position greatly outweighs the benefit even if you are right and if you use instruments that reduce the risk they are very timing sensitive.

Was it always going to zero? Yes. Could I tell you when that was going to happen? Nope. Therefore no short opportunity other than going for a momentum trade.

Most of the people saying "I told you so" have held the exact same line of reasoning on the way up, at the peak and on the way down. The only people that have decided things are different are the people selling crypto, i.e the people that bought and and yes, "We told them so".

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by woodruffw on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:28PM (#31831037)
Some feel that it’s unethical to take any financial (not political) position concerning cryptocurrencies. I count myself as one.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by phailhaus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:19PM (#31830987)
Short positions:

* Have unlimited downside

* Are more difficult to get your hands on

It's not really reasonable to expect everyone bearish on crypto to also take uncapped risks.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:25AM (#31832648)
No. What you’ve described would apply to short selling but not all short positions. If you buy a put on Ethereum (the right to sell at a specific price by a certain date), then you are short Ethereum because you benefit from price declines. Your losses are limited to what you paid for the put. You just need to have the cash for it and you can do so on LedgerX/FTX.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by sumy23 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:21PM (#31830995)
You can buy short options that have capped downside.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by peter422 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:38PM (#31831110)
So if you think crypto is mostly a scam the solution is to get into options trading?

Staying away and warning your friends/family about the scammy nature of many coins is a perfectly reasonable response.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by phailhaus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:54PM (#31831212)
No, OP is saying that you can't make fun of it unless you put your money where your mouth is. Obviously, most people disagree.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by phailhaus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:33PM (#31831076)
Good point
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by joshjdr on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:23PM (#31831006)
Alternatively, refer to comment archives, or historical records of your choice.

Some, many here, have consciously objected to speculating on crypto valuation.

>unless you put your money where your mouth is

What about your pocket? That’s not an acceptable alternative?

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by grey-area on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:46AM (#31832470)
People have showed conviction by staying away and investing in companies/assets that actually generate returns.

Taking a short position in illiquid assets likely to go to zero would be almost as stupid as going long. You are also highly likely to lose your money as most schemes to short use some other ‘stablecoin’ and you’d have to be able to time the bubble. That’s not a sensible position and just as risky as being long.

Why insert the hur dur?

Mentioning financial regulation in the context of unregulated get rich quick schemes is totally appropriate and people have been warning about these scams for a long time.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by Tao3300 on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @10:10PM (#31831316)
The smugness is appropriate with Terra though.

This is the guy at the helm in the face of criticism that the whole thing could implode: https://www.twitter.com/stablekwon/status/146489797779372851...

Anyone exhibiting or associating with that level of hubris drove up the smugness of skeptics when it imploded.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by xwdv on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:27PM (#31831027)
There are few joys in life greater than being able to self-righteously say “I told you so” to those who felt so strongly about something wrong.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by _carbyau_ on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:37AM (#31832070)
I prefer "Play stupid games, win stupid prizes." :-)