News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:07PM (#31830932)
I mean, we did tell 'em.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:12PM (#31830951)
Who did you tell?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:31PM (#31831061)
You're welcome to review my post history.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:41AM (#31832733)
Okay, I’ll bite. Your comment history doesn’t have you mentioning Terra, TerraUSD, or Luna before May 9, e.g.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

You just made generic anti-crypto recommendations, some of which look good in hindsight. That’s not the same as identifying the specific mechanism that proved to be Luna’s downfall; it’s more like being a permabear who predicted 8 of the last 3 stock market crashes. You can likewise claim to have “told you so” about Dai’s collapse, with equally good epistemic grounding.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:33AM (#31833727)
Why can't I rely on "avoid crypto, it's a scam"? I have to identify every new coin and it's mechanism of failure?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:13AM (#31835605)
For the reason I just gave: it would mean that others could say “I told you so” about Dai/Compound etc not crashing. If it’s still not clear, imagine I was always saying the stock market is a scam and would collapse. Do I get credit for predicting Netflix’s recent tumble? Even if it happened for completely unrelated reasons to the mechanisms of collapse I was warning about?

It’s fine to be risk-averse and avoid crypto as a rule; that’s not the same thing as knowing Luna couldn’t work long-term.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:27PM (#31838140)
> it would mean that others could say “I told you so” about Dai/Compound etc not crashing.

No, they really cant. Like, I have no idea what DAI/Compound are, and trivial googling didn't answer. A random counterexample doesn't disprove every famous and/or high market cap coin crashing.

To use your market example, if you kept saying tech stocks are overpriced we would judge it based on the performance of the NASDAQ. You wouldn't be able to say "well, Apple still convinces people to give them all their money and they're still doing well so you were wrong."

Besides, it's not enough for the greater fools to continue to exist. There needs to be a credible mechanism for wealth to actually be created.

> It’s fine to be risk-averse and avoid crypto as a rule

Being risk-averse and avoiding crypto are different things. I don't touch crypto because I think it's a scam

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:45PM (#31838417)
>No, they really cant. Like, I have no idea what DAI/Compound are, and trivial googling didn't answer.

Well ... yeah, that kinda highlights the problem. If you don't know what something is, and are unwilling to learn, and have a hard time with google[1], then no, you don't get to claim vindication as having wisely made an appropriate inference based on valid evidence. Hence my point.

To fill you in: articbull's comments were vague enough to apply equally well to lending out the stablecoin DAI no the Compound platform, which did not crash or have to suspend withdrawals at any point.

Also, you have no idea, but you knew to switch Dai to all caps? :-p I think you're switching modes.

>A random counterexample doesn't disprove every famous and/or high market cap coin crashing.

>To use your market example, if you kept saying tech stocks are overpriced we would judge it based on the performance of the NASDAQ. You wouldn't be able to say "well, Apple still convinces people to give them all their money and they're still doing well so you were wrong."

Okay, and if you had been saying to avoid tech stocks for the past ten years, then you wouldn't be able to claim credit for the few times it does fall back, esp if it was up o average (hence my point about predicting 8 of the last three crashes).

You definitely wouldn't be able to claim credit for "having warned" someone about a specific stock's fumble (like Netflix's unforced errors), if "tech bad" is all you were basing it on, which is what arcticbull was doing when claiming to have to have warned about Luna in his comments merely because of a general anti-crypto stance.

>I don't touch crypto because I think it's a scam

The point is that that's not the same as differential insight into which specific ones are scams and why. If some aren't scams, that makes you wrong about them, and inability to differentiate means you can't claim to have had deep insight even when some do turn out to be scams.

IOW, you can be right for the wrong reasons, and if so, you can't claim that as vindication.

[1] Also, really? "dai cryptocurrency" and "compound cryptocurrency" both take you directly to explanations of what they are. On google, the latter pops up a "what is compound..." question which, when expanded, explains that it's a protocol for lending and borrowing.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @06:20PM (#31842581)
> you have no idea, but you knew to switch Dai to all caps

I wasn't unable to find anything about DAI/Compound. Google turned up results. I couldn't find succinct enough information to see why it would be uniquely different.

> If you don't know what something is, and are unwilling to learn

I don't have to read 1,000 pages on crystal focusing power with amethyst to dismiss it. At some point the burden is on you to explain simply enough why everything else sucks but this is different for me to continue.

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:25PM (#31843211)
All you needed from that reference was that it was another stablecoin and platform that was on solid grounding and didn’t collapse, which was implicit from the original context. It wasn’t a huge leap or research burden.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by HWR_14 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:28PM (#31844516)
It was claimed that it obviously didn't have the same structural issues as Terra/Luna. That is in no way

> All you needed from that reference was that it was another stablecoin and platform that was on solid grounding and didn’t collapse,

Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by SilasX on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:23PM (#31887592)
Don’t lose sight of the main point: arcticbull was claiming he “told you so”. He obviously didn’t. If you’re ready to accept that there’s a big difference between the two cryptocurrencies that needs research to understand, then you accept that he had no good faith basis to claim to “have told you so” in his comment history, because he didn’t do the research either.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:32PM (#31831068)
Do you also welcome retail investors that haven’t heard of HN?
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by arcticbull on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:36PM (#31831098)
Welcome? Not sure what you mean. I maintain a similarly opinionated Twitter feed. It’s also to be clear not my responsibility. This whole “nobody could have known” is as asinine as it was predictable.
Re:TerraUSD crash led to vanished savings, shattered dreams by dubswithus on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @09:52PM (#31831199)
There’s a lot of grumbling on HN and on Twitter but most won’t hear it.