News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by istillwritecode on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:14AM (#31774054)
I wish I could post a screenshot of this site, because it proves beyond all measure why the commercial web sucks. Two modals for "sign up for our mailing list" and "accept all cookies". Fuck you very much. Why would I read your opinion whining about the web when you contributed to the downfall of the web yourself?
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:23AM (#31775112)
Because the messenger is not the message.

The argument is so tired. It is unconvincing.

Whereas it would be perfectly valid to dislike the opinion because it is published in a lefty publication, the web design annoyances described really have little to do with the political stance of the publisher. The op-ed author likely has no control over the web design.

This site like "99.9%" of other sites looks just fine in the links text-only browser. The annoyances of web design usually depend in part on the browser. If one uses a browser where Javascipt, CSS, images and cookies are enabled, then one is at the whim of "web developers". Less so if one is using a simple HTML viewer like links, w3m, reader mode or some other way to read the text of the page.

HN uses some Javascript. Does that mean every HN commenter favours Javascript. I make zero use of the Javascript that is in HN pages. I use a text-only browser. I do not see indented comment threading or text colours. Because I publish opinions on HN does not mean I use Javascript or even that I necessarily approve of HN's graphical design, whatever it may be.

EDIT: Wow, HN just changed the title. It no longer matches the title chosen by the author. The author must be hitting a nerve with HN's "tech" worker reader base. I used the internet in the late 80s while there was still a rule against advertising and commercial activity. It was amazing. I used the www when it went public in 1993. There was generally no advertising and certainly no surveilance like today.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by 323 on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:52AM (#31776808)
> Because the messenger is not the message.

Jacobinmag it's not your average website. It's full on communism over there. So they should guard better against critiques like "some animals (our righteous website) are more equal than others (their commercial websites)"

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by arandomhuman on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:35AM (#31774159)
I was not familiar with the publisher posting this article, but briefly overlooked your comment before opening the link. At first glance, I was amused, genuinely thinking this article/website a interesting parody of making a website with all the dark patterns and implementation of sign-up-to-mailing-list/tracking/shopping/subscription/etc. and was excited thinking it was awesome someone was so aware of the problems with the internet today they encapsulated the issues into the website itself satirically.

But upon clicking around around further the author was indeed completely unaware of the irony of its own article.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by hnbad on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:22AM (#31775110)
Hipocrisy is a valid criticism but not a counter-argument.

I believe the meme format is "you want to improve society somewhat yet you participate in it".

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by arandomhuman on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:15AM (#31775825)
I don't see how my comment was proposing an argument to the content within the article. It was merely a criticism and would hope to it interpreted as such. Wouldn't be nice to see a higher level of quality and consistency in commentaries like this, especially when the title is as ambitious as something as 'fighting for the digital future'?

I don't mean to sound rude, but your response sounds a bit presumptuous and complacent with hypocrisy.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by streamlining on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:30AM (#31775164)
What? The website has one pop up for me and it looks nice actually.

Cookie consent notices are the fault of lacking browser standards, not individual web sites.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by hgomersall on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:06AM (#31774986)
As a meta point, the requirement to discuss ethics independently of one's ability to exercise said ethics is critical for honest discourse. This applies to general opinion too. I'd be surprised if the author of the piece has any influence on the web design, so discounting it on that basis seems rather limiting.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by golemotron on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:25AM (#31775125)
It does point out how ungrounded one's ethics might be if one can't even bother to adhere to them in the small. The piece could have been posted to a blog.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by oh_sigh on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:57AM (#31774286)
Try browsing by default with javascript off, and enabling it only for sites that don't work. It's actually not that annoying to do since many sites degrade gracefully and degrade the "features" I don't want anyway(like promo or cookie banners).

I can read the whole article without any distraction, except for the bright red banner which remains at the top.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by InCityDreams on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:32AM (#31775553)
Bright red banner? Those are the things that really make me appreciate the pipette(?) tool in ublock. My joy of the internet somewhat improved with that, especially on return/ repeat visits to various sites.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by fleetwoodsnack on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:07AM (#31774319)
I’m not sure if this is genuine question or not (and forgive my presumption, if there is any, as I know not everyone is privileged with both a technical and legal education), but the reason these kinds of modals exist is because of (1) legal expectations, and (2) the organization’s function as a(n advocacy) publication and a likely desire to collapse two necessary but intrusive elements into a single interruption/intervention.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by colechristensen on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:09AM (#31774332)
You don’t need cookies or to force someone to decline to sign up for your newsletter to do those things.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by fleetwoodsnack on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:57AM (#31774555)
Again, I don’t want to be presumptuous, but I would encourage you to (1) investigate the privacy laws behind cookie permissions and why consent forms are becoming ubiquitous, and (2) the UIUX logic governing prioritization of interactive elements.

“Need” here is overdetermined. From a primordial perspective I suppose you could argue the design “force[s]” users to take certain actions, but it’s not like there isn’t a substantive and more intellectually honest take, which is that the modals are annoying but unextraordinary and in-line with standard legal expectations and design practices.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by dmitriid on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:13AM (#31774633)
> but I would encourage you to (1) investigate the privacy laws behind cookie permissions and why consent forms are becoming ubiquitous

If you're referring to GDPR and ePrivacy, then there's literally no reason to show that consent form for cookies that are strictly required for the functioning of your site.

> and in-line with standard legal expectations and design practices.

False on the legal expectation.

Sadly true on the design practices.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by fleetwoodsnack on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:47AM (#31774863)
> If you're referring to GDPR and ePrivacy, then there's literally no reason to show that consent form for cookies that are strictly required for the functioning of your site.

This is why I guard against presumption: so I don’t make references to forms of European legislation (GDPR and ePrivacy) as if they are the singular authorities governing internet privacy law, or that legal expectations are formulated exclusively through civil law.

You’re out of your depth here.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by Dylan16807 on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:22AM (#31775107)
> This is why I guard against presumption

> You’re out of your depth here.

Don't be a vague asshole. If you want to talk about real laws, don't make people play guessing games, especially when you're excusing these sites' bad behavior. If you're basing your argument on theoretical laws, then it's not the other person that's out of their depth.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by fleetwoodsnack on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:13AM (#31775442)
Fact of the matter is that the comment we’re both party-to displays some fundamental misunderstandings of the law.

You may call it “playing guessing games,” but to those with domain-specific knowledge, glaring errors with respect to fundamental legal concepts are obvious and indicates a lack of expertise (e.g. here, not understanding the consequences of the jurisdiction of their named laws to the soundness of their argument) and a possible violation of the law (though the present situation does not rise to that level).

Calling out false expertise is part of the self-regulating nature of the professions, even if doing so can be reasonably called “be[ing] a… asshole.” I think it’s worse to mislead people.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by dmitriid on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:25AM (#31775514)
Demagoguery. There are no "fundamental legal concepts are obvious" that require a cookie pop-up.

> not understanding the consequences of the jurisdiction

It was your third chance to name which particular laws and jurisdictions you allude to. And it was the third time you didn't take it. So, I presume, you have no idea what you're talking about.

> I think it’s worse to mislead people.

That's exactly what you're doing.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by fleetwoodsnack on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:06AM (#31775769)
Look, superficially I could list out ICO, IITA, AAPPI, and a host of other privacy and cookie-related laws and legal bodies. Anyone with Google can do that and it’s not really an indicator of expertise because listing things doesn’t mean I understand their content or their consequences.

Also recall, the jurisdiction you’re demanding was mentioned in my very first response to you: Europe.

What exactly is it that you’re trying to argue at this point?

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by dmitriid on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:51AM (#31777342)
> Look, superficially I could list out ICO, IITA, AAPPI, and a host of other privacy and cookie-related laws and legal bodies. Anyone with Google can do that

Yes, you could. No, you didn't.

> Also recall, the jurisdiction you’re demanding was mentioned in my very first response to you: Europe.

This is what you said: " I guard against presumption: so I don’t make references to forms of European legislation"

So no, you didn't make references to Europe, and you continued to vaguely describe some vague unknown jurisdictions.

> What exactly is it that you’re trying to argue at this point?

That's a question to you, really. I've said my piece here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31774633

You could, of course, respond by pointing out legal frameworks or laws where the discussed cookie banner is actually required. And yet, here we are, in a pointless thread where you've pointed out none.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by diordiderot on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:16AM (#31774652)
"If we don't someone else will"

The dark patterns / bad behaviour works. If someone doesn't use them they fade into obscurity and the message never gets heard.

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by culi on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:49AM (#31774522)
Where are you seeing these modals? I didn't get a single popup. Just a bottom banner with the options to accept or reject cookies. No popup to sign up
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by dmitriid on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:10AM (#31774618)
This is what it looks like for me in mobile https://imgur.com/a/lTDE6CD (second screenshot is when I clicked Deny All on the cookie banner)
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by skywal_l on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:14AM (#31774637)
Ironically, thanks to noscript, I don't see any of the popups mentioned on the original website, but I can't open your image !

Here: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/noscript/

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by dmitriid on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:27AM (#31775523)
Haha. The internet has really failed us, hasn't it.

Direct image links: https://i.imgur.com/1UwHC59.png and https://i.imgur.com/mIRmN7Q.png

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by aendruk on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:08PM (#31784396)
You’d think. But Imgur has fooled you, and actually still serves text/html with the full suite of their trash when other people follow those links.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by pvg on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:49AM (#31776782)
Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by aendruk on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:11PM (#31784422)
I’d argue that in the ironic case they’re no longer tangential.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by pvg on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:31AM (#31788450)
You could, that wouldn't make them less uninteresting even if we somehow accept an exceptionally generous interpretation of irony that includes 'generically yelly tropecomment'.
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by chrisMyzel on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:40AM (#31774465)
I had exactly the same thought when coming to the site!
Re:Review of Internet for the People: The Fight for Our Digi... by riidom on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:08AM (#31775409)
Compared to my general, average impression of news sites:

1) The amount of trackers is 4-5 times lower

2) The cookie banner is best-in-class: A directly visible "reject all" button

3) The modal, I half-way agree here, but at least appears only on first visit

It is a commercial site, after all. I couldn't see any paywalled articles, but if you try to browse the archive by tags, it'll tell you to subscribe first.

For a price of 1.60 per month, which is what I personally consider reasonable and sort of ten times lower than what news sites usually want you to pay.