The best run was the 0% one: 442670.
All results:
2%: 238773
0%: 442670
50%: 21106 (early crash)
4%: 255726
Edit: Forgot to note that, while the other runs got the +12% iMac trees and the -12% drought/disaster events, the 0% run also got a -10% "loss of faith in the market" event thrown at it as well.
So, 0% interest rates and 0 banker interference is good enough in the SimCB model, and can normalize its way through random negative events too.
Anyone else with results from other constant interest rates?
In reality, I agree though. Just putting to 0% and letting it ride required far less prediction ability and it worked out fine.
It seems that the whole system tops off at a zero-effort 500K or something, and the best approach is to do nothing to mess it up, just keep things cheap and stay away.
This is similar to strategic reserves. There is a really great planet money story about the rice shortage about a decade ago, which was completely artificial. There was plenty of rice, but a panic lead people to hoard rice which caused an actual shortage. The way they eventually stopped the panic was to announce they were going to sell rice from this huge strategic reserve… and just by announcing that, it caused the price to return to normal. They didn’t have to actually sell anything, just announce it.
Markets are not purely rational
The best I found was to try to raise rates during the good times so there is wiggle room during downturns."Nobody Really Knows How the Economy Works. A Fed Paper Is the Latest Sign": https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/01/upshot/inflation-economy-...
Greenspan: There was a "flaw in the model of how I perceived the world works.": https://www.propublica.org/article/greenspan-says-i-still-do...
"Greenspan Says I Still Dont Fully Understand What Happened": https://youtu.be/R5lZPWNFizQ
Since the income from the central bank's interest is paid out to the people (and vice versa, negative interest will be passed as debt), the challenge seems like finding the correct ratio to increase GDP: inflation and interest income. New money is only generated through loans, so if I understand this correctly, one should strive to have high interest rates?
edit: After tweaking my strategy a bit to try to keep interest rates as high as possible without closing any business, I got to 443647.
edit: up to 444823
Inflation rised steadily as people ate all the apples in the market.
At the beginning it looked like inflation would never stop, but at some point an orchard managed to become profitable, becoming crazy rich ($22000) because apple prices were at $100. This made apple prices crash, going down to $0.02. This pattern repeated itself a few times.
GDP stayed very low, obviously.
In reality, keeping a steady nominal GDP is a good idea. In fact, adopting a nominal GDP level target will make the market help you keep things steady. (By anticipating your central bank actions.)
The game moved way too fast for me, perhaps I did something wrong. Is there a way to make it turn-based and only advance when you tell it to?
Btw, the 'magic' of a nominal gdp level target isn't just in the stable gdp itself, but in announcing a target, so that economic actors can profit by anticipating the actions of the central bank. And that anticipation itself stabilises the economy already.
It might be interesting to allow the expected trend to be changed by announcements and such as you suggested.
Heck, less than 440K?
Yeah, that's pretty silly in reality. There's no zero lower bound in reality.
Negative interest rates work just fine. Or even simpler: buy assets that are not just short term debt. (In the extreme case: any positive price for a 'perpetual bond' corresponds to a positive interest rate. Or take inspiration from Singapore's Monetary Authority: they buy foreign exchange instead of bonds, and thus don't have to worry about interest rates at all.)
For example, are you aware that when launching a rocket, you want to avoid wasting fuel by going to full throttle in the thick, lower part of the atmosphere, where you’ll waste a lot of the energy you gain to air resistance?
There’s a reason one of the checkpoints in a space shuttle launch sequence was “go for throttle up”.
So even if you wanted to talk about economic management as being like ‘launching a rocket’ you could still make an argument for leaving some power in reserve for when the going gets easier.
> are you aware that when launching a rocket, you want to avoid wasting fuel by going to full throttle in the thick, lower part of the atmosphere, where you’ll waste a lot of the energy you gain to air resistance?
Yes, you’re referring to “max Q”. It’s still a completely different comparison though because you only have those events early on and then you go full throttle until you hit your first stage goal.
They’re not proposing an isomorphism, they are making a comparison to motivate you to modify your thinking.
I’ve always been apprehensive of how low interest rates dropped around 9/11 and nobody had the political courage to raise them after that, leaving little room for leverage. What I have learned from racing games is that in order to win, it’s not all about holding down the gas pedal the hardest. Its about keeping on the track first, which requires lower speeds to navigate complexity, and only using max speed in straightaways.
Or to quote the eminent Charlie Sheen, right after his infamous ’banging 7 gram rocks’ he said, “I only have one speed, I only have one gear: GO.” History tells how well that worked out.
That may work on a straightaway, but in this world, there’s people and there’s pandemics and wars and politics. Had rates been at a higher level they could have been slashed at the start of the pandemic, but there was no room to drop at that point.